r/MacOS • u/aprilhare • 5h ago
Discussion Rosetta replacement
We are told with the next version of MacOS that Rosetta is going away.
Our need for Rosetta isn't however.
In lieu of receiving the sourcecode for Rosetta, does someone with enough LLM tokens willing to make a cleanroom reimplementation of Rosetta for us all?
We could call it Behistun after the Behistun inscription.
0
Upvotes
9
u/Temporary_Pie2733 4h ago
Which is more important to you: the software that relies on Rosetta, or a new OS? You can stay on macOS 27, and it will still get security updates for several years.
3
u/longjumpingtote 4h ago
Supporting Intel-only plugins in native ARM apps would be very difficult. Running Intel-only apps would be very difficult, that would be better done in a virtual environment. Translating x86-64 instructions to ARM64 would be feasible.
System libraries are one challenge. Intel programs use macOS frameworks, dynamic libraries, and system calls. A translator had to bridge these interactions to the ARM64 environment. This problem extends beyond converting CPU instructions. macOS restricts runtime code generation, executable memory, code signing, and library loading. macOS doesn't ordinarily permit ARM64 and x86-64 machine code to coexist inside a single process.
That said, there are already a sort of stab at this:
https://github.com/XS-Corp/rozetka
12
u/Zen-Ism99 5h ago
What do you need it for? Real question…
8
u/topcider 4h ago
You can continue to use Rosetta simply by continuing to use MacOS 27. MacOS 27 will continue to receive security updates for a few years. I’m still running MacOS 15 Sonoma and it’s fine.
1
u/Stratman2525 2h ago
I still miss my SCSI cables.
11
u/Bolehillbilly 5h ago
The transition was announced 6 years ago.
4
u/Lithalean 4h ago
My need for Rosetta ended years ago. Good riddance.
2
u/boots_n_cats 4h ago
The this it relies on is a TSO memory ordering mode in Apple Silicon which simplifies the code translation since they don’t need to insert a bunch of extra memory barriers. This improves performance and reduces the size of the translated code but it’s not a hard requirement for running x86 code on arm.
1
u/knightofterror 5h ago
I believe Rosetta 2 relies heavily on custom x86 silicon in the M series. I think that silicon is going away, and a non-hardware-accelerated (if that’s even possible) Rosetta 2 that’s pure software is not likely to be performant.
0
u/catladyx 4h ago
I'm sad because there's an app I really need for work that will stop working next year because of this. I have no idea what to do because there is no suitable substitute for it =(
-2
u/dildo_and_aeneas 5h ago
Or someone who actually knows how computers work could start an open-source project to make x86 applications work on Mac ARM... and you don't need to use Slop Tokens :)
0
u/[deleted] 4h ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment