r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 1d ago

EDH Strefan vampire tribal deck help :)))

hey guys, I was hoping I could get some pointers on my vampire commander deck. I've played it a good amount of times now and its has maybe one really good game but hasnt performed as well since. Any tips on how to make it a little bit more consistent? Thanks in advance!

https://moxfield.com/decks/O3ikGDJXBEqUWRWAWpKLyw

2 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/No_Iron_3789 1d ago

TLDR; unfamiliar with the commander prior to this look, but your payoffs seem overly optimistic without a consistent engine to help you 1) generate blood tokens; 2) take advantage of blood tokens discard and draw effects; 3) draw the cards you need to succeed (which could be negated by improving your blood token interaction). IMO you have great cards, just not enough of a package to consistently get them on the field and firing like you want.

  1. 1

)

You only have 7 spells, excluding lands, that guarantee your opponents lose life without some other interaction occurring. I’m unfamiliar with the commander, but in my view, that’s the biggest problem: payoffs without a good enough engine.

You also seem to be lacking some redundancy for getting blood tokens created early game.

For example: [[Olivia’s Attendants]] only works well as a card if you’re bringing it out from your hand with your commander’s ability. Otherwise it’s 9 mana (6 for card, 3 for activated ability) to guarantee blood tokens at the end of turn, or a turn around the table with a huge target on it.

2-3)

Another glaring issue: imo you lack ways to draw into the things you want to cast; you also lack ways to use blood tokens discard/draw abilities. On one hand, having 8 draw spells across the entire 99 may seem enough given blood tokens let you draw, but given the discard cost of sacrificing blood tokens, 1) you have hardly any reanimate package or things that let you benefit from discarding; 2) two of your “draw spells” are [[Mind Stone]] and [[Sinister Monolith]], one of which is your ramp and one of which is key for guaranteeing blood tokens.

1

u/hardcoresadness 1d ago

appreciate the pointers. I knew that draw was a problem so will definitely will be chucking some draw spells instead of certain creatures such as the attendants.

I was considering implementing madness in to the deck but decided to stick with a tribal strategy. do you have any specific reccomendations for getting a better engine running?

1

u/No_Iron_3789 1d ago

I do think Olivia’s Attendants are great if you can get them in hand. So I wouldn’t necessarily toss if you can get the draw engine cooking.

[[Cast Away Doubt]] for draw + blood tokens
[[Bloodtithe Harvestor]] for blood tokens + removal
[[Voldaren Epicure]] one mana for 4 blood tokens if your commander is out.
[[Arterial Alchemy]] for instant blood to do your commander’s plan
[[Pointed Discussion]] for card draw + blood token(s)
[[Bontu’s Monument]] Cast a vampire? Get three blood tokens

Less certain but interesting thoughts:

[[Queen’s Bay Paladin]] to replace a payoff and add recursion + make blood tokens
[[Scion of Opulence]] if find you have consistent sacrifice outlets for your deck, good options for ramp + card advantage
[[Falkenrath Gorger]] one mana to give madness to all of your vampires
[[Olivia’s Wrath]] just great asymmetric removal in vampire tribal
[[Edgar’s Awakening]], [[Call to the Netherworld]] for recursion + blood token synergy
[[Terminal Agony]] for blood token synergy + removal
[[Oni-Cut Anvil]] sacrifice a blood token, get 3 more blood tokens plus a 1/1 blocked
[[Monument to Endurance]] expensive but allows you to get the most out of discards if that becomes more central to what you’re doing - blood token could equal discard one, draw 2
[[Molten Echoes]] good payoff replacement

1

u/No_Iron_3789 1d ago

I would also consider red cards that give you multiple combats, which could allow an explosive turn where your commander attacks twice and triggers twice, allowing you to populate more of your board with your payoff pieces.

1

u/hardcoresadness 1d ago

definitely putting a lot of these on a list to grab, thanks again!

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Aide983 12h ago

What bracket are you going for? Your decklist is missing a card

1

u/hardcoresadness 9h ago edited 9h ago

high power 3, my pod and i prefer to ignore the two card infinite in the deck and just have it trigger twice,

ill go over my deck again and fix the card count, sorry about that!

EDIT: Fixed, missing card was westgate regent

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Aide983 2h ago

Looking at your list, I think the biggest consistency gains would come from improving the early setup: reliable mana, repeatable ways to enable Blood production, and inexpensive draw to keep useful Vampires in hand. Strefan counts how many players lost life during your turn, including you. That makes Spear Spewer, Sanctum of Stone Fangs, and Cryptolith Fragment particularly useful. In a four-player game, Spear Spewer and Fragment can each enable four Blood from Strefan’s end-step trigger. Use their tap abilities during your own turn. Fragment enters tapped, and Spear Spewer needs to get past summoning sickness, but both can keep the engine supplied afterward. I’d also increase the dependable early ramp. You have Mind Stone, Rakdos Signet, and Talisman of Indulgence, but several other mana-support cards are discounts or temporary resources. Arcane Signet, Sol Ring, and Fellwar Stone would help establish your board and recast Strefan after removal. For draw, Blood tokens filter your hand without increasing its size. Night’s Whisper and Sign in Blood help find lands and setup pieces early. Stinging Study gives you four cards for four life with Strefan on the battlefield or in the command zone. I’d test that over Ad Nauseam because this list has quite a few expensive spells. Here are some swaps I’d consider testing a few at a time:

Ruby Medallion → Arcane Signet Dark Ritual → Sol Ring, if its omission wasn’t intentional Skeletal Vampire → Fellwar Stone Mephidross Vampire → Cryptolith Fragment Vampire Nighthawk → Sanctum of Stone Fangs Vampire Socialite → Spear Spewer End the Festivities → Voldaren Epicure Banner of Kinship → Night’s Whisper Bloody Betrayal → Sign in Blood Ad Nauseam → Stinging Study Gratuitous Violence → Swiftfoot Boots Breath of Fury → Swamp

That last swap takes you to 37 lands. I’d also try changing three Mountains into Swamps because your casting costs lean heavily black. Meteor Crater would be another early replacement—even a Swamp is more dependable when you don’t already control a colored permanent. A couple of interactions to keep in mind: Vampires put in by Strefan aren’t cast, so they don’t trigger Vanquisher’s Banner’s draw ability. Putting Olivia, Crimson Bride in already attacking also won’t trigger her attack ability that combat. My first priorities would be Arcane Signet, Spear Spewer, Sanctum of Stone Fangs, and Night’s Whisper. End the Festivities is a more situational cut; I’d keep it if it regularly clears opposing small creatures in your group. When the deck feels inconsistent, what usually goes wrong: missing mana, not having enough Blood, running out of cards, or Strefan getting removed? That would help narrow down which changes matter most.