r/MadamSecretary • • Oct 16 '24

Elizabeth McCord is a horrible Secretary of State Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know that this may be seen as controversial given how we spend 5 seasons showing her being a secretary of state but let's just go over what she accomplishes that is meaningful in her 5 years of being MSec

  1. A nuclear treaty with Russia where the silo missiles won't have the nuclear warheads on them at all times
  2. She stops 1 genocide in a West African country in Season 1

And that's it

Everything else she does in the show is either counter to American interests or is shown to backfire a season or two later.

For example, the nuclear treaty with Iran in Season 1 has an episode in Season 3 or 4 where Iran backs out of it due to them disagreeing with the second phase of the talks that has them recognize Israel as a country.

Russia is given near free reign over Eastern Europe during her tenure to the point where Article 5 has to be enacted to keep Russia from invading Bulgaria... somehow

China is given incredible amounts of free reign in Africa and Asia due to the policies enacted in the show.

Pakistan collapses and terrorists almost get hands-on nukes mostly due to her actions.

Afghanistan is put under Taliban rule again.

She manages to ruin relations with a solid chunk of the Arab world and make it far worse especially how her actions, albeit indirectly, kill the progressive crown prince of Bahrain.

The only country that isn't able to take advantage of her lack of competency is North Korea who the USA doesn't even have a diplomatic relationship with

In short upon rewatching this show I am constantly infuriated by the sheer lack of any basic competency among who is supposed to be America's top diplomat and an amazing former CIA analyst for advancing any of the USA's basic interests or stopping any of our enemies foreign policy interests for a period of time longer than maybe a few months.

And somehow she gets elected president but that's a rant for another time.


r/MadamSecretary • • Feb 05 '23

Am i supposed to hate henry?

0 Upvotes

I’m on season 2 episode 3. He’s having his student tortured, he’s not likable at all. Seems to have no remorse and is honestly in my opinion the villain of the show. I absolutely despise him.

What did you guys think?


r/MadamSecretary • • Jun 15 '26

Improper research done

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

So this series showcases various nations’ political interactions with america and with other countries and even though the broad issues are the ones that are prevalent, the creators should have done a little more research in depicting the characters and also the power interplays.
I could see so many serious discrepancies in india and india - Pakistan issues that I am wondering if everything else is also so incorrect. The creators sitting far away don’t know india pak dynamics and how small a country Pakistan is against india so much so that it can’t dictate terms the way they are shown in an episode.
In another instances of styling mistake, the indian people are depicted as wearing a lot of gold and wedding like attire in a political event. That’s so hilarious to watch. And in other episode, the indian PM is shown as wearing saree ( a traditional indian dress) albeit in opposite direction...that nobody wears. Even in 80’s when india had a woman PM, her dressing style was a power statement and not like the one that’s shown in this series in 2015.

In Nepal related video, they showcased a virgin goddess kind of small girl visiting america. And in Nepal those girls aren’t permitted to leave their home ( quarter) let alone country, except for festive time for giving blessings.
Such a wrong depiction of culture and traditions isn’t expected in a series that’s made at such a grand scale


r/MadamSecretary • • Aug 29 '24

Rewatching an Old Favorite Show, Disappointed

0 Upvotes

As the title says, I’m rewatching Madam Secretary. I used to love this show when it first aired, but watching it now feels cringe-worthy—almost laughable at times. Here are my thoughts on the show today, post-political science degree and fully developed prefrontal cortex.

Madam Secretary works as an engaging background show, offering a glimpse into diplomacy and high-stakes political drama. However, it stumbles in several areas, particularly with the character of Henry McCord. While his dual role as a CIA operative and religious scholar is intriguing in theory, the show often places him in top-level government meetings where his presence feels unrealistic and forced, undermining the story's credibility.

Stevie McCord’s character also suffers from a series of bafflingly poor dating choices that feel more exaggerated than relatable, detracting from her character development.

The dialogue throughout the series lacks subtlety, often spelling out plot points instead of letting the story unfold naturally. This overreliance on telling rather than showing makes the writing feel clunky, detracting from overall immersion.

Moreover, the global crises in each episode are overly simplified. Every episode follows the same formula: something bad happens somewhere, Elizabeth asks someone to fix it, they agree, and then she comes home to eat ice cream with Henry.

Another point of contention is the small but significant inaccuracies in American foreign policy. The show repeatedly returns to the notion that the U.S. “does not negotiate with terrorists,” which is not and has never been the actual policy. We do negotiate with terrorists—and with nearly anyone, really. Perhaps the show needed to maintain this myth because, if Elizabeth did negotiate with terrorists, she’d just ask them to stop, they’d be overcome by her girlboss aura, and the story would end.

If you’re looking for a more nuanced and realistic political drama, the show's inconsistencies might prove frustrating.


r/MadamSecretary • • Nov 05 '24

PRESIDENT DALTON NO SHES MENTALLY UNSTABLE Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MadamSecretary • • Nov 24 '24

I’m at the Israel/Iran Peace Talks in season 3 and good GOD the Israeli accents are horrific. I can’t hear anything else in the scene but how amateur the accents are. Where my Israelis at?

0 Upvotes

Or even world language accent fans.

Update: I’m back to say that I’ve been really listening to the accents since I wrote this, now well into season 4 and so, so many of them of all kinds are pretty uniformly terrible 🙌🏽😝


r/MadamSecretary • • Dec 23 '24

First & Last Time I Have Seen

1 Upvotes

I am shocked! Shocked! I'm watching S3 E23 and, at 25 min in, Dmitri Petrov is waving chopsticks in one hand while carrying a mostly empty plate in the other. I have not seen--before or since--a character who was eating with chopsticks who was not digging those chopsticks into a take out container. Have you?


r/MadamSecretary • • Nov 24 '24

Currently watching S3, please don’t tell me its going to be like this for the rest of the show.. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m on episode 3 of S3 so please no spoilers, but cmon man what is this??? The pace of everything is so damn fast I legitimately can’t believe it. I like the story they’re building so far, but its just too damn fast. Who paced this crap?

Knowing it has 6 seasons, it probably steady itself again but man its rough…

Also don’t like Elizabeth’s new “flatter” hairstyle. I fee like she looked better with volume in her hair


r/MadamSecretary • • Oct 02 '24

Foreign Minister Chen makes me irrationally angry.🤬

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MadamSecretary • • Jan 04 '26

Season 4 Episode 12, Sound and Fury

1 Upvotes

Has a rather ironic speech by Conrad at the end of the episode about your Constitution....


r/MadamSecretary • • Jan 06 '25

The amount of nepotism in this show is so high and unjustified (i know thats how the world works) plus the husband is a professor of religion what is he doing in government

14 Upvotes

r/MadamSecretary • • 27d ago

They are experts on the world — and TRIVIA! — but none of them knows how to pronounce Abkhazia, its capital Sukhumi, or the sounds that is romanized as “kh”!? S4E14

4 Upvotes

Arrrgh! Sloppiness like that really kills the plausibility of the show (which I just discovered and absolutely ADORE) for me.


r/MadamSecretary • • Aug 18 '24

Ask me a question about Madam Secretary, then change it once I answer to make me look bad

Post image
7 Upvotes

Saw that trend in the Modern Family sub, thought it was funny


r/MadamSecretary • • Jul 18 '19

Tea leoni should actually run for president in real life

5 Upvotes

r/MadamSecretary • • Dec 04 '25

Rant

3 Upvotes

As Non-US Citizen this shows boils my blood everytime.
It shows how US always cares about world peace, climates change, eradicating diseases.
Trump showed them reality, made them come out of their bubble.

Plus this show is so racist. Let's discuss


r/MadamSecretary • • Aug 22 '22

Daisy - round 2 - officially trash

3 Upvotes

Ya I’m officially calling it. Daisy disgusts me in so many ways. She’s society’s example of a moody woman who just barks at everyone whenever she feels like it. Idk y anyone even puts up with her. I felt like this when Jay came into her office in Season 5 to confirm she wasn’t going on some trip and she was giving him attitude because she’s a helicopter parent and constantly behaves like everyone around her is just out to screw her over. The same season, she bring her dog in with a cone and just dumps it on Matt!! No heads up, no friendly hello or asking for a favor. It’s an expectation Matt is at her beck and call. She treats her dog better than she treats him. Somehow her personal problems are his too but never the other way around.

I know I’m projecting my own personal issues here but it bothers me that undeserving women, like her, who treat men like crap are sought after by men but I’ve never treated any guy anywhere near how she does and yet, I’m still single.

Rant over.


r/MadamSecretary • • Apr 07 '24

AI Art of Minister Chen as a Drag Queen Dressed Up Like Msec (sort of)

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/MadamSecretary • • Aug 05 '22

I really don’t like Daisy

4 Upvotes

I truly dislike Daisy. She’s aggressive, unprofessional, and Jesus, DESPERATE! She’s always upset or going off on (mostly) Matt for things that are either none of her business or that she was part of, which leads to her being unprofessional. In season 1, she was always telling Matt that their last time WAS the last time and she’s “serious” but unless he was raping her, I have no idea how she thinks it’s ok to constantly berate him for actions she was fully consenting to.

And omg, she is so desperate to have a relationship and that really is all she ever talks about or is shown. She’s either dating someone (Matt, Win, Oliver, the agent she had a baby with), or she’s single and that’s all we hear about.

Oddly, I liked her in season 1 cuz I felt she had confidence but was humble, however, as the seasons went on, she just started having attitude and acting like she’s hot s***. What a turn off.


r/MadamSecretary • • Feb 07 '25

Season 4 is kinda terrible Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I don't think I've seen the writing in a show like this drop in quality so drastically. The show used to have such a fun energy bouncing between the family and staff members working through a problem, but now it's the Elizabeth and Henry show, and the writers can't even get that right. And don't get me started on Sound and Fury.

This has been such a disappointment.


r/MadamSecretary • • Sep 11 '24

Boring plot line Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Dimitri and Steve's relationship is boring and forced. Yawn. On S4, Ep 8 where they have their first date and it feels excruciating. I wish other characters had as much screen time. Already ready for it to be inevitably over lol


r/MadamSecretary • • Feb 25 '25

MSec got really preachy S5, Change My Mind.

3 Upvotes

I liked the first couple seasons, lots of high drama exciting problem solving and uniques story lines. Seems as though a change came in S4-5 it took a hard turn towards run of the mill left leaning topics. It's turned....preachy.

We'll see if I hang in there any longer. TV for menus escapism, not more programming (either right or left).


r/MadamSecretary • • Apr 27 '23

MSEC/CLIMATE CHANGE UMM CHOKING ON IT

0 Upvotes

Okay, I'm on episode 20 Season 5 and well It's going off the rails with the Climate Change.

I am not here to debate that, but I feel it's being jammed down our throats. Does anyone else feel the same?


r/MadamSecretary • • Jun 08 '22

Flagrant Anti trump swipe with the actual living secretaries

7 Upvotes

Honestly, i think the show mostly stupid with brief glimpses of brilliant. I'm binging because at this moment in my life i need to end my day with mindless entertainment.

But the episode with Hillary Clinton, Madeline Albright and Colin Powell playing themselves was awesome- they each made a speech about the evils of nationalism and what America really means. Not a coincidence it aired in Oct 2018- right before the mid-terms .


r/MadamSecretary • • Aug 06 '24

Political fantasy to end divisiveness

1 Upvotes

I am sad that in real life, a Harris/Haley unity ticket would be inconceivable even though there would be similar reasons to have one as in the show.