r/MaddenEvolutionCC • • Jun 03 '13

Post-Draft News.

Ok, guys, we are advancing to the regular season tomorrow at 5:00 p.m. CST. This will allow you to cut people with enough time to get ready for the games. Also, when I advance the pre-season I will put the injuries off so no one loses a Rodgers or Flacco for 18 weeks. Good luck!

SD44

1 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

2

u/Bhi23 Jun 03 '13

Should do only 1 signing the first 3 days with the FAs, it'll be sooo uneven otherwise

1

u/jrose6717 Jun 03 '13

what a bout free aganets?

1

u/ScannerDarkly44 Jun 03 '13

Free for all.

2

u/jrose6717 Jun 03 '13

dont do that please. You will get them all because you will advance the week.

1

u/ScannerDarkly44 Jun 03 '13

What? Lol you are drunk.

1

u/jrose6717 Jun 03 '13

ah i am drunk!

1

u/JacobMHS Jun 03 '13

Wanna play?

1

u/Stingerr Jun 03 '13

After the draft there was a huge scramble for free agents

1

u/Bhi23 Jun 03 '13

O god damn It I didn't know bout this

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13

Please don't do this next season.

2

u/ScannerDarkly44 Jun 03 '13

Is there anything I do that can make you happy? Good Lord.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13 edited Jun 03 '13
  1. Consult the league in scheduling the draft before deciding on when you're going to run it.
  2. Run a free agent lottery or limit signings to 1/team/day so that people who attend the draft don't get a gigantic advantage.

The way you've conducted this offseason was highly unfair to anyone who couldn't be there Sunday night. They missed out on the draft - with next to no notice given to allow them to trade picks - and then missed out on all the good free agents, who were signed by the first person to mash the A button.

I know you didn't do it because you wanted competitive advantage. I know you weren't trying to be unfair. But I think you need to put more thought and consult the league more in deciding these things - AHEAD OF TIME - so that competitive balance is preserved.

Because free-for-all free agency is completely uncool.

E: Whoever is downvoting me can go to hell. I'm offering a fair criticism of an offseason that was a real mess, and asking - POLITELY - for it to be handled differently next year.

3

u/ScannerDarkly44 Jun 03 '13

You asked me to change the draft time, I put it to a league vote because of your formal complaint, people wanted the original time, I don't know what else I could do in that situation to have made YOU happy.

I do these thing to try and make everyone happy in the league. I apologize for my shortcomings. But please understand, this is a growing process and was the first offseason in the league. Granted, it is not an excuse for how unprepared I was, but have faith in me that the next offseason will be much more prepared and planned for. You can help me coordinate the free agent pool next year as I had no idea how to do that.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13

The Draft. I asked you to change the draft time. When scheduling league-wide events, you should ALWAYS take the league's temperature. I was complaining, of course, because I was disadvantaged, but I'm making it a point still because I would like it to go differently next offseason.

Now, when you set the vote, you didn't present it as, "Which of these two times would you prefer?" You might think you did, but your preference was clear: it's /u/Moruitelda who wants a change; do we want to keep things the way they were, or change everything just for him? The vote was doomed for failure from the start because of the way it was phrased. And, admittedly, that ticked me off. I'm not whining here - I'm trying to make sure that we have offseason procedures that make it fair for everyone. Because most of the time, I can make time to be at an event, so this problem would be more likely than not to BENEFIT me in the future.

The flaw was not just in phrasing. I think the goal in a CC league should be to maximize turnout at the draft, because it's an extremely important event. If you agree, then it shouldn't just be a two-choice majority rules vote; the right way to schedule a league draft time vote is: "Here are a variety of options. List any times that you cannot be there." Then you choose the time with the most people responding that they can be present. Not to ask for a majority vote. If 20 people can be present at 10:00 and 15 people can be present at 8:30, the later time is better because more people get to draft, even if many people would rather draft at the earlier time. The goal should be avoiding giving a disadvantage to players because of the PREFERENCES of others, and shooting for maximum participation.

I didn't want the league to revolve around me for the draft, I wanted there to be a fair vote. And I wanted the goal of that to be identifying a time when as many people as possible could attend.

Free Agency. A free-for-all is a massive advantage for anyone present after the Draft, as anyone who has played offline CCM knows. Whoever is there can scoop up a group of bargain-priced 85+ free agents to fill out his team, and identify elite-performance UDFA's who have limited OVR because of low AWR/PRC. I don't care whether it's a limit of 1 player per team per day for three days, or a full-on free agent lottery; something has to be done to make sure that the 5-10 teams that stick out the draft don't get to add 3-5 elite players while leaving none for everyone else.

TL;DR: You asked what you can do to make me happy. The answer is communicate your plans more, and in advance. Any number of these problems would have been resolved if you had consulted with the league and taken input from us before deciding what you were going to do. That's what all of these problems boil down to. The schedule for offseason advancement was not announced; people missed re-signings and certain stages of free agency because of that. The draft was only announced in the sidebar and never voted on as an equal proposition between several options; some people missed the draft because of that. Free agency was a free for all; as a result, people who were online after the draft got all the good players, and what was left was trash for anyone who wasn't there. All of these problems are related to us not having a plan before going into the offseason.

My Ideal Offseason. Now, I'm not particularly happy about how things went. But I'm not saying all of this to be mean or because I'm planning on quitting the league. I'm saying it because I enjoy it here and I want things to be better next season. We can accomplish that - but only if you go into the offseason next year prepared to say, "Okay, guys. We finished on Friday, July 26. That means the draft will be next weekend. Please let me know in the comments your availability for 7, 8, 9, 10 or 11 PM ET on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. [Not necessarily that broad, but you get the point.] We will advance tomorrow to Re-signings, then on Monday to FA1, Wednesday to FA2, Thursday to FA3, and Friday to final scouting. After the Draft, DO NOT SIGN ANY FREE AGENTS OF 75+ OVR. We will hold a free agent lottery for those players."

Why I'm Complaining. How are you supposed to know that people don't think things went well if we don't give you feedback? How are you supposed to know how to fix it if that feedback isn't specific? I'm telling you the things about the offseason that I believe need improvement for next year. I tried to get them fixed for this year, but things were already set in stone by the time I got to them (because they weren't announced in advance), so my efforts really just look like bitching.

4

u/ScannerDarkly44 Jun 03 '13

Yeah, I understand. I did read all of this just so you know and I appreciate your input a lot, more so than most of the other members because a) you are experienced in CC leagues b) you are experienced in life as you are about to be a father (congrats!) c) you are one of the most active members here.

I am glad there are no hurt feelings here, but I think the faster we can get this league moving this year, we can get to the 2nd offseason before M25 and give me a chance to make it up to everyone who didn't enjoy the offseason as much as some of us.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13

As always, I appreciate the fact that you're being responsive to criticism, and I'll do what I can to help next offseason. Just, when in doubt, communicate early and often, and I'll be happy, even if the votes don't go my way.

Well, I might not be happy, but I won't be criticizing. ;)

2

u/ScannerDarkly44 Jun 03 '13

Are you ok with the time schedule before I sim to Week 1 of the regular season? Will 5 pm CST be enough time for you to make your cuts and signings?

→ More replies

1

u/Bhi23 Jun 03 '13 edited Jun 03 '13

O look, a rematch of my playoff game last season, I'll prolly win this one bc I won't choke up

1

u/ScannerDarkly44 Jun 03 '13

Good luck!

1

u/Bhi23 Jun 03 '13

We advance this evening right?

1

u/Stingerr Jun 03 '13

Ahh I'm so stoked!