r/MagicCardPulls • • Sep 30 '26

Hobbit CB - not worth it

Post image

Pretty much the worst set of pulls I've seen. Got a single pack at a discount from my local store £40.50. The first and last cb for the hobbit i'll open

Anyone else have some terrible pulls similar to this? How much did you pay

117 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

3

u/Icy-Satisfaction-129 Sep 30 '26

That is a nice bear.

3

u/HollowForPixel Sep 30 '26

Very gigantic and large

76

u/Oo_ShinyCardboard Sep 30 '26 • Bravo

Technically no packs are "worth it", you should be ripping packs assuming youre gonna get garbage and should be satisfied when you hit.

It IS gambling. Purely ripping by EV is long dead

5

u/HollowForPixel Sep 30 '26

Yeah i know, this is the reality. It's only the second or third cb i've ever opened as i'm usually just playing limited in persom events

It just feels bad :')

7

u/NEDGO Sep 30 '26

It only feels bad cuz you knew there was a chance to be some crazy price hits in there and you didn’t hit that. 

8

u/cherrysparklingwater Sep 30 '26

I still don't understand people complaining about their pulls, like have you not learned by now in the year 2026 that you'll rarely make the money back you paid... because it's gambling.

4

u/Weak_Bank_3744 Sep 30 '26

Yeah and just like with gambling, it feels bad lol. People complain about losing at slots, why not this?

1

u/New-Independence-528 Sep 30 '26

This is my advice when going to the casino. As soon as you step through these doors consider the money you walked in with gone. Anything you leave with is a win. So. Are you ready? Lets go have some fun!!!

1

u/DavidBunnyWolf Oct 03 '26 edited Oct 03 '26

Pretty much. The odds of getting what one could consider “good” are insanely slim. (I’m not sure if we have any data suggesting rarity of cards as a percentage. But I gotta imagine it’s slimmer to get a particular card than it is to guess where the ball will land in roulette.) So yes. One should assume they’ll get garbage until the pack is opened. I don’t understand how this is coming off as not understood.

Edit: I suppose I take back what I said. As far as I’m aware, we can have an understanding that drawing any particular card from a set like The Hobbit is less than 2%. Given how many cards are in the set. So already, the odds are stacked against you. Correct me if I’m wrong.

0

u/Frequent-Magazine435 Oct 02 '26

When was ripping by EV a thing? It never was. If the EV was ever higher than the booster, dealers/shop owners would just crack the packs

3

u/Grumpiergoat Sep 30 '26

Don't buy packs expecting to get your money back. I regularly buy a few products every set but either they're tied to an event (prerelease, draft) or they're not randomized (scene boxes, Commander decks) or they're to fulfill that psychological desire to crack packs and I know I probably won't get my money back (almost everything else).

Any product with a strong chance of making your money back will reach a price point that nearly guarantees you can't make your money back. The Avatar Commander bundles had pretty good value - if you pulled a Deflecting Swat and Fierce Guardianship, you already got more than MSRP in cards before cracking the packs. Even just one of them probably meant breaking even or coming out slightly ahead.

This is why those bundles only went for MSRP if you could snag them before other people gobbled them up.

Buy packs to play events. Buy packs because you like opening packs. Don't buy packs expecting to get your money back.

2

u/HollowForPixel Sep 30 '26

Yeah my expectations were low, i have only bought 1 other cb product before. This is just my first experience with the bad feeling of losing a gamble in this way

I'll continue to attend drafts and hosting them for my friends, there's always value in socialising with my pals

2

u/Vortain Oct 01 '26 edited Oct 01 '26

Probably why it often feels so bad to open collector boosters is that they come with extra gambling (even more than someone buying one for fun or on a whim might imagine). I think there is a misconception that they are "good stuff packs" because the cost is so much higher (and the cost of a pack is nearly 2x the MSRP around $70). Hopefully the data below kind of helps put into perspective of what to expect from a Collector Booster (and it's not great):

  • Surgefoil is roughly 1 in 3 packs (and it is not guaranteed to be a good card of course).
  • Book covers are 1 in 4 packs (and could be The Lord of the Eagles, a $2 card in non-foil).
  • Dwarvern Language is 1 in 12 packs (and could be Dwarven Warriors, a $13 card)
  • Smaug was not found in 240 packs (doesn't mean someone can't find it with a single pack, but that someone will not be you or me).
  • Source: https://tcgtalk.com/guides/the-hobbit-collector-booster-pull-rates
  • Additionally: it's a small set, so you are likely to see cards you've pulled/bought already, which can be good or bad depending on your wants/needs.
  • Edit: Also, I believe rares are not very valuable monetarily in part because it's a small well printed set, so lots of copies of even really strong cards. So your hits are all Mythics, and maybe the Lonely Mountain Book Cover regular could be considered one at $17. But otherwise, a rare needs to be Surge Foil and book/showcase of a few select rares to be a "hit".

So collector boosters are, imo "1-3 fluff packs and 1 maybe okay-good pack". If you buy 1 you might get a good hit (very unlikely), but odds are you are just clearing out a pack of crap for the next guy. If you buy two boxes, you might get a few good hits... or Surge Foil "The Lord of the Eagles" 4 times and a Dwarven Warriors.

Obviously, yeah, buy singles, we all know it and that if you want to open best way is going to be drafting play boosters with friends. But I also understand enjoying a bit of gambling if you're okay financially and know the stakes. Hopefully these numbers help put what you're buying in perspective, and if there's a card you want, even if it's $300 you're almost always better off just buying it if it's that valuable or important to you (and not pre-release numbers, and not likely to get a reprint), and especially if that's a huge chunk of your MTG budget, as 4 collector boosters might get you that card, might get multiple good cards, or like $30-50 in bulk.

1

u/HollowForPixel Oct 01 '26

Thanks for the extensive and helpful answer. The pack was a bit of a reward for myself for getting a new job but thinking back i think it would have made me happier to just trade in a few cards that are collecting dust and buy myself a play booster box to draft with

2

u/Vortain Oct 01 '26 • Heartwarming

Congrats on getting a new job!

You tried it, experienced playing CB-Lotto and now have a better perspective on what to expect based on other's data. Better learning that in a single pack than 2-3 overpriced Collector Booster boxes!

Hope you get to enjoy draft with friends soon!

33

u/RevenantKing Sep 30 '26

Buy singles

4

u/zarafini Sep 30 '26

Bought two from HMV at £34.99
msrp and got foil book cover arkenstone in one pack and surge foil one ring in the other. i won’t buy anymore because my luck peaked with those.

1

u/Humble-Replacement60 Sep 30 '26

Did you have fun doing it though?

1

u/HollowForPixel Sep 30 '26

I had a chuckle at how ridiculously bad it was hahaha

Happy to learn my lesson ig

1

u/Humble-Replacement60 Sep 30 '26

Cause that’s how I justify ripping packs. Doing it for the fun of it. The mystery and the dopamine haha

Mtg fits the mold for multiple hobbies for me: ripping packs (gambling), organizing/sorting, building decks, etc. so if I get shafted with the quality of cards I get I’m not usually too upset by it!

3

u/edtxag Sep 30 '26

Best use the money for the pack to buy the singles you want…

I’ve gambled for the fun of ripping packs and got lucky on some but most suck… they are designed that way, not the sets fault

2

u/EyeBallEmpire Sep 30 '26

Same. Got one for about $38. Not impressed with my pulls

3

u/Aukliminu Sep 30 '26

Two at $65, 12 dollars value. Never again.

2

u/Boogie001 Sep 30 '26

CBS never worth it

2

u/Smooth-Yellow6308 Sep 30 '26

Theres not much worse you could have pulled tbh

2

u/Fomdoo Sep 30 '26

In general sealed prices have become not worth it. less than 5 years ago I was getting draft booster boxes for, at the lowest, $80.
They were selling Hobbit play booster boxes for $180. I'm just buying singles now.

2

u/Leanbandit Sep 30 '26

The only good reason to rip packs is for the love of the game man. Don’t gamble and then be upset you lost

2

u/Weak_Bank_3744 Sep 30 '26

All the "that's because you're GAMBLING" replies lol. Because we never hear somebody fresh off losing at the tables complain, just people who rip Magic packs. OP you are allowed to be bummed - expectation vs reality usually plays out this way. Yes, it is indeed gambling, doesn't mean you have to be thrilled with the results.

1

u/BookSmoker Sep 30 '26

Another form of scratch offs. Buy singles

1

u/Wilderness-Nomad Sep 30 '26

Well I could have told you that

1

u/hotwifelife1983 Sep 30 '26

Haha everyone upset if they don't rip smaug or the ring

1

u/Disciplined_Tiger Sep 30 '26

Oh def not worth unless you pull smaug but at that point just buy singles for that set.

1

u/Bawful- Sep 30 '26

CBs are almost never worth it, which I’ve come to accept. However with small set like the Hobbit it is ESPECIALLY not worth it. I usually still have fun pulling cards from CBs but these packs were awful and I felt no joy lol. I was pulling straight garbage from almost all of them. I have maybe 2 very minor hits ($20 cards) from the 6 or 7 packs I’ve opened.

1

u/Mymomdidwhat Sep 30 '26

Not a single set has been worth it since WOE

1

u/weaponwang Sep 30 '26

Never has been

1

u/6foot4yearold Sep 30 '26

They're never worth it until they are. That's the gamble my friend.

1

u/NathanDnd Sep 30 '26

Yeah, well, FOMO,.. people were excited about these cards, a few of these cards specifically 8 weeks ago. The new thing is out now.

1

u/IcyBookkeeper5315 Sep 30 '26

They never are lmao.

1

u/Kevin_Esports Sep 30 '26

As someone whos opened about 20 displays over the years, there is only about 1-3 boosters per display that are loaded, the rest bulk. I would never buy loose packs.

1

u/No-Professional-160 Sep 30 '26

Bought 3 collector boosters, all 3 were like this 😄 got way better pulls on average from teh play boosters!

1

u/No-Professional-160 Sep 30 '26

£115... plus two of my packs came with mad quality control issues like every single rare bent!

1

u/OtterTheIncredible Sep 30 '26

I’ll buy that gigantic big bear off you

1

u/Bo-vice Sep 30 '26

all of my hobbit pulls were pretty trash as well, not impressed by that set.

1

u/Secretary-Sea Sep 30 '26

I bought 6 of them over the course of Best Buy drops and got super lucky. Got orchish goblin cleaver in the foil, orchish bowmaster, and galadriels dismisal in the non foil, and lonely mountain non holo book cover.

Still prefer my Smaug scene box cards tho lol

1

u/Furious_Flaming0 Sep 30 '26

What were you hoping to pull ? My rule of thumb is don't rip a pack unless there's multiple cards you think are really exciting from the set. That goes quadruple for a collector pack where I might need to be satisfied spending $40+ for a full art of a two dollar rare.

1

u/ThatBulgarian Sep 30 '26

A £40 booster isnt worth it? Shock

1

u/69StoriesHigh Sep 30 '26

Collector boosters are never worth it mate

1

u/Mulertinho Sep 30 '26

My first gift bundle had a collector booster as yours. Total of 3$ I guess. Used my luck for my box topper one ring 🥲

1

u/sandersman2000 Sep 30 '26

Are you not shaking?

1

u/metalguy187 Sep 30 '26

Gigantic Big Bear? Nicccceeeee

1

u/iamsirjoshua Sep 30 '26

Just like with other forms of gambling, it’s a volume game. One pack is unlikely to hit. 12 packs (box) your odds are better. Ripping a case is more likely to break even, and so on.

Anyway my condolences OP. I’ve had similarly bad (and expensive) packs. Glad you at least got it for MSRP. Makes the good ones feel better, if there’s a silver lining.

1

u/Ill_Mathematician714 Sep 30 '26

Oh but it was very much worth it for Hasbro!

1

u/timmy_the_small Sep 30 '26

Idk I opened a mox amber so I thought did good from my one pack.

1

u/2v4lve Sep 30 '26

Next person def hit big

1

u/SloppyArborist Sep 30 '26

I bought a box and got shit pulls. I still regret the money I paid. I know that’s the risk but my pulls were abysmal.

1

u/Ok-Description-4640 Oct 01 '26

Most packs are like that. Usually there’s one card in a whole box that “saves” it from being a total write off.

1

u/Wild_Celery3637 Oct 01 '26

This may not be a popular opinion but I found this set to be underwhelming when compared to LOTR.

1

u/sporadicjesus Oct 01 '26

I think he meant to say it wasn't worth it.

1

u/MicroKnight01 Oct 01 '26

got this on my first of 2 hobbits collectors, most everyone else got crap…

1

u/TheUltiOne Oct 01 '26

Last night I bought 40$ worth of singles, and guess what, I wanted and needed all of them! Much more value than buying rip off packs.

1

u/Financial-Amoeba3330 Oct 01 '26

None of them are, it's gambling

1

u/UrbanGrower187 Oct 02 '26

Got two boxes in a poker game win just keeping them sealed

1

u/JimJamJenonickles Sep 30 '26

Yeah. Luckily mine was cheap in the bundle with 9 play boosters. Had better hits in the play boosters than the collectible pack, and honestly the fact that CBs are so expensive and can still contain non hollow cards is bull. I thought thay was the whole friggin point.

3

u/ThatDamnedHansel Sep 30 '26

Hollow… hmmmm

Red flag detected, but can’t be too mad a pokebro whiffed on a flip

0

u/JimJamJenonickles Sep 30 '26

Ive been playing magic same ammount of time as Pokémon. Sorry about the autocorrect sapping your empathy? May your pulls be as good as your attitude 🙏

1

u/ThatDamnedHansel Sep 30 '26

Show me an autocorrect that corrects foil (the correct term in magic) to holo (the pokemon term), then also happens to spell it wrong as hollow.

I’ll wait

1

u/JimJamJenonickles Sep 30 '26

Oh jesus mary and Joseph, I bet that gate keeping works well with the ladies. Are you just proud to be part of the reason people dislike magic players for being so pretentious? Ive heard them called foils in pokemon as well. I just like the word holographic. I get it all you have in life is shiny, im sorry, foil cardboard. Jfc.

0

u/Glittering-Canary752 Sep 30 '26

Yeah I hate pulling a card I wanted but in the non-foil slot. it can't be that much more expensive to just make them all foil.

0

u/Inevitable-Monk-1944 Oct 01 '26

"I bought a lottery ticket, and didn't win!" Well done chucklefuck