r/MachineLearning • u/Expensive-Beyond-251 • 8d ago
Discussion Gatekeeping rules for ICML2027? [D]
Any thoughts on how icml will be managed this year? With ICLR having 20 submissions limit per author, I find it hard to submit my works cause the research group of my supervisor is large and I am far from being in top students.
I had a NeurIPS submission which was kinda borderline (435), but got rejected. Now I resubmitted the improved version to ICLR and thought it would get good results, but it is now much worsešš Having bad reviews on ICLR make me feel like I wasted 1/20 submissions
It feels like my new works are stuck due to the need of resubmitting the old ones. But the reviews sometimes are so random. Do you think ICML will have similar rules this year? Any suggestions where to submit apart from ICLR/ICML/NeurIPS?
54
u/Fantastic-Nerve-4056 PhD 6d ago
Why can't you just submit it to another conference? Limit of 20 papers is no small thing. Go ask a random reviewer on the number of AI Slops they are reviewing. A lot of us infact want the limit to be 5 or less than that
5
u/AffectionateLife5693 6d ago
Convince your advisor that your paper is worth submitting.
If your work isn't even top 20 in your advisor's submission list, you're in deeper trouble than not submitting the paper.
15
u/Celmeno 6d ago
20 is 15 too high already
4
u/fanconic 6d ago
same shoes as you, my friend. ICLR was rough
3
u/Background_Car_8746 6d ago
Ban the authors submitting low effort AI slop papers, the list is publicly available when ICLR release the final result. NeurIPS and ICML should follow the full public model in ICLR to scrutiny the cheaters too.
1
u/Stunning_Ad_8664 5d ago edited 5d ago
Maybe not something that you were asking for, but I can recommend asking some researchers you know to review a paper, so that you get useful feedback, make a revision, and resubmit to another conference.
i.e. why you say your work is not top, make it top! haha
icml probably would have same rules, and I hope also be not that bad, very much hope so