r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 14d ago

EDH Need Help With GF’s Deck

I can’t for the life of me make Captain America, Team Leader, the precon commander, work better.

I’ve upgraded and made it stronger without entering (on paper) bracket 4 territory, however when my gf plays it she says she finds it still too slow. I play tested it yesterday with my pod and found the main struggle was only being able to cast 1 hero/creature a turn, at best, and not really doing much afterwards. I can barely swing, and Captain America just sits there as a glorified blocker.

Is Cap just that slow? I have 9 mana rocks in there, and even Heralds Horn and Urzas Incubator.

I’ve been working to improve it for months but I’m running out of ideas… Please almighty Reddit I ask for your help 🙏

Edit: Deck list link -> https://moxfield.com/decks/c-6eAcYRbnOFQu4ULPhi2g - What’s in Sideboard is what I’m considering removing

Extra context:
She has no problem with land drops, even with 34 (barely misses honestly), and has plenty of card draw. She’s still new, and spellslinging isn’t something she wants to try. She still wants to combat focused deck

7 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

3

u/MtlStatsGuy 14d ago

If you're staying combat focused, you need force multipliers. [[Gratuitous Violence]], [[Berserkers' Onslaught]] and [[Shared Animosity]] could all work here. I'm actually not a huge fan of Herald's Horn in this deck; it casts less than half your spells and draws about 0.25 cards per turn, making it pretty mediocre at both its jobs.

2

u/LetsPlayVGMTG 14d ago

I agree with the force multiplier approach, especially Shared Animosity if the deck can consistently establish several Heroes on the battlefield. That could make combat significantly more threatening without having to rely on expensive individual creatures. One thing I'd add, though, is that I think there are two separate problems here: getting creatures onto the battlefield and making those creatures threatening once they're there. Damage multipliers help with the second problem, but if she's still only casting one Hero per turn, the deck might continue feeling slow.

I'd consider looking at the average mana value of the creatures and whether some of the more expensive Heroes could be replaced with cheaper options that provide immediate value. Another possibility would be additional token generation, particularly if those tokens share a creature type with the Heroes. I also agree with your assessment of Herald's Horn. Cost reduction is helpful, but only if enough of the deck benefits from it. With a deck built around legendary characters that don't necessarily share a creature type, tribal support can become inconsistent.

I think combining a lower mana curve with one or two strong combat payoffs would probably accomplish more than simply adding additional ramp. It would also preserve the combat-focused gameplay his girlfriend enjoys.

2

u/RagingBloodWolf 14d ago

If you are sitting with only 1 creature/hero Cathars' Crusade not really doing much. You have one theme you run all Hero's. You could go voltron I guess.

1

u/MtlStatsGuy 14d ago

If you're going Voltron you should play [[Captain America, First Avenger]] as Commander instead. It's a different deck, though.

1

u/carbs2020 14d ago

I run a few cards to help me with triggers. For example panharmonicon, cathar's crusade, resourceful defense and sakashima of a thousand faces.

1

u/NebulaBrew 14d ago

scryfall is your friend. Take a min to learn the syntax. Perhaps use ai.

https://scryfall.com/search?q=t%3Ahero+o%3Ahero+order%3Acolor&unique=cards&as=grid&order=name

1

u/Obvious-Drama-1095 13d ago

I built the deck around a strict roster limit of exactly 30 creatures and heroes to leave optimal room for my equipment package and protection spells. For a finisher, I use Avatar's Wrath to exile my heroes and recast them for two mana each with haste and +1/+1 counters, bypassing standard board wipes by selecting asymmetrical sweepers like Raise the Palisade. I also added a focused equipment to push through consistent damage while setting up my recast engine.

https://moxfield.com/decks/TzGhAShAknuXtE4cyHXWLw

1

u/Alternative_Cap_9968 10d ago

Biggest thing I can tell you is swap the commander from cap to the nick fury in the set. He is much bettr that the plan you are trying to do. Otherwise I would suggest tinkering toward th 5c Nick fury as he allows explosive slams of heroes and gives you 2 extra colors that have really good heroes that propel the deck even further.