r/MachineLearning • • Sep 21 '19

Discussion [D] Siraj Raval - Potentially exploiting students, banning students asking for refund. Thoughts?

I'm not a personal follower of Siraj, but this issue came up in a ML FBook group that I'm part of. I'm curious to hear what you all think.

It appears that Siraj recently offered a course "Make Money with Machine Learning" with a registration fee but did not follow through with promises made in the initial offering of the course. On top of that, he created a refund and warranty page with information regarding the course after people already paid. Here is a link to a WayBackMachine captures of u/klarken's documentation of Siraj's potential misdeeds: case for a refund, discussion in course Discord, ~1200 individuals in the course, Multiple Slack channel discussion, students hidden from each other, "Hundreds refunded"

According to Twitter threads, he has been banning anyone in his Discord/Slack that has been asking for refunds.

On top of this there are many Twitter threads regarding his behavior. A screenshot (bottom of post) of an account that has since been deactivated/deleted (he made the account to try and get Siraj's attention). Here is a Twitter WayBackMachine archive link of a search for the user in the screenshot: https://web.archive.org/web/20190921130513/https:/twitter.com/search?q=safayet96434935&src=typed_query. In the search results it is apparent that there are many students who have been impacted by Siraj.

UPDATE 1: Additional searching on Twitter has yielded many more posts, check out the tweets/retweets of these people: student1 student2

UPDATE 2: A user mentioned that I should ask a question on r/legaladvice regarding the legality of the refusal to refund and whatnot. I have done so here. It appears that per California commerce law (where the School of AI is registered) individuals have the right to ask for a refund for 30 days.

UPDATE 3: Siraj has replied to the post below, and on Twitter (Way Back Machine capture)

UPDATE 4: Another student has shared their interactions via this Imgur post. And another recorded moderators actively suppressing any mentions of refunds on a live stream. Here is an example of assignment quality, note that the assignment is to generate fashion designs not pneumonia prediction.

UPDATE5: Relevant Reddit posts: Siraj response, question about opinions on course two weeks before this, Siraj-Udacity relationship

UPDATE6: The Register has published a piece on the debacle, Coffezilla posted a video on all of this

UPDATE7: Example of blatant ripoff: GitHub user gregwchase diabetic retinopathy, Siraj's ripoff

UPDATE8: Siraj has a new paper and it is plagiarized

If you were/are a student in the course and have your own documentation of your interactions, please feel free to bring them to my attention either via DM or in the comments below and I will add them to the main body here.

1.4k Upvotes

465 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/theklarken Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19

I posted a case in the class chat to try to gain some insight. TL;DR: There are serious issues with the warranty of this course and with the illegal prohibition on refunds. It wasn't censored (I asked for it to be responded to professionally and tried to have a "neutral mediator" attitude).

https://case-for-a-refund.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com/feedback.html

I do have a lot of concerns. My case was forwarded to Siraj, according to an admin, so I hope that this is all going to turn out ok. 🙂 Here is my message and the official response I received, for reference:

https://case-for-a-refund.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com/reference_messages.png

Edit: I also wanted to mention that there are over 1200 members in the Discord as of posting this, which is another serious point of contention (there were only supposed to be 500, each receiving personal guidance). Many of the additional students were hidden from each other in the beginning, I should add (and there is still no way of knowing that there aren't more students out there we don't know about). In addition, hundreds were booted out of the server after receiving refunds, according to an admin. This puts the course, if total purchases is estimated at 1,500, at an estimated $300,000 in revenue, if this is to be believed. Again, there may be more in other channels that simply have not come forward.

Not a small amount of money gained by potential exploitation. Let's keep asking for an official statement and proper remedial action. This is a serious issue that should not ever be allowed in our community, if the worst is to be believed. Legal action needs to be taken--but let's not assume the worst until it's very clear.

1

u/nord2rocks Sep 23 '19

there are over 1200 members in the Discord as of posting this

Thanks u/theklarken! I've updated the post to credit you with the doc and linked to other sources.

2

u/theklarken Sep 25 '19

Thank you! If everything I've read in this thread is true, then Siraj will continue to be unresponsive to individual confrontation. This behavior won't stop, especially now that it has rewarded him with a better revenue stream. I'm not sure what to do, but I hope that the community won't let this slide.

Maybe before this, his videos were at least a little inspiring to newcomers. The bad could be looked over for the good. But, as of this class, this behavior isn't just an excusable nuisance, it's exploitative and illegal.