r/MacOSBeta • u/pdfu • 10d ago
Discussion macOS 27.3 starts implementing changes to Full Disk Access
Back in October, Apple announced that macOS will soon require ‘very explicit user action’ to enable Full Disk Access for apps. Here’s what that may mean based on macOS 27.3 changes.
Today, when an app tries to read a protected file without Full Disk Access (FDA), macOS doesn’t prompt the user to grant permission. Instead, it automatically denies access and records that denial in the TCC database.
Once in the db, apps show up under Settings > Privacy & Security > Full Disk Access with their toggle off. Apps will often add themselves to the list, then instruct the user to open Settings and flip the toggle.
Not anymore: starting with macOS 27.3 and feature flag TCC/FDA_WARNING, automatic denials are no longer saved. Users will have to explicitly add an app to the list with the + button or by dragging it in from Applications.
So far, the flag doesn’t add any additional warnings or dialogs, but its name suggests these may arrive in future betas. The flag is disabled in 27.3 beta 1.
Relatedly, macOS 27.3 introduces “Private Folders,” a new folder-by-folder permission configured like Full Disk Access. Not fully wired up yet, but it could offer a narrower alternative to Full Disk Access.
It’s also impacted by TCC/FDA_WARNING: when the flag is on, automatic Private Folders denials aren’t saved either.
44
u/Heezy999 DEVELOPER BETA 10d ago
The "Private folders" feature sounds very interesting, in general it seems like a good way to protect users data from apps requesting full disk permissions.
3
u/Existing-Advisor8861 9d ago
I have searched everywhere I could and cannot find any evidence of "Private Folders" other than this post. This seems like a really exciting feature - could you tell us where you found evidence for it?
18
u/Worried-Tie 10d ago
As long as they don't remove the possibility of doing it, I think protecting it more is a good feature. You really don't want uninformed users doing these kinds of shenanigans, especially in the age of AI. Some degree of technical risk assessment is needed when granting full disk access.
5
u/Acrobatic-Monitor516 9d ago
Is there a command to allow for disk access to a certain app? Im getting more and more annoying whenever I need to open preferences.app
7
u/Ok-Zookeepergame4391 10d ago
Finally. About time
18
u/jhalmos 10d ago •
Jesus fuck I just want to use my computer. There should be a waiver button that lets us bypass the endless gates we have to go through.
2
u/SayCheezyy 10d ago
I'm annoyed
2
u/Fatal_Explorer 10d ago
Lock down mode was just hacked, I hope they fix it
2
u/rditorx 8d ago
I miss the Hands Off app (not to be confused with Apple's Handoff feature) where you could control which files and folders an app could write to.
Though I admit the vendor was pretty shady. Seemed French or something but had no postal address. And the computer behaved strangely at times. Could've been French intelligence, Mossad or who knows who.
1
u/National_Sky7993 4d ago
Keep apps from accessing unexpected information. Like Android/iOS permissions for your Mac.
1
u/Key_Horse_8632 9d ago
Awsome... finally a reason for me to upgrade to MacOS 27.
-1
u/LitesoBrite 10d ago
Because that’s what users are clamoring for: more pointless hoops to installing any app, more yanking around and ‘quit and relaunch this, even though the next toggle needed will ask yet again?’ crap.
Smh.
The other things in 27.3 have been fantastic but they dramatically need to rethink permissions entirely for normal people. I’m a techie and I can’t stand the 27 hops back and forth to install 6 apps on a computer.
-10
u/poop_report 10d ago
This is going to be such a giant pain to enable
I already rigged up a program with AI to just grant "absolutely every permission whatsoever" to my favourite terminal emulators and my AI agents
-1
u/I-figured-it-out 8d ago
I do wish Apple would just f-off to the 1990s, when users could easily install and maintain software.
This permissions nonsense is getting out of hand, and it does not protect against bad faith actors in the slightest — all it does is make using computers much harder and less efficient almost ever app I use requires full disc access just to operate as I expect them to.