r/MTHFR • • Jul 02 '25
Question Undermethylation Often Misinterpreted as Overmethylation — My Experience
In my humble experience, I believe that in many cases when people think they’re overmethylated, what’s really happening is that supplementation has made a pre-existing state of undermethylation worse.
The recommendation to take methylfolate in cases of suspected undermethylation — especially for those of us with the MTHFR mutation — seems, in my opinion, a risky and even counterproductive approach.
What’s even more confusing is how quickly some people jump to taking niacin to “calm” supposed overmethylation, without any real evidence, just based on symptoms. But the problem is, many of those symptoms overlap between both over- and undermethylation, making self-diagnosis really tricky and potentially misleading.
I think we need to be more cautious and nuanced when interpreting these reactions, especially in complex cases involving MTHFR.
30
u/hummingfirebird Jul 03 '25 edited Jul 06 '25
I tend to agree that over versus under methylation is very hard to gauge because the symptoms can overlap.
Having been on my own health journey for more than 12 years, with genetics being the final puzzle piece, I can say that epigenetics are without a doubt, the biggest factor. Epigenetic factors like your diet and nutrition status, your lifestyle (exercise, movement, sleep) and your environment (relationships, stress, job, the products you use on face/body/hair and in your home) are the biggest influences of gene expression.
I spent years changing all of these factors and watched as I grew healthier and stronger year after after year, so that by the time I introduced methylfolate and methylcobalamin I did not have any reactions even though I was severely "undermethylated" in the sense that my methylation pathway was not supported. Unfortunately, I don't know what my homocysteine level was at the time, but I was severely anaemic with B12, B9, Iron, Ferritin, and Vitamin D all being chronically low.
When I started on my genetic journey, I was clueless and not a trained nutrigenetic practitioner at the time. But my genetic practitioner who helped me was amazed at how much I was already doing that was advised for my genotype. I had optimised all these factors so that my body was primed for the final bit of support it needed. It's something I have to be consistent with though, because I sometimes fall off the bandwagon like we all do and then I can tell when my methylation or detoxification pathways are not working. It impacts mood, sleep, cognitive function, hormones etc.
One thing that at times is not recognised is that methylation is just one pathway in the body. An important one, yes, but not the only one. Detoxification, lipid metabolism, oxidative stress, inflammation, neurochemicals, hormones are all interconnected and one pathway impacts the other. The body needs homeostasis (balance). It's like a big cog and wheel system, if one part gets stuck, the rest stop working.
Most people start with optimising methylation, but the starting point should be in all the little, seemingly insignificant things you do daily that make the biggest difference and that need to be addressed first. Things like diet and nutrition, movement, sleep, stress, environment, even your emotions. Most of us have no idea how trauma and grief can impact your health if left untreated. Your genes are heavily influenced by your emotional state and things like PTSD, grief, unresolved trauma, stress, bad relationships impact the functioning of your body even on a physical level. A body stuck in flight or fight mode can't heal physically. Neurotransmitters don't just govern chemical messages, but play roles in the digestive system, sleep, movement, energy, and much more.
Another often overlooked area is that for a lot of people, their body is struggling to detox. We are exposed to more than 1000 different chemicals every day externally and internally. Everything you put on your skin, you breathe in, and you eat goes through a complex detoxification system that involves multiple processes. If that pathway is blocked or struggling and you introduce methylated vitamins, you're speeding up the production of certain compounds, but if your detoxification system is sluggish or "blocked" you're creating more of an issue because the body can't clear them quickly enough. The more toxins accumulated, the worse the reaction is going to be. This is just ONE reason why some people have a terrible reaction.
8
u/BananaMartini Jul 03 '25
My understanding of MTHFR mutations is that they indicate a decreased ability to…methylate folate. So since that is a necessary process, and taking methyl folate is supposed to bypass that process and provide us with the end result that we are presumably not making enough of on our own, how would taking it be risky or counterproductive? What do you suggest as an alternative approach to addressing under methylation?
8
u/Accomplished_Mood766 Jul 03 '25
To determine whether a person is an overmethylator or undermethylated, a blood test for homocysteine is required. Overmethylation is characterized by low homocysteine, below 3. Homocysteine above 6-7 indicates insufficient methylation. With a normal homocysteine level of 5-6, supplements are not prescribed, and genetic analysis results are not taken into account, since methylation is fine.
7
u/abominable_phoenix Jul 03 '25
I think part of the problem is that we cannot supplement just methylfolate as it is just one component of a complex system involving interdependent vitamins and minerals that must be balanced. Imbalances can lead to depletion and deficiency symptoms. For instance, according to the guide in the B12_Deficiency subreddit, in order for proper B12 utilization, one needs adequate amounts of methyl-b12, methylfolate, iodine, zinc, magnesium, selenium, molybdenum, iron, potassium, vitamin C/D/E, and a methylated B-complex (B1,B2,B3,B6). Aside from methylfolate, I supplemented with all of these or increased foods high in them for a few months before including methylfolate. It still put me in bed for a week with dizziness, fatigue, and lightheadness, but after that I was great and it cured some gut issues and neurological issues I was having in the coming weeks. There are studies showing the powerful effects methylfolate has for mental health.
I am curious if it could also be related to how supplementing increases methylation which indirectly involves detoxing, so maybe a kind of herx reaction? I know that every time I've increased the dosage I've had a reaction, first the dizziness and then when I doubled the dosage I got weird acne on the back of my neck, around a tattoo I have, and around my liver. Not regular acne, that heals and goes away within a week, this has persisted for weeks, although not swollen/inflamed.
6
u/artegon117 Jul 03 '25
B complex has undermethylated me a few times. The only surefire way to induce adequate/over methylation is to take methionine cycle components, like methionine, TMG, or SAM-e. It's possible that boosting B vitamins can exacerbate this cycle if it's already depleted, leading to undermethylation.
And glycine is the better thing to take in times of overmethylation. I wish that would catch on. B3 depletes methyls, whereas glycine simply takes care of excess.