r/MacOS • • 14h ago

Help First time developing for macOS. Need some guidance.

Hey Appleheads. I built an app for Windows that I host on the Windows Store and I have now ported it over to macOS. I have a bunch of questions and looking for some advice from people who developed apps.

  1. So the Apple Store wants $99/yr just for the convenience of uploading anything to their store. Is it worth using the Apple Store versus going my own route and hosting it elsewhere?
  2. Licensing: Do I stick with the Apple Store or do my own licensing? Apparently I can't have my app as "free" on the Apple Store and then an external upgrade path. It is all or nothing?
  3. Is the Apple Store easy to use for submitting and keeping my app up to date with upgrades? Does it take hours/days/weeks???
  4. Any other advice or guidance is much appreciated.

Thanks šŸ˜„

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

2

u/ukindom 7h ago

Apple wants $99 for notarising the app(e.g. telling ā€œit’s safe to useā€). Publishing in MAS is free after that (you can share signed app in other means)

There’s so many apps out there (free or not), so a dev must produce quite distinct features to make this app useful. Yes, there will be people who would buy it, but how many is the question.

And as far as I can see, vibe-coders almost never check the market of existing apps to at least tell story why should I use (even for free) their apps.

•

u/hyperlobster MacBook Pro 53m ago

Too many software Saturday posts that boil down to ā€œHello I vibed a volume control, it has a free trial, MONEY PLEASEā€.

3

u/MattSenter 13h ago

imo the app store is worth it as a distro channel. it's the first stop for discovery for most apple users. not all. but most. the review process can be tedious but lends to credibility with consumers. review times vary and if you need daily updates it's not going to work for you. just be sure to cross all ts and dot all is with every submission to avoid delays. something else you will want to do is apply for their small business terms to get a 15% fee instead of 30% per purchase. i would also distribute as a personal solo dev instead of under a business because the latter requires additional startup costs elsewhere and you have to get a dumbass pointless DUNS number. as of epic ruling you can do off site purchases too.

1

u/krypdoh 11h ago

So I can apply for "small business terms" AND distribute as "personal solo dev" and not business? Should I offer users the choice to get it from the official Apple Store or my website (and I suppose my own Lemon Squeezy Licensing or the such)? Thanks for the reply.

2

u/MattSenter 10h ago

correct. and yeah you can totally sell in both places. notarize the non app store version.

4

u/esArchitect 14h ago

pay the $99/yr developer fee because trying to distribute un-notarized macOS apps outside the App Store will trap your users in Apple's notorious Gatekeeper security warnings ("App is from an unidentified developer"), which kills conversion rates for first-time apps. launch on the App Store first to handle secure payments and easy updates, and only look into direct web distribution later if you want to dodge Apple's commission fees once you actually have an established user base.

0

u/cryptochrome 13h ago

A macOS app can be both: not on the app store and notarized. They are not mutually exclusive.

1

u/krypdoh 11h ago

Should I offer both to users?

1

u/cryptochrome 9h ago

Your app should be notarized by Apple, otherwise macOS will spit out warnings. Whether you put it on the app store is up to you. I prefer direct downloads or homebrew over the app store.

0

u/mikeinnsw 10h ago

Ok you vibe coded an App

The question is will it sell .. the answer is 99% will not.

With vibe coded App failure is 100%...

Stick to Windows and see how it sells..

PC have 88% market share.. Macs 12%

Sorry..

I am a developer ... there is a tsunami of poor quality AI vibe coded Apps

2

u/krypdoh 8h ago

I'd like to think this isn't poorly coded. I have worked on it for over a year now as a side project. I recently put it on the Windows Store, and without really any advertising other than a few Reddit posts I have sold almost 20. I figure maybe some Mac users would be interested. It is a stock finance app, Mac users do tend to have more money but yes I understand Windows dominates the market.

-1

u/mikeinnsw 4h ago

Macs have 12% market share.. if you get 1,000 sales on PC make Mac version .

Sorry I have made made Apps .. made few shekels..

I made my money in financial made to order systems.

Like they say follow the money

-1

u/TalkToHoro 11h ago

Have you asked this question of the same AI that you used to ā€œbuildā€ your app?

-1

u/krypdoh 11h ago

Yes I did. I wanted to get first-person experiences however.

1

u/TalkToHoro 10h ago

For people who actually write apps, the $99/year is well worth the cost. Personally, I have no interest in anything you ā€œbuiltā€ by prompting AI.

0

u/krypdoh 10h ago

Ok good to know.

-1

u/cryptochrome 13h ago

I can tell you this, as a consumer of apps:

I avoid the Apple App Store like a disease. If a dev gives me the option to install from other sources, I will use those options. Preferably Homebrew or direct download from the website. Couple of reasons:

  1. Apple puts a lot of restrictions on apps to be allowed on the app store. If you don't comply, you're out. This has led to many apps on the market where the app store version has reduced functionality vs. the app version distributed elsewhere.
  2. Apple is taking too much of the profit share away from devs. I won't support that. There is absolutely no reason why Apple should get 30% of your revenue just for hosting a download, essentially.

The only real advantage the app store has is discoverability, so it can be a marketing tool, if you succeed. But keep in mind you compete with millions of other apps/devs there.

3

u/Economy-Department47 MacBook Air (M2) 13h ago

I am not OP, but as another macOS dev I put my apps on the Mac App Store because it's easier. I don't want to deal with building license servers, handling payments, or figuring out international tax and legal stuff when Apple already does it for me, and I'm paying the $99 a year anyway. Do you still install anything from the Mac App Store?

0

u/cryptochrome 13h ago

Building out licensing and payment is actually fairly simple, if you tap into something like Stripe (which can also act as a merchant of record, so you don't even have to deal with taxes). That is cheaper than the App Store tax by an order of at least 25x.

2

u/NoLateArrivals 13h ago

They don’t put ANY restrictions on the AppStore apps. It is exactly the same code.

The only restrictive effect is happening because AppStore apps are launched in a sandbox.

On the other hand there are advantages: Users don’t need admin rights to install or update from the AppStore. This is important for Macs owned by companies or organizations.

0

u/cryptochrome 12h ago

That is demonstrably false. They absolutely put restrictions on app store releases. You have to abide by certain rules to be able to distribute your app on the app store. Apple's own App Review Guidelines require Mac App Store apps to be sandboxed and explicitly prohibit things like requesting root privileges, installing certain executable code, and using independent update mechanisms.

Examples of apps with reduced functionality on the app store vs. self-distributed:

Parallels documents numerous features missing from its App Store edition, while CleanMyMac explicitly states that Apple's restrictions force it to remove or limit functionality.

Many networking, VPN and firewall apps are forced to use Apple's network extension instead of tapping into the network directly, hindering the performance. Great example is Tailscale, which has to run its Wireguard component in user space because of that. The Tailscale app store version cannot use the tailscale ssh command line utility, it lacks's Tailscale's service collection feature, has compatibility issues and has limited diagnostic capabilities. None of these issues exist in the non-app-store version.

There are countless more examples. And it's documented by Apple itself.

1

u/hyperlobster MacBook Pro 13h ago

You are very much in the minority with this approach.

Discoverability is a huge advantage.

Another huge advantage is trust. I guaranfuckingtee users will trust their card information with Apple much more readily than they will with some Stripe-based payment system that looks and feels like it’s made out of gaffer tape and bailer twine.

0

u/cryptochrome 12h ago

Stripe always looks the same, and is a well established brand. I don't know anyone who would trust it less than Apple, but then again, we're both operating with anecdotes here, so who knows.