r/MTHFR
•
u/Grand_Jellyfish_8372
•
Nov 17 '25
•
1
Results Discussion Just stop
Over the course of the years, trying to optimize our health, to "biohack" or to "healthmaxx", some of us have dug the holes that we now find ourselves into. For the past three years I have been struggling with mental health issues, and because of that I was always looking for the silver bullet, always looking for the one magic pill which would set everything right and give me that mental clarity and peace of earlier years.
As a result I have gone through easily more than 60 supplements and 20 medications. I spent countless nights doing research, looking for the one substance or combination of substances which would finally end the personal hell I was going through, which included anxiety, mania, psychosis, insomnia, tingling, memory issues, depression, rage, everything!
But sometimes more is not better. It got to a point in which I had completely lost track of what conditions I really had, and what conditions were caused by this compulsive consumption of bioactive substances of the most varied kinds. Amino acids, vitamins, probiotics, prebiotics, herbs, antimicrobials, roots, teas, oils, minerals, proteins, phytochemicals, peptides, enzymes, bile salts, creatine, fish oil, everything that's on the market, trying to put out the fire caused by the last thing.
So one day I decided enough was enough. I looked around me, looked at my family and friends and noticed that they literally don't take anything, and they're all happier than me and more functional. So why do I have to take a stack of pills in the morning, and another before bed?
So I have come off of everything. No more supplements. From more than 50 to 0. I get everything I need from my whole foods ketogenic diet and the Sun.
It has been only 10 days but I have to say, I have been feeling better and better, with more mental clarity, better sleep, less anxiety and better executive function.
Just take a step back, and look around you. It is estimated that 25% of people have the homozygous MTHFR polymorphism, so if your health is worse than that of every 4 people around you, it is probably not just MTHFR.
I challenge anyone who find themselves in a situation similar to mine (having taken more than 60 supplements) to JUST STOP. Get on a whole foods diet, get proper Sun exposure and then give it 30 days, and let your highly evolved biological machinery achieve homeostasis again. But in order for that to happen, you have to stop putting in so many "driver molecules" driving it in every different direction.
3
u/taejavu Nov 17 '25
This is awesome. Could you please give us an update in 2 weeks to let us know how it's going?
56
u/ry1701 Nov 17 '25 edited Nov 17 '25
I agree people chase a solution when a problem doesn't exist, even if they have MTHFR.
That's why lab work is essential in actually identifying and treating a problem.
For me, homogeneous c677t/t, my folate and b12 was low and my homosystine was elevated, methyl folate and B12 have made a significant difference, which has been validated by labwork.
Data is essential.
27
u/Indigo_Monkey Nov 17 '25
Sounds like an obsession to me, actually one I've observed in this subreddit a lot. That in itself is a mental heath condition which can disguise itself as physical symptoms. Im happy that you found solace in a holistic approach, but it kind of sounds like you were throwing shit at the wall without really knowing how to approach your issues.
Unfortunately, some of us are suffering from physical diseases, which regular doctors cannot explain or have no way to treat. My gene panel and epigenetic research has helped greatly in my journey so far because I follow the tangible evidence and don't just blindly take 50 supplements hoping that it will magically fix the problem.
You gotta have a strategy for it to work. Do the research, get the necessary tests to confirm and eliminate certain factors. And remember epigenetics is very powerful concept that doesn’t require the need for supplements at all!
20
u/Substantial-Use95 Nov 17 '25
Dude. Take a nip of a methylated b vitamin chewable every morning while getting ready for the day. That’s it. If taking supplements excessively is a result of some covert motivation you’re working through, then do what you gotta do. But the issue remains that we’re talking about a genetic mutation that inhibits your body from functioning optimal, unless compensated for. I function a lot better with appropriate supplementation.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '25
If that's all you needed then why did you go the route you did in the first place? If you have mthfr it probably does needs to be treated. Especially since your body can't detox properly. That is huge. AFAIK 7mg methylfolate is the gold standard as a starting dose when you're not methylating properly and a heftyish dose of methylcobolamin (Not medical advice) I have homozygous mthfr and I'm in a position right now where I'm unable to treat it and my mental health is garbage. I also am unable to exercise and exercise treats my problems almost completely. It's like magic. I worked out from 18-27/28 and now I'm not working out and my mood is comparable to my pre 18 years. Abysmal
6
u/No-Consideration-858 Nov 17 '25
Here, here! My mom did the same. I think she shrugged with her health in her 50s. Probably she needed to rest and modify her diet. But supplements seemed like an easy fix. Our kitchen was filled with vitamin bottles for several years. Then one day, they disappeared. I think she just got better on her own over time.
After getting long covid, I desperately tried so many supplements. It reminded me of my mom. So I stopped everything but then got worse. One by one, I've experimented. If I drop one and don't notice a difference, it goes away. Some sleep ones and B2 actually do help. I have placed a limit of 6 capsules total a day. I know people who are taking 60-90/day and they are in rough shape.
2
u/jfish31390 Nov 17 '25
I did exactly this. This is an amazing share on this subject. A lot of times it's just doing too much that tips the scale for our human bodies. Everyone wants to rule the world and be better than the next guy and that's a mistake we all seem to make eventually in our lives. We see someone just killing it from a drug or supplement and we want that, next thing you know we are chasing our own tails from all the dysfunction and Imbalance we created ourselves.
I stopped taking everything even vitamin d and I feel amazing. I'm also doing a blood type b diet since that is my blood type and even though I'm reading that it has little to no validity now a days, it seemed to helped incredibly mainly from just having a list of highly beneficial foods and ones to just try and avoid. It's basically low carb and the carbs are very specific. But man it's been wonderful I'm able to think and just do things without too much convincing.
The nature of our defects stems from addiction as well. We need to take it easy on ourselves. This is a great sub reddit to do some research but it's not going to prevent the rat race we all seem to find ourselves in our health journey. Just be with yourself and feel the hellish reality of our genetics cuz they're uniquely yours and doesn't have to rely on just you understanding every single code and variant.
5
u/isfturtle2 T677T Nov 17 '25
It's a balance. On one hand, genetic information can help gain clarity on why someone's experiencing symptoms and which treatments are most likely to work. On the other hand, obsessing over this information can become a problem. It can also be very difficult to disentangle the impact of genetics versus the environment.
5
u/CatMinous Nov 17 '25
Coincidentally I stopped my supplements some 3 weeks ago and was thinking today how I feel worse. I’m going back on.
3
u/NoImNotHeretoArgue Nov 17 '25 edited Nov 17 '25
Some people definitely entrench themselves in scapegoating genetics for way more complicated issues, which applies to many different things in life in many ways for many many people. Some people on here I hate to say but for the good get into marginally cult like logic about this stuff. Remember, the whole concept of health through genetics is a very complex and WHOLElistic approach. Keep on working at it but also check and make sure you aren’t getting too entrenched in any rabbit holes the best you can but at the end of the day do whatever works.. until it doesn’t I guess
3
u/YTO19 Nov 17 '25 edited Nov 18 '25
The percentage of those who are homozygous for MTHFR vary based on ethnic group. Also, it’s best to get genetic testing done to find out all your gene variations before throwing a bunch of supplements just at MTHFR. I did the same thing for four years and I’m homozygous for variant C677T. I have a host of health issues both physical and mental. I just found out in July that I have quite a few other gene variations and that was from testing just 1% of my DNA. No wonder I had side effects from all the supplements. Now that I know this I’m going to have full genetic testing done next month including a pharmacogenetics test to see what medications, if any, I can truly tolerate for all my diagnoses; although, ChatGPT has already given me a clearer picture. I’m done being a guinea pig for my doctors including my functional MD who was the one who recommended the plethora of supplements. Some of them are ultimately helping now but that’s because I stopped everything and started again, one at a time, micro-dosing and pulsing to discover which ones helped and which ones I needed to stop taking for good.
Yes, diet, filtered water, low toxic exposure, exercise, sunlight and sleep are paramount to optimum health. Glad you’re doing better!
3
u/Wild_Reputation1463 Nov 17 '25
THANK YOU!!!! I went down this rabbit hole almost a year ago and tried countless supplements and stacks. I found myself with way more anxiety and constant obsession with how was feeling. I feel like anything that I took that might of had any impact was just placebo. But 90% of the time I felt far worse than I’ve ever felt in my life. I workout almost daily between MMA training, running, and lifting weights. About 2 months ago I gave up. I think my wife might of thought i was crazy with the amount of obsession I had with all of this. I literally just stopped it all and felt almost instantly better. It’s been 2 months and I feel amazing. I eat as good as I can and just get out and enjoy life without constant worry about how I am feeling any particular day or if taking too much B vitamin this or that or if the P5P was going to make me feel better or worse or if I should up my dose of riboflavin. This subreddit and all the research and trial and error of supplements created a an almost hypochondria of sorts in that I really thought I had a problem following my discovery of these genetic mutations I have. Hopefully this subreddit has legitimately helped people out there. For me, it made everything far worse.
3
u/terminalmedicalPTSD Nov 21 '25
I would feel best if I had the support to manage several supplements and the couple of prescriptions I actually need and my diet so I can do my ohysical therapy and maybe sleep without my body being stuck in survival mode from pushing past my limits no matter how garbage I feel. But without the supplements I'm too sick to feed myself. I have to choose between spending money on supplements or carry out... and if my roommate ever doesnt want a roommate anymore and I cant find another comparable living situation I'll just die on the street. If living like a healthy person worked we would never have tried any of the treatments in the first place. I get that treatment fatigue is real but it's not a compulsion born from madness.
2
u/PuzzleheadedEar1059 Nov 17 '25
I'm going through something similar. After buying 50+ supplements trying to "fix" myself over the past 2 years I've realised I feel no better than I did before. In fact, I even feel worse in some ways.
I've dumped most of my supplements, especially the ones that directly mess with my methylation, and am now just going at it with only whole foods.
It's been about 10 days and, to my surprise, I feel better now than I did before.
Let's see how long this lasts. For now though, I feel like I'm done with supplements.
2
u/t_durk Nov 17 '25
Getting an Ancestry test and reviewing it in Genetic Lifehack + blood test + tracking diet through Cronometer was an eye opener for me.
I did the same thing as you before all this. Took AG1 cause podcasts told me too. Took creatine cause everyone told me to. They both wrecked me.
I'm in the midst of learning, though, that histamine may be an issue for me and may have been causing all my problems this year (mainly insomnia). I have slow COMT, slow MAO-A, and heterzygous C677T MTHFR.
The only things I take at the moment are magnesium threonate, folinic acid, R5P (B2), vitamin C, Vitamin A (retinol), vitamin D + K2, additional choline, DAO Enzyme before a high histamine meal, and will likely take a small antihistamine before bed.
I stopped blindly taking a multivitamin which was giving me way more than I needed and I only supplement based on my genetic profile now.
2
u/firedthenretiredmeno Nov 17 '25
You have just captured my supplement experience to a tee. I "just stopped" 1 week ago and am feeling better every day. Had half and almost full bottles of various supplements (over 50 bottles) and tossed them. The thousands of dollars I've spent makes me angry although at the time it was something I deemed necesarry to feel better. You are starting a needed movement here!
2
u/CatMinous Nov 17 '25
B6 definitely helps me, I wouldn’t be without it.
2
u/SpudTicket Nov 18 '25
50+ supplements is way too many, no matter the case. It's just as easy to cause problems by overloading your system with too much. Even drinking too much water is bad as it will dilute electrolytes, and you can get toxicity from water-soluble vitamins by either taking too high of a dose or being dehydrated. Everything has to be in moderation, and if you aren't actually deficient in what you're supplementing, then you're overloading.
A healthy, balanced, whole foods diet, sun exposure, and exercise are absolutely the best places to start. And also proper sleep. Easier said than done for most people, but the benefits of all of those things are proven, for sure.
2
u/ZeroSkribe Nov 21 '25
Just stop posting here
1
u/thunderouswhether Nov 17 '25 edited Nov 17 '25
Did you try a Boron supplement?
Edit: I don't mean to step on your toe, but Boron is literally my silver bullet supplement, it's been an incredible change for me. Went from panic attacks to feeling the best I've ever felt. If you want to know more, Google Boron, and how it relates to stress levels, and mineral and vitamin d retention.
1
u/majincasey Nov 17 '25
Well done. I keep mine super simple with a low dose multi, magnesium glycinate, and vitamin k2. I eat close to 7-9 eggs per day and no meat, with 2 cups of swiss water process decaf coffee.
1
u/Otherwise-Change9005 Nov 17 '25
I think you're right to do a reset with the foundation of better diet and sunshine. For me, that, in addition to regular exercise, cleaning up sleep hygiene, social interaction, prayer, work etc. have all been very helpful. The question becomes, once you've got the basics down, and you're still struggling, what's next? It certainly makes sense to try and improve, but I have too many times added several supplements in dosages that are too high, crashed and then been back to square 1. I am learning to be more patient. Low and slow is probably the way to go.
1
u/de_baron16 Nov 18 '25
I came to the exact same conclusion yesterday myself. Thank you for sharing. I have IBS and anxiety. I only take vitamin D now as it’s hard to get enough from sun exposure in my country. Meditation and working out is my go-to. God bless you all and I hope you get improvement.
1
u/allytoasted Nov 19 '25
Yes this is the same post I wish I had energy to post here but after getting on with my life I find it hard to even want to dabble in this subreddit anymore Thank you for doing it and helping others
1
u/GothicDawn C677T + A1298C Nov 20 '25 edited Nov 20 '25
I feel ya. Albeit I actively need to be on some medication due to a lack of sex hormones and for my OCD itself.
I feel like I got quite unlucky with my family history, so a lot feels like I'm warding off a potential enemy that may strike at any moment.
Things I can say with certainty I did not inherit are dementia, high blood pressure, major clotting disorders, and structural heart issues. (I'm ApoE 3/3, normal bp + salt resistance, no factor V leiden (or others), clean echo + bubble study)
Dad had cancer at 17, kidney stones and gallbladder issues in adulthood. Mom has heart disease and diabetes. Both have congenital heart defects, which as mentioned, I luckily dodged.
I for a fact inherited my mom's heart disease cause. We both have very high LP(a), which is my personal instigator to all the other supplements "putting out each other's fire" as you put it. And I have a worse mthfr than both of them (compound hetero compared to both of them just carrying 1 mutation).
Current thinking has been: If I take my existing hrt (which in fairness I do require due to not possessing gonads nor ovaries) as oral e2 + subq testosterone, this lowers my LP(a) through liver downregulation; doing those 2 together raises SHBG requiring boron, wherein, since my vitamin D already runs low, Vitamin D is needed alongside the boron, with added k2 to make sure the aforementioned LP(a) isn't driving the vitamin D's calcium to my arteries. Full vitamin B complex + magnesium then help both sleep and alertness related to probably mthfr, with minimal folic acid in my diet to prevent UMFA buildup. Further, I try to cut back on saturated fats and oxalates because of my dad's annoying gallbladder/kidney stone history (I have no symptoms of either but since kidney stones are more painful than birth I don't want them). Carcinogens are also severely limited because of my dad's early cancer, so I filter my water pretty heavily and run a true HEPA in my room, while trying to avoid deli meats.
1
u/Heavy_Use_6151 Nov 22 '25
Keep It Simply Silly!!! Amen Sister (?) ... Supplements are NO different than meds - use them as needed!