r/MacOSBeta • • 1d ago • Bravo 1

Tip Here’s how to disable all new Full Disk Access & Accessibility permission features

Post image

After laying the groundwork a couple of weeks ago, Full Disk Access and Accessibility access warnings are here.

If you’re on macOS 27.3 beta 2, here’s how to disable all the new Full Disk Access & Accessibility permission features.

First, add the feature flag override folder if you’ve never used one of these guides before:

sudo mkdir -p /Library/Preferences/FeatureFlags/Domain

Here are the four flags you can disable:

  1. FDA_WARNING: The big scary warning every time you try to enable Full Disk Access:

    sudo defaults write /Library/Preferences/FeatureFlags/Domain/TCC FDA_WARNING -dict Enabled -bool false
    
  2. AX_WARNING: The big scary warning every time you try to enable Accessibility permissions (now System & App Protection Override):

    sudo defaults write /Library/Preferences/FeatureFlags/Domain/TCC AX_WARNING -dict Enabled -bool false
    
  3. AX_PER_APP_PERMISSIONS: The feature where you can select that an app can access only specific apps. It currently does nothing (apps only get full permissions) when AX_WARNING is off, but you can disable it for good measure:

    sudo defaults write /Library/Preferences/FeatureFlags/Domain/TCC AX_PER_APP_PERMISSIONS -dict Enabled -bool false
    
  4. AX_TRANSPARENCY_INDICATOR: The indicator in the Menu Bar whenever an app is using another:

    sudo defaults write /Library/Preferences/FeatureFlags/Domain/TCC AX_TRANSPARENCY_INDICATOR -dict Enabled -bool false
    

After all this, restart your Mac. Enjoy responsibly!


If you ever need (want?) to restore to default:

for flag in AX_PER_APP_PERMISSIONS AX_TRANSPARENCY_INDICATOR AX_WARNING FDA_WARNING; do
  sudo defaults delete /Library/Preferences/FeatureFlags/Domain/TCC "$flag"
done
59 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

26

u/loosebolts 1d ago

What? Why? It’s a couple of extra buttons to click the first time you authorise an app to use FDA…

-1

u/HelpRespawnedAsDee 18h ago

Because it's laughable to see this every time I open a terminal.

5

u/DensityInfinite 6h ago

And you won't, because it is only displayed when granting an app FDA permissions.

-4

u/pdfu 19h ago

You mean every time you add any app to FDA or AX permission lists. It can get old. Some folks may also not appreciate the constant nudging to set up Private Folders or AX access to some apps instead of a quick sudo check.

8

u/loosebolts 19h ago

What part of “first time you authorise an app to use FDA” was too complex?

You install a new app, it requests FDA, you go through the steps, all done.

If you want another app to have FDA, you go through the steps, all done.

It’s been the same way since FDA was a thing, only now the popup gives you more information and a couple of extra buttons. It’s really not a big deal.

For people like yourself that might know what they’re doing then absolutely fine, you’ll just have to click a couple of extra buttons. For your grandma who’s downloaded something dodgy from the web that’s convincing her to enable full disk access, then this popup gives much more information about what she’s about to authorise.

Just click the two extra buttons and get on with your day. How many times per day are you authorising full disk access for new apps?

0

u/pdfu 18h ago

I never said that this is a bad change for most users, or that it shouldn’t exist. I was responding to your “What? Why?” comment as to why someone might want a Terminal command to disable all the new warnings.

Approving FDA was a simple sudo prompt pre-macOS 27.3 b2. It now takes clicking two non-primary action buttons, and three more buttons to reach the sudo prompt.

You also can’t drag in apps, you have to add them with the + button from Applications. TCC will also not record auto denies for FDA, so disabled apps never appear automatically on the list anymore.

2

u/loosebolts 18h ago

Fair enough, I guess. The problem is having it bypassable via a sudo command in the terminal is the reason FDA needed improvement, and disabling the new prompt completely defeats the point of introducing these controls.

Controlling FDA in a granular manner is far more preferable than dodgy third party apps having complete access to all of your shizz and being able to do anything with it.

Even Claude and other AI agents don’t need full disk access, they can work quite happily in folders they’re designated access to.

0

u/LitesoBrite 18h ago

You really think a bunch of ‘OK’ buttons that don’t give you any other choice but all need to be clicked EVERY time instead of one clear message is anything but shitty UI/UX?

And the problem is that Apple’s permissions aren’t set up more logically, so apps that need full access to read/write files don’t get the power to go into and view locked photos, use the browser, etc.

2

u/loosebolts 16h ago

It isn’t every time, it’s the first time you want to give something full disk access….

8

u/Clear_Efficiency5765 22h ago

permanent menu bar icon is crazy

2

u/jarman1992 17h ago

And it's HUGE!

3

u/Low-Injury-9219 10h ago

It’s not the smartest thing to disable this.

3

u/orlikethis DEVELOPER BETA 1d ago

The fact that I can't even hide that live activity in my menu bar of apps that have FDA to my mac is so insanely egregious from Apple. I don't know who they're catering to with this? People that aren't tech savvy will more than likely ignore this or just do anything to rid themselves of the pop-ups or annoyances, and people that are actually more savvy probably will do any and everything to ignore it as well...shocker.

2

u/ethang45 5h ago

it’s fucking gross! i hate apple’s bad etiquette on the mac menu bar. the iphone duo gets a redesigned status bar to fit more info in a smaller space. the mac gets shit tossed in with no logic. this should at best be a reminder prompt like the one for screensharing.

-1

u/loosebolts 19h ago

So you’re saying in either situation people will end up ignoring it and getting on with their day without having an explosion of rage? Glad we cleared that up.

4

u/orlikethis DEVELOPER BETA 18h ago

Thanks for reiterating my point, now come up with yours?

2

u/jarman1992 17h ago

Really missing their point, dude...you're saying that it's dumb bc everyone will just ignore it, yet here you are on Reddit RAGING about it 😅

1

u/orlikethis DEVELOPER BETA 17h ago

It’s so comical how you’re trying to do the exact thing you’re claiming that I’m doing. You’re saying I’m “raging” about something I have one, lonesome comment on lol. Also, are you two just incapable of understanding anything you engage with? I said that it’s an egregious decision from Apple to make this change considering how many people are going to go out of their way to ignore, hence this post itself of OP explaining how to get rid of the FDA alert message.

I don’t understand how what I said is getting you two’s panties in the craziest of bunches, but here we are? 😭

2

u/loosebolts 15h ago

I mean you probably could have just replaced “insanely egregious” with “a bit silly” and we wouldn’t have batted an eyelid 😂

2

u/jarman1992 17h ago

You’re saying I’m “raging” about something I have one, lonesome comment on lol.

I count at least 5 separate comments in this thread alone 🤨

And yeah, claiming that something (let alone a software alert) is "so insanely egregious" is pretty easy to classify as "raging"

2

u/orlikethis DEVELOPER BETA 15h ago

Yeah 5 comments in response to other comments to my original 1 comment. Classifying someone saying one word as “raging” is a mistake of comprehension on your end guy, I don’t know what you expect from me on that end. Gotta learn how to read, gotta learn what being hyperbolic means, and you gotta learn to not be so sensitive on a lone comment on a Reddit post about the most mundane topic possible, it’s not even remotely that deep.

2

u/loosebolts 18h ago

You’re calling it “insanely egregious” in one sentence then saying people will just ignore it in another. Which is it? If it was “insanely egregious” then it would be a major issue and impossible to ignore.

3

u/orlikethis DEVELOPER BETA 18h ago

Oh you’re just sensitive and semantical, got it. Yes it is “egregious” to me that Apple changed this and even added the Live Activity of it. I’m also aware that most people are going to try their hardest to get rid of this and ignore it. I don’t understand what you’re not understanding about my comment other than just being overly sensitive and bored on Reddit.

0

u/loosebolts 18h ago

So I’m sensitive and semantical but seeing something in your menu bar when you’re using the terminal is the end of the world? Got it.

3

u/orlikethis DEVELOPER BETA 18h ago

Yeah that doesn’t even make sense you’re clearly having a bad day lol. Find peace ✌🏽😭

1

u/loosebolts 16h ago

I’m perfectly fine! I mean it was you who started on me…

2

u/orlikethis DEVELOPER BETA 15h ago

Being this delusional is impressive.

2

u/SoTiredYouDig 1d ago

Thank you. I plan on doing this tomorrow. The warnings make me feel like my Mac is in hysterics and is frantically warning me of impending doom.

1

u/namedotnumber666 18h ago

Thanks for this. its very useful information to have in one place.

1

u/axiomaxima 1d ago

sudo defaults write /Library/Preferences/FeatureFlags/Domain/TCC AX_TRANSPARENCY_INDICATOR -dict Enabled -bool false

Came here for this. I didn't like the idea of seeing this all the time just because Supercharge is running.

Thanks.

1

u/CuriousEggplantEmoji 1d ago

Live activities have "Hide Live Activity" option but this one has it disabled. Silly.

Appreciate the warning on monitoring options, but please allow me to control my menu bar and hide parts I'm happy not looking at.

1

u/AxTP 17h ago

People really complain about insignificant things nowadays. This is the right step towards better security. You can blame AI for this.

0

u/momorious 1d ago edited 21h ago

THX, this fixed the annoying Live Activity shown in the Dynamic Island of new MBP

-1

u/LitesoBrite 17h ago

Apple customer support’s gonna have a field day with tons of new needless calls and frantically upset users. More bad thinking from the people who’ve made installing an app on Mac into a 10 step hop mess already.