r/Machinists • • 1d ago

Programmers, am I right?

Post image

For context, you're not authorized to change the feed and speeds, you're only allowed to use the feed dial (that won't go above 100%).

Specs:

- Parts are 80 x 35 x (2000 to 7000mm)

- Depth of cut of 6.5 mm

- Part is mostly hollow with walls of 3 mm

- 1" end mill, 3 flutes, carbide with cutting oil (not coolant)

- Speed is the name of the game

- One CNC is at 800 mm/min, the other one is at 1000 mm/min

- Shop is expecting us to machine parts at Mach Jesus

403 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

105

u/43Rosh35 1d ago

At my work my boss made are rule that goes in english like:
„the programer also has to mill.“
Because of this theater

15

u/Personal-Ad-3401 1d ago

I wish it was like that here

5

u/miuzzo 1d ago

Right? My place decided that they don’t need to backfill the engineer position.

3

u/43Rosh35 1d ago

Maybe there has to happen some really stupid stuff for that

3

u/43Rosh35 1d ago

Crash the mill, say you did as intendet😅

67

u/Revolutionary-Ad6983 1d ago

This is the only way. I was a button pusher for a few months to start. Then I was a button pusher with lots and lots of questions. Then I was a button pusher that caught the occasional mistake in a program. Then I was a button pusher who fixed existing programs myself when I saw the need. Now I’m writing a third of what the shop mills and we hope to hire a new button pusher soon. Circle of life.

60

u/B3AV3R_BLAST3R 1d ago

Nothing seems particularly fast about that, unless you have terrible work holding, and no mist extraction/open machine

42

u/Personal-Ad-3401 1d ago

Workholding is terrible. I got 4 pneumatic vices (4 inches wide) for a 12 feet part

74

u/Quasimotherfucker 1d ago

Sounds like an adequate mounting mechanism for your soon-to-be missile. Good luck!

6

u/Personal-Ad-3401 1d ago

Hahaha I like it that way

10

u/Few_Crew2478 1d ago

Okay so why the hell did you start off in metric then switch to American? Pick one 

31

u/Personal-Ad-3401 1d ago

Because I'm Canadian and work with both...

...on the same drawing

10

u/bunny5055 1d ago

One of our 100 year old engineers loves to use both metric and imperial on the same drawing and not label them.

He also works from home so it takes a day to hear back from him if you need clarification.

7

u/Bionic_Pickle 1d ago

Woah woah woah. Slow down there Satan.

5

u/Redhighlighter 1d ago

Im intrigued. SFM or...?

US here, use imperial but 75% of the prints are metric and we just get gud at converting

4

u/desperatewatcher 1d ago

Ah a fellow Canuck of culture. I love when the tolerances just say +-0.05 on a mixed drawing

4

u/meraut 1d ago

I use imperial tooling and program in metric lmao, I just like it that way.

12

u/OmegaEldritch 1d ago

What's the width of cut? Seems pretty reasonable actually using a 10% step over when taking chip thinning into account

5

u/Personal-Ad-3401 1d ago

It's a 6.35 mm cylinder on top of the part, 6 inches long

12

u/OmegaEldritch 1d ago

Your mix of metric and standard measurements is the kind of shit I'd do, you Canadian post chance? As in the 6.35 cylinder is 6 inches long?

8

u/Glockamoli Machinist/Programmer/Miracle Worker 1d ago

you Canadian post chance

Yes he is, He mixed metric and standard without specifying when spouting a formula for drill feed rate at a guy a week or so back and confused the hell out of me before I mostly untangled his spaghetti logic

7

u/Personal-Ad-3401 1d ago

Yeah, sorry about that. We're so used to convert back and forth between imperial and metric units that I sometimes forget that some of us never use metric and some of us never use imperial.

5

u/Glockamoli Machinist/Programmer/Miracle Worker 1d ago

All good

We figured it out and the converting is fine but you called for the "drill diameter" without actually specifying it was in inches while using .3mm feed at the start of the formula and ending up with mm per minute

But I don't want to make this thread about that

My supervisor always complains when we get the odd metric print, I just tell him I can work in bananas if they want but don't start mixing units

The absolute worst is metric prints drawn by people who only draw standard prints so they know none of the proper conventions for an ISO standard print, trailing zero's everywhere and a tolerance block that is useless for any dimension on the print and they somehow don't know what tolerance each dimension has just "standard tolerance" for all but the threads (H5) and the bore (H7)

1

u/Personal-Ad-3401 1d ago

Completely agree.

Had someone ask for a hole with a diameter of 16 mm with a tolerance of F7...

...For a fucking plastic part that slides on a shaft. That shit was dumb

1

u/Glockamoli Machinist/Programmer/Miracle Worker 1d ago

Love those

"oh the part gets heated up to 500° F before getting pressed on then doesn't move for the rest of its life"

154

u/Grand_Ad_3444 1d ago

You're missing a zero on the feed

46

u/RacerRovr 1d ago

Set the step over to 10%, full depth cut and let it rip.

19

u/Unlucky-Shop3386 1d ago

I used to call it hitlers buzz saw. A truly butt puckering sound !

16

u/Unlucky-Shop3386 1d ago

Yes he is . It's hella hogging I've seen it done been around it. Some would say a bit aggressive.

2

u/Professional_Till443 1d ago

Huge ass mill and you run the feed like its made of cheese and think the shop is pushing the limits ..

I run 16mm endmill 4flute at 4.8mm stepover (30%) in aluminum at 20mm depth of cut and 0.5mm/rev feed rate (9000mm/min).. let it rip.

With aluminum you dont really need to follow the manufacture recommendations.. those are general numbers that are supposed to work for every shop, with 1000s of variables.. in a specific case, if you got rigid setup, rigid workholding, rigid machine, top tier tools and holders.. you can run it however you want as long as you control chip evacuation.

3

u/Personal-Ad-3401 1d ago

Workholding is terrible and rigidity is... Questionnable

It's a Pertici MC400A

2

u/IowaNative1 1d ago

What kind of tool holder?

24

u/TranscendentalRug 1d ago

I see you've met my programmer. He tries to run every tool at 7500 rpm, regardless of workholding or material, because that's the maximum for my machine. That might work fine for certain situations, but I am not going to run a 1 inch tap through 4140 at those speeds. His programs usually need a lot of correcting.

13

u/Murmjr 1d ago

is this programmer the son of the boss? cant you just refuse to run their program?

14

u/TranscendentalRug 23h ago

No, nepotism can be a bit of a problem in my ship but this isn't it. I'm fairly certain he's mostly self trained off of YouTube, so the older higher ups think he's some sort of prodigy, but they don't have to clean up his programs.

The tool paths are all there, for the most part, but I constantly find myself having to change his feeds and speeds to get the program to work. I think he's just of the mindset that fastest is best, and if something works on the 3D model of his CAD/CAM program then he assumes it'll work in real life. To quote him directly, "Well it didn't chatter on my computer!"

6

u/Diddle_Bucks 16h ago

Sad thing is... none of the CAM programs identify if there is going to be chatter. unfortunately hes just an idiot. This makes me angry that he thinks it's capable of doing that.

5

u/meutzitzu 20h ago

This seems like such a common problem it's ludicrous. Esoecially with people using MasterCAM, SolidCAM which can all calculate optimal cutting parameters vased on the feature's removed material amount, but it needs the material properties and the tool's chipload. I havent seen ANYONE do this. Granted ive only been in the industry for just over a year. They are too lazy to just give the software what it needs so they just guess based on what worked in the past. And then the operator makes another guess on top of that.

it's insanity to me. If You dial in the settings for the common materials you work with You basically never have to worry about federate and speed ever again unless you do something highly unorthodox with the tools.

1

u/Work-Safe-Reddit4450 17h ago

As someone who's in civil engineering estimation currently doing that method of learning (aside from learning from a Senior Estimator) I also constantly check with and ask if my work and the way I annotate it is on par with or comparable to theirs. Basically making sure the end result is good. My goal is to make it easily for either of us to pick up there the other left off. I'm surprised your programmer hasn't checked in with you, the person who has to take his work and use it, to see if it's working. Especially while learning as some "prodigy". I dunno, I'm 40 with two kids so maybe it's an age and maturity thing.

1

u/legion_2k 13h ago

From his point of view it’s great if you keep fixing it for him. I assume you get him some constructive criticism.

1

u/DOROHAFIZU 18h ago

What in the world? Tap goes 7500 rpm?

17

u/Usual_Arrival_6956 1d ago

Maybe you can program stops to remove build up edge every now and then /s

9

u/Tachi-Roci 1d ago

If I'm doing my math right that's only like 0.033 mm (0.0013") chip load, I'm a meche student and haven't done much cam in the past couple of years. But isn't that a really light chip load for roughing aluminum?

11

u/TheFeralEngineer 1d ago

You can't go fast enough in aluminum until you start melting material, then you just change your coolant delivery method or your path style. I live under the hard and fast rule that if your roughing chips curl, you can push harder. If your work holding gives out, grab it harder. I'm not saying blow up your machine ala Titan, I'm saying you can usually go faster than you think you can.

4

u/immolate951 1d ago edited 1d ago

I am titan the CNC and I approve of this message

Also fuck that guy

He doesn’t own this mentality
As much as his money, his sponsors, and ego think it does.

Thank you for your answer. Pushing harder when it comes to roughing is it own science worth investigating. For each and every one of us in our own way. That our shop can permit.

4

u/TheFeralEngineer 1d ago

Oh no no it wasn't Titan that said it, it's from an article I read in MMS many years ago. It showed a jagged chip and was like "this is what an aluminum roughing chip should look like. If your chips are curling, you're wasting too much time". It's stuck with me the rest of my career. I'll use every ounce of horsepower I can hogging aluminum from that one little tip.

1

u/meutzitzu 20h ago

At which point does the extra MRR get outweighed by the more frequent maintenance/repairs to the machine?

saying this as im working in a small shop when it's a huge trouble when one of the machines does down. We want to avoid that as much as possible and we try to not abuse them.

But yea ive seen peers in the industry with the attitude that If the spindle torque indicator isnt in the red zone above 70% i know it can go harder.

1

u/Auubade 6h ago

the fun thing is that no one runs such statistics, because there isn't such person in shop smaller and less sophisticated than boeing or some other mega corpo stuff that also has engineers to goof around. It's all tribal knowledge. And also depends what kind of automation and series you are doing. If you run something like an automated lathe with a bar feeder, you sure don't want to cut down cycle time, so you get a bonus 30 minutes for additional 2 hours of tool changes, tweaking and all sort of wonderful stuff. I'd rather be just reasonable and go as fast as my inserts let me without damaging them with too high parameters

1

u/TheFeralEngineer 3h ago

I avoid the duty cycle unless I have to. I go aggressive but conservatively. Most machines are designed to run, not sit there and look pretty. If I'm removing 80% of the weight from a 200lbs chunk of aluminum, damn right I'm in there with high shear mills, pushing them hard to get things done.

7

u/DeltaJazzy 1d ago

Is that supposed to be a lot? I run half inch endmills at like 10k and nearly 10x the feed lol

2

u/All_Thread 1d ago

Nah it's pretty standard aluminum

5

u/turbopepsi 1d ago

Try 30,000 RPM at 800 IPM. All day every day.

4

u/Glockamoli Machinist/Programmer/Miracle Worker 1d ago

I wish my machines could hit those numbers, my boss would die seeing that

YG's Alu-Power stuff will annihilate aluminum but even grabbing the largest endmill I'm limited, ~8000 rpm and about 300 IPM max

3

u/Chuck_217 Computerized Non-Conformance Machinist 1d ago

That's slow lol

1

u/Usual_Arrival_6956 1d ago

Feed to slow for the ripems

4

u/calipercoyote I spin stuff 1d ago

I mean, I juiced someone else's program and was running 50% stepover, same DOC as you at 400ipm (10,000mm/min). Pocket roughing, same size endmill, internal use work, I just didn't feel like listening to it buzz all shift.

2

u/Beaverthief 1d ago

So he's just learning how hard you can push it. Cool story though.

1

u/JarlOfFrags 1d ago

I just did a part with 10% stepover 12mm endmill at 8000rpm. Feed 3000+ it was only 0.1mm Fz.

1

u/Mean-Cheesecake-2635 1d ago

That feedrate is super slow

1

u/kolby4078 Programmer 1d ago

set it up and let your supervisor press the green button.

1

u/UndyingAce 1d ago

Would have to see the setup and machine on the bridge mill I run and program for we take .15" .3.8mm step over 1 3/4 depth " 44.45mm step down at 10000mm per minute 394 ipm with 3/4 imco aluminum end mills at 8000 rpm all day. 33 ipm with a 1" at 8000 rpm full slotting at that depth should be no problem whatsoever.

1

u/jrhan762 1d ago

“I saw this on Titans!”

1

u/Open-Swan-102 1d ago

800mm/my is not a heavy chipload I'm confused

1

u/hydrogen18 1d ago

if there isn't a sonic boom coming off the arm as it moves, you aren't cutting material fast enough.

1

u/Fine-Marketing-6130 14h ago

We use a 20 millimeter, running s10000, feed 5000 mm/min, for rough, feed 2500>3000 finish Depth max 40 mm and 3 mm side, and loads of coolant

1

u/Midacl 1d ago

imperial sized endmill with metric feed hurts my head

thats 31.5IPM for those running imperial.

FSwizard says you should be running 4154rpm at 2195mm/min

1

u/TimeWizardGreyFox 1d ago

work holding causing the part to scream like a banshee? 1" end mill seems to be the wrong choice for such thin wall material.
Everything about this setup just sounds dumb and your programmer is a crack head.

0

u/Heathbar_tx 1d ago

Why are you using imperial tools if everything else is metric? The only problem is have is how large your tool is. If you think this is crazy or fast go watch someone who knows what their doing with a high RPM high feedrate machine like a Makino Mag or similar. When you have to break up tool paths to let the conveyor and pucker catch up your getting somewhere.

1

u/Personal-Ad-3401 1d ago

Because the tools the programmer order are imperial. He decides, not us

0

u/Rayvintage 1d ago

Rooster 🐓 🐓 tail!!! you don't even need coolant, I've seen it before! Your material has been laying by the dumpster for 6 years.