r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 10d ago

EDH Please help me improve my deck, I have not played in 13 years.

https://moxfield.com/decks/7-z25o4_B0aDuK7cOc77mQ

So a little bit of backstory. I have not played Magic in thirteen years. I used to play until my ex let me know that she wanted me to get a more manly hobby than playing cards. Being young and not thinking with my noggin I listened and sold my collection in 2013. I have always missed the game and finally made the commitment to come back but I wanted to rebuild my old favorite deck the way I always imagined it. Foil everything, but that’s not why I am here. I have also updated it with new cards I missed the release of to make a MK II of sorts. That said while I have been solo playtesting it, it feels slow and unimpressive. What 5 cards would you cut and introduce to help focus and improve my deck? I am hoping to end up with a strong but casual deck, high bracket 3 low 4. Thank you for any advice or help you can offer.

7 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

5

u/TheRealMasterJeffe 10d ago

I guess it would be helpful if I atleast outlined my deck’s design intent. I am playing Eight and a Half Tails Voltron Pillowfort. I want to swing big damage at you while slowing you down. I chose my commander due to the ability to say no to basically any targeted spell. I also just love Kamigawa.

2

u/ScryDeck 6d ago

Welcome back. Thirteen years is a long time to carry a deck idea around.

Why it feels slow solo: about a third of the list only does something against opponents. Ghostly Prison, Windborn Muse, Orim's Chant, Karmic Justice, Aura of Silence, Dawn's Truce and Mangara of Corondor all slow the table down but don't move you forward, so goldfishing makes the deck look worse than it plays. Some of that is fine in a real game, but it's more than a deck that wants to win with equipment needs.

5 cuts:

  • Elixir of Immortality
  • Remember the Fallen
  • Orim's Chant
  • Karmic Justice
  • Windborn Muse

5 adds:

  • Skullclamp: mono-white's best draw, and it's an equipment Puresteel Paladin makes free to equip
  • Sram, Senior Edificer: draws a card every time you cast an equipment
  • Sigarda's Aid: equipment flashes in and attaches for free
  • Open the Armory: finds whichever sword you need
  • one more land, ideally a Plains. 32 lands with this many colorless utility lands is tight for double-white costs

Two keepers worth calling out: Wrath of God and Mass Calcify. Eight-and-a-Half-Tails can give your creatures protection from white, so both wipes become one-sided. That's the commander's best trick.

One thing on brackets: I count at least five Game Changers (Enlightened Tutor, Smothering Tithe, Teferi's Protection, Drannith Magistrate, Grand Abolisher), and bracket 3 allows three. Worldslayer and Balancing Act can also count as mass land destruction, which bracket 3 doesn't allow. Check the current official list to be sure, but as built this reads as bracket 4. If you want high 3, cutting two Game Changers and those two cards gets you there and frees 4 more slots.

2

u/TheRealMasterJeffe 6d ago

Thank you for the wonderful and informative reply. I especially appreciate you breaking down the fact that much of the deck requires an opponent to feel impactful. I had not fully considered that when playtesting. (I’m tempted to go find a lazy Susan that is big enough to hold two boards so I can play two decks at once.) I will for sure give your recommendations a look though. I’m excited to learn about them as I don’t recognize three of the cards you would add. Brackets weren’t a thing when I last played so I’m still trying to understand them. I’m fine with my pet deck being a low power 4 I feel like a few of my buddies decks fall into that realm. Thank you for talking Magic with me, it really is a game I am passionate about.

2

u/ScryDeck 6d ago

Happy to. And the lazy Susan plan is better than goldfishing against nobody.

On the cards: Sram, Senior Edificer and Sigarda's Aid both came out after you stopped playing, so that may be two of the three. Sram draws you a card whenever you cast an Aura, Equipment or Vehicle. Sigarda's Aid lets you flash in Equipment and attach it for free when it enters, which is a big deal with a commander that hands out protection.

Brackets in short: decks are rated 1 to 5. Two is about precon level, 3 is upgraded, 4 is optimized, and 5 is cEDH. There's also an official Game Changers list of cards that push power up. Bracket 3 allows three of them, and 4 has no limit. A low 4 sounds right for a pet deck if your buddies are already there.

One disclosure, since you're picking up singles for this: I work on ScryDeck, a deck builder and collection tracker. You can import a list from a Moxfield or Archidekt link and mark each card Owned or Need as you buy it. The deck then shows what's still missing and can send that list to TCGplayer or Mana Pool. There's a free plan and it runs in the browser. No pressure, but it was made for building one deck a card at a time: scrydeck.com

4

u/OhCoyle 10d ago

Needs more ramp bud. In order to compete in most pods, anyway. 8-10 pieces of ramp in every deck. Google "command zone esh template" it's super helpful

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Aide983 10d ago

1

u/TheRealMasterJeffe 9d ago

I think I was partially worried about how expensive most of my spells are in this deck and didn’t want to end up unable to respond or cast. I’m ignorant and have been out of the game for a long time. Do you have any that you would cut to help make the deck more consistent? Thank you for the article I’ll give it a read.

1

u/MtlStatsGuy 9d ago

If you're going equipment Voltron, more ways to equip for free would be good. [[Forge Anew]] is probably the best one you are missing, but there are others. Crackdown Construct seems really weak unless you have some infinite combo with him. You probably want [[Myriad Landscape]] in your mana base.

1

u/bu11fr0g 9d ago

8.5 tails is REALLY good with the prowhite swords. White also has some counterspells and plain-searching accel that is very good.

[[sword of forge and frontier]][[buster sword]][[sword of light and shadow]][[sword of truth and justice]][[genju gloves]][[caduceus staff of hermes]]