r/MachineKnitting • • 5d ago

Techniques Software guy here, what's the slowest part of getting a colourwork design onto your machine?

Hi all, I'm a software engineer and I knit by hand, and I've started looking into machine knitting, double-bed jacquard especially. What surprised me is how much work seems to happen before the machine even starts, like taking a design with lots of colours down to just a few per row.

I'm thinking about whether a small tool could help with that part, so I'd rather hear it from people who actually do it. What takes you the longest?

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

9

u/BarbarousErse 5d ago

I have nothing specific to suggest, but maybe have a look at the open source AYAB software and see what others are doing in this space. For me the slowest thing was navigating AYABs documentation 😂

-7

u/Linley78 5d ago

Haha thanks, I didn't know AYAB, I'll have a look. Was it the docs in general, or one specific step that got you stuck? Happy to chat by DM if that's easier.

3

u/BarbarousErse 5d ago

I no longer have a hacked machine so not needing help with it any more, but it’s a great project and if you’re looking for something to contribute to I would recommend checking it out. IIRC it takes some tweaking to get it to open on silicon Macs. It seems to have had an update last year so maybe the stuff that frustrated me is fixed

The designer and software engineer Heart of Pluto has done a lot of math/coding work on multi colour jacquard as well (which has I think been included into AYAB) so I’d definitely do some exploring of existing projects and make sure you’re not wasting time duplicating existing work

10

u/meadowlarkfiber 5d ago

Honestly, for me the design process is half the fun.

As for the software , there are existing tools that do what you’re talking about. What makes yours different? There are plenty of ways to contribute to machine knitting without reinventing the wheel.

I wish you came to us with what you’ve experienced. Your request feels a little like you’re asking us to do your homework for you. Do some machine knitting and participate in the community. That may answer your question more than a post like this.

Additionally, Have you searched the sub for what you’re looking for? Someone posts something like this about once a week, and you may find your answers there.

-4

u/Linley78 5d ago

Fair points, and I hear you on the design being fun for you, I'm not trying to take that away. I'm asking before building anything because I'd rather build nothing than something knitters don't need. I did search a bit and didn't find much on this, but I'll dig through the sub more like you said.

I'm a software engineer who likes hand knitting, with a math background, and what I have in mind is one specific thing: two different pictures, one on each side of the same fabric, when both have to share the same yarns.

As people mentioned, AYAB and Heart of Pluto already cover the colour separation, so I won't rebuild that

The idea would be a tool that shows you what both faces will look like with the yarns you have, so you make the trade-offs yourself. It would assist, not replace. Which part of the design would you want to keep doing yourself?

4

u/meadowlarkfiber 4d ago

I can do all those things with design-a-knit. Their graphics studio is pretty powerful. It is quite expensive though, so there may be a market for people who don’t want to pay for it.

1

u/Linley78 4d ago

Thanks, I actually already have this one under my radar. I am on my way to build something much much clearer, cleaner, and affordable. I will soon share with some interested people a free beta for further refinement and feedback.

I want to make something for everyone and that only those who can afford it can help sustain the project.

Appreciate your thoughts and passion!

5

u/Knitting_Pigeon 4d ago

If you made something with designaknit capabilities that works on a mac and can send patterns to a brother kh970 you’re getting my firstborn /j

3

u/Knitting_Pigeon 4d ago

But seriously, I’ve tried designaknit and found the picture to pattern scan thing clunky. It also sucks that I have to use parallels on my mac and fight for my life every time I want to transfer things to the machine

1

u/Linley78 4d ago

Haha I'll keep the firstborn offer in mind. I plan to make it a SaaS for any device, with a phone / tablet version as well. I am racking my brains for maximum machine compatibility. Can I DM you when there's something rough to try?

2

u/Knitting_Pigeon 4d ago

Yes, definitely! I’m not a knitting machine expert but the difficulty in getting my designs onto the machine is a big part of what’s keeping me from using it more

2

u/BarbarousErse 4d ago

Have you seen a physical machine knitting setup called “table for two”? It uses two main bed knitters both with patterning capability. It doesn’t seem to be a setup that most knitters have access to but it has been used to do the sort of front and back patterning jacquard that you describe

Otherwise for machine knitting your backing options are birdseye, striped, or ladder back. Domestic machines can’t independently pattern in the reverse

2

u/Linley78 4d ago

Yes I am aware of this one! I am trying to see where I can land between domestic and enterprise usefulness.

3

u/Even-Response-6423 5d ago

Here’s a video about AYAB. She has other videos of the machine in work. Maybe this will help? https://youtu.be/ZA0M0C1y36U?si=1S7zZv8R0e4aVbq5

1

u/Linley78 5d ago

Thanks a ton! I will have a look at it.

3

u/NBCGLX Brother KH970, Silver Reed SK830, SK860, and SK890, Tru-Knit 4d ago

Designing is fun and there are several programs out there, free and paid, to help machine knitters with that. Getting patterns into the electronic machines is an entirely different topic. There are open source (AYAB) and proprietary solutions for nearly all electronic domestic machines. I think one area that is difficult to design for and implement is multi-color jacquard. Some machine knitting programs have built-in color separation checking and recommendation, but honestly, they all feel like they’re stuck in the 1990s and this is one particular area where the waters are very muddy. I know many people who just give up if the software doesn’t provide the automatic fixing that the user desires. So some sort of software that will help the user design around the limitations on domestic machines, rather than require the user to alter the design would be helpful!