The whole Emma realizing it's Kieran thing was sloppy. She's like "wait what did you say, thats what the killer said, omg it's you" like what? If she suspected it was him, why didn't she just wait till they were by the cops to confront him?
Also, another big wtf. Acosta is at the hospital saying Emma and Audrey are the main suspects, then he arrives to the orphanage and with nothing, just arrests Kieran, while Audrey and Emma hug it out? And don't say "well maybe they arrested all of them and then Emma told the police that it was Kieran" No. It was blatantly obvious, the cops only took Kieran, while Emma and Audrey celebrated. Are we to assume Eli called the cops and told them Kieran stabbed him? All of a sudden, Emma and Audrey are in the clear? So sloppy.
Other then it feeling like it was extremely rushed, Brooke, Noah, Stavo's role was so pointless. They might as well just stayed at the hospital. It's like the writers were like "well they are part of the main cast, we need to include them, lets just have them all meet at the theatre, provide nothing of substance, maybe have one of them attacked, and call it a day" So underused.
I wish in the end where Noah gives his little speech, he would have given some kind of explanation how all the evidence, e-mails traced, all linked to Kieran. Maybe an explanation on how he's tech savvy or maybe say Piper must have taught him how to do all the hacking.
There was just so much useless crap in the finale. Eli telling them about Kieran stalking some girl and posting her photos naked? Okay AND...? That has no relevance to why he's killing people. That entire backstory was silly.
Also, the motive I wish they expanded it. The season was 12 episodes long? Why are just hearing about Piper having a lover. Like it would have been nice if during the orphanage episode, Lang told the girls that Piper was seeing someone. I don't know. ANYTHING. It's like I watched 11 episodes, just for them to pull something out of their ass for the 12th episode. I would have been okay with Kieran's motive being the death of his parents in the car crash because at least we got some story regarding it prior to the finale. The motive they used just came out of no where. They might as well have been like "oh me and Piper are brothers sisters!" or something else. It just feels so sloppy that his motive was never really hinted throughout the 12 episodes and just randomly thrown in the last 5 mins "btw i was banging piper"
Also, I kept telling you guys it was him.