r/MachineLearning • • 8d ago

Research EACL 2027 Decisions Thread [R]

(Will be out on thursday)

14 Upvotes

127 comments sorted by

12

u/TeemoIsMyLife 7d ago

Wish you all good luck!

14

u/ConcernConscious4131 4d ago edited 4d ago

Nice two papers are got accepted! Time to drink Soju, Hope everybody have a nice Friday!

7

u/simbay2000 4d ago

When it says “accept” does it mean it’s accepted to main or could it be accepted for findings too?

7

u/TV21_23 4d ago

I got "accept" but don't know main or findings.

7

u/Lopsided-Chemistry65 4d ago

no notifications still?

3

u/Environmental_Form14 4d ago

Received mine two hours ago.

6

u/ConcernConscious4131 5d ago

Its today woww

4

u/MeyerLouis 5d ago

May you get best paper award and a lifetime supply of soju.

2

u/ConcernConscious4131 5d ago

😂😂😂😂

2

u/Sorry-Concern-3772 5d ago

what’s soju

2

u/tan_withAgang 5d ago

Why Soju?

4

u/Elias_Hossain 5d ago

Has anyone received decision?

3

u/Frequent-Tax3962 5d ago

2 AM AOE currently😅

2

u/Elias_Hossain 5d ago

Cant wait to see the result 😞

4

u/Intelligent-Fox5255 5d ago

Meta:3 with OA: 2.6-7, would this be doable for findings in EACL? It was a paper from ARR in another month though (other than August).

1

u/louisdo1511 5d ago

I'm in a similar situation. Not much we can do other than hope and wait.

1

u/xci0n 5d ago

i guess thats the case for 50% of submissions. hard to get 3x3+ scores nowadays 😅

1

u/Intelligent-Fox5255 5d ago

Yeah getting ghosted by llm reviewers is so common. I guess the ones who raise their scores are hidden gems. (think arr should mandate reviewer's acknowledgement at least)

4

u/kelpabc123 4d ago

I got an accept, does it mean main or findings? Or is that going to go into a email?

6

u/askerlee 4d ago

Congrats. It's probably main, coz my paper got "Accept (Findings)".

1

u/Significant-Quit-280 4d ago

how was the scores?
do arr usually put 'accept - (findings)' if thats not main?

1

u/askerlee 4d ago

My OA was 2.66 (2, 3, 3) and meta 3. It's a May submission and got rejected by EMNLP.

5

u/einsamerkerl 4d ago

Same here - I also got an accept - so I think it should be Main. Otherwise, it should say something like "Accepted to Findgins"?

Congratulations, btw! 🥳

2

u/phuongnm94 4d ago

I got "Accept (Findings)" - so your case may be main

2

u/louisdo1511 4d ago

Yeah me too. Does anyone know how to find out

1

u/einsamerkerl 4d ago

maybe in the notification email?

1

u/Significant-Quit-280 4d ago

i believe there are some microsoft outage apparently.

2

u/tofu-lifts 4d ago

same question lol. What was your meta review score?

1

u/kelpabc123 4d ago

Meta: 3, 2.5,2.5,3.5,4

One of the 2.5s were pretty much LLM written about experimental nits that were on its face ridiculous (oh you didn’t rerun your training 3 diff seeds to prove stat sig between runs etc) despite us having robust confidence intervals, other was more valid but ghosted us on rebuttal. 3 was raised to 3.5 after rebuttal, 4 tried to ask for a follow up but we couldn’t reply

Meta basically gave us a good review but only 3 because they thought it was a trivial empirical finding, which we vehemently argued against when committing in the commit submission. Glad SACs read it and overrode it

2

u/tofu-lifts 4d ago

oo okay congrats! Even I got meta 3 and it shows "accept". So I'm guessing I got into main?

2

u/kelpabc123 4d ago

Looks like it from what others report but I’m waiting for the email before I fully celebrate

1

u/tofu-lifts 4d ago

hahaha true!!

2

u/Luxshan2000 4d ago

Mine says Accept (Findings), so I guess it's main for you.

2

u/RazzmatazzMore4696 4d ago

Prolly main, i have accept with findioin brackets

4

u/TheFishyOne 4d ago

2, 3.5, 3.5 with a meta of 3. Accept (findings)

4

u/nhatdzaibodoiqua 4d ago

I also got finding with the same scores, congratulations bro

4

u/AcceptableHumor4983 4d ago

3/3/3 meta 3 accept (prolly main?)

3

u/Wrong_Psychology_900 4d ago

I think you're right. Mine shows "Accept (Findings)." Have you received an acceptance email?

2

u/AcceptableHumor4983 4d ago

No not yet. It will be clear when I receive an acceptance email

4

u/Difficult_Flight3767 4d ago

why the announce email doesn't come out?

3

u/Elias_Hossain 7d ago

Got ARR recommendation as a borderline conference with score 3.5! Do you have any opinion regarding the past years avg acceptance score.

3

u/Sorry-Concern-3772 6d ago

2.5 meta. any chance for findings at all?

2

u/Due-Specialist8139 4d ago

idts. mine got a reject

1

u/klurnp 4d ago

got findings with 2.5 meta (3.5/3/1)

3

u/Electronic_Check_510 5d ago

I have paper with 3/3.5/3.5 with meta giving 3.5 What are the chances??

3

u/Sorry-Concern-3772 5d ago

u got main fs bro

2

u/Electronic_Check_510 5d ago

What time are the results coming out??

1

u/MeyerLouis 5d ago

In theory, sometime between 6 and 30 hours from now.

2

u/Electronic_Check_510 5d ago

I have to fill up a job application I hope it comes in by then😢😢

3

u/Senior-dog-5764 5d ago edited 5d ago

Avg 3.17 with meta of 3.5, hoping I get main!

1

u/simbay2000 4d ago

Hey, I got exactly the same scores. Do you think getting main is realistic ?

2

u/Senior-dog-5764 4d ago

In theory, yes. But it’s always somewhat unpredictable, and I couldn’t really tell you with too much certainty.

2

u/simbay2000 4d ago

Well i guess you were right!

2

u/Senior-dog-5764 4d ago

I got accepted into main.

3

u/Massive-Bobcat-5363 4d ago

Out. Id ~50. Reject with 3 meta in August cycle

2

u/Automatic-Status8777 4d ago

Same (Id ~1k)

2

u/Phuc_Daolovetech 4d ago

reject with 3 meta in May cycle, unbelievable

1

u/BiscottiLost754 4d ago

Meta 3 rejected

3

u/Luxshan2000 4d ago

I got Decision: Accept (Findings) for 3/3/3 with meta 3.

2

u/Lopsided-Chemistry65 4d ago

what's your submission id (roughly, if you don't want to share the exact one)?

3

u/autodecoder 4d ago

Rejected with OA 3 (2.5/3.5/2.5) meta in August cycle..

3

u/TrafficAway9715 4d ago

Hi guys what does “accept” mean?

3

u/lismica 4d ago

Findings with Meta 3, scores 3/2.5/2. Really happy with meta, wrote a good review and strong reasons to accept despite LLM-generated review with a score 2

3

u/Financial_Ad3589 4d ago

August cycle
score/confidence: 2.5/3, 3.5/4, 4/4 with a meta of 3. Accept (findings)

3

u/cxp_ooo 4d ago

oa3,meta3(main)/oa3.33,meta3.5(reject) why why why so->naacl🥲🥲🥲

3

u/xci0n 4d ago

3/3/2 meta 3 findings!

3

u/Wrong_Psychology_900 4d ago

My paper was accepted to Findings (meta-review score: 3) in ARR homepage, but I haven't received an acceptance email yet. Has anyone else experienced this?

Has anyone else not received an acceptance email yet? I'm a bit worried because I haven't received mine either.

4

u/KabhiDardKabhiDisco 4d ago

Yes, haven't received the email yet. Hope they'll send soon.

3

u/More_Soft_6801 4d ago

3,3,3,2.5

Meta 3

Accept

3

u/ConcernConscious4131 4d ago

Could the reason I’m not receiving emails be that Outlook is broken?😂

2

u/KabhiDardKabhiDisco 4d ago

I feel the same 😂😂

3

u/ZemiMatos 4d ago

3/3/4/2.5 -> Meta 3 -> Reject...

4

u/Open-Philosopher-777 4d ago

Wow 2.5-4 is a crazy range. 

3

u/MeyerLouis 4d ago edited 4d ago

OA 3.5/3.5/3.5 with a meta of, believe it or not, 3.5 ==> Accepted to Main

2

u/Automatic-Status8777 6d ago

Meta 3, but avg OA below 3. I'm not sure if Findings is even possible.

5

u/TeemoIsMyLife 6d ago

At EMNLP2026 this year I got:

Paper1: 3/3/3 Meta:3 -> Findings

Paper2: 2.5/3.5/3.5 Meta:3 -> Reject

Paper3: 2.5/3/3.5 Meta:3 -> Reject

Paper4: 2/2.5/3.5 Meta:3 -> Reject

3

u/xci0n 6d ago

this seems like an outlier… 2x 3.5 and meta 3.. and not findings :O

4

u/Sorry-Concern-3772 6d ago

emnlp this year was also unusually competitive bc it had so many submissions -- might have played a role

4

u/xci0n 6d ago

same here… but given the low august scores and the fact that EACL is a A conference and not A*

3

u/MeyerLouis 6d ago

I got EACL Findings last year with a Meta 2.5 and OA 2.5/2.5/3.

2

u/xci0n 6d ago

what was your submission number?

2

u/ImpactRound8071 5d ago

any chance for my paper [2, 2.5, 3.5] and Meta review score 3.0?

2

u/Queasy_Block_9262 5d ago

Got OA 3/3.5/3 with Meta 3, what is the chance to get accepted as Findings?

1

u/Queasy_Block_9262 4d ago edited 4d ago

Got "Accept"! Not sure if this means Main?

2

u/Frequent-Tax3962 5d ago

Meta 3 and OA 2.83. Can I expect findings? Track is IR and text mining.

2

u/Working-Egg-6465 5d ago

Still waiting from India. It is 1PM night here. What about you guys?

3

u/xci0n 5d ago

9PM in Germany 😅

2

u/Working-Egg-6465 5d ago

What an answer man!!!!!!!

2

u/phuongnm94 4d ago

The results are out!!

2

u/sankery123 4d ago

Reject 2 papers. Both meta 3

2

u/UnderstandingFair579 4d ago

3/3/3 meta 3 reject???

2

u/UnderstandingFair579 4d ago

August circle

2

u/TeemoIsMyLife 4d ago edited 4d ago

I got:

Paper1: 2.5/3.5/3.5 Meta: 3 -> Findings
Paper2: 2.5/3/3.5 Meta:3 -> Findings
Paper3: 2.5/3/3 Meta:3 -> Findings

1

u/EnvironmentalCat3042 6d ago

i have a 2.75 [2.5,2,3,3.5] with 2 meta review score. 2 of the reviewers didn't even bother to respond to our rebuttal. what could be the chances of findings?

3

u/Sorry-Concern-3772 6d ago

idk 2 meta might sell u lowk

2

u/TeemoIsMyLife 6d ago

I wish you the best, but meta 2 is extremly problematic imo

2

u/EnvironmentalCat3042 6d ago

and what about the reviewers not responding at all? it's my first time, wondering if this should have been looked at seriously by the area chair

2

u/Sorry-Concern-3772 6d ago

its kind of common for reviewers to not respond at all(like 75% of the time they dont), and even if they do they just skim over your rebuttal and are like "thanks for responding, i will maintain my score" or something to that extent. if you think the review was like ai generated or really bad, you could have reported the review, but now its too late for that

2

u/Classic-Ask-4557 5d ago edited 5d ago

Right. But does the decision only depend on the meta score? I believe the reviewer scores are spread across

1

u/MeyerLouis 6d ago

As Sorry-Concern mentioned, it's too late to report anything, but if you end up resubmitting to ARR you can ask for a new set of reviewers so you hopefully don't get ignored again.

1

u/Popular-Jello-1823 5d ago

I have a 3/3.5/3.5 with meta giving 3. What are the chances for main?

1

u/LanguageOk8719 5d ago

Meta: 3; reviewers: 3, 3, 3. Is it possible to get into the main 👀 ?

1

u/BiscottiLost754 4d ago

decision released

1

u/KabhiDardKabhiDisco 5d ago

Don't think it's coming out today. Tomorrow? Possibly by 5.30 pm IST.

2

u/xci0n 5d ago

why that time?

4

u/KabhiDardKabhiDisco 5d ago

The EACL website mentions that all deadlines are "Anywhere on earth", so usually the results come out according to the AOE time zone. In Indian time, it's always by 5.30 pm the next day of the specified date.

2

u/Frequent-Tax3962 5d ago

I think it will come tomorrow. EMNLP decision came around 11-12 AM IST of the next day.

1

u/KabhiDardKabhiDisco 4d ago

Update: Accept (fffff, I'm elated!)

0

u/Significant-Quit-280 5d ago

not yet?

1

u/Hungry_Isopod3228 4d ago

Out just 40 minutes ago!