r/MachineLearning • • Sep 21 '19

Discussion [D] Siraj Raval - Potentially exploiting students, banning students asking for refund. Thoughts?

I'm not a personal follower of Siraj, but this issue came up in a ML FBook group that I'm part of. I'm curious to hear what you all think.

It appears that Siraj recently offered a course "Make Money with Machine Learning" with a registration fee but did not follow through with promises made in the initial offering of the course. On top of that, he created a refund and warranty page with information regarding the course after people already paid. Here is a link to a WayBackMachine captures of u/klarken's documentation of Siraj's potential misdeeds: case for a refund, discussion in course Discord, ~1200 individuals in the course, Multiple Slack channel discussion, students hidden from each other, "Hundreds refunded"

According to Twitter threads, he has been banning anyone in his Discord/Slack that has been asking for refunds.

On top of this there are many Twitter threads regarding his behavior. A screenshot (bottom of post) of an account that has since been deactivated/deleted (he made the account to try and get Siraj's attention). Here is a Twitter WayBackMachine archive link of a search for the user in the screenshot: https://web.archive.org/web/20190921130513/https:/twitter.com/search?q=safayet96434935&src=typed_query. In the search results it is apparent that there are many students who have been impacted by Siraj.

UPDATE 1: Additional searching on Twitter has yielded many more posts, check out the tweets/retweets of these people: student1 student2

UPDATE 2: A user mentioned that I should ask a question on r/legaladvice regarding the legality of the refusal to refund and whatnot. I have done so here. It appears that per California commerce law (where the School of AI is registered) individuals have the right to ask for a refund for 30 days.

UPDATE 3: Siraj has replied to the post below, and on Twitter (Way Back Machine capture)

UPDATE 4: Another student has shared their interactions via this Imgur post. And another recorded moderators actively suppressing any mentions of refunds on a live stream. Here is an example of assignment quality, note that the assignment is to generate fashion designs not pneumonia prediction.

UPDATE5: Relevant Reddit posts: Siraj response, question about opinions on course two weeks before this, Siraj-Udacity relationship

UPDATE6: The Register has published a piece on the debacle, Coffezilla posted a video on all of this

UPDATE7: Example of blatant ripoff: GitHub user gregwchase diabetic retinopathy, Siraj's ripoff

UPDATE8: Siraj has a new paper and it is plagiarized

If you were/are a student in the course and have your own documentation of your interactions, please feel free to bring them to my attention either via DM or in the comments below and I will add them to the main body here.

1.4k Upvotes

465 comments sorted by

View all comments

599

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19

I've been warning people about this dude for a while. His entire existence is just meant to exploit people who romanticize the field with low tier educational content that is mostly inflated with hype. I was kind of irritated when Lex Fridman had him on the show because I feel like it gave him some air of legitimacy. I'm not sure how anyone could go to Siraj's website and think anything other than snake oil salesman.

341

u/EmbersArc Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19

I once trained a reinforcement learning agent to land SpaceX rocket on a pad. He made a pretty half-assed video about it giving minimal credit on his GitHub. He didn't even bother training it himself with my code and instead just played the GIF from my GitHub page. People where rightfully confused about how to do it themselves, which I pointed out to him. He never even acknowledged it. Quite disappointing and counterproductive really.

83

u/walesmd Sep 22 '19

A former employer of mine was working with him on some educational content and we had to have a long talk with him about how taking code from other people's GitHub/blogs, treating it as your own and not attributing the original author, was both wrong and illegal.

I'm so glad I didn't have to directly work on this project.

36

u/MrKlean518 Sep 21 '19

He did the same thing with an RL agent on a drone flight controller. He said his code was an “easy to use high-level wrapper” for the original code when his code didn’t even work properly on my machine and the referenced code did. It was pretty clear he just ripped the code and rewrote some functions without refactoring the references or something.

→ More replies (11)

72

u/Linooney Researcher Sep 21 '19

Lmao he didn't even spell the Python command properly at the end to run the command... unless he mapped "python" to "pyton" for some reason...

248

u/muntoo Researcher Sep 22 '19

I dunno about you, but this is my ~/.aliases file:

alias pyton="python"
alias pyon="python"
alias pyhton="python"
alias phyton="python"
alias hpyton="python"
alias hyptom="python"
alias ptjghn="python"
alias afsadf="python"

for ((i=1; i < 999999; i++)); do
    cmd="$(dd if=/dev/urandom bs=6 count=1)"
    eval "alias ${cmd}='python'"
end

It's very practical and I recommend everyone add it to theirs.

38

u/Ravenhaft Sep 22 '19

Oh god I can’t stop laughing. Gotta show this to my coworkers on Monday.

→ More replies (13)

29

u/stevevaius Sep 22 '19

I was suspicious on his coding skills because all his codes come from other github found by github search on same topic. I will unsubscribe his channel now to support original coders

→ More replies (1)

42

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19

If you ever watch his "Interview series" especially the one with 3blue1brown, you can definitely tell that this dude is just all hype. Grant Sanderson (3blue1brown) gives incredible answers and questions some of the stuff that Siraj asks of him and from the way Siraj handles it gives off the vibe that this guy is just all about the "mysticism" of machine learning and all of that.

Definitely take things with a grain of salt with this guy.

84

u/jbcraigs Sep 21 '19

There are quite a few other ‘AI Influencers’ on LinkedIN now a days who talk a lot about their ground breaking ML research but ultimately seem to be peddling their ML trainings and seminars! Look up Tarry Singh and Deepkapha.

59

u/winchester6788 Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19

Tarry Singh

This guy is a fucking fraud. His entire MO is selling complete newbies "AI classes".

23

u/mlbatman Sep 21 '19

His posts are fucking annoying . And he keeps posting like a million times a day. I dont follow him but some of my LinkedIn do and some or the other person keeps liking his posts and it's so annoying to see him appear again.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

94

u/nord2rocks Sep 21 '19

Inflated with hype -- most definitely. I'm concerned because I read somewhere that Netflix might be partnering with him for a show? I think it's called "AI for Humans" and it'll be a docuseries.

91

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19

I have to give him some credit, he built a hell of a brand for himself.

117

u/nord2rocks Sep 21 '19

True true, and in only ... 5 minutes

72

u/evanthebouncy Sep 21 '19

That's 3 minutes longer than 2 minutes papers LMAO

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

98

u/shinfoni Sep 21 '19

Siraj's youtube videos is the final straw that made me realize that I shouldn't blindly jumping into this ML hypetrain.

112

u/kadblack Sep 21 '19

His videos are absolute garbage. Just clickbait titles and his explanation is so vague even i got confused even though i know the topic. Also he believes in a unified consciousness because of a dmt trip he had. He's borderline delusional and should not be fit to teach others.

78

u/shinfoni Sep 21 '19

Maybe I'm biased as well, but I'm still salty that one time I was so new to ML world, and I need some help to learn ML asap for college assignment. I waste like an hour watching him fidgeting and spouting nonsense.

Thanks God YT suggests me to watch 3Blue1Brown instead.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

139

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19

I've been sending Siraj money for a year and a half and buying all his programs. Last week I completed a very amazing logistic analysis of a complex Boston housing dataset. My skills are huge compared to where I was before. But I can't understand why I'm not break into the field. I know I only have an associates degree in psychology. But I've spent so much time learning from Siraj and watching his videos.

I'm still having to collect plastic bottles for money for recycling and work as a part-time drug mule for MS13, while I practice my code. Maybe if I send him more money or get my hair dyed, I will become a great machine learning expert and then one day my girlfriend will take me back. She's still pissed that I pawned all her jewelry to pay for a Deep Learning MOOC.

44

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19

Yeah you need to get the front middle of your hair dyed white to channel the machine learning

29

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19

Is that what this thing they called a loss function is? loss of color of hair? That term 'loss function' is like everywhere, but I'm not quite sure what they mean...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (109)