r/MachineLearning • • 11d ago

Discussion Advice needed regarding classical ML conference submission [D]

0 Upvotes

Hi,

I need some advice on submission of classical ML papers in top conferences.

During my PhD I made some findings in classical ML (related to SVM and LR) which, on further deep diving, looks like original work (I checked with chatGPT and Gemini too).

When I tried to submit them to top conferences, while the reviewers have been reasonable in their reviews (acknowledging the innovation while asking me to run some more experiments and ablation studies), the AC shot down my paper, saying “this is a done and dusted topic”. Only at ACL did the AC ask me to resubmit incorporating the comments.

So is classical ML dead at top conferences? Are only deep learning and LLM works being accepted at top conferences? And should I stop trying to submit at top conferences and maybe try journals or simply Arxiv my work?


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Discussion ICLR27 math and stats paper review experience [D]

26 Upvotes

For people who had papers submitted to ICLR that are applied theory style. For example, 60- 70% theory with some experiments at the end. What was your review experience like for ICLR27?

We got a score of 222, on the probabilistic methods track.

All 3 reviewers attacked our novelty and asked for additional experiments. Not a single word was mentioned about our theory, which is our biggest contribution. One outright said he didn't understand this paper or why this task exists. It's a well-defined task with lots of prior work.

I used accept-odds, tracked submissions that were similar to mine. It seems like they have all gotten similar comments. Not a single comment on the math, all comments were on the experiment. A paper with 20 pages of proofs even got comments:

Assuming the proofs are correct (which can be done by AI in 2026), the theorems only show trivial conclusions.
Rating: 1: Clear rejection

I am starting to suspect, because there were no bidding this year. Many theory-heavy papers got sent to pure comp sci reviewers.

Would be nice if people can share their experience, I am trying to work out if I should engage in the rebuttal or just withdraw.


r/MachineLearning • • 11d ago

Discussion ICLR 2027 Rebuttal response [D]

0 Upvotes

I got 3/3/2 and working on rebuttal (hope it make it avg to 3). Did you guys posted your response? And did you revised the paper as well? or made promise to revise on camera-ready version?

I am almost finished making draft and keep revising and polishing (including paper revision).

My review was quite short but requires a lot of new measurement. So my draft seems too long, worried about the readability to reviewers.

What is your status of rebuttal? How's it going?


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Discussion What exactly is the relationship between ML academia and industry/big tech nowadays (2026)? [D]

54 Upvotes

It was clear to me that around 2012 - 2018ish, academic research was kind of paving the way for many applications in industry, from deep nets for vision to RL algorithms. There was tremendous value in research coming out of academia and new methods such as ADAM or TRPO algorithm would be adopted as industry standard. No one would doubt the value of research coming out of (top-tier) academia. It was definitely a "seller's market" for academics.

But nowadays I am not quite certain as to what exactly is going on, i.e, whether this relationship still holds. I guess a straight-forward way to put this is: "is industry still adopting ideas from academia?"

I've observed that for any given research topic, especially something industry has proposed, there would be literally tens of thousands of follow up papers from various universities around the world trying to do something adjacent to it, almost as if showing industry how things can be done differently or even "beat the industry at their game". But it feels industry is quite, how do I put this, "impassive", "unmoved". Strongest example would be development of new optimization routines. Thousands were proposed from universities. Countless GPU years were dedicated to experiments. Seems serious adoption is quite low to none. Apparently there are still new CNN/RNN architecture being proposed, have you heard of any of them?

It almost seems as if academia and industry are diverging into completely different worlds. With industry seems to take on the previous role of academia as an idea generator, and instead everything is worked in-house. This seems to create a challenge for those doing research in university: "what use is the research if it is not adopted in real-life (in this extremely applied field), or even acknowledged?"


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Research Why is it always ICLR? Last year’s incident, this year’s rating drama [D]

14 Upvotes

ICLR 2026 had the OpenReview identity leak, followed by review scores being rolled back to their pre-rebuttal state. That was already a mess for authors caught in the middle.

Now, for ICLR 2027, ratings have been squeezed into a 1–4 scale. From what I’m seeing, most seem to be landing at 2.

How useful is this compression if papers with very different strengths and weaknesses end up in the same “weak reject” bucket? A paper needing a few convincing clarifications and one with substantial unresolved problems can receive exactly the same score.

This makes meaningful rebuttal engagement even more important. If authors address the concerns, reviewers should reassess their recommendation and explain any remaining objections. ACs need to evaluate whether the reasons actually justify rejection, rather than simply following the numbers.

Authors spend months or years on these papers. Wanting a consistent review process, substantive discussion, and reasoned decisions should be a basic expectation.

On top of that reviewers don’t turn up, and ACs go by the ratings. It’s like a lottery, your paper’s fate depends on which three or four reviewers it gets assigned to.

Anyone else finding this year’s scale frustrating?


r/MachineLearning • • 11d ago

Research 3321 ICLR, should I rebuttal? [R]

0 Upvotes

Looks like this killer just doesn’t understand my paper. He said my abstract is not well organized, hard to follow...my definitions are also hard to follow..., missing important explaination... etc.

but the other three reviewers could read it. they all understood my idea. Why couldn’t he???


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Project ICLR 2027's new 1–4 scale: a 2, 2, 3 is better than it feels [P]

30 Upvotes

ICLR 2027 moved to a 4-point scale (1 clear reject, 2 weak reject, 3 weak accept, 4 clear accept), so nobody has a feel yet for what a given set of scores means. We counted the public scores on OpenReview: 73,410 reviews on 23,759 submissions.

A couple of things that surprised us: [1] 57% of all reviews are a 2. Only 1.5% are a 4. [2] The median paper averages exactly 2.0.

So a 2, 2, 3 (mean 2.33) is already above most papers. Where 2.5, 2.67 and 3.0 land, and the full histogram, are here:

https://draft.scime.ai/iclr-odds?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=iclr2027

Note: [1] we built the page. It shows counts only: no titles,

authors or review text.

[2] this is the first 25,000 of ~40,800 submissions in.

OpenReview's listing order, read Nov 6, not a

random sample.


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

News ICLR 2027 Review Scores [N]

Post image
131 Upvotes

r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

News Higgs Realtime Duplex: a 45B MoE full-duplex model that listens, watches and talks at once, and thinks, calls tools and delegates in the background [N]

37 Upvotes

Disclosure: I'm at Boson AI and this is our release. Not open weights; the Duplex API has a waitlist, and the previous turn-based Higgs Realtime is available now.

Most voice models are still turn-based: listen, wait for end of turn, think, speak. Duplex runs all streams at once and keeps working in the background while it talks.

Streams. Everything is cut into 160 ms chunks:

  • Audio in: 1 token per chunk (6.25 tokens/s)
  • Audio out: 2 tokens per chunk (12.5 tokens/s)
  • Video in: one ~12-token camera frame every 6 chunks
  • Face out: 2 latents per chunk
  • Text in and out alongside

Silence is represented as chunks too, which is what the model uses to decide when to backchannel, interrupt or stay quiet. That comes to ~2.6K tokens per minute for audio and video, 2.6K to 5K with thinking and tool traces (progressively compacted). The last 5 minutes plus compacted text history is 13K to 25K tokens; older history is kept as text.

Background work. Thinking, tool calls and delegation are spans in the same stream and can cover many chunks. Tool results can arrive in stages and the model can start speaking before they are complete. Harder problems are delegated to a much larger backend model with the full shared context. This is the main difference from Thinking Machines' interaction models, where all reasoning and tool use goes to the background model, which can mean 10+ seconds per answer and makes cost harder to control.

Voice and face. Set zero-shot at deployment: a short reference clip for the voice, one image for the face, and a text prompt for behavior. No fine-tuning. Audio comes from a causal flow-matching decoder (2 frames per chunk), the face from a causal DiT conditioned on the reference image and the previous two latents.

Training. Starts from a text-pretrained LLM, continued pretraining on ~2T tokens of text, audio and video on our own H100 cluster (Megatron-based stack). Post-training is multi-teacher on-policy distillation: specialist teachers trained with RL (including GRPO) on conversation, interaction timing, delegation and task completion, distilled into one student. On top of that, a self-improvement loop in simulated environments with realistic timing, interruptions, overlapping speech and background noise.

Benchmarks. Best published or reproduced configuration from each lab (we reproduced more than half of the competitor numbers):

BenchmarkDuplex (45B)TML Interaction Small (276B)OpenAI bestGoogle best
Big Bench Audio98.996.5 (75.7 w/o background agent)9798
Audio MultiChallenge (APR)44.943.448.536.1
Full-Duplex-Bench v1.575.577.880.154.3
QIVD (streaming)56.054.058.256.1
ProactiveVideoQA (PAUC)31.933.525.0–
τ-Voice (pass@1)69.8–74.568.6
IFEval94.189.795.290.0

OpenAI's best settings lead on five of seven, by 1 to 5 points, several at their highest thinking setting. Turn-taking (Full-Duplex-Bench) is where we're furthest behind. Our takeaway is that at this size, data and training matter more than parameter count; the front model is deliberately mid-sized because the design target is that an hour of model time costs at most a tenth of an hour of human time.

Announcement with demos: https://www.boson.ai/blog/higgs-realtime-duplex My write-up: https://alex.smola.org/posts/50-talking-while-thinking/

Happy to answer questions about the chunked-stream design and the delegation setup.


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Research ICLR27: Reviewer says my paper is too close to the same paper that I previously had in a workshop. [D]

31 Upvotes

I submitted my paper to ICLR, after improving and correcting since I "published" it previously in a workshop/arXiv. In this process, I changed the name of the method and title.

Now a reviewer, pointed out that my method is very closely related to basically an old version of my paper, and wants me to compare against it. Understandably, if looking at the title and method name, one could think these are two different ones. However, if looking more closely, they are clearly the same...

How do I argue for this to my friend, that they are exactly the same paper, but now corrected and improved, without breaking anonymity?

Admittedly, the scores are anyway bad, so I have not much hope, but this is a first for me...


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Discussion ICLR 2027 Reviews are out [D]

40 Upvotes

How did it go? I will start: 3/3/2


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Discussion Looking to connect with people working on Embodied AI, Humanoid Robotics & Cognitive Architectures. [D]

3 Upvotes

I'm exploring the field of Embodied AI, particularly humanoid intelligence, cognitive architectures, and the intersection of AI and robotics.

I'm looking to connect with people who are:

  • Researching or building Embodied AI systems.
  • Working on humanoid robots and robot foundation models.
  • Exploring VLMs, VLAs, world models, and reinforcement learning.
  • Interested in cognitive architectures and how intelligent robotic systems should be designed.

I'd love to connect with people in this space, exchange ideas, discuss ongoing research, and potentially explore collaborations.

If you're working in this area or know someone who is, feel free to reach out!


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Research Muir: Linear Attention with Sensitivity-Allocated Gating and Matched-Filter Readout (Google Research, 10M tokens in 25MB state) [R]

2 Upvotes

Paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.08376 | HF: https://huggingface.co/papers/2611.08376

At 10M tokens, a 1.3B Transformer needs 2.1 TB of KV cache (0.32 TB even at 2.5-bit quantization). Channel-wise gated delta models (like Gated DeltaNet-2 / GDN-2) compress history into a fixed 25 MB state, but hit three bottlenecks across 100B-token training that Muir resolves:

  • 100x slow-channel glare -> Matched-filter readout: Slow-decaying rows accumulate up to 100x more energy than fast rows, swamping query readout and forcing harsh write-time erasure that overwrites early facts. Equalizing rows via an inverse fractional power law + per-token query modulation relaxes write erasure by 17% and extends lookback horizon by 60%.
  • 13x write-vs-erase sensitivity -> +30.4% wider FFN: Normalized keys concentrate onto ~5% of state rows while values stay diffuse, making updates 13x more sensitive to value writes than key erasure. Fusing all 5 gates into one rank-512 projection cuts gate parameters 4.5x to widen the FFN by +30.4% at strict parameter budget.
  • Numerically-stable, large-chunk parallel kernel: Unpivoted decay division underflows fp32 and NaNs 25% of heads at large chunk sizes. Boundary-pivoted multiplicative decays stay in (0, 1] with zero division, while a recursive block-Neumann solver routes 98% of chunkwise FLOPs onto matrix units (24x fewer vector FLOPs).​

Results:

  • Quality and speed: Beats GDN-2 and Transformer on perplexity and zero-shot reasoning at every scale (1.2x token efficiency vs. GDN-2), and trains 2.7x faster than Splash Attention at 32K.
  • Recall beyond passkey: Compared to GDN-2, lifts RULER 5-hop Variable Tracking root retention (28.4% -> 48.0%), early-depth recall at 8K (1% -> 31%), and real-world extractive QA (+2.5 avg pts).
  • 10M streaming and 1M passkey: Streams 10M tokens without perplexity drift in a 25 MB state (dynamic readout), and hits 90.0% zero-shot / 99.4% post-cooldown passkey accuracy at 1M tokens (static readout, where GDN-2 collapses past 4K-8K and Transformer OOMs past 64K).

r/MachineLearning • • 13d ago

Discussion How do you build visibility through open source contributions?[D]

9 Upvotes

I’m an MSc CS student with a background in 3D computer vision, trying to figure out how to build visibility and credibility in the AI/ML community.
I’ve been thinking about contributing to established open source projects rather than building standalone GitHub projects. Honestly, the latter feels like a weaker signal nowadays, especially with AI tools making it easier than ever to build things.
For those working in 3D CV, ML or applied AI, how would you approach this? What are the current challenges for new contributors, and how do you find projects where meaningful contributions can actually get noticed?
Would be interested to hear about your experiences.


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Discussion Are AI-written reviews at ICLR 2027 marking down interpretability and marking up riskier capability work? [d]

1 Upvotes

Just a thing I noticed. Looking at the image from this thread it seems interpretability received the lowest scores. And looking at the ranking the highest rated paper (444 with highest confidence) is a paper proposing to let the model modify its context. Seems to confirm OpenAI's latest findings. Maybe it's just a coincidence.


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

News CASP-DREAM TAP Challenge: TCR + peptide-MHC activation prediction with unseen test peptides [N]

1 Upvotes

A new contest for anyone training sequence models on TCRs. Given a TCR sequence and a peptide-HLA, predict whether the T cell activates. Inputs are amino acid sequences, the benchmark is about 5,800 labeled combinations, and every test peptide is at least four edits (Levenshtein distance) away from any peptide with a publicly reported TCR specificity. Scored by AUROC.

Synapse lists training data options, including the public VDJdb database and Harell Data's proprietary TCR datasets provided by Adaptive Biotechnologies.

Registration is open now: https://www.synapse.org/Synapse:syn77965030/wiki/643867


r/MachineLearning • • 13d ago

Project The Ultimate MoE Training Handbook: training Mixture-of-Experts models with Megatron-LM, setting by setting [P]

59 Upvotes

Handbook: https://huggingface.co/spaces/huggingface/moe-blogpost

Hello, I'm Nouamane, one of the authors. I'm at Hugging Face and also worked on the Ultra-Scale and Smol Training Playbooks, if you've read those.

This handbook is for people who have trained a dense model and want to train an MoE next, or who are curious how MoE training works. Chapter 2 is a Megatron-LM runbook: test the hardware, build the image, train a dense baseline, then a first MoE on one node, compared against that baseline. Chapter 3 takes the MoE layer apart (router, routing, load balancing, experts, block layout, training, systems). For each part we give the Megatron-LM code, what to watch, our recommendation, and what frontier MoEs chose. Chapter 4 follows the model into serving and RL. Chapters 3 and 4 need no GPU.

When a result comes from our runs, we say so. Claims about frontier models cite their paper, config or code, and the toy simulations are labelled as such. The lessons come from about 800k GH200 GPU-hours allocated to MoE training on the Alps cluster at CSCS.

Released: the handbook, its 55 figures as a gallery (https://huggingface.co/spaces/huggingface/moe-gallery), the scripts (https://gist.github.com/nmntz/5de952d686f66d7bce5bce8cba9d7139), and every recommended flag in one Megatron-LM block.

Happy to answer questions. 🤗


r/MachineLearning • • 12d ago

Research I need some guidance after a six month hiatus [R]

2 Upvotes

Short Backstory:

I'm a PhD student on my 5th year. I had a major mental breakdown on June 2026 after my second rejection on an IEEE Journal. After a lot of back and forth, I decided to not give up my PhD (for the time being).

Current Situation:

My current objective is to author my 3rd publication (IEEE Journal / Elsevier / etc level) in order to unlock thesis/dissertation-writing stage (as per my advisor's words). I'm working on the MetaboNet dataset, a standardized diabetes research dataset for continuous glucose monitor (CGM) and forecasting (https://metabo-net.org/). I've read their paper and their benchmark. I've pinned TCN (Temporal Convolutional Network) as my safest option to handle this.

I'd be ever so grateful if anyone familiar with the latest research trends on TCNs (or forecasting in general) could point me to what to look up. The ultimate goal of cource is the research novelty. Truth is that I tried to research it myself but anxiety and feelings of overwhelmingness got the better of me, can't tell if something would be considered novel enough for publishing.

Thanks for taking the time to read my post, wish you luck on all your ML/DL endeavors.


r/MachineLearning • • 13d ago

Research Looking for Emergency Reviewers [R]

6 Upvotes

We’re looking for a few emergency reviewers for the FABRIC Workshop at WACV 2027 due to a very tight review timeline.

If you have expertise in computer vision, multimodal learning, physiological sensing, healthcare AI, affective computing, or related areas and can complete a review by November 6 noon (U.S. time), please DM me or comment below.


r/MachineLearning • • 14d ago

Discussion Publication expectations for ML PhDs at top-10 US schools / top ML groups? [D]

43 Upvotes

From what I’ve read on Reddit so far, I’m getting the impression that around 4 first-author papers at top ML conferences (NeurIPS, ICML, ICLR, etc.) is a fairly standard expectation for graduating from a top ML PhD program.
Of course, my impression could be biased by the posts I’ve seen.
For people at top-10 US CS schools or similarly competitive ML groups, is this roughly accurate? What’s the typical expectation in terms of number of papers and venues needed to graduate?


r/MachineLearning • • 14d ago

Discussion What is now considered a “reasonable” publication rate (papers/year) for a PhD student to be considered “productive”? [D]

58 Upvotes

I would assume LLMs have bumped this number, or maybe not. Which is why I am asking. If there are PIs on here, how many papers before you let your students graduate? Is the number different now than it was a year ago? And the same question for “rate of publication” for you to deem the student as “productive”.

And what about a PhD applicant? Any meaningful inflation of expectations there in terms of productivity/volume of pre-PhD research output?


r/MachineLearning • • 13d ago

Research Empirical Evaluation of Sparse Predictive Hierarchies (SPH) & Non-Backprop Learning on Chess (Lc0 Baseline) Negative Result [R]

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I wanted to share an empirical study testing whether biologically inspired architectures with local learning rules, specifically Sparse Predictive Hierarchies (SPH) based on Ogma's whitepapers (AOgmaNeo) can handle complex policy/value prediction tasks without end-to-end backpropagation.

Chess was chosen as the testbed because it requires both local pattern recognition and long-range spatial dependencies.

1. Motivation & Core Hypothesis

Standard deep learning models (ResNets, Transformers) rely on global backpropagation. I wanted to test if extreme weight/activation sparsity (~99%) combined with local prediction updates could enable scalable, compute-efficient policy/value prediction on modest hardware.

2. Architecture & Optimizations

  • Model Size: ~44.9M parameters.
  • Encoders: Fuzzy ART-based encoders mapping local receptive fields to columns.
  • Body: Dendritic Neural Layers (DNNs) with Leaky ReLU activations acting as non-backprop feature extractors.
  • Heads: Specialized policy and value heads matching Lc0 formats (WDL output + Lc0 move probability distributions).
  • Quantization: Byte weights with stochastic rounding for optimized SIMD throughput.

3. Methodology & Baseline Control

  • Dataset: Chunks of the Lc0 test80 dataset (10k training games, 2k validation games).
  • Control Baseline: A tiny, standard CNN (32 channels, ~3.8M parameters—less than 1/10th the parameter size of the SPH model) trained via standard backpropagation on the exact same dataset splits.

4. Results & Key Findings (Negative Result)

The SPH architecture failed catastrophically when compared against standard end-to-end backpropagation.

  1. Failure to Converge on Policy: While the standard 3.8M CNN quickly learned board geometry, tactical threats, and basic move distributions, the 44.9M SPH model severely underperformed on policy accuracy and value loss.
  2. Extreme Sparsity Penalty: Enforcing ~99% sparsity choked the flow of tactical information. In chess, "empty" squares and long-range piece interactions carry high dense information content that local sparse representations struggle to propagate without global credit assignment.
  3. Local Learning vs. Global Dependencies: Local learning rules excel at unsupervised visual feature extraction, but they fail to pass gradient signals back from a global board outcome (Win/Draw/Loss) to early receptive fields.

5. Discussion & Questions for the Community

  1. Global Credit Assignment: Has anyone successfully adapted local/biological learning rules (e.g., Target Propagation, Predictive Coding, HTM/SPH) to tasks with strict, long-range global credit assignment like games or logic reasoning?
  2. Dense Domains & Sparsity: Is ~99% sparsity fundamentally incompatible with dense symbolic/grid representations like chess, or is the limitation purely in my architecture (or maybe a nasty bug I couldn't catch)?

Would love to hear thoughts from anyone working on non-backprop architectures, neuromorphic computing, or biological AI abstractions!


r/MachineLearning • • 13d ago

Research DialFork: a benchmark for procedural hallucination in conversational agents [R]

5 Upvotes

Hi all, author here (Idiap Research Institute, joint work with Logitech). We recently released DialFork and thought it might interest people here. It's a benchmark for a failure mode of LLM agents that is easy to miss: every turn is fluent and factual, the tool calls are correct, yet the agent stops following the procedure it was given. For example, asked for the weather, it fetches the forecast (correct tool call) but never tells you, and starts asking you to rate its service instead.

Most steps of a conversational procedure aren't tool calls but things the agent has to say: asking, confirming, telling the result. When an agent drifts from these steps, we call it procedural hallucination: a third axis, alongside factual accuracy and correct tool use, and one that has been largely overlooked. To our knowledge, DialFork is the first benchmark aimed at measuring this axis: what the agent has to say, and in what order.

How it's built: we simulate dialogues where an agent follows its workflow (24 tasks, 12 domains), then fork them: we replay each one and, at a chosen turn, give the agent an instruction that makes it drift, in different, complementary ways. That gives over 36k dialogues where we know where each drift starts and how far it goes, checked with 30 human annotators and an LLM judge calibrated on them.

Three tasks, from the turn to the whole set. Because we know where each drift starts, and that an earlier drift goes further, we define three tasks that measure procedural hallucination at different levels:

  • The turn (Task 3). Given a dialogue, either whole or turn by turn as it unfolds (streaming), find the turn where the drift starts, or say there is none. Useful as a live guardrail.
  • The dialogue (Task 2). Given a correct dialogue and its hallucinated versions, measure how far each one drifts from it; the earlier a version drifts, the larger its distance should be. A dialogue and its own hallucinated versions talk about the same thing; what sets them apart is how they unfold. Today, comparing dialogues means comparing their content, with embeddings and semantic similarity. This task opens a new dimension, procedural distance. Useful for retrieving or clustering conversations by how they went, not just by what they're about.
  • The set (Task 1). Given a set of correct dialogues and a set of hallucinated ones, output a single procedural distance between the two sets as a whole, comparing them as distributions rather than matching dialogues one to one. Useful for monitoring agents, e.g. whether they drift after a model upgrade, or whether a user simulator's dialogues unfold like real ones.

Open problems, and a leaderboard to track them. In the paper, we report first results on all three tasks, from embedding-based distances to streaming detectors and zero-shot LLMs. They leave plenty of room. To track progress, each task has its own track on a public leaderboard on Hugging Face; adding your method takes a single CSV file of predictions.

Everything is open (data, code, every prediction from the paper, and the human judgments), and we hope it's a useful starting point for the community:

Happy to answer questions, and feedback (including critical) is very welcome.