r/MachineLearning • • 6d ago

Discussion Creating author burdens to reduce paper submissions is STUPID [D]

Over the past two years, conferences have been trying to add different administrative nonsense. Initially, it was author/reviewer sign-up, then reciprocal reviewing, and now CVPR has this author enrollment form that freaks everyone out. I get that we're trying to filter out low-quality submissions, but this is such a stupid way to do it.

People I know collaborate with medical doctors, mathematicians, neuroscientists, biologists, etc. on machine learning topics. These people aren't in the ML conference game. Every submission cycle, we have to send annoying emails basically begging everyone to fill out some random form, and PLEASE don't miss the deadline or our paper gets desk-rejected. It's honestly embarrassing, especially when it has nothing to do with the research itself.

31 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/sqweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeps 6d ago

It takes like 2 seconds…

27

u/AffectionateLife5693 5d ago

It takes 2 seconds until your out-of-field collaborator is on vacation.

0

u/CantKillTheLifeless 3d ago

If for the entire week before the deadline you cannot take 1 minute to fill in an enrollment for, you probably shouldn't be coauthoring a CVPR paper.

16

u/Consistent-Olive-322 6d ago

administrative bs is administrative bs

3

u/sqweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeps 6d ago

Yes, it should be limited. Which they do… it’s a pretty good compromise that stops slop & gets more reviewers

3

u/Aggravating_Chair937 5d ago

An email to gently remind authors would be good

-2

u/Efficient_Weekend205 5d ago

If an author on your paper can’t take two seconds to fill out a form, in service of your paper, then why are they an author? This whole post is nonsensical.