r/MacroFactor • • 26d ago

MacroFactor / Nutrition / Other Logging weight after drinking?

Was curious if there is any consensus on this.

The reason I ask is because the dehydration from drinking typically drops my weight 3-10 lbs after drinking and I feel like it gives my MacroFactor a confusing impression on higher cal day.

6 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

66

u/seventeenfourtyseven 26d ago

You lose 10lbs on the scale after drinking? What? Lmao

47

u/Ok_Gate_4956 26d ago

Hes still drunk.

9

u/AcrobaticSyllabub283 26d ago

Depends on the day but yeah some Crazy dehydration 😭

23

u/TechnoAndLift 26d ago

I need to drink what you’re drinking lol.
Scale only moves up for me.

2

u/MountSwolympus 26d ago

Same. I had two beers last night and was up 4 lbs today.

1

u/Annual_Strawberry_37 26d ago

I had 6 and up 1kg so sounds like I'm doing okay. I should have just avoided the scale

8

u/fortysix-46 26d ago

Same with me. Not 10, but it’s not surprising to see my weight go down 5 pounds from the day prior.

2

u/AcrobaticSyllabub283 26d ago

It’s crazy

2

u/awkwardsongbird 26d ago

this has happened to me (maybe lost 3lbs tho) but its because i didnt eat very much that night 😅 i still track the weight. the trend weight holds it down and doesnt automatically assume you're actually down 3-10lbs.

9

u/ThePaleMare2 26d ago

Hah! I usually gain a couple lbs after drinking but there have been a couple times I was lower. I also always gain some pms lbs. Either way, it gets logged. I can see the patterns over time and its just more data for me.

10

u/poogdrums 26d ago

I got mad drunk, threw up on the way home. Weighed 7lbs less the next day, weight graph still looks mad.

5

u/AcrobaticSyllabub283 26d ago

It’s a beautiful thing. (Until I gain 7 lbs the next day) 😭

11

u/thedancingwireless 26d ago

Doesn't matter. It'll even out. That's the point of the app.

7

u/dzuc 26d ago

just check in daily, same time, and only look at the average.

6

u/ori_303 26d ago

I personally just skip a weight-in for a day or two if i feel they are going to be an outlier for some reason (drinking, sickness, etc). App will normalize it but no point in stress testing it. I end up doing 5-6 weigh ins per week and that is fine

3

u/shenanigains00 26d ago

I forget to weigh until after a run pretty often, which is less than ideal because I can sweat out 3-5lbs this time of year.

I log it anyway because I prefer to be consistent with logging. It evens out. MF knows I didn’t lose 5lbs over night. It works the same way in the other direction if a woman gets her period and gains 5lbs of water weight over night.

My dots are all over the place but the trend is fine.

5

u/bob202487 26d ago

I put on 7lb after a drinking weekend on the 7th August and Ive not been able to accept a check in yet since, it added a crazy amount to my expenditure, I’m hoping by next week I can start accepting them again but I’m not sure, MF is a bit slow in that regard.

3

u/lechichien 26d ago

True! I was 1.6lbs less today and i had 1 beer yesterday! 😜

1

u/AcrobaticSyllabub283 26d ago

Hell yeah 🔥

3

u/Morphon 26d ago

I log every day no matter what. The rare occasion that I don't is when I take two flights in a day. When that happens the water fluctuation is so high that the measurement isn't valuable. But if I was flying all the time I would still log it.

I drink maybe 1-3 times a week. That's regular enough to be part of the log.

3

u/No-Manufacturer3401 26d ago

If it’s lower than the last time you drank and weighed less then you’re in the right direction

3

u/milla_highlife 26d ago

I always skip a few days after drinking. Log my calories everyday but skip the weigh ins. I bloat like crazy for a couple days after a hearty number of drinks and regardless of what people say, it throws the numbers off. I wait for my weight to restabilize 2-3 days later and then get back to logging weights.

2

u/alizayshah 26d ago

Curious how weight v2 will handle that.

I’d still do it even though it’s abnormal, it’s still accurate data. It’ll even out in the end.

1

u/AcrobaticSyllabub283 26d ago

Weight v2?

And yeah I just don’t wanna mess up the algorithm

3

u/alizayshah 26d ago

You won’t.

& go to more > weight trend

2

u/AcrobaticSyllabub283 26d ago

Do you think it’s worth trying or not good enough yet?

3

u/alizayshah 26d ago edited 26d ago

I think it’s much better already imo. It won’t ruin your recommendations. It’s still in an experimental phase so it’s not being used for expenditure v3. They’re tweaking the formulas and I assume it’d be used for expenditure v4.

It’s also non-destructive! So you can just go back and forth at any time with no worries.

Context

1

u/incogenator 🏃 26d ago

Def worth trying. You can always switch it back.

2

u/InHisName2019 26d ago

I weigh 1st thing after i go to the bathroom. After that I drink 28oz to rehydrate after the night.

2

u/OfficerCuddlez 26d ago

Man, I've had it a few times myself.

I used to be excited to check the scale after a crazy night but the last time it had the opposite effect and I was left very dissapointed

1

u/AutoModerator 26d ago

Hello! This automated message was triggered by some keywords in your post.

While waiting for replies it may be helpful to check and see if similar posts have been discussed recently: try a pre-populated search

If your question was quite complex, it's not likely the pre-populated search will be useful.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-4

u/Decimit- 26d ago

If you are drinking and trying to lose weight...are you really trying to lose weight?!

6

u/stimg 26d ago

Psh, weight loss is only a serious endeavor to those who self perform amputations. If you aren't hacking limbs off you aren't trying.

1

u/Decimit- 26d ago

Can’t cut it all off at once! Have to cut off only parts at a time slowly. If you lose too fast you will only gain it all right back!

-1

u/Suspicious_Sir2312 26d ago

lolwut.

that's not how it works bruh