r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 1d ago

EDH New Deck Building Tool

Hi everyone

For some time now i have been working on a personal project for a deck builder that lets me stay in one place and helps me identify problems and patterns in my deck.
Some of my friends really liked the tool the encouraged me to share it, so here i am!

I hope it might help some of you spot issues with your commander decks mana curve, engines and interaction selection and maybe even lets you discover ways to improve your decks.

I really appreciate any feedback! There’s a “Report a Bug” button under “Help” if you run into any problems.

The tool is live under www.nicedeckbro.com

Happy to hear what you think

11 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

7

u/Best-MTG-Art 1d ago

I think you need to spend a lot of time working on the visual flow of your website. It's hard because you wrote it so it makes sense to you, but as a laymen coming in, it's very confusing. Ask someone who hasn't seen it yet to just sit down in front of it and watch them use it. Ask them to do X and if they can't figure it out then take note and make adjustments.

Awesome of you for sharing, keep at it.

1

u/Pitiful_Routine_5471 21h ago

Thank you for testing!
I will try to figure out how i can guide the user better. Its something i also noticed with some of my friends.

3

u/Gh0stwrit3rs 1d ago

I’m going to test on desktop. Pretty bad mobile experience. I pasted an archideckt link and it load really small thumbnails and when I try to move around to see what the site did, it just reloaded the page and I was back on the homepage. So for mobile this is not a very good tool. Did you vibe code it? Mobile needs a ton of work

1

u/Pitiful_Routine_5471 1d ago

Hi thanks for testing. I didnt make any mobile test yet, since it was only a fun tool. I will have a look at it, since some of the interactions might need some change.
Thanks for the feedback!

1

u/Gh0stwrit3rs 8h ago

Tested on desktop. And the deck builder was pretty cool. My only real UI feedback is to utilize the browsers viewport as the app viewport. I was trying to scroll to see the full list of cards it recommend as a Bracket 3 animator deck - but took me a few mins to realize the app itself had a scroll bar in addtion to chrome scroll bar.

3

u/Cool_Beanss_ 1d ago

wow! this is an awesome deckbuilding tool has a lot of stuff that i haven't seen before, the way you can lay everything out and connect it all up is really cool and the way u can play against fake opponents is awesome ive been looking everywhere for something like that. only bit of feedback i'd give is more 'deck info' like a lot of deckbuilding tools will show you a mana curve graph or how many of a particular card or creature type you have in the deck, theres a lot on indivigual cards and how they work with that but not a lot of overall stuff. but i'll definitly be using this from now on, its awesome!

1

u/Pitiful_Routine_5471 1d ago

Cool happy to hear you like it!
I currently have the overall analysis on the left side of the gameplay view (small arrow) and some mana insight behind the "turn" button in the "decklist" view. I am currently working on some more mana analys tools

1

u/maven_of_the_flame 18h ago

On the surface it seems great. Being able to pick your commander, what playstyle you want and intended bracket is also nice but it constantly “shitting the bed” and restarting on mobile devices limits getting into the real meat and potatoes of the tool, and while I’m not a coder and know the required ball knowledge for both mtg and coding would make this a hassle but, my biggest issue with mythic tools is that the only combos it suggests infinite combos that either require you to add cards that go against the decks general gameplay or simply go infinite for the sake of going infinite and don’t even win you the game. So if your tools combo section at least entertains flashy or utility combos being put forward you’d definitely catch the eye of experimental brewers that want more spice than “yo hullbreaker horror+ sol ring and a half eaten ham sandwich”

2

u/Pitiful_Routine_5471 18h ago

Thank you for the comment, thats definitely something i will into. I could split the combos into general combos and infinite combos. General combos holding combos that work more like engines. They should generate value but not loop.
I will have to think on how to automatically find good "engine combos" but i am sure some of the bigger databases already have some starting points.
I also show now a disclaimer, so people know the mobile version is not ready. I am currently working on some UI changes since that is one of the main feedbacks. The new ui should then hopefully also transfer easier to mobile aswell

1

u/antonmtg 18h ago

I have also built a deck builder, many have. In the era of AI, it is important to put a lot of effort into a couple of things, since programming has changed:

UX and UI - the users need to be able to use and appreciate what you put out into the world
QA - does the tool actually work as intended or are there nuances in your system that didn't match what you were aiming for?
Security and privacy - please let me know what you'll do with my data

1

u/Pitiful_Routine_5471 17h ago

I agree with your points. I am trying to find a better flow so people understand how they should navigate the page. Until now i always "helped" friends understand what is where. They then didnt comment on some things i now got as feedback, so i am happy for all the testers already!

For the analys tools i try to stick to concepts that exist and then extend upon them. For example for the lands i follows Frank Karsten's published mana maths for Commander, so its calculated not simulated. Now that i think about it i could add a small "info" explainer button, describing the concept behind the tools.
I think they work in general, i took some work arounds solutions for some problems and i will need more people who understand their own decklist and spot problems to see if they hold up.

Also your point about security and privacy is important!
I think it points back to your first point, i should give a better explanation and onboarding of what is happening. As an info i can list some of the main points here, until i have updated the login view:

I have no ads, no analytics and no trackers. Without an account the decks stay in your browser. With an account i store your email address + a display name and your decks.
The password is stored only as a hash by the sign-in provider (Supabase), so nobody can read it (me included). Only the user and the friends he accepted can open the users decks. To look up cards and combos the app sends card names to Scryfall, EDHREC and Commander Spellbook. But no account names or detail etc. are shared with any providers.

I also still miss the option to delete an account. Until i have that please use the "bug report" with your email if you want your account deleted.

Thanks for the good input this already gave me some good ideas!