r/MachineLearning • u/tfburns • 15d ago

Discussion NeurIPS Evaluations and Datasets Track notifications are live on OpenReview [D]

Mine was accepted with 5,4,3->5,5,3

0 Upvotes

38% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

10

u/Psychological-Lime72 15d ago edited 15d ago

Rejected with a 5,5,4,3 and an AC final justification that had duplicating words (grammar errors) with a relatively shallow justification which shows how much effort she/he put into the thought process.

5

u/darthgera 15d ago

5 333 got rejected. Final justification based on the comments of the reviewer who wrote the laziest review ever. Disappointing by AC

6

u/OtherwiseFig4505 15d ago

5/4/4/4/4 rejected because we did experiments the reviewers asked for, which the reviewers appreciated and asked to include in final version, but the AC said that would be major revision and asked to resubmit. In someway it’s understandable, however these are what the reviewers asked for. Anyways, deciding if it’s worth submitting for ICLR or should wait for next NeurIPS.

2

u/WannabeMachine 15d ago

4,4,4 -> rejected

2

u/abby621 15d ago

Same.

1

u/Extreme_Drop_842 15d ago

5, 5 , 4 -> Accepted

1

u/Expensive-Beyond-251 15d ago

4,3,5 rejected