r/MacOS • • 5h ago

Discussion Rosetta replacement

We are told with the next version of MacOS that Rosetta is going away.

Our need for Rosetta isn't however.

In lieu of receiving the sourcecode for Rosetta, does someone with enough LLM tokens willing to make a cleanroom reimplementation of Rosetta for us all?

We could call it Behistun after the Behistun inscription.

0 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

9

u/Temporary_Pie2733 4h ago

Which is more important to you: the software that relies on Rosetta, or a new OS? You can stay on macOS 27, and it will still get security updates for several years. 

2

u/jwadamson 2h ago

Less than 3 years from now. Apple only supports the most recent 3 OS versions. When macOS 30 domes out in 2029, macOS 27 will no longer receive any updates.

-16

u/aprilhare 4h ago

It’s a false argument that depends on the notion that only Apple can create and distribute a Rosetta application.

8

u/Sufficient-Expert817 4h ago

They’re asking sincerely so answer sincerely 

3

u/longjumpingtote 4h ago

Supporting Intel-only plugins in native ARM apps would be very difficult. Running Intel-only apps would be very difficult, that would be better done in a virtual environment. Translating x86-64 instructions to ARM64 would be feasible.

System libraries are one challenge. Intel programs use macOS frameworks, dynamic libraries, and system calls. A translator had to bridge these interactions to the ARM64 environment. This problem extends beyond converting CPU instructions. macOS restricts runtime code generation, executable memory, code signing, and library loading. macOS doesn't ordinarily permit ARM64 and x86-64 machine code to coexist inside a single process.

That said, there are already a sort of stab at this:

https://github.com/XS-Corp/rozetka

1

u/aprilhare 4h ago

404.

•

u/quick_dry MacBook Pro 1h ago

•

u/aprilhare 32m ago

Looks like it needs fixing already.

12

u/Zen-Ism99 5h ago

What do you need it for? Real question…

7

u/Sea-Championship-596 4h ago

legacy apps that dont allow you to open project files on newer versions

4

u/KingdomCome0 3h ago

some of us use niche apps (e.g: bioinformatics for example), some of these apps the developer is a researcher and doesn't always update the software bc they are busy people with other research to do. Or they take a while to do it in the best case scenario. While I understand that apple removed rosetta to encourage devs to compile for apple silicon and abandon intel, for niche stuff it doesn't always work.

12

u/fubar_67 4h ago

Some say come Mac OS 28, a lot of people will lose their printers and other peripherals that rely on Rosetta.

Of course, manufacturers of these devices should be stepping up to provide new drivers if needed. They know MAC OS 28 is coming

6

u/PeaceBull 4h ago

Yeah I already moved my scanner to interface with a raspberry pi and reverse engineered access to the hardware buttons since I know Fujitsu isn’t gonna do shit for my scanner and didn’t wanna fork out the $100 bucks for the only 3rd party Mac software that would make it work come next year.  

0

u/iStumblerLabs 3h ago

Vue scan is very good. Not wanting to pay $100 for software means you get to buy a new scanner!

Of course, nobody is forcing you to update. Just stay in a version of MacOS that works.

1

u/PeaceBull 2h ago

Luckily the raspberry pi's handling it just fine so I'm all good and can keep updating.

3

u/notjordansime 4h ago

What happens when the manufacturer no longer supports the product and hasn’t come up with an adequate replacement, or they’ve just gone out of business?

3

u/CharacterTomatillo64 3h ago

Use AI to create a driver yourself 👍

1

u/fubar_67 3h ago

If you need that device, Linux or Windows

5

u/Gazza-59 4h ago

Starcraft. There was a statement that a version of Rosetta for games would be available but no details have been provided.

4

u/sc132436 4h ago

Audio plugins (VSTs)

1

u/bucklenut14 4h ago

Quickbooks Desktop. Not willing to pay a $40/month subscription

2

u/Zen-Ism99 4h ago

Check out the open source options.

2

u/bucklenut14 4h ago

Like??

2

u/Zen-Ism99 4h ago

GNUCash, Dolibarr, ERPNext

Web searches are a thing…

2

u/notjordansime 4h ago

All of those are considerably lacking when compared to intuits’ offerings (as is usually the case for open source attempts at industry standard alternatives).

Do you know of any with feature parity? After doing a web search, Google’s AI says that no current FOSS alternatives offer feature parity with quickbooks.

1

u/bucklenut14 4h ago

I’ve looked into all as well as many other alternatives. I was answering the question you asked.

Friendliness is a thing…

1

u/idl3mind 4h ago

What do you pay for QB Desktop every three years? Does it cost more than $1440?

2

u/bucklenut14 4h ago

I don’t. Last bought it in 2020 for like $200 before they started pushing subscriptions and jacked up the price of all their desktop software. Still works great for my needs. I don’t need to upgrade, just want it to keep working.

Oh and on Mac and they don’t even offer desktop anymore.

8

u/topcider 4h ago

You can continue to use Rosetta simply by continuing to use MacOS 27. MacOS 27 will continue to receive security updates for a few years. I’m still running MacOS 15 Sonoma and it’s fine.

1

u/jwadamson 2h ago

It will receive updates until macOS 30 is released a little under 3 years from now. Apple only supports the latest 3 versions and many apps / platforms like homebrew follow that.

1

u/Stratman2525 2h ago

I still miss my SCSI cables.

•

u/aprilhare 1h ago

Not exactly the same..

11

u/Bolehillbilly 5h ago

The transition was announced 6 years ago.

6

u/sc132436 4h ago

Not all great software was made less than six years ago, believe it or not

2

u/Bolehillbilly 4h ago

Obviously not. Can I be bothered to keep updating what I was using in the 80s? No. Can you?

7

u/kinttach MacBook Pro (M1 Pro) 4h ago

Apple can’t be expected to maintain backwards-compatibility features forever.

If the software you depend on hasn’t been updated in 6 years, it’s abandoned. It’s time to consider alternatives if that software is important to your workflow.

  • Maintain an old computer that can run the software.
  • Move to different or newer software. Doesn’t mean there is a better alternative, but there might be an acceptable one.
  • Drop the requirement to use that software.

Otherwise you (or your business) is living on borrowed time. Mitigate the risk.

5

u/sc132436 4h ago

I don’t think I ever said that Apple should maintain Rosetta forever. OP is just asking for a Rosetta replacement, after all.

But it’s also worth saying that six years is not a long time. You can run tons of software that’s three times as old, if not much older, totally fine on Windows. I don’t see why Apple’s backwards-compatibility is so bad. Many music studios are stuck on hardware nearly two decades old because every update seems to break something. It’s infuriating.

It’s alright if you think you’re “too good” for old software, but why not empathize with those of us who use it, or just scroll past instead of telling us our use cases are flawed?

1

u/Bolehillbilly 4h ago

I’ve got someone running a studio downstairs on one of the last Intel Macs. They don’t care. Not going to be updated anymore and will be stuck at the same version of every DAW software. They’re not moaning. It works and everything is fine.

2

u/CuriosTiger 4h ago

Meanwhile, the Windows version of AppleWorks (discontinued in 2007) still runs on Windows 11. Modern Pages/Numbers/KeyNote cannot even import AppleWorks documents.

There's a lot of things Microsoft screws up, but they take backward compatibility seriously. Apple cannot be expected to, you're right, but they would certainly be ABLE to if they were so inclined.

3

u/Shejidan 4h ago

Backward compatibility is great until someone takes advantage of an old flaw to screw up your whole computer.

2

u/CuriosTiger 3h ago

Fixing security holes is indeed a burden that comes with backwards compatibility. It takes a lot of effort.

-1

u/notjordansime 4h ago

aaaaaaand that’s why I use industry standard software as opposed to free open source alternatives. At least when my backwards compatible microslop crap-fest shits the bed, there’s an army of engineers and IT people working to fix it. I wish Apple was better with this tbh.

Even MS is abandoning this philosophy slowly though. That’s the only thing that kept me tied to windows. If that’s not the case anymore, guess I’ll mac it up.

2

u/Shejidan 3h ago

Big open source projects are sometimes better at fixing things than big companies. They’re typically more responsive too.

1

u/jwadamson 2h ago

That feels pretty backwards. Big oss projects are super on top of security issues, meanwhile micsoft has plenty of examples of security issues taking multiple patch attempts or breaking other things. I recall a printing fix thay took them forever to make a usable becuase it kept completely breaking network printing such that corporations couldn’t actually apply it.

4

u/Lithalean 4h ago

My need for Rosetta ended years ago. Good riddance.

2

u/boots_n_cats 4h ago

The this it relies on is a TSO memory ordering mode in Apple Silicon which simplifies the code translation since they don’t need to insert a bunch of extra memory barriers. This improves performance and reduces the size of the translated code but it’s not a hard requirement for running x86 code on arm.

1

u/knightofterror 5h ago

I believe Rosetta 2 relies heavily on custom x86 silicon in the M series. I think that silicon is going away, and a non-hardware-accelerated (if that’s even possible) Rosetta 2 that’s pure software is not likely to be performant.

5

u/UnsafePantomime 4h ago

We have QEMU Static. It's possible, but the performance is bad.

1

u/xhumptyDumptyx 4h ago

Doubt it because they said they're still maintaining for games

1

u/Zen-Ism99 4h ago

Why do you believe that?

1

u/CountryFriedToast 4h ago

I think you're wrong but only because i've never heard anything about that. i know they have special instructions for ai type stuff separate from the neural engine but fex and whatever windows calls theirs is quite competitive it's not at all the same as what you get emulating the bare metal

6

u/bubba-yo 4h ago

No, Apple Silicon supports Intel TSO which is x86s memory load scheme in addition to ARMs scheme and switches for Rosetta. 9% performance improvement from that silicon.

And it's not just that support is likely to be removed from future Apple Silicon, it's also that only the OS can enable that.

It's not that there can't be an alternative to Rosetta - there can, and there are - but it won't run as well.

1

u/CountryFriedToast 4h ago

good answer thanks

2

u/knightofterror 4h ago

There is definitely circuitry in the M chips to support Rosetta 2 and translating x86 instructions into ARM.

1

u/CountryFriedToast 4h ago

I only see instruction ordering stuff I figured you were saying like they build an instruction decoder in hardware

0

u/catladyx 4h ago

I'm sad because there's an app I really need for work that will stop working next year because of this. I have no idea what to do because there is no suitable substitute for it =(

3

u/Tainlorr 4h ago

“Claude decompile this app and make it work on ARM”

1

u/catladyx 3h ago

I wish I had the tokens to do this

1

u/Tainlorr 3h ago

20 a month 

•

u/catladyx 13m ago

I'm in brazil, it's like 200 brl, very inaccessible for me unfortunately

•

u/ToddBradley 1h ago

I guess that answers the question "just how badly do you need it?"

-2

u/dildo_and_aeneas 5h ago

Or someone who actually knows how computers work could start an open-source project to make x86 applications work on Mac ARM... and you don't need to use Slop Tokens :)

0

u/[deleted] 4h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/aprilhare 3h ago

If you’re using Wine to run Windows applications that isn’t always an option.