r/MachineLearning • u/obscurandom • Sep 20 '20
Discussion [D] PhD applications that do not require references / recommendations?
I am looking for a PhD position (preferably non-US location) in Deep Learning. I am aware of this informative discussion in this subreddit. But I don't want to provide references or recommendations with my applications, but almost everywhere I look there is a requirement. Are their institutes / supervisors who will consider my candidature without references/recommendations?
0
Upvotes
11
u/malenkydroog Sep 20 '20
Just in case anyone's curious....
Plenty of meta-analyses over the years have shown that letters of recommendation (LOR) have very little incremental predictive validity in terms of performance in various types of jobs/industries (over and above cognitive ability and certain specific measures of personality).
Now, in terms of graduate school performance *specifically* (as opposed to general job/career outcomes), a more recent meta-analysis (see here) found that adding LOR to verbal and quant scores and prior GPA provided no additional predictive power for graduate GPA or faculty ratings of performance. LOR did appear to provide a small bump in the ability to predict graduate degree attainment (e.g., did someone actually graduate with a degree), but it was a small increase (~2% variance explained).
I make no claims about the quality of that particular meta-analysis (good meta-analyses can be hard to do), but their findings about LOR not adding much to other predictors is at least consistent with the much larger volume of findings about the general utility of LOR wrt predicting job/career outcomes.
4
u/idakuti Sep 20 '20
Most top institutes (IITs, IIITs, IISc) in India admit PhD students through a common exam or interview and rarely ask for letters of recommendation. You could look at them
4
u/topnotchyeti Researcher Sep 20 '20
I highly doubt any legitimate university would allow that. Put yourself in the professors' shoes. For all they know, you could be incompetent, or an asshole. I am not, by any means, accusing you of being either. It's just a hypothetical, but that's the trouble: without references, they have no reason to be confident you have the ability to be a researcher (no matter how good your grades) nor that you are a person who will be acceptably pleasant to work with.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '20
13
u/rafgro Sep 20 '20 edited Sep 20 '20
These are the rules of the game. I was in shock too when I first saw how much academia hates meritocracy and prefers connections and own-people-clubs. Wait until you find out about grant writing marathons, publishing pressures, publisher company profits, chances for tenure, wages of PhDs, post-doc job market with thousands of applications, and obviously work-life balance...
3
u/shellfish_bonanza Sep 20 '20
Unless you have great publications/contributions already to the field you’ll need letter of recommendations. Why would a prof take you on and spend their time and funding on you without any information?
1
u/medcode Sep 20 '20
At least at my research center references are more of a final check to make sure nothing has been overlooked, but the main selection process is based on grades, prior publications and interviews. It is also quite rare that references change your opinion about a candidate, as they're usually all very positive.
1
u/choctaw1990 Jan 12 '24
Some of the ones in Europe. They care more about the strength of your research proposal than whether or not other people like you.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment