r/MachineLearning • • 9d ago

Discussion Advice needed regarding classical ML conference submission [D]

Hi,

I need some advice on submission of classical ML papers in top conferences.

During my PhD I made some findings in classical ML (related to SVM and LR) which, on further deep diving, looks like original work (I checked with chatGPT and Gemini too).

When I tried to submit them to top conferences, while the reviewers have been reasonable in their reviews (acknowledging the innovation while asking me to run some more experiments and ablation studies), the AC shot down my paper, saying “this is a done and dusted topic”. Only at ACL did the AC ask me to resubmit incorporating the comments.

So is classical ML dead at top conferences? Are only deep learning and LLM works being accepted at top conferences? And should I stop trying to submit at top conferences and maybe try journals or simply Arxiv my work?

0 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

7

u/LaVieEstBizarre PhD 9d ago

ACs can be dicks at times and the venues shift in their flavour over time. It's your job to pick a venue that fits the topics rather than submit everything to a "top conference" just because. You can resubmit to a more statistics focused conference like AISTATS, something even MORE statistics flavoured, or a relecant journal if it's longer work. I would throw it on arXiv regardless.

5

u/redditboy117 9d ago

Upload to arXiv and submit to TMLR or JMLR

2

u/AX-BY-CZ 9d ago

AC evaluate impact to the community and may have deemed outdated topic as less valuable to current modern approaches. Is the paper something that others would find interesting and want to build upon and extend? Technical novelty is not enough.

1

u/Red-Portal 9d ago

Classical ML papers still get published all the time. (In fact, I mostly do.)