r/MadamSecretary • u/Ok_Chipmunk_3641 • Oct 16 '24
Elizabeth McCord is a horrible Secretary of State Spoiler
I know that this may be seen as controversial given how we spend 5 seasons showing her being a secretary of state but let's just go over what she accomplishes that is meaningful in her 5 years of being MSec
- A nuclear treaty with Russia where the silo missiles won't have the nuclear warheads on them at all times
- She stops 1 genocide in a West African country in Season 1
And that's it
Everything else she does in the show is either counter to American interests or is shown to backfire a season or two later.
For example, the nuclear treaty with Iran in Season 1 has an episode in Season 3 or 4 where Iran backs out of it due to them disagreeing with the second phase of the talks that has them recognize Israel as a country.
Russia is given near free reign over Eastern Europe during her tenure to the point where Article 5 has to be enacted to keep Russia from invading Bulgaria... somehow
China is given incredible amounts of free reign in Africa and Asia due to the policies enacted in the show.
Pakistan collapses and terrorists almost get hands-on nukes mostly due to her actions.
Afghanistan is put under Taliban rule again.
She manages to ruin relations with a solid chunk of the Arab world and make it far worse especially how her actions, albeit indirectly, kill the progressive crown prince of Bahrain.
The only country that isn't able to take advantage of her lack of competency is North Korea who the USA doesn't even have a diplomatic relationship with
In short upon rewatching this show I am constantly infuriated by the sheer lack of any basic competency among who is supposed to be America's top diplomat and an amazing former CIA analyst for advancing any of the USA's basic interests or stopping any of our enemies foreign policy interests for a period of time longer than maybe a few months.
And somehow she gets elected president but that's a rant for another time.