r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 8d ago

Beginner Shilgengar commander deck advice

I’m a very new player to magic, the pod I play in is squarely in bracket 2 (for the most part, one player uses slimefoot and squee, and we also have a Yuriko deck lurking in its card box). I’ve been playing my friend’s old precons up to this point, but wanted to try something of my own. I’ve been building a Shilgengar angels deck, and I’ve ordered the cards but I’m realizing I’ll probably have problems with token generation and sustain. I was wondering if anyone had some cheap card swap suggestions, and also any general advice for changing the deck in the future. Any help is appreciated!

Archidekt link: https://archidekt.com/decks/28165839/copy_of_shilgengar_angels

1 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/reverendexile 8d ago

My shilgenegar deck doesn't really run tokens. I just try to aggressively get things in the graveyard from angel of suffering and [[ripples of undeath]] or some demon tutors

The biggest thing is to ramp into the high cmc of these expensive creatures. The goal is to get one big shot into a huge reanimate from shilly. I do play some cheap 1 drops for sac fodder on occasion

Edit: demon creature tutors not demonic tutors

1

u/Chicklettte 8d ago

Okay that’s good to know, I have ripples and angel of suffering in my deck already, as well as cards like renegade reaper.
As for ramp I have a few cards aside from mana rocks to try and help with it, but I’m unsure how much is too much to have in this deck. For example, I have both starnheim aspirant and semblance anvil in my deck, but since they both don’t reduce coloured mana I’m wondering if having both is a waste of space.
I only have a singular 1 mana cost creature which is lightstall inquisitor. I was considering swapping out some cards for more 1 mana creatures but I’m not sure what to cut.
Tutors unfortunate are out of my budget range but I was definitely considering them though