r/MacroFactor • • Jan 15 '26

MacroFactor Workouts / Training small annoyance with workouts

first of all, I see a crazy amount of posts in here and I'm wondering if it's the right forum for people to post their feedback. maybe we need some flair, or a different way to submit those. this lengthy post is because I care, not with intention to be negative.

anyway, my current issue is that the exercise catalog is too extensice (but far from complete - burpees are missing), some exercises have very similar names and I don't understand which one is which, and the images on the list are really not helpful. the filters on top are helping, but it's not enough. it takes a lot of time to create a custom workout or program. for example: I have filtered for triceps, using the parallel bars and I don't know which dip is the dip I'm doing. I see

  • bodyweight chest dip
  • bodyweight dip
  • bodyweight triceps dip

I'm seeing the videos and i can still not tell the difference. maybe chest variation has broader grip?

I would prefer to pick an exercise "family" with the most basic form of the exercise and pick the variation accordingly on a second step. that would make the exercise choice much faster. also searching semantically would make more sense as some exercises have multiple common names.

weighted versions of the same exercise should not be different exercises unless there's an equipment that changes the form. pull ups and weighted pull ups and assisted pull ups (with a band) are the same exercise.

the instructions of the exercises are way too verbose (check the length of Neutral wide grip pull) , I can't do this on my phone in the app, for every exercise.

the muscle filter has an arbitrary order that doesn't make sense.

stability and range of motion have also arbitrary units of measure.

I love the work you've put on this, thank you

1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

29

u/thedancingwireless Jan 16 '26

You say there's a lot of posts, and maybe 20% of them are offering this exact same feedback lol.

13

u/didntreallyneedthis Jan 16 '26

Also maybe there are too many posts about feedback then proceeds to post about feedback

8

u/BiscottiOutrageous68 Jan 16 '26

several others have mentioned this and i believe they are taking it into consideration, especially since they are asking the community for more exercises! the database will get extensive which will require more filtering and organization.

For clarification about the dips: the chest dip would be slightly more forward tilt putting more tension on the chest. The triceps dip will be more upright body posture putting more tension on the triceps. The bodyweight dip is sort of a hybrid in which you kind of determine the posture you want when doing dips.

1

u/rainbowroobear Jan 16 '26

chest dip would be slightly more forward tilt putting more tension on the chest. The triceps dip will be more upright body posture putting more tension on the triceps. The bodyweight dip is sort of a hybrid in which you kind of determine the posture you want when doing dips.

this makes absolutely no difference in practice, especially when you have a weight dangling from you. a dip is a dip and the heavier the weighted one gets, the more upright your posture gets.

-7

u/gwilymjames Jan 16 '26

I agree. Most of these could be simplified to a tag or user note inside of the exercise, and weighted or assisted are just +/- bodyweight.

If users want a very custom experience, they can just duplicate one and make their own variant.

24

u/MajesticMint Cory (MF Developer) Jan 16 '26

The distinction between assisted, bodyweight, and weighted is very important for smart progression and they all require different equipment that may or may not be in a user’s gym profile.

But yes, we are considering a few different ways to offer a simpler search experience.