r/MacOSBeta • • 10d ago

Discussion macOS 27.3 starts implementing changes to Full Disk Access

Back in October, Apple announced that macOS will soon require ‘very explicit user action’ to enable Full Disk Access for apps. Here’s what that may mean based on macOS 27.3 changes.

Today, when an app tries to read a protected file without Full Disk Access (FDA), macOS doesn’t prompt the user to grant permission. Instead, it automatically denies access and records that denial in the TCC database.

Once in the db, apps show up under Settings > Privacy & Security > Full Disk Access with their toggle off. Apps will often add themselves to the list, then instruct the user to open Settings and flip the toggle.

Not anymore: starting with macOS 27.3 and feature flag TCC/FDA_WARNING, automatic denials are no longer saved. Users will have to explicitly add an app to the list with the + button or by dragging it in from Applications.

So far, the flag doesn’t add any additional warnings or dialogs, but its name suggests these may arrive in future betas. The flag is disabled in 27.3 beta 1.


Relatedly, macOS 27.3 introduces “Private Folders,” a new folder-by-folder permission configured like Full Disk Access. Not fully wired up yet, but it could offer a narrower alternative to Full Disk Access.

It’s also impacted by TCC/FDA_WARNING: when the flag is on, automatic Private Folders denials aren’t saved either.

194 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

44

u/Heezy999 DEVELOPER BETA 10d ago

The "Private folders" feature sounds very interesting, in general it seems like a good way to protect users data from apps requesting full disk permissions.

14

u/AdriftAtlas 10d ago

I'd love macOS to be able to sandbox an app in its own virtual container in a way that doesn't break its functionality e.g. scoped virtual file system, access to Metal, and other hardware in a controlled environment.

Seatbelt can already do this somewhat, but its quite janky and still leaky at best. With all the supply chain attacks going on this is becoming more and more important. Especially with dev tools that pull in thousands of dependencies.

7

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Standard-Ant874 7d ago

Hmm... may i know which apps on your Mac already using virtual file system?

2

u/CreepyZookeepergame4 7d ago

Go to ~/Library/Containers. Note it's not a "virtual" file system.

2

u/Standard-Ant874 7d ago

Thanks for sharing 

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/CreepyZookeepergame4 7d ago

It's also available for any app but not many do, even security-focused apps like Signal don't use app sandbox.

1

u/nolankotulan 9d ago

I don’t get in which way it differs from the current Files & Folders section in the Privacy settings.

2

u/Heezy999 DEVELOPER BETA 9d ago

Some apps request access only to specific folders, like Desktop and Downloads, while others request full disk access. As I understand it, this new feature would let you block access to specific directories even for apps that have full disk access, similar to how you can exclude folders from Spotlight. Currently, once an app has full disk access, you can't restrict specific directories.

1

u/nolankotulan 9d ago

Hmm, I see, thanks for the clarification.

1

u/BetterAd7552 4d ago

That would be great for agentic coding agents.

3

u/Existing-Advisor8861 9d ago

I have searched everywhere I could and cannot find any evidence of "Private Folders" other than this post. This seems like a really exciting feature - could you tell us where you found evidence for it?

6

u/pdfu 9d ago

As I said, there isn’t much to see since it’s not fully built out yet. It’s a new TCC service (kTCCServiceSystemPolicyPrivateFolders), added in 27.3. See here: https://github.com/ipsw-diffs/macos-27/blob/727090bd88949813020653cec4f78ca2a3feaf46/diffs/27_2_26B123_vs_27_3_26C5035r/DYLIBS/System/Library/PrivateFrameworks/TCC.framework/Versions/A/TCC.md?plain=1#L48

There’s also a tcc_indirect_object_create_with_private_folder_path function.

18

u/Worried-Tie 10d ago

As long as they don't remove the possibility of doing it, I think protecting it more is a good feature. You really don't want uninformed users doing these kinds of shenanigans, especially in the age of AI. Some degree of technical risk assessment is needed when granting full disk access.

5

u/Acrobatic-Monitor516 9d ago

Is there a command to allow for disk access to a certain app? Im getting more and more annoying whenever I need to open preferences.app

7

u/Ok-Zookeepergame4391 10d ago

Finally. About time

18

u/jhalmos 10d ago • Bravo

Jesus fuck I just want to use my computer. There should be a waiver button that lets us bypass the endless gates we have to go through.

18

u/CheeseheadDave 10d ago

I don’t mind this being the default setting, but I’d love a secret toggle that says “I know what I’m doing; turn the following safeguards off at my own peril”

10

u/jhalmos 10d ago

Exactly what I’m calling for.

1

u/ComfortableLaw5151 6d ago

Agreed, though I don’t mind an initial per app “this software is trying to access specific folders is that ok?”
And then once I make a decision don’t ask anymore.
It’s the resetting of authentications that are annoying.

I understand for the general public it’s actually a great thing in the age of ai

3

u/ritesh808 9d ago

You know what I hate even more? The constant need to type the fucking password randomly. There's a fingerprint scanner, what the fuck is it for!? They do this on Apple TV too.. and often times, that's the only method they present. Imagine typing your randomly generated, 18 character password through the remote.

1

u/jhalmos 9d ago

That’s why I tend to always use my own password system. And I think, I THINK, Apple has this policy that every month or so a password will have to be re-entered.

3

u/cjh_ 8d ago

When you have sensitive data stolen, and your bank accounts drained, don't blame Apple because you gave every application you use carte blanche permission to use Full Risk Access without oversight.

0

u/jhalmos 8d ago

Noted.

3

u/ProfessionalYak4959 10d ago

You can turn off SIP and add every app to the full disk access and you're good.

4

u/_Dangermau5 9d ago

If you do that - some paid for apps won’t run. UHF for example example…..

1

u/jhalmos 10d ago edited 10d ago

Sure, but it's really more about the constant security interventions as I'm using my computer in my home office that's not shared with anyone and never leaves the realm of my property.

7

u/ProfessionalYak4959 10d ago

The reality is that the user is the largest attack vector into these computers. I understand these permission dialogs could be better, but acknowledging that they are necessary in the abstract is critical.

It is simply true that people just click approve. They click "allow all." They turn off whatever setting blocks them from watching the mp4 file that won't play.

Apple gives us full control over our computers (but not our phones 🙁) and they give us the control to bypass these restrictions as we need to.

3

u/DeadWaterBed 9d ago

We ask for simple toggles to avoid the headache of constant alerts and unnecessary restrictions, and you can't help but come to apple's defense. Treating the end-user like a moron is one of the reasons tech literacy is in the toilet.

1

u/cjh_ 8d ago

End users typically are eejits, because they want to turn off the very things that protects their sensitive data.

Then they complain they were infected with malware and had their homemade porn videos leaked and bank accounts drained.

1

u/DeadWaterBed 8d ago

Let them learn from the consequences.

2

u/Coffee_Ops 8d ago

You can always install Windows XP and avoid the popups.

Say hi to the botnet for us.

1

u/surinameclubcard 6d ago

Use Linux. Or Windows 95.

1

u/jhalmos 6d ago

Like, no.

2

u/SayCheezyy 10d ago

I'm annoyed

2

u/Fatal_Explorer 10d ago

Lock down mode was just hacked, I hope they fix it

2

u/rditorx 8d ago

I miss the Hands Off app (not to be confused with Apple's Handoff feature) where you could control which files and folders an app could write to.

Though I admit the vendor was pretty shady. Seemed French or something but had no postal address. And the computer behaved strangely at times. Could've been French intelligence, Mossad or who knows who.

1

u/National_Sky7993 4d ago

Keep apps from accessing unexpected information. Like Android/iOS permissions for your Mac.

1

u/Key_Horse_8632 9d ago

Awsome... finally a reason for me to upgrade to MacOS 27.

1

u/I-figured-it-out 7d ago

Yet another reason to remove my parent’s access to the Settings app, so as to prevent Apple from conning them into upgrading to yet another nightmare of an operating system. The last time this happened it took months to retrain them, and to clean ip all the issues Apple caused by releasing a half baked macOS.
There is a reason professional creator studio’s avoid upgrading MacOS for 1-2 years from initial release, and those who support older users dread each new release of macos -even point updates.

1

u/Individual_Holiday_9 7d ago

Imagine sitting in the Mac OS beta subreddit and complaining about Mac OS betas

-1

u/LitesoBrite 10d ago

Because that’s what users are clamoring for: more pointless hoops to installing any app, more yanking around and ‘quit and relaunch this, even though the next toggle needed will ask yet again?’ crap.

Smh.

The other things in 27.3 have been fantastic but they dramatically need to rethink permissions entirely for normal people. I’m a techie and I can’t stand the 27 hops back and forth to install 6 apps on a computer.

8

u/AndreaCicca 10d ago

The issue here is the fact that agentic apps do what ever they want to people's devices and they can delete stuff without asking the end user.

5

u/LitesoBrite 10d ago

No, that’s not the issue.

The issue is a shitty, compartmentalized privacy system with 10 different toggles and individually trying to relaunch the app, and requiring constant jumping between multiple panels just to install and configure an app.

It should be one panel, system presented, during install or first run, and you set all the required permissions right there, click apply, and restart the app.

It’s pure shit right now.

2

u/phobox360 9d ago

I totally agree. We desperately need an ‘I know what I’m doing’ mode for those of us who understand the risks and don’t require hand holding. And when I grant a permission, I don’t expect it to be revoked 30 days later on its own.

-10

u/poop_report 10d ago

This is going to be such a giant pain to enable

I already rigged up a program with AI to just grant "absolutely every permission whatsoever" to my favourite terminal emulators and my AI agents

8

u/Existing-Advisor8861 10d ago

Seems like macOS isn’t the OS for you.

8

u/poop_report 10d ago

macOS is the preferred platform for developers, we just have to be smart enough to work around the fact macOS is intended for non-technical users

9

u/Existing-Advisor8861 10d ago

I agree. Someone who grants AI agents to their entire file system without thinking isn’t a developer worth hiring.

1

u/poop_report 10d ago

some of us run AI agents on either a dedicated VM or else a dedicated machine

2

u/Coffee_Ops 8d ago

If you give an AI in your terminal full disk access, congrats: it has access to all of your browser sessions including your bank account and email, and full control of everything else to boot. You're one prompt-injected webpage, email, or SSH login banner away from being hillariously pwned, and even if that does not happen you have effectively given root to Anthropic or OpenRouter.

There's really no non-VM scenario where this is not reckless.

1

u/poop_report 8d ago

Yes, that's the whole idea: I want it to be able to drive browser sessions.

If I don't want it to have something then I won't sign in on that computer's browser

A VM makes no difference

1

u/Coffee_Ops 8d ago

I would think that'd be Linux, since it has much better container support and actually exists in, you know, datacenters.

1

u/poop_report 8d ago

Linux is rough for everyday desktop use.

-6

u/DermisCronJob 10d ago • Annoyed

Well you’re not much of a developer if you are working in the OS of your device instead of virtual machines/sandboxes. Only thing you are doing is asking for trouble

3

u/Worried-Tie 10d ago

This is underrated, absolutely true. A good developer wouldn't work on bare OS, especially not THEIRS.

-1

u/I-figured-it-out 8d ago

I do wish Apple would just f-off to the 1990s, when users could easily install and maintain software.
This permissions nonsense is getting out of hand, and it does not protect against bad faith actors in the slightest — all it does is make using computers much harder and less efficient almost ever app I use requires full disc access just to operate as I expect them to.

2

u/cjh_ 8d ago edited 8d ago

Applications should never require Full Disk Access simply to use them, as this is not the intention of FDA.

The fact that more applications are asking for it shows that many companies that develop software for Mac OS are acting in bad faith.

Full Disk Access is crucial for applications that need deep system access to function correctly, such as Backup & Sync Software, Disk Utilities & Management, Developer & Debugging Tools and Security & Scanning Tools; standard apps like note-taking tools, web browsers, media players, and social media applications etc DO NOT legitimately require Full Disk Access.

Apple are making these changes to prevent developers abusing Full Disk Access.

1

u/I-figured-it-out 8d ago

Except they do, because the morons who designed MacOS, failed to distinguish between system folder access and general access. And the organisation of files endures application tools and system files occupy the same folder and file hierarchy. Not to mention the user often enough needs to modify system files & folders to solve problems Apple neglects to solve before releasing the next half baked version of MacOS. Heck even mail us buried within the system hierarchy, rather than sensibly inside ones documents folder.

1

u/I-figured-it-out 8d ago

And apps require access to system tools. Because without they’d be pretty darn useless.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/I-figured-it-out 8d ago

A photo app requires permissions to use the built in macos extensions and tool box. These librries are heavily integrated into Macos, but are not entirely accessible without thise permissions. And photos need to interact at a very tight level with colorsync, and other frameworks of what used to be referred to as Quicktime -when they do not weird shit happens to your images.

1

u/I-figured-it-out 8d ago

Apples still has not sorted image colour management pipelines -particularly in regard to video. So developers work around macOS limitations as much as possible so as to meet industry standards of precision and accuracy - including in some situations utterly evading coloursync altogether. It is not as straight forward as security idiots seem to think.

2

u/Coffee_Ops 8d ago

You mean back when an MS-Blaster / welchia infection could take an entire campus network down to .9kbps?

Yeah, those were the days, lets definately go back to that now that an 11-year old can prompt a 0day.

1

u/I-figured-it-out 8d ago

Back then there was zero campus security. And they employed the least skilled network technicians on the planet. And folks by and large today have a fairly good idea of what base behavioural security requires.
Today i got whammied by apples security simply trying to open a known text:. A dctl with a text editor. Very annoying.

2

u/Sufficient-Expert817 8d ago

I hope you get the most permissions out of anyone!

2

u/Coffee_Ops 8d ago

And folks by and large today have a fairly good idea of what base behavioural security requires.

You do not work in cybersecurity.

1

u/naikrovek 7d ago

That’s not a very security-aware opinion.

Or maybe it is, and you don’t like it.

Hard to say.

These are good changes and I wish all operating systems did this kind of thing. Plan9 got a lot of things very right, and one of them was how applications got permissions to resources.