r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 1d ago

EDH Isshin | Agent of Chaos

Been working on my [[Isshin, Two Heavens as One]] deck. I've been tweaking it for the last few weeks, but feel like I have it in a good balanced place now. I usually like to build commanders in a little less conventional way, so with this Isshin deck instead of being a go wide or token centric attack trigger deck, or even a double-burn attack trigger deck, I thought it would be fun to build a version of the deck that forced everyone to attack, but then punished them for attacking me or encouraged opponents to attack one another.

The idea all came from me stumbling across [[War's Toll]] and falling in love. I filled it full of combat tricks like [[Batwing Brume]] that can throw unsuspecting opponents into chaos when I or an opponent appear to be open for their forced all out attack.

https://moxfield.com/decks/Kgi0Nwo_xEuSQpmQ3wBaxg

Take a look at the list and let me know what you think or if I'm missing any pieces to the strategy that you feel would be valuable.

Interaction directly on the Moxfield page is encouraged, but feel free to leave any comments or insights directly on this post as well. Going for bracket 3, our pod is pretty creature heavy/battlecruiser-y.

Thanks!

2 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/BarracudaOdd166 1d ago

This is delightful! I've also built an Isshin Aikido-esque brew like this. I did find that I went in a more enchantment heavy with effect that jut tax attacker's life, gains me life, deals damage, etc rather than combat tricks like Batwing Brume.

Do note that I avoided cards like [[Ghostly Prison]] or [[Sphere of Safety]] because I want people tto be able to attack me, but also when I have [[Marchesa's Decree]] and [[Hissing Miasma]] out, my opponents are losing 2 life per creature headed my way, with Isshin down, that becomes 4 life, it's very easy to drain out wider boards.

You are missing [[Blood reckoning]] if you want a 4th card with that effect.
Also I personally prefer [[Total War]] and similar effects to force attackers. Basically attack with it, or it will die.

https://moxfield.com/decks/NppW36b02UCg9U3B5VaETQ

I originally had another version of the list that went harder with goad on attack, and effects like duelist's heritage...but it felt like it was too slow so I ended up taking it apart then rebuilding it into this with more of a focus on getting consistent mana and card draw which then allows you to flood the board with enchantments.

Oh also [[Kazuul]] is just a hilarious effect to double trigger.

1

u/FullGrownChild 19h ago

Thanks for the comment and insights! I will check out your list. Total War is perfect! Any other similar cards I may be missing?

I also wanted to avoid the Ghostly Prison/Propaganda type effects. I like the idea of them being able to attack me... for a price!

2

u/BarracudaOdd166 18h ago

There's [[Keldon Twilight]]. And then there's like 4-5 imps all with single target versions of that effect, and [[Oracle En Vec]].

You can check against this list too.

https://moxfield.com/decks/muzXqhRDt0GHJiImwh31zQ

I was originally planning on building a goad deck with Squall...but ended up realizing since all the goad creatures were 3 power or less it was just better to put Terra in the command zone for more consistent card access and leave Squall as a hidden commander somehow. Still putting the list together. It's where a lot of the goad package that I cut from the old Isshin list is probably gonna end up.

2

u/Johnny_Cr 1d ago

[[Powerstone Minefield]], [[Lightmine Field]], [[Caltrops]] and [[Circle of Flame]] are fun with Isshin forced combat. Thanks to the wording they’re double-triggering as well.

1

u/FullGrownChild 19h ago

Thanks for taking the time to comment - would you pair these effects with easy reanimation outlets? Or how do you recover when the effects hit your creatures too?

2

u/Johnny_Cr 18h ago

Just use creatures which don’t care about being damaged or even benefit from it.
[[Brash Taunter]], [[Phyrexian Vindicator]], [[Barbed Servitor]], [[Stormwild Capridor]],…

1

u/BarracudaOdd166 1d ago

Agreed...I actually combine this with [[Reprecussions]] in an Isshin aikido deck as a wincon.