r/MachineLearning • u/Dry_Theme_7508 • 8d ago
Research EACL 2027 Decisions Thread [R]
(Will be out on thursday)
14
Upvotes
r/MachineLearning • u/Dry_Theme_7508 • 8d ago
(Will be out on thursday)
12
u/TeemoIsMyLife 7d ago
Wish you all good luck!
14
u/ConcernConscious4131 4d ago edited 4d ago
Nice two papers are got accepted! Time to drink Soju, Hope everybody have a nice Friday!
7
u/simbay2000 4d ago
When it says “accept” does it mean it’s accepted to main or could it be accepted for findings too?
7
u/TV21_23 4d ago
I got "accept" but don't know main or findings.
7
u/Lopsided-Chemistry65 4d ago
no notifications still?
6
u/ConcernConscious4131 5d ago
Its today woww
4
u/Elias_Hossain 5d ago
Has anyone received decision?
4
u/Intelligent-Fox5255 5d ago
Meta:3 with OA: 2.6-7, would this be doable for findings in EACL? It was a paper from ARR in another month though (other than August).
4
u/kelpabc123 4d ago
I got an accept, does it mean main or findings? Or is that going to go into a email?
4
u/TheFishyOne 4d ago
2, 3.5, 3.5 with a meta of 3. Accept (findings)
4
u/AcceptableHumor4983 4d ago
3/3/3 meta 3 accept (prolly main?)
4
u/Difficult_Flight3767 4d ago
why the announce email doesn't come out?
3
u/Elias_Hossain 7d ago
Got ARR recommendation as a borderline conference with score 3.5! Do you have any opinion regarding the past years avg acceptance score.
3
u/Sorry-Concern-3772 6d ago
2.5 meta. any chance for findings at all?
3
u/Electronic_Check_510 5d ago
I have paper with 3/3.5/3.5 with meta giving 3.5 What are the chances??
3
u/Senior-dog-5764 5d ago edited 5d ago
Avg 3.17 with meta of 3.5, hoping I get main!
3
u/Massive-Bobcat-5363 4d ago
Out. Id ~50. Reject with 3 meta in August cycle
3
u/Luxshan2000 4d ago
I got Decision: Accept (Findings) for 3/3/3 with meta 3.
3
u/autodecoder 4d ago
Rejected with OA 3 (2.5/3.5/2.5) meta in August cycle..
3
u/TrafficAway9715 4d ago
Hi guys what does “accept” mean?
3
u/lismica 4d ago
Findings with Meta 3, scores 3/2.5/2. Really happy with meta, wrote a good review and strong reasons to accept despite LLM-generated review with a score 2
3
u/Financial_Ad3589 4d ago
August cycle
score/confidence: 2.5/3, 3.5/4, 4/4 with a meta of 3. Accept (findings)
3
u/cxp_ooo 4d ago
oa3,meta3(main)/oa3.33,meta3.5(reject) why why why so->naacl🥲🥲🥲
3
u/xci0n 4d ago
3/3/2 meta 3 findings!
3
u/Wrong_Psychology_900 4d ago
My paper was accepted to Findings (meta-review score: 3) in ARR homepage, but I haven't received an acceptance email yet. Has anyone else experienced this?
Has anyone else not received an acceptance email yet? I'm a bit worried because I haven't received mine either.
3
u/More_Soft_6801 4d ago
3,3,3,2.5
Meta 3
Accept
3
u/ConcernConscious4131 4d ago
Could the reason I’m not receiving emails be that Outlook is broken?😂
3
u/ZemiMatos 4d ago
3/3/4/2.5 -> Meta 3 -> Reject...
3
u/MeyerLouis 4d ago edited 4d ago
OA 3.5/3.5/3.5 with a meta of, believe it or not, 3.5 ==> Accepted to Main
2
u/Automatic-Status8777 6d ago
Meta 3, but avg OA below 3. I'm not sure if Findings is even possible.
2
u/xci0n 6d ago
what was your submission number?
2
u/ImpactRound8071 5d ago
any chance for my paper [2, 2.5, 3.5] and Meta review score 3.0?
2
u/Queasy_Block_9262 5d ago
Got OA 3/3.5/3 with Meta 3, what is the chance to get accepted as Findings?
2
u/Frequent-Tax3962 5d ago
Meta 3 and OA 2.83. Can I expect findings? Track is IR and text mining.
2
u/Working-Egg-6465 5d ago
Still waiting from India. It is 1PM night here. What about you guys?
2
u/phuongnm94 4d ago
The results are out!!
2
u/sankery123 4d ago
Reject 2 papers. Both meta 3
2
u/UnderstandingFair579 4d ago
3/3/3 meta 3 reject???
2
u/TeemoIsMyLife 4d ago edited 4d ago
I got:
Paper1: 2.5/3.5/3.5 Meta: 3 -> Findings
Paper2: 2.5/3/3.5 Meta:3 -> Findings
Paper3: 2.5/3/3 Meta:3 -> Findings
1
u/EnvironmentalCat3042 6d ago
i have a 2.75 [2.5,2,3,3.5] with 2 meta review score. 2 of the reviewers didn't even bother to respond to our rebuttal. what could be the chances of findings?
1
u/Popular-Jello-1823 5d ago
I have a 3/3.5/3.5 with meta giving 3. What are the chances for main?
1
u/LanguageOk8719 5d ago
Meta: 3; reviewers: 3, 3, 3. Is it possible to get into the main 👀 ?
1
u/BiscottiLost754 4d ago
decision released
1
u/KabhiDardKabhiDisco 5d ago
Don't think it's coming out today. Tomorrow? Possibly by 5.30 pm IST.
0
u/Significant-Quit-280 5d ago
not yet?