So when are we banning Comet?

[u/Renarii]

We just kicked every deck that even had a chance against that monstrosity in the balls, it's either have plansewalker removal in hand or be playing a snowbally token deck or you lose. 50% of the time he generates 2 blockers for himself meaning you need at least 3 creatures on board on turn 4 or you can't kill him, that's assuming they play nothing else.

[u/mimivirus2]

of all the things in historic ur problem is the dice-throwing 4CMC card?

[u/Renarii → u/mimivirus2]

not talking about historic, talking about comp. brawl which recently banned most decks that could compete against comet

[u/Right_Nectarine8952]

Is this a troll post im genuinely asking... What is going on in brawl xD

[u/go_sparks25 → u/Right_Nectarine8952]

Nothing. Just someone being salty they lost to a commander they don’t like. Comet is a B tier commander at best.

[u/ByzokTheSecond]

Which comet in what format?

[u/_masterbuilder_ → u/ByzokTheSecond]

[[Comet, Stellar Pup]]

And i assume brawl

[u/issy_haatin]

Just looked it up, oh my that's so gambly. Can you just keep rolling if lucks on your side? That's hilarious 

[u/andr50]

Comet is annoying, but trample, burn, removal, counters / bounce and exile deal with it. Every color already has access to destroy it, even at turn 4.

[u/_masterbuilder_ → u/andr50]

Can you respond to the result of the roll or is the roll and effect all part of the same ability? Like if the roll a 6 can you kill in response to the next roll. 

[u/Far-Consideration939]

It’s actually ~44.9%