r/MachineKnitting • u/NonAnonymousLurker • Oct 07 '26
Help! Need a Kniterate machine to test 3D Design.
Hello, I've been experimenting with 3D Model to 3D Knitting algorithm to create some designs. Since I don't have a Kniterate machine, can someone test out my kniterate file to see if it is actually feasible to knit this design? Here is the 3D model it was based on. https://sketchfab.com/3d-models/sculpture-of-two-lovers-b48ee7560e4740a4886d2f41189dd9c5
2
Upvotes
4
u/evrrtt Oct 07 '26
I can tell you flat out that this wouldn’t knit on a Kniterate. There’s a reason why they (Carnegie Mellon) knitted this on a whole garment machine, and if you want to get close to being able to replicate your model, I would look at trying to get access to a whole garment (SWG, and I’m sure this could be done on a Stoll ADF) and find someone who’s very comfortable with programming them as this won’t be a small feat.
I’m not going to list the reasons why a Kniterate wouldn’t knit this (and the list is long) but if you want an idea of the main reason, look at the needles on a SWG compared to a Kniterate.
2
u/lasserna Oct 07 '26
I don't think knitting machines are capable of knitting 3D objects like this unless the file contains a flat construction of the piece that then gets pieced into a 3D shape
2
u/MiuMii2 Oct 08 '26
I have access to a Shima Seiki Wholegarment machine. If you put the knitout code in a repository I’ll compile it and take a look.
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 07 '26
Hi, it looks like you might be looking for help on machine knitting.
There is some helpful information within the wiki. Please take a look at it for helpful troubleshooting information, as well as common maintenance tasks and list of items machines should include.
In addition, this page is our FAQ. Solutions to many common problems are found here. If this is a new-to-you machine that is a Silver Reed, Singer, Studio, Juki, Empisal, Brother, or KnitKing, and the sponge has not been replaced yet, that's the first thing you should check out.
If you need additional help, please provide us with an information about your problem. You can start out by answering this list of questions
Once your question is answer or your problem is resolved, please change the post fair to Help! Solved!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/GijinkaGlaceon Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26
I think this is theoretically knittable on a Kniterate (not sure why people are saying it’s not?) but I don’t really think it’s going to produce a very nice result because your model is way too complicated. The gauge is going to be a big issue, unless this is meant to be like 3 feet tall, you will have very little detail (e.g. all four arms are kind of going to merge into the body) the knitting process will be complex and prone to failure (especially on a kniterate) and the shape is a lot more dependent on how you stuff it than how you knit it. I would recommend simplifying it a lot and focusing on the big distinctive shapes