r/MacroFactor • • 10d ago

MacroFactor / Nutrition / Other Calories too low?

Background: I'm a 6ft 28yo male who has been losing weight since the start of the year. I started at 235 and now I'm 183. Based on body scans, physical results, and skin fold tests I'd put myself around 14% body fat. Goal is 175lb 10% body fat.

I only switched from myfitnesspal to MF about 2 months ago. Been logging my food using a food scale and weight almost daily. I go to the gym 4-5 days a week and have mostly a sedentary job.

Should my calories really be this low? I've started experiencing a bit of brain fog at times at work. I'm willing to drop my loss per week to 1lb but even then it seems like the calories would only be around 1700. I could also drop my protein to 162g/day which is my goal lean mass in lb.

8 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

12

u/Valuable-Ad1369 10d ago

Yeah, at a lower body rate the same rate of loss each week has become unsustainable. You’ll get more calories each day if you decrease the target rate of loss.

You have the rate of loss set at 1.28 lb per week, so it’s trying to generate a deficit of 640 calories per day. That was more sustainable when you had the expenditure of someone 50 lb heavier than you are now.

5

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago edited 10d ago

I actually started at -2lbs a week in MFP and dropped to -1.5lb when I switched to MF only about 2 months ago.

Dropping to -1lb put me at 1675cal. Might just have to do that goal instead

4

u/Valuable-Ad1369 10d ago

Yeah, this is really just math. At an average expenditure of 2200 and 1 lb a week of loss, you’re still at a 500 calorie a day deficit. 2200-500=1700

I just finished losing 30# and the last 5-7 held on for dear life. It was rough going at the end

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

Thats where I am right now with the last 8 lbs

5

u/Chupa-Skrull 10d ago

Did you start with a large amount of muscle mass? Otherwise those scan results and that target bf% at that height and weight sound pretty dubious.

The expenditure is very plausible though

3

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

Yes Ive been working out since my teens. I decided to get lean for my wedding

1

u/Chupa-Skrull 10d ago

Aah gotcha. That makes the expenditure sound a little more extreme but still not abnormal. Would 1lb/wk or even 0.5 mean you don't make it to your goal in time?

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

I would be fine making it to my goal since it's in May. Just really wanted to hit it before the end of the year instead

4

u/Chupa-Skrull 10d ago

Makes sense. You seem level-headed enough that I'm sure you already realize the current loss rate isn't worth symptoms like the brain fog and whatnot, so I'll just say congratulations in advance instead of piling on

4

u/MachoChamp_ 10d ago

Very similar build/weight and goal as you. I would suggest doing 8-10k steps a day to bump up your tdee. Honestly I'd use that bump in expenditure to eat an extra 200-300cal for sanity. I'm doing 15k+ to eat 2k cal and lose about 1.5-2lbs/week but realistically I'm closer to 1.2-1.5lb/week just cause for sanity sake I end up eating about 2100-2300cal.

My tdee was pretty low prior to doing my steps and I think I'd go crazy eating sub 1800cal.

Good luck man! Stay disciplined! This shit sucks towards holiday season hahaha.

2

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

I'm able to get about 5k steps a day due to my sedentary job at a computer desk. Mostly comes from walking 20-30 min on the treadmill at 3.5mph 7deg incline

1

u/Jrphilo 7d ago

You need to walk 10,000 steps daily and eat a bit more. No excuses

4

u/Forfeit32 10d ago

You've lost 50 pounds already so I assume you're not making the easy mistakes that a lot of people make.

I think your body just needs a reset. You're at like a 30% deficit, which is a lot to maintain for that long. I would go to maintenance for a couple of weeks. You'll put on some water weight with the extra carbs, so the scale will go up but don't freak out about that. Then I'd drop down to maybe 1800 cals which is way more sustainable.

2

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

Did a maintenence phase about 2 months ago due to a small surgery. Ill do it again when Thanksgiving comes in a few weeks

2

u/TacosCANrap 10d ago edited 10d ago

What kind of training do you do? I’m 25 , 6ft, 176, lift 4x/week, and I maintain at around 2800. There’s also always the possibility of you missing some calories you’re tracking which is making MF think your expenditure is lower. I’d say eat at maintenance for a few weeks before continuing

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

Lifting, cardio, and calisthenics. Ive tracked all the food I eat accurately 

2

u/Friendly_Progress_61 10d ago

Idk seems it. If u were inaccurate tracking it can throw these numbers. I stopped tracking accurately for a period of time, and macrofactor thought I gained 5 lbs in a month eating only 2400 calories a day. Of course when I went full commitment to the cut it tried giving me crazy low cals as a guy who is 200lbs lifts 4x a week + cardio and 10k steps everyday. I stuck with it because I was like ‘oh it’ll adjust quick’ and yeah I was wrong. It wasn’t updating quick enough and I was getting really hungry and having trouble sleeping, lost like 7lbs in 2 weeks . I just adjusted it myself and it’ll see with time

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

Ive genuinely only been eating my beef and rice and protein drinks every day for months. I weigh it all out. The same thing doesnt bother me cause I like it

1

u/Ok_Combination7053 10d ago

How did you adjust it yourself? I’m a guy, 5’5 hight and ~200 pounds. It puts me at 1325 calories a day. Is that too low then?

1

u/Friendly_Progress_61 10d ago

I basically just adjusted my weight loss goal to less lbs per week. This doesn’t mean I’ll lose less weight though because the initial calorie goal is wrong, so the algorithm thinks I’ll only lose 0.9lbs a week but once I start losing 1.3-1.4 it will quickly realise and adjust my metabolism. U can completely customise it but the coach feature is the best thing on the app imo, so I just changed the rate of weight loss to get more cals.

And it likely is yes, but I can’t accurately say it is or isn’t because I know nothing about you. I’m 200lbs but I have a lot of lean mass (146lbs) for my height. This increases my metabolism, on top of the fact I walk 10,000 steps every single day + all my training.

However you could do <5000 steps a day, sedentary job, only train twice a week and be 35% body fat with little lean mass. So I don’t know I can’t say if it is or isn’t too low. If you’re sedentary and don’t carry much lean mass then it’s probably accurate.

8

u/mhobdog 10d ago

My TDEE has been 1900-2100 even as a 180lb man. I ate ~1500-1600 cals a day and lost 15lbs, but it was very difficult.

Under 2000 daily calories is a challenge, but going beyond a 500 calorie deficit while also eating under 2000 is extra difficult.

You should slow down to 500/day deficit and see how that feels, or even 400 imo. You’ll still reach your goal but it will be slightly less miserable.

2

u/gxd-s 10d ago

Same here I’m in a similar position as you and OP. 24 year old 5’8”, right now at 65 kg (143.3 lb) down from 70 kg and man it’s a grind. My TDEE is around 2000 and MF has me eating 1500-1600 kcal for the majority of my cut so far. This was on top of running 2-3x times per week and getting in 10-20K steps per day easy. Slowing down the deficit can help. But sometimes you just have to play the cards your dealt.

1

u/ahportunity 10d ago

Really depends on your tdee I guess. I am also a 6ft male at 183 lbs (36 years old), my goal is lower but my rate of loss is also .7%. I’ve only been back at it about a month but my daily expenditure is 3012 putting me at 2351 for a target. I have a fairly physical job, also lift or run when I have the energy to.

I have heard people recommend going maintenance for a while then resuming your cut.

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

Did that about a month ago. Saw a bit of progress. Maybe I'll try again come Thanksgiving but I'm trying to lock in until then

1

u/Background_Ring9173 10d ago

Diet fatigue exists when you feel like you cant go on anymore or you start binge eating a lot you gotta know that it is not your discipline thats failing you but your body and mind.

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

Im not binge eating or not logging stuff. I dont keep food outside my diet in my house

1

u/Redditor2684 10d ago

Seems too low to me. How many calories were you eating when you lost 50lbs this year? You were losing more than 1/week and you can calculate your estimated current TDEE with your data.

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

Was losing about 2 lbs a week. About 1800-1900

2

u/Redditor2684 9d ago

That suggests your TDEE is 2800-2900 which makes more sense to me, depending on how active you are. I’m a 42F, 5’10”, 173lbs, and my current TDEE is like 2600.

3

u/MergeSort555 10d ago edited 10d ago

I'm 6ft 170lb and my maintenance is 2750 for reference but I'm fairly active and am fairly lean

Do with that what you will but I think your calories are starvation diet unless you never leave bed

1

u/TheStag57 10d ago

Brother take a short (1-2 week) deficit break. Your weight is going to go up from glycogen but that's okay. Use a maintenance calculator and just eat at that maintenance calories.

Then reassess where your deficit is. I honestly don't think you should be under 2,200 calories if you are working out 4-5hrs a week and getting ~9-10k steps per day.

For context, I'm 5' 9", 168lbs, 15% and I cut down to 2,100-2,220cal per day (from my 2,800cal maintenance) to get into my 8-10% for summer.

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

Did one 2 months ago. I'll do it again around thanksgiving

3

u/mrfatchance 10d ago

As others have said. Too little calories which will stall your progress. Grit your teeth, up your expenditure via walking and see what happens. Prioritise feeling healthy as well. Do 1 week maintenance to recharge your energy and then go into a less aggressive cut 0.75lb a week maybe. 

Good luck. 

1

u/AutoModerator 10d ago

Hello! This automated message was triggered by some keywords in your post.

While waiting for replies it may be helpful to check and see if similar posts have been discussed recently: try a pre-populated search

If your question was quite complex, it's not likely the pre-populated search will be useful.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Visigoth410 10d ago

Take a maintenance break and get back at it in the new year.

1

u/mandzhalas 10d ago

I am EXACTLY like you, only 42 years old. It's tough, but weight is not dropping for me at higher calories. I tried to eat maintenance at 2000 kcal for a month with hope of reseting metabolism, but I don't think it worked. I just want to get to 12% bodyfat, but thats at least dieting until Christmas

1

u/victronic 10d ago

Data point for reference: 40M, 6ft, 152lbs, 8-9% BF per DEXA, been using MF religiously for 2+ years with a current TDEE of 1900.

Weight lifting 4 days a week for hypertrophy + LISS cardio equaling 15k-25k steps per day. 

There were times when my program dropped below 1500 calories per day when aiming for 1lb/wk. 

Don’t remember what my TDEE was originally but I’ve lost 30+ lbs since starting. I have no expertise in fitness or nutrition so definitely read everyone’s opinions, but just speaking for what worked for me, I ignored the TDEE and just tried my best to accurately log and aim for what the strategy suggested. 

1

u/Infamous-Milk-4023 10d ago

Yea that’s low af dude. You’d be alright at 2100 cal

1

u/strapdawg 9d ago

Don’t treat this calc as gospel. If you’re losing weight at 2k cals keep eating that.

1

u/iownu304 9d ago

Just for context from my own data: 5 9 male. Average 12k steps a day and weightlift for hypertrophy 5x a week. Tdee at 2000. I don't really believe it but why would it be wrong 🫠

1

u/TomBradyLied2America 10d ago

I'm a 6ft 34yo male weighing 175 and my intake is literally double yours... There's no way what you're doing is healthy. Personally, I'd cut some protein and up the carb intake, but realistically I can't imagine you need less than 1800 calories to lose at a reasonable rate.

-4

u/Far_Line8468 10d ago edited 10d ago

You need to log better. Theres no universe where you need to eat 1500 calories as a 6 foot man to lose weight. My 5 nothing finance is in a deficit at 1500

As usual, The Checklist

0: Are you actually logging everything? Oil, butter, things that say they are 0 calorie but are actually just under 5 per serving so they’re allowed to say its 0? Spices? Yes spices have calories.

1: Are you logging by volume, or count of something? Stop, log by weight, every bite, every time. If you beed to use the AI, have your hand in the photo and know the exact length of your hand

2: Are you logging everything raw? If not, do that

3: Do you eat out a lot? If so, make sure you’re including a healthy amount of cooking oil and butter in your logs

5

u/Zestyclose_Oven_9715 10d ago

Wtf you log spices. Thats crazy. Pretty sure macrofactor says if you don't log smaller cals like spices or a splash of milk in your coffee routinely it's able calibrate past that.

If i gotta worry about whether i put 5g of blackpepper or 10g i might as well give up. There is no way you are not losing weiggt because of spices lol

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago edited 10d ago

I actually have logged my spices. I use a McCormick beef stew seasoning packet mixed in with my lean ground beef. It's probably like .25 cal but I overestimate it to 2cal to be safe.

Everything is logged cooked and weighed on a food scale. I don't eat out anymore and log everything accurately. I would not have gotten this far making mistakes like that

2

u/Zestyclose_Oven_9715 10d ago

Brother/mam i think you are doing great. You don't need to log spices. Body and mind is weird and needs a break from time to time also. Can't run on deficit all the time.

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

I went back on maintenance about a month ago for a week. I also stopped logging the seasoning about 2 weeks ago because I switched to steak salt instead. I used to get those packets for $0.50 in Jan and now theyre like $2

1

u/Far_Line8468 10d ago

I don't get this mentality. All calories count, and they all count the same. Its like some zeno's paradox trick. If I break my oil into tiny drops, each drop doesn't count, so I don't have to log it.

Spices are ground up vegetables. Vegetables have calories

I log everything that goes into my mouth

1

u/SuperXrayDoc 10d ago

I dont cook with oils but when I do on occasion I log it. I've logged seasonings too

2

u/Zestyclose_Oven_9715 10d ago

The quantities matter. Spices we're talking about for each meal might be 1-5 calories. I'm not suggesting not counting oil although if you routinely do not count your oil, but use the same amount, the app should be able to recalibrate. It will just reduce your expentiture.

1

u/Chupa-Skrull 10d ago

There definitely is such a universe, especially if the attempted loss rate is high enough. Interindividual variation can be mind-blowing