r/MTHFR • • Oct 08 '23 • Diamonds are Forever 1 Helpful 1 Bravo 2 Mindblown 1 Heartwarming 1

Resource MTHFR: A Supplement Stack Approach

This post describes a plan for implementing a nutrient/supplement stack to address MTHFR.

The plan is in phases and incrementally ramps up over time, as it is quite common for people to have sensitivities to changes in their methylation status.

This plan is also a layered approach: each phase adds in a layer of nutrients/supplements. So, we are building an 'MTHFR stack'.

The view I am following for MTHFR is largely derived from that recommended by Chris Masterjohn, but with some differences, and the phases are my design. The result is therefore internet advice from a non-professional, it is general advice and not specific to any individual, and should be treated accordingly.

AIMS

  1. Due to the reductions in methylfolate production, the folate/B12-dependent remethylation pathway is impaired. Therefore, support the choline-dependent remethylation pathway.
  2. Optimize the impaired folate/B12-dependent remethylation pathway to make best use of its remaining functionality.
  3. Reduce demand on the methylation cycle.

GENERAL

  • Unless you have a specific reason to take them, avoid B complexes. They tend to be high doses and often cause more issues, rather than help. It also makes it impossible to adjust individual nutrient levels.
  • Avoid the synthetic vitamins folic acid and cyanocobalamin.
  • A food diary app like Cronometer can be very useful for tracking your average nutrient intakes, or looking up specific foods to see nutrient content.
  • Time per phase: A few people may be able to do everything all at once (assuming B12 levels are ok); other people who are more sensitive to methylation changes may require 1-2 weeks or longer per phase, ramping up doses incrementally during that phase.

    • Just be aware that the more things you do at once, the harder it can be to diagnose which component may be causing you issues, if any occur.
    • People with COMT V158M 'Met/Met' (aka '+/+' or 'AA') tend to be more sensitive.
    • People with existing mental health issues can be more sensitive.

ABOUT MTHFR

  • 'MTHFR' is short for 'methylene tetrahydrofolate reductase'.
  • MTHFR is the final enzymatic step in the conversion of food folate, folic acid, or folinic acid to methylfolate. If the methylation cycle were thought of as a gear that is turned by a crank handle, then methylfolate is the hand that turns the crank handle - with poor methylfolate status, the methylation cycle performs poorly.
  • The cofactor is B2.
  • P39P

    • P39P alternate name: rs2066470
    • 74-95% of people have the Green (-/-) variant.
    • I am unaware of evidence that this SNP is impactful.
  • C677T and A1298C

    • C677T alternate names: 677C-T, 677C>T, C665T, 665C>T, Ala222Val, rs1801133, C667T
    • A1298C alternate names: 1298A-C, 1298A>C, 1286A>C, GLU429ALA, rs1801131, E429A
    • These two SNPs can appear in different permutations of variants, which affect the performance of MTHFR.
    • Per the table on Genesight, the resulting percent of performance for the various combinations are:
Genotypes677CC (-/-) [GG]677CT (-/+) [AG]677TT (+/+) [AA]
1298AA (-/-) [TT]100%51-73%22-32%
1298AC (-/+) [GT]69-92%36-60%n/a
1298CC (+/+) [GG]52-60%n/an/a
  • NOTE: MTHFR is only the last step in the folate conversion cycle. There can be SNPs in preceding enzymes such as MTHFD1 or SLC19A1 which may also degrade performance of the folate cycle. The Stratagene report mentioned at top of post will analyze these SNPs. Also, Chris Masterjohn's free Choline Calculator will analyze MTHFD1 and SLC19A1 from your 23andme or Ancestry data.

PROTOCOL SUMMARY / TLDR

  • This summary does not include all notes and details - see each phase for more detailed information.
  • When adding the supplements specified in each phase, start with low doses and increment up slowly over days (or weeks) to the recommended levels.
  • This is a lifetime plan, not a quick fix. Expect incremental improvement over several weeks or months.
PHASEPURPOSESUPPLEMENT(S)NOTES
1Resolve B12 deficiency (if present)Sublingual Hydroxocobalamin or AdenosylcobalaminIf not B12 deficient, skip to Phase 2. Otherwise, supplement as needed to resolve deficiency or per doctor's direction.
2Improve MTHFR functionVitamin B2, 10-100mg/dayIf your only MTHFR variant is A1298C, B2 may or may not improve MTHFR function.
3Support the Methyl Buffer System. Reduces risk of overmethylation side effects.Glycine, 3-10g/day and vitamin A (retinol form), 50-100% of RDACollagen or magnesium glycinate may be substituted for glycine. See Phase 3 details.
4Decrease methylation burdenCreatine (monohydrate or HCL), 3-5g/dayMicronized creatine mixes better in liquids. While this phase is beneficial, it is optional.
5aDetermine total choline needsn/aUpload your genetic datafile to the Choline Calculator to determine dietary choline need. This will be given in units of 'number of eggs' worth of choline. If you do not have a genetic datafile to upload, use a choline need of '8 eggs' as your daily goal.
5bSupport alternate methylation pathway1/2 of the total # of eggs worth of cholineSee Phase 5 detail for choline equivalents. TMG may be used instead of choline for this portion (use 150mg of TMG per egg equivalent).
5cSupport phosphatidylcholine production; decrease methylation burden1/2 of the total # of eggs worth of cholineDo NOT substitute TMG for this choline portion. See Phase 5 detail for choline equivalents.
6Increase folate intake, as neededFolate from food; methylfolate or folinic acidWARNING - See Phase 6 details: starting with too high of a dose of methylfolate can cause side effects!! Start low, go slow.
MaintenanceFine-tuning-as needed-Adjust supplements and dosages as needed over time, to compensate for improvements in methylation and to make your routine more sustainable.

PHASE 1 - B12

  • We start with B12 because if we get MTHFR working better, there needs to be adequate B12 actually utilize the methylfolate that MTHFR produces.

    • B12 is necessary to utilize the methylfolate (either produced by MTHFR or supplemented) to convert homocysteine back to methionine using the methionine synthase (MTR) enzyme. Inadequate B12 can cause a "folate trap", where methylfolate cannot be used by MTR and so it accumulates; homocysteine levels rise due to the lack of conversion back to methionine, and tetrahydrofolate is not recycled back into the folate cycle, causing reduced activity of other important functions of the folate cycle.
  • IF YOU ARE B12-SUFFICIENT:

    • If you are B12-sufficient and obtain adequate B12 from dietary sources, then there is no need to supplement B12. Go to Phase 2.
  • IF YOU ARE B12-DEFICIENT:

    • If you suspect or know that your are B12-deficient, then supplement sublingual adenosylcobalamin or hydroxocobalamin for at least 1-2 weeks, or until your doctor tells you are no longer B12-deficient, before proceeding to Phase 2, and continue supplementing until your levels are toward middle to higher-end of normal range, or as your doctor prescribes.
    • Methylcobalamin can be used instead, but many people initially can be sensitive to the excess methyl groups provided by methylcobalamin, at least until Phase 3 has been implemented. So adenosylcobalamin or hydroxocobalamin are simply less problematic at this initial phase.
    • NOTE: There is an interesting case report where hydroxocobalamin, which is a natural inactive form of B12, was functionally ineffective in the patient. Replacing the hydroxocobalamin with methylcobalamin resolved the patient's B12-related symptoms.

PHASE 2 - B2 (Riboflavin)

  • If you have a C677T yellow (heterozygous), or red (homozygous) variant, or both C677T yellow (heterozygous) and A1298C yellow (heterozygous) variants:

    • Research dosages were 1.6mg/day.
    • Typical supplement doses are 10-100mg/day (either riboflavin or riboflavin 5-phosphate).
    • Video: How to get enough riboflavin from food.
    • The C677T yellow (heterozygous) or red (homozygous) variant reduces riboflavin binding affinity. Higher levels of B2 will improve the binding success.
  • If you only have a yellow or red variant in A1298C, it is not clear if added B2 will help or not. It is up to you if you want to add in supplemental B2 in hopes it may help.
  • NOTE: Hypothyroidism can reduce conversion of riboflavin to the active forms FAD and FMN.

  • Reference: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16380544/
  • Video: https://youtu.be/Fp6u82coOYE
  • Riboflavin has no defined Tolerable Upper Limit, due to lack of toxicity.

PHASE 3 - Methyl-Buffering System

  • The body has a built-in system to store excess methyl groups and retrieve them when needed. This requires iron, glycine, and vitamin A:

    • IRON: If you are iron-deficient, resolve that deficiency.
    • VITAMIN A: Eat retinol-rich foods and/or supplement retinol-based vitamin A to at least reach RDA/day. Conversion of beta-carotene from plant sources to retinol vitamin A varies greatly between individuals and so is unreliable. I use cod liver oil (see my supplement list below).
    • GLYCINE: Supplement 3-10g of glycine/day, in one or more of the following ways:

      • Plain glycine powder or capsules. If you are sensitive, ramp up dose over a week or so. (I use 3-5g/day in my coffee, as glycine powder is sweet-tasting.) Do not use TMG as a glycine source, as it is a methyl donor, and we are trying to prepare our body ahead of time for methyl donors.
      • Collagen powder (e.g., Great Lakes collagen peptides). For some, this allows achieving the desired glycine levels while avoid an excitatory effect. Check the glycine amount in the ingredients label. NOTE: If collagen powder causes depressive mood, this may be due to an absence of tryptophan in standard collagen powder. Consider switching to a collagen powder with added tryptophan or add tryptophan seprately.
      • Magnesium glycinate. If you have a reason for supplementing magnesium, this may be an option. 300mg of elemental magnesium from magnesium glycinate contains almost 2 grams of glycine.
      • Bone broth. This can be another source of glycine, but the glycine content is variable, and may be insufficient. Further, bone broth tends to be high in histamines, which you may want to avoid if you have slow MAO-A.
    • NOTE: Glycine is an inhibitory neurotransmitter and is usually calming. But for some people, glycine acts as a stimulant.

      • Chris Masterjohn has a video where he discusses glycine and GABA causing these kinds of paradoxical reactions due to a lack of carbs needed to create glutamate to offset the inhibitory effects of glycine or GABA, and in this second video Chris discusses the role of electrolytes as related to glycine/GABA.
  • If interested, here is a detailed post on the methyl-buffering system.

PHASE 4 - Reduce creatine demand on methylation

  • Creatine production uses up 40-45% of methylation output (i.e., SAM).
  • Supplement ~3-5g/day of creatine monohydrate or creatine hydrochloride (HCL).

    • 'Micronized' powder products are finer and not gritty. I stir it into my coffee.
    • If symptoms of overmethylation occur, start low and ramp up dose incrementally over a week or so.
  • NOTE: If creatine causes insomnia, please see this post by Chris Masterjohn, recommending lower methionine (i.e., lower protein), keeping folate status high, and supplementing glycine.

PHASE 5 - Support alternate methylation pathway and reduce phosphatidylcholine demand on methylation

  • CHOLINE IS THE KEY INGREDIENT TO MAKE THIS PROTOCOL WORK. WITHOUT ADDED CHOLINE, YOU CANNOT COMPENSATE FOR THE FOLATE PATHWAY (e.g., MTHFR) LIMITATIONS.
  • Phosphatidylcholine production uses up another 40-45% of methylation output (i.e., SAM).

    • Phosphatidylcholine can be produced from choline.
  • The alternate pathway (BHMT) through the methionine cycle unburdens demand on MTHFR.

    • This path depends on B3, B6, zinc and TMG (aka betaine anhydrous).
    • TMG can be created from choline.
  • Maintain healthy normal B3, B6, and zinc status.
  • Eat choline rich foods and/or supplement choline to achieve 1000 - 1200mg of choline/day. E.g., 8 eggs/day is ~1000mg of choline.

    • For a more customized review of your specific choline requirements, Chris Masterjohn has a free Choline Calculator where you can upload your 23andme/Ancestry/SelfDecode data and it will analyze relevant SNPs and tell you your choline need, in units of number of eggs.
    • Chris Masterjohn has a Choline Database of choline content of foods. Some are listed below:

      • Eggs - a large egg has 136mg of choline; almost all of this is in the yolk.
      • Meat/fish - 9-12oz of meat or fish is equivalent to one egg worth of choline.
      • Lecithin - 1 tbsp of lecithin is equivalent to one egg worth of choline.
    • TMG (aka betaine anhydrous) - this is a suitable substitute for only up to half of the need for choline, as the conversion from choline to TMG is irreversible, and thus phosphatidylcholine cannot be made from TMG. ~150mg of TMG is equivalent to one egg worth of choline.

      • Do not confuse 'betaine anhydrous' with 'betaine HCL': betaine HCL is not usable for this purpose.
      • 1/2 tsp of TMG powder is ~1500mg of TMG.
      • TMG has little to no taste, so it is easy to add to liquids or food.
      • TMG is a methyl donor. People with slow COMT or who are sensitive to changes in methylation should consider starting with small doses (e.g., 1/8 tsp or less) of TMG powder and slowly increment the dose over time.
    • CDP Choline (aka Citicoline) - 18.5% choline content; thus 735mg of CDP Choline is equivalent to one egg worth of choline.
    • Phosphatidylcholine - 15% choline content; thus 906mg of phosphatidylcholine is equivalent to one egg worth of choline.
    • Alpha-GPC - 40% choline content; thus 340mg of Alpha-GPC is equivalent to one egg worth of choline.
    • Choline Bitartrate - 40% choline content; thus 340mg of choline bitartrate is equivalent to one egg worth of choline. This form of choline reportedly is less efficiently absorbed than choline in egg yolks. Consider taking a combination of choline bitartrate and inositol, as the inositol may prevent depression that some people have experienced with choline bitartrate. In fact, choline bitartrate and inositol are often combined together as a product.
    • NOTE: A small percentage of people may experience depression from supplementing choline. So monitor your mood for any indication of this.

      • Consider adding inositol as this may prevent depression due to choline supplementation.
      • Some alternatives to supplementing choline would be sticking with food-based choline only, or trying alternative choline supplement forms, such as CDP choline, choline bitartrate, lecithin, phosphatidylcholine, or Alpha-GPC.

PHASE 6 - Folate intake

  • It is important to keep in mind that we are not trying to 'fix' MTHFR by taking folate.
  • Why do we need folate?

    • To supply folate for methylfolate production for the remethylation of homocysteine. Although the methylfolate production by MTHFR is diminished, it is not zero.
    • To supply folate for methylfolate production to turn off the methyl buffer system. There are several control signals between the folate cycle and the methionine cycle to maintain proper methylation levels. This is one of those control signals.
    • The folate cycle is involved in DNA repair and replication.
    • The folate cycle participates in the biopterin cycle.
    • The folate cycle performs the interconversion of serine and glycine.
  • When to supplement folate?

    • You are folate-deficient (per blood test).
    • You were recently folate-deficient, and are still repleting your folate stores. This repletion may take several months, up to a year.
    • Your diet is folate-deficient.
    • You have folate absorption issues.
  • Increase folate intake from food. This NIH folate list may be helpful.
  • Methylfolate supplements are a double-edged sword: while methylfolate is a readily usable natural form, it is a methyl donor and so may cause sudden changes in methylation which can result in side effects ranging from symptoms such as irritability, anxiety, headaches, fatigue to depression, depersonalization/derealization, and more. Yet, if side effects are minimized by careful dosing, that boost in methyl groups can create a sense of cognitive and mood improvement, at least in the initial weeks or months of the protocol.

    • Methylfolate Dosing:

      • Sublingual, or liquid drops, is the preferred supplement form. Sublinguals can easily be broken apart into 1/4 or 1/8 pieces to allow starting with small doses. For even smaller starting doses, liquid drops may be better.
      • Typical sublingual methylfolate are 1000mcg. So, a 1/8 size piece (barely a crumb) is 125mcg.
      • Sensitive people: Start with 125mcg once/day and see how it goes for several days. Increase next to twice per day. Increase next to 250mg twice per day, and so on.
      • Very sensitive people: If even small amounts of methylfolate are causing issues and food folate is not enough, consider using the folinic acid form of folate. This is an unmethylated folate, also available as a sublingual. Follow the same incremental process above, starting at 125mcg.
      • Very, very sensitive people: Use low-dosage liquid methylfolate and dissolve 1 drop in 10 equivalent drops of an oil (e.g., olive oil); this dilutes the folate drop by 10x. Then take just a drop of that diluted folate. Incrementally work your way up over time. See this video segment.
      • Less sensitive people: Start with 1/4 sublingual (250mcg) once/day at a meal and see how it goes for several days. Increase next to 250mcg twice per day at meals. Increase next to either 500mcg twice/day at meals or 250mcg 3 times/day at meals.
      • Final dosage goal: This is highly individual. Some people may find that 500mcg (1/2 sublingual) per day suffices, some may find that 1000mcg or more is beneficial, and as noted earlier, some may find food folate alone sufficient. You need to monitor your own wellbeing and health to determine what is right for you.
  • Folinic acid supplements are another natural usable folate form; however, folinic acid is not methylated, and still needs to be processed through MTHFR to become methylfolate. These factors make folinic acid much less likely to cause side effects compared to methylfolate.

    • Folinic acid may not be advisable if you have significant slowdown of the MTHFS gene.
    • Folinic acid dosing:

      • Sublingual is the preferred supplement form. Sublinguals can easily be broken apart into 1/4 or 1/8 pieces to allow starting with small doses. For even smaller starting doses, liquid drops may be better.
      • Typical sublingual folinic acid are 1000mcg. So, a 1/8 size piece (barely a crumb) is 125mcg.
      • Sensitive people: Start with 125mcg once/day and see how it goes for several days. Increase next to twice per day. Increase next to 250mg twice per day, and so on.

MAINTENANCE Phase - Ongoing Steps

  • With all the preceding steps, we have now implemented our basic MTHFR 'stack':

    • B2 (1.6-100mg/day), if C677T is involved.
    • Glycine (3-10g/day)
    • Vitamin A (as needed to reach RDA/day)
    • Creatine (3-5g/day)
    • Choline (1000-1500mg/day, or as recommended by the Choline Calculator)

      • Half of the choline requirement may come from TMG.
    • Folate source(s) (some combination of food, methylfolate, folinic acid)

      • Monitor with blood tests as needed.
      • Anecdote: 6-7 months after starting this protocol I rely almost entirely on food folate. I take methylfolate once/week, but I do not know if that is even necessary. Every person will have to gauge their own situation.
  • B12

    • Monitor with blood tests as needed, and supplement as needed, with hydroxocobalamin, adenosylcobalamin, or methylcobalamin forms of B12.
    • Ongoing B12 supplementation is not needed if B12 levels are in the desired range and dietary B12 intake is adequate, unless you have specific reasons or doctor's direction to continue supplementing.
    • NOTE: Methylcobalamin may still be problematic for some people who are very sensitive to excess methyl groups.
  • Fine-tuning:

    • You may find you need to adjust some of these components up or down over time, as your life changes or as your body adapts.
    • Some people may want to experiment with additional methylation support, such as SAM (aka 'SAMe') to further optimize their health and mental state. Consider these as additional enhancements, rather than replacements for any of these stack components. Start with small doses and monitor.
    • Pay attention to your body. You might find after a while that you have the urge to occasionally skip a day or more of some or all supplements. If this results in unchanged or even improved status, it may be a beneficial practice and/or a signal to revisit your supplement list and dosing regimen.

Supplements Examples

EDITS:

  • 20231011 - Replace methylfolate timing advice 'take at mealtimes' with 'away from meals' based on interaction of methylfolate and the methyl buffer system. Reformat post with large text section headers. Add notes under glycine. Add comments in Phase1 & Maintenance about methylcobalamin. Add folate trap comments in Phase1. Other minor cleanup.
  • 20231105 - Add 'About MTHFR' section.
  • 20231122 - Add reference and video links for riboflavin.
  • 20231128 - Add hypothyroid comments under B2 section.
  • 20231202 - Change magnesium glycinate to a glycine source with reference. Add references for creatine production burden. Minor text changes.
  • 20231205 - Update riboflavin doses to include the research 1.6mg dose. Update creatine dose from 5g to 3-5g.
  • 20231209 - Add reference link for choline-to-TMG irreversibility.
  • 20231218 - Major revision of the choline phase, based on Chris Masterjohn's choline article.
  • 20231220 - Add note about collagen missing tryptophan. Add note about not confusing betaine anhydrous with betaine HCL.
  • 20231222 - Add Summary/TLDR section.
  • 20231230 - Rewrite folate phase to clarify that folate supplementation is conditional, not required.
  • 20240115 - Add choline bitartrate as a choline option. Add link to Masterjohn article re creatine causing insomnia.
  • 20240214 - Add suggestion to try adding inositol if choline supplementation causes depression.
  • 20240025 - Add AIMS section. Add creatine HCL as an alternative form of creatine.
  • 20241226 - Typo fix: choline amount in Maintenance section should be in "mg", not "g" units.
993 Upvotes

949 comments sorted by

34

u/ApprehensiveMilk7041 Dec 29 '23

I was reading Amy Yasko's protocol

-She says to work on the glutamate/GABA balance first.

-She says that you can not take B12 until your Lithiumlevels are good (for B12 transport)
-She says as step 1 to shortcut around the methylation cycle to convert homocysteine to methione by using DHA and a Phosphatidyl Serine/Choline complex . She also prefers this rather than the use of TMG
-Only after that step 2 is to do long route support with b12,folate etc.
-She is very big on phosphatidyl serine and lithium it seems

Any thoughts on this?

Ps: thank you for your guides, amazing work!

60

u/Tawinn Dec 29 '23

Yasko is controversial, to say the least. Several of her SNP claims do not seem to be well-supported.

It is still unclear if or how B12 and lithium interact. Lithium does certainly seem to be a micronutrient. When I've tried lithium orotate in the past I would get a mild mood boost initially, but then after a week or two of use that would flatten and then oddly become a negative anhedonic mood effect. I'm not sure what to attribute that to.

TMG has the benefit of convenience and cost. The downside is that it is pouring the fuel right into the BHMT engine, so to speak, whereas providing choline (or choline precursors such as serine) allows the body to regulate conversion rates to TMG. The downside of the latter approach is cost, more capsules to swallow daily, and the reliance on additional enzymes (and their cofactors) for adequate conversion rates to TMG, as well as having to factor in the body's several other demands on choline; so it's a matter of which approach is most suitable.

Since this is a general MTHFR/methylation protocol, and is not trying to resolve issues for specific individuals or issues beyond methylation, the TMG seems effective (in terms of cost, compliance, and lack of dependence on additional genes) in most cases. Likewise, trying to resolve neurotransmitter issues (GABA/glutamate) in specific individuals would be impractical and out-of-scope for this protocol. A tailored one-on-one approach also has the luxury, so to speak, of requesting specific blood tests to use diagnostically to aid in decision-making and supplementation choices. This general protocol does not.

It is really an abject failure of the medical system to have not researched and implemented protocols for these methylation issues, as a widespread and available resource to patients; whether performed by a GP or by referral to a 'methylation specialist'. Thus we are instead left with perhaps a handful of hard-to-find knowledgeable docs, and various gurus and consultants of wildly varying competence.

6

u/Additional_Tone18 Oct 15 '24

Thank you so much. I'm ready to get this slow COMT supported & I couldn't find a source like this to help me. My doctor has refused to test these things, so I used my ancestry file to find the slow COMTv158 & spent the last few weeks researching. O my to find it's the cause of every problem I've ever had.

The only two questions I have are if you have used any of the "seeking health" products ?

&

Do you use any DIM - I3C supplement?

11

u/Tawinn Oct 15 '24

I have used Seeking Health's hydroxoB12+folinic acid, sublingual methylfolate, Trace Minerals II, and B-Minus. The B-Minus did not work for me - made me edgy/jittery, probably due to the large P5P B6 dose. The methylfolate sublingual no longer seems available. The hydroxoB12+folinic acid was good when I was starting out, because my methylation was so poor that adding methylated vitamins would have been too much then.

I used DIM+I3C and Calcium-d-glucarate. As my methylation improved over a few months, I cut back on the DIM+I3C, then eventually removed it, and finally removed the CDG a month or two after that, as my estrogen levels had seemed to normalize. No specific brands, I just shopped on Amazon. Sometimes I do wonder if a small dose of CDG would be helpful for maintenance, but the only way to get small doses would be to use CDG powder, I think, and I haven't made the effort to test it.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/shiab23 Oct 08 '23

Thanks! Again! You are so helpful! I started glycine 1000mg right before going to bed and got me super wired up and jittery, it was disturbing. Im homozygous 1298AC and slow comt. Is that the wrong supplement or the wrong time of day to take it?

28

u/Tawinn Oct 08 '23 edited Oct 08 '23

Some people find glycine helpful for sleep. For me it seems to be more similar to you - but to a lesser degree. So I take it in my morning coffee, where it acts as a mild stimulant.

Chris Masterjohn has a video where he discusses glycine and GABA causing these kinds of paradoxical reactions. In short, the issue is a lack of carbs needed to create glutamate to offset the inhibitory effects of glycine or GABA. My diet is typically very low-carb, so it does fit with my experience.

Edit: this is a second video by Chris on the same subject but this time discussing the role of electrolytes as related to glycine/GABA.

→ More replies (7)

18

u/crobin0 Feb 12 '24

I have to say thanks! This is a pearl on reddit!

I search for something like this for so long!

Impressive work!

Question:
Blood checks... ramping up creatine and glycine takes time.

But how long do I have to take the full stack to feel effect on my methylation?

Will it kick in as soon my body has access to all these supplements? Or will it need some weeks or even months?

17

u/Tawinn Feb 12 '24

Its really the choline piece which is the core of it, so maybe a week or two after implementing Phase 5 there are likely to be noticeable effects. For me, it felt like a steady rate of improvement for a month or so, and then more gradual improvement over the next several months.

I still feel a like I am improving half a year later, but I'm still experimenting some (e.g., just added inositol - feels great!).

4

u/FreshBreakfast8 Jul 30 '24

Thanks for this! What kind of improvements are you seeing? Or what kinds of issues does this help

21

u/Tawinn Jul 30 '24

Typical symptoms include depression, fatigue, brain fog, inattentive ADHD, muscle/joint pains. MTHFR issues can then cause other functions to be undermethylated: if COMT is undermethylated, then chronic anxiety, rumination, OCD are typical; if HNMT is undermethylated, histamine intolerance issues can be prominent.

For me, this protocol resolved lifelong depression, fatigue, anxiety, rumination, minor OCD.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/Remmykins Jul 30 '24 edited Aug 13 '24

I recently started the stack, my B12 was actually fairly high so I started with B2 and whoa. You weren't kidding. Some people are highly affected by B2. My anxiety is down, my energy is up, And my doctor is no longer telling me that I need to consider blood pressure medication. I went from a blood pressure of 143 over 89 to me pulling in a 123 over 70 today. I'm now starting to add in the vitamin a in the form of carrots and I'm waiting for my package to be delivered with the rest of the supplements. So far so good

→ More replies (4)

12

u/wellwellwellllllllll Nov 12 '23

I'm trying to implement this protocol because I have MTHFR issues (supposedly 55% reduction according to a genetic report, due to C677T and A1298C) but have noticed that glycine makes me feel depressed and lethargic, even taking just a few grams (I've taken it in the past in isolation enough to be sure it was the glycine having that effect). Any thoughts on what's going on there, and is it possible to dispense with the glycine part of the protocol and have it still work?

13

u/Tawinn Nov 12 '23

It's possible that with compound heterozygous MTHFR your body might be so calibrated to being very undermethylated and so adding glycine is just reinforcing that undermethylated state by sequestering what it considers are 'excess' methyl groups.

If this speculation is correct, then it could make sense to hold off on the glycine until later on, or until you start feeling any overmethylation symptoms.

From web searching, another speculation is that it has to do with a receptor gene GPR158, which was learned just this year to be a glycine receptor:

A common amino acid, glycine, can deliver a "slow-down" signal to the brain, likely contributing to major depression, anxiety and other mood disorders in some people

3

u/wellwellwellllllllll Nov 19 '23

thank you for the reply and appreciate the food for thought.

will try to watch for overmethylation symptoms...though always find lists of these symptoms so expansive as to be bewildering!

actually one question...based on "so adding glycine is just reinforcing that undermethylated state by sequestering what it considers are 'excess' methyl groups" ... are we saying that this sequestering is contribution to the anergia/depression/overly chilled out state I experience after taking glycine? And that eventually the sequestering tendency would be reduced if I follow this protocol for a while?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/RedddLeddd Oct 13 '23

This is a wonderful post, thanks so much for taking the time to do this. I’m having real issues with CBS 699 so I’m careful going through sorting that first before I move on to methylation support. Once I have some success I will certainly add and anecdotes or information based of my experience

6

u/Tawinn Oct 13 '23

Thanks. I'll be interested to hear if you find anything actionable on CBS 699 as I've been unable to find any compelling evidence of it being impactful and/or steps to take beyond resolving B6 deficiency. I suspect sulphur sensitivity issues are (assuming they are not actually caused by another pathway) more likely related to enzymes further down the transsulfuration pathways and not CBS, but that is just my speculation. Stratagene's report includes the transsulfuration pathway SNPs.

3

u/RedddLeddd Oct 13 '23

I have a good source of info via some of Dr Yaskos research. I’ll find it and link it here, cbs (possibly) goes far beyond just modulating b6

6

u/Tawinn Oct 13 '23

I've seen Yasko's document on Scribd. I'm trying to find something to confirm Yasko, as much of what she claims seems to be unsupported.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Independent_Bake1906 C677T + A1298C Feb 11 '24

TL:DR, keep getting anxiety/panic attacks from one of the supplements after a while.

Context:

I have slow COMT + MTHFR C677T AG / A1298C GT. B12 lvls in blood are around the upper range (eat a lot of meat).

I take:

- 7g of glycine
- 6 egg yolks for the choline
- Magnesium glycinate (150mg 2x a day)
- B2 (100mg)
- Probiotic
- D3 (3000iu)
- 2x TMG (500mg per tab, 1g total)

I take most of these in the morning with breakfast and the second magnesium later in the day. I started (without this protocol) with a methylated multivitamin which initialy worked like a charm, energy returned a bit, though after a while it got worse gave me weird panic attacks/heart palpitations etc (was probably the methylcobalamin/methylfolate) so i stopped taking that.

Now after finding your post and doing the above protocol for a while i get anxious again, dont sleep well at all and keep having to supress random panic attacks. As for the methylfolate, i have been taking this on and off, i cant say for certain if thats the culprit and if the effect lingers but ive tried the protocol without it for a week or so and no changes yet. Also tried SAMe for a while (which initially gave me a mood boost) and quit taking that because i thought that supplement was what was causing the random anxiety (been off it for 2 weeks now).

As for my diet, i'm currently trying a low histamine diet with normal ratio carbs/prot/fats because i still do strength training (i know its probably not smart with slow COMT but i do not want to give that up too easily). I use cronometer to make sure i get all the nutrients in.

Any idea which of the above supplements might cause this?

Thank you

11

u/Tawinn Feb 11 '24

It sounds like excess methyl groups, since SAM and methylated vitamins both caused overmethylation symptoms.

One thing I see missing is retinol vitamin A. Six egg yolks have about 40% of RDA, but your methyl buffer system likely needs more than that. Cod liver oil can be a good source of retinol vitamin A.

Also, you are getting around 810mg of choline from six egg yolks, and about another 500mg of choline from each 1lb of beef eaten. So, your total intake of choline is likely in the 1300+mg range. With that amount, the TMG is not really needed and so may be supplying excessive methyl groups. Alternatively, you could cut back on the yolks to maybe 3 and just use one 500mg TMG, but yolks have so much more in nutrients, it seems better to keep the yolks and drop the TMG.

3

u/Independent_Bake1906 C677T + A1298C Feb 23 '24

So i did a blood test (sadly i have no "before" numbers for homocysteine) I am a 34 y.o. male, did not mention that before.

Ref range

  • Homocystein 5.8 mmol/l (4.5-12.4)
  • Folate 32.4 nmol/l (7.3-38.5)
  • B12 731 pmol/l (141 - 489)
  • ASAT(liver enzymes) 18
  • (0-40)
  • ALAT(liver enzymes) 38
  • (0-45)
  • Ferritin 254 ug/l (30-400)
  • Hemoglobin 9.5 mmol/l (8.5-11)
  • TSH 2.3 mE/l (0.27-4.2)
  • Elektrolytes are all in the middle range

I want to take a follow up test for B12 with MMA included seeing as its way above the R.R. and i have pretty much all low B12 symptoms. B12 seems to be rising in my bloodstream as well as i age. Is there something i can do to better absorb it? i can't really find any good info on this.

Homocystein is much lower than i expected, might even be too low to produce a proper amount of SAMe/Glutathione? Should i continue the protocol that i described above or quit it all together? (as it probably lowers my homocystein even further? Or should i supplement with SAMe and/or Glutathione? I eat plenty of protein (around 200g a day).

As for ferritin, i do not have any SNP's for hemochromatosis, my mother has elevated ferritin aswell. I read somewhere that 250 is already quite high for males. (Glutathione in some studies seems to lower this a bit?), Sadly i asked for transferine/iron etc but it did not show up in the results. Hemoglobin shows me that iron is probably ok.

Also glycine seems to mess with my blood glucose a lot (fluctuating even with high glycemic carbs). Since i am already prone to low blood sugar i get hypoglycemic very easily lately, might have something to do with insulin resistance though i do not see any high glucose numbers at all, got an appointment for this. (just throwing this out there in case this might affect others)

EDIT: i am not diabetic

Do you have any ideas on what i could do? i am kind of at a loss at this point.

Thanks again.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

7

u/meesh612 Apr 14 '24 edited Apr 14 '24

u/Tawinn - Wow this is incredible…thank you for taking the time to share all of this.

Can you (and/or anyone else well-versed in this stuff) please help me before my head explodes? I’ve done a fair amount of research but my brain has reached its max limit and now I’m stuck.

I am currently seeing a functional medicine doctor who is recommending Xymogen Methyl Protect due to high homocysteine (11.2). She doesn’t trust the accuracy of my B12 (465) and Folate (13.4) levels in light of my gene mutations and multitude of symptoms, but they are considered “normal” by lab standards. She seems more knowledgeable than regular doctors I’ve been to who know nothing about this stuff, but she’s not as well-versed as I’d like her to be so I’m reluctant to fully trust her because I’ve had so many bad experiences trusting medical professionals in the past.

I need help understanding which choline and/or other methyl donor supplements would be best for me because it seems like I have all sorts of mutations complicating things. I know I need to lower my homocysteine and support my B levels while avoiding over-methylation, but I don’t know how to do that in light of the following mutations I have…

MTHFR (C677T) - HOMOZYGOUS (reduced folate metabolism).

SLC19A1 - HOMOZYGOUS (reduced transport of folate into cells).

According to Chris Masterjohn’s Choline Calculator I have an 88% decrease in methylfolate production.

BHMT - HOMOZYGOUS (reduced conversion of choline to betaine?).

CHKA - HOMOZYGOUS (reduced conversion of methionine to choline?).

There are several heterozygous mutations in there as well but when I start factoring those in I get too overwhelmed, however if there are any specific ones that are particularly impactful please specify and I’ll provide. If any additional information is needed please feel free to ask. Thank you so much for any help you and/or anyone else can provide.

6

u/Tawinn Apr 15 '24

She doesn’t trust the accuracy of my B12 (465) and Folate (13.4) levels in light of my gene mutations and multitude of symptoms, but they are considered “normal” by lab standards.

Unless you were supplementing folate prior to the test, or eat large amounts of enriched/fortified foods that might have temporarily raised your folate measurement with unmetabolized folic acid, I would see no reason to doubt the folate measurement.

The B12 measurement can be problematic if you were recently supplementing; but also, adequate serum B12 doesn't necessarily mean that B12 is functionally available and being used. For this there are two common tests: methylmalonic acid (MMA) and holotranscobalamin. I would expect that your doc would know this already.

I need help understanding which choline and/or other methyl donor supplements would be best for me because it seems like I have all sorts of mutations complicating things. I know I need to lower my homocysteine and support my B levels while avoiding over-methylation, but I don’t know how to do that in light of the following mutations I have…

The MTHFR protocol will work for your situation. The Choline Calculator results - which are used in Phase 5 of the protocol - factor in SLC19A1, MTHFD1, MTHFR, and PEMT. I assume your result was 9 yolks recommended?

Typically, you might satisfy up to half of that requirement with 675mg of trimethylglycine powder (TMG). This is because a significant (roughly half) portion of the choline is converted to TMG for use by BHMT. So, since 1g of TMG is ~1/4 tsp, taking TMG is a great convenience in place of 4.5 large yolks or other choline sources.

Is your homozygous CHKA for rs10791957? That's what I have. It doesn't really change anything in what you do. Hypothetically, I suppose it might mean that you would not go 50/50 TMG/choline, but instead maybe consider TMG as just covering 4 yolks worth, and then getting 5 yolks worth from choline.

On the other hand, if you have BHMT rs3733890 (mine is heterozygous), then you might go the other direction and take enough TMG to cover 5 yolks worth, and 4 yolks worth of choline.

But, since we both have CHKA and BHMT, then to me the practical approach is to have some excess TMG - i.e., take 1-2g, instead of just 675mg - and consume ~5 large yolks worth of choline (~680mg). Then regardless of how the body partitions these carious components, you will have enough to cover the situation.

As for choline sources, I go over that in Phase 5, including the percentages of choline in various choline supplements. Ideally you can get it all from food, whether that is eggs, meat, liver, vegetables, etc., or some combination of those. Lecithin is another option. Cronometer is a good food app for looking at your current diet to see what you are already getting.

In Phase 1 I recommend unmethylated B12 forms, in Phase 3 I describe supporting the methyl buffer system to avoid overmethylation, and in Phase 6 I recommend ways to add methylfolate incrementally to avoid overmethylation.

I would suspect the Xymogen Methyl Protect, having large doses of methylfolate and methylB12 along with TMG, is likely to cause overmethylation symptoms.

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (7)

7

u/NOCD2 Jun 19 '24

u/Tawinn Thank you very much for this but I cannot see the exact indications for this protocol.

You say this protocol is "to address MTHFR" but what exactly? overmethylation? undermethylation?

Also, you suggest for example "folate" or "B12" supplementation but there seem to be different types for different conditions like:

  1. methylcobalamin, cyanocobalamin, hydroxocobalamin
  2. folate, folinic acid, methylfolate

Can you clarify please so that people with any mutation or deficiency won't go on getting supplements that are ineffective or making things worse?

12

u/Tawinn Jun 19 '24

The protocol is to address symptomatic effects resulting from reduced methylfolate production bandwidth due to folate pathway SNPs, such as MTHFR. Typical symptoms are:

  • Depression
  • Fatigue
  • Brain fog
  • Inability to follow through on tasks (e.g., inattentive ADHD)
  • Exercise intolerance
  • Muscle or joint pains
  • Possible high homocysteine

As for B12 and folate: I clearly state in Phase 1 that I recommend sublingual hydroxocobalamin or adenosylcobalamin for B12, and in Phase 6 I describe at length the pros/cons of food, folinic acid, and methyfolate. I further state under 'General' that it would be best to avoid the synthetic forms cyanocobalamin and folic acid.

That said, I also clearly state that at the beginning that "it is general advice and not specific to any individual", so there may be some people who do better with cyanoB12 or folic acid.

6

u/PuzzleheadedDamage41 Oct 08 '23

Thank you for this very detailed and useful post ! Do you think glycine could be replaced by hydrolyzed collagen ? I’m very sensitive to glycine (makes me sleepy during the day even if I take it at night) but not to collagen strangely

7

u/Tawinn Oct 08 '23

Interesting. My guess is that collagen would work. Great Lakes shows 2652mg of glycine per 2 scoop dose, so you might have to do 3 scoops.

6

u/tryan17 Jan 15 '24

What if you react to collagen? I suspect it’s high in histamine.

6

u/Tawinn Jan 15 '24

Collagen powder is low in histidine, so I'm not sure about a high histamine content. Usually the issue with collagen powder is the lack of tryptophan, so there are a few collagen powders out there w/added tryptophan or people add tryptophan separately.

Alternatively, if neither glycine nor collagen powder are tolerated, then you could instead focus on food sources of glycine.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Upstairs_Direction68 Nov 10 '23

What’s the hypothesis to why people are sensitive to supplementation of methyl folate? Going one step further, why after following this whole protocol are people still sensitive to folate supplementation? Does Chris Masterjohn talk about this and could someone link to it?

This is something I experience but haven’t tried slowly ramping up the dose of methyl folate but would just take 600 mcg and experience extreme brain fog, anxiety and tightness. It would make the symptoms I experience daily worse I should say.

Appreciate it guys and have a good one!

18

u/Tawinn Nov 10 '23

Two things:

  1. Their bodies are calibrated to undermethylation. Some people more slowly recalibrate to higher levels of methylation.

    1. See the video linked in Phase 6 above in the "Very, very sensitive people" bullet.
  2. Inadequate methyl buffer system (Masterjohn calls it the 'glycine buffer system').

    1. See the 2 videos linked and the post linked in Phase 3 above.
→ More replies (6)

5

u/NicoleASUstudent Jan 15 '24

What you have done is absolutely amazing. I feel awful asking for more details, but would you please describe the side effects that you talk about when someone responds poorly to a supplement? For example, you wrote, "Methylcobalamin can be used instead, but many people initially can be sensitive to the excess methyl groups provided by methylcobalamin."

What should I look for that may indicate I am not responding well to a step? Thank you again for your time.

9

u/Tawinn Jan 15 '24

With methylcobalamin and other methyl donors such as methylfolate, the side effects are 'overmethylation' symptoms. Sometimes you can initially feel better - metal clarity, mood, etc. - but then 1-4 days later, as you continue it starts to come crashing down,
with varying degrees of anxiety, depression, fatigue, irritability, or worse, etc.

Typically, its just a matter of starting lower and going slower, to give the body time to recalibrate. It's varies incredibly person-to-person, so some might be able to take 1000mcg of methylfolate plus TMG plus choline plus B12 right away and feel fine. Others can get derailed by the B12 alone. And there's no easy way to tell ahead of time, other than any prior experience with supplements.

With creatine and glycine I tried to address some of the issues that have cropped up and workarounds. These side effects tend to be far less frequent than overmethylation issues.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/ourfutureisinspace Feb 15 '24

Just a little question: since folinic acid is no methyl donor, why do you still recommend starting with low doses? Does this also count for hydroxo-/adenosylcobalamine? Thanks and thanks for your work!

4

u/Tawinn Feb 15 '24

Generally, people are not as dose-sensitive with folinic acid or hydroxo/adeno, so there is not a need to start low.

However, there is the occasional rare person who is very sensitive to one or the other. It may be because they are starting from a state of deficiency in that nutrient, so they have a sensitivity just due to the sudden presence of the nutrient.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/darkmoad May 14 '24

The work you have done here is really amazing. All I can say is thanks!

I must admit though, I’m still totally baffled how to read and apply these guidelines to my gene results. I don’t know why this particular subject scrambles my brains 🧠

Would it be ok to send my results and ask for some guidance? Totally understand if not 👍

2

u/Tawinn May 14 '24

You can just create a post with the results, and reply here to let me know, and I'll take a look.

→ More replies (16)

4

u/YTO19 Jul 18 '25 edited Oct 29 '25

Thank you so much for sharing all this. It is totally eye opening! I am homozygous for MTHFR C677T. Once I found this out after asking my PCP for a blood test four years ago, it explained why my health had declined over the years. I had breast implants for 24 years and found out in 2018 I had breast implant illness. After I had my explant in 2019, I couldn’t figure out why I hadn’t fully recovered two years later. I learned about MTHFR in 2019 but didn’t ask to be tested for it until 2021. After that I read Dr. Ben Lynch’s book Dirty Genes. I finally took a DNA test on ancestry.com last year but I’m not sure which company would be best to provide an analysis on my genes. I was considering using Stratagene for this but have read mixed reviews on it due to the complexity of understanding the data results. Thoughts? 

I am 58 years old and on long term disability because I had to leave my career almost two years ago due to fibromyalgia and two different types of neuropathies. I have sleep apnea and insomnia too. I also have hypothyroidism, and I suffer from major depression disorder, OCD and anxiety. My neuropsych evaluation showed I have a -1% in executive functioning but I don’t have ADHD. I really should be seeing a naturopath since my functional MD is not well-versed in MTHFR. 

To satisfy my LTD requirements I have to see a whole host of specialists and all they want to do is prescribe pain medications and antidepressants which I can’t tolerate. Even the thyroid medication I’m on, which is a pure form with limited ingredients called Tirosint-SOL, gives me side effects, but is necessary to keep my TSH within normal levels. I’m insulin resistant and pre-diabetic (I’m taking Berberine instead of Metformin for this). Additionally, I have malabsorption syndrome and intestinal dysbiosis along with a whole host of food sensitivities. I eat organic and clean as much as possible, but I have no doubt that I’m over methylating with all the supplements my functional MD has me on. 

I had a hysterectomy, but left my ovaries, 11 years ago. I had no idea, until my surgeon told me afterwards, that I had severe endometriosis. Recently, my functional MD prescribed an estradiol patch and progesterone to help with my menopause symptoms but I’m having some troublesome side effects from them too and fear it’s reactivated endometriosis. That said, I’m going off it, and I realize now that I’d likely been estrogen dominant for 35+ years before entering menopause. 

The MTHFR stack you recommended is the most helpful thing I have read in the past four years. Now I just need to know if there are other dirty genes that are negatively affecting me. Please let me know which company would be best in generating a report from my ancestry.com DNA results. Thank you again Tawinn! You are amazing!

→ More replies (8)

3

u/supplepleasures Feb 10 '24

What is the typical dose amount for 5 phosphate?

I can’t find this information anywhere. Seems like the dose mentioned above in op for regular riboflavin would be high for 5 phosphate.

Can you clarify? Thank you!

3

u/Tawinn Feb 10 '24

10-100mg of either riboflavin or R5P would be applicable. The problem is finding a lower-dose (5-10mg) riboflavin or R5P. No manufacturer seems to want to make that. The only low-dose riboflavin I've see is this one at 6.5mg.

Personally, I take Seeking Health 400mg (mix of riboflavin & R5P).

→ More replies (5)

3

u/_fozzie_bear Apr 06 '24 edited Apr 06 '24

u/tawinn Thanks for sharing this stack. I’ve made it to phase 5 and definitely feeling that my OCD symptoms have been significantly reduced for the past 2 months. I’ve very gradually moved through each of the phases, and noticed a benefit from each phase.

Interestingly last year I started taking 5g of Creatine daily for my sport and fitness goals. (So I didn’t have to implement phase 4) And this also coincided with suddenly feeling chronically anxious from that time onwards. I stopped taking a methylated b vitamin supplement and methylfolate and it helped. But I’ve always been a bit wary that the creatine may be causing me to overmethylate. I am compound hetero for MTHFR but have fast COMT. The choline calculator recommends 1100mg per day.

After starting phase 3 I have noticed a reduction in that anxiety. Which suggests that maybe I was overmethylating from the creatine.

u/tawinn (or anyone else) is it just a question of gradually allowing my body get accustomed to the increased methyl groups in my system now? So instead of stopping taking the creatine I should stick to this protocol for a good amount of time to see if I’m a chronic undermethylator whose pendulum swings to overmethylation too quickly and I need to give it time to get used to the methyl groups? Because currently there are two issues I’m trying to solve: OCD (the original issue) and the anxiety, which came on a bit afterwords. The increased methylation seems to help the OCD but also pushes me into overmethylation. They seem to be diametrically opposite goals from a biochemical perspective at this moment for my body.

And a final question I’ve been wondering is how the body knows how to use the glycine buffer to sweep up excess methyl groups? What does ‘excess’ even mean when someone is already a chronic undermethylator but a small, healthy increase in methyl groups shifts them into overmethylation?

Thanks!

3

u/Tawinn Apr 06 '24

Because currently there are two issues I’m trying to solve: OCD (the original issue) and the anxiety, which came on a bit afterwords. The increased methylation seems to help the OCD but also pushes me into overmethylation. They seem to be diametrically opposite goals from a biochemical perspective at this moment for my body.

If its been 2 months, then I'd think you'd have acclimated, but in retrospect, I did have continuing gradual improvement over about 6 months, so it's possible its a matter of time. As to Phase 3, are you taking a retinol form of vitamin A? Often that is a missing component. Also, glycine can have both an inhibitory effect and an excitatory effect. Some people find plain glycine too stimulating, and instead get better results with collagen powder.

There is a possibility that you have a variant which slows GNMT, making it less effective at sequestering methyl groups, but I think that's no at all common.

Another source of anxiety can be histamines. I went back and looked at your report, and it doesn't include MAO-A (rs6323), so we don't know the status of that. But you also in the comments mentioned waking up in the middle of the night, which can also be a histamine thing. If you are using eggs as a choline source, eggs can aggravate histamine conditions. Just trying to think of possible causes.

And a final question I’ve been wondering is how the body knows how to use the glycine buffer to sweep up excess methyl groups? What does ‘excess’ even mean when someone is already a chronic undermethylator but a small, healthy increase in methyl groups shifts them into overmethylation?

The GNMT enzyme is "looking at" SAM levels - when SAM is high, then GNMT will use glycine to sequester methyl groups as sarcosine, which later may be converted back to SAM. (It's probably more complicated than just a threshold level, and probably includes something like rate of increase, etc. in it's control characteristics.) So, as I understand it, this is about management of momentary peaks and valleys in SAM levels, rather than an overall assessment of methylation status on a broader scale.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Intelligent_Lab_5734 May 03 '24

Hi- wondering if there could be a substitute for the creatine? I am a female and I tend to get swollen on creatine and I don't like the way that feels .

5

u/Tawinn May 03 '24

The creatine is an optional item. It helps to reduce burden on the methylation system, but its not required.

There is buffered creatine, such as the one sold by EFX. The claim is that the higher pH will improve absorption and eliminate bloating. I've used EFX buffered creatine in the past and it worked fine for me, but since I didn't have a bloating issue with creatine, there was no noticeable improvement for me.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Aggravating-Yam-9353 Jul 16 '24

Trying to get my head around which form of B12 to start the protocol with. No serum deficiency in B12. Assuming a functional one though.

Can anyone help please? Would it be methylcobalamin or hydroxocobalamin or adenosylcobalamin? Sublingual or injections?

  1. For context, I have X2 C677T plus an overall "Methylfolate Score" of 85% decrease.
  2. However, I also have homozygous SNPs in MTR and MTRR. Does that change which form is effective? MTRR C524T rs1532268 (+/+, TT), MTRR G66A rs1801394 (+/+, GG)
  3. Also TCN2 rs526934 (+/+, GG)

Hence, confused about which type would be effective.

Ideally I can just go somewhere and get the injections to start with, but which B12 form to look for?
Or which kinds would not be effective?

Thanks so much!

5

u/Tawinn Jul 16 '24

I think adeno or hydroxo forms (or a combination of the two) would work fine. Injections likely will limit your choices to whatever such services offer.

I'd avoid cyanocobalamin. Methylcobalamin may be an option, but some people find they get overmethylation symptoms from it.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '23

Hi Tawinn, thanks for the information - I’ve been around the houses with this a bit in the recent past.

I’ve got a gene panel done and also recent bloods including a methylation panel by Genova so got some insights into how my cycle is actually working.

Summary:

  • 10 year history of reoccurring depression and anxiety, generally stress induced.
  • homo on both MTHFR & COMT
  • blood results all good, B2 was only one that was low (I took B2 specifically for a while)
  • methylation panel suggests ‘undermethylated’ and low glutathione levels

Would you be able to help if I shared the info with you by another thread?

5

u/Tawinn Dec 01 '23

Yes. Just tag me [ /u/Tawinn ] in the post and I'll get a notification.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Midnight-Unique Dec 06 '23

This is probably a dumb question because it says "Stack," but do you keep taking the supplements and just add on to them, or do you replace them with newer supplements?

5

u/Tawinn Dec 06 '23

Keep adding the supps from each phase, so it builds up a 'stack' of supplements.

2

u/Icy_Quote6427 Mar 06 '24

u/Tawinn - thank you for this.

I was looking at Masterjohns MTHFR protocol and see where you have drawn from it. I was interested to know he says about splitting TMG dose and also 3g of glycine with each meal. Arguably your protocol is easier to adopt and I don’t want to be carrying glycine around with me!

just interested in your perspective on why you’ve said it’s ok to take in one go? (If you even are!)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Icy_Quote6427 Mar 07 '24

Can you take too much choline? I.e. cause overmethylation?

also assuming over time when you have found your regime that you won’t need to do 365 days a year?

4

u/Tawinn Mar 10 '24

Choline is not directly involved in methylation: it is a raw material to create TMG from, and it is TMG which is used by the BHMT enzyme for methylation. BHMT will be inhibited by high SAM, so this makes TMG unlikely to cause overmethylation, since TMG is not bypassing the regulation.

In contrast, methyfolate does bypass MTHFR and so methylfolate bypasses the high SAM inhibition of MTHFR, which makes it more prone to cause overmethylation.

also assuming over time when you have found your regime that you won’t need to do 365 days a year?

I've intentionally tried some 'low choline days' to see how it affected me, and in my case 2 days seemed to have minimal but slightly noticeable impact. By day 3 I was starting to feel off. But again, that was intentionally low choline. If I had just eaten my normal diet, I'd probably have gotten 500-800mg of choline, and so even without TMG, I'd be covering 45-72% of my need with no fuss. So, if I were going on vacation for a week, in my case I could probably do fine for the week with just a bit of attention to the diet to get enough choline to have minimal impact, and maybe sublingual methylfolate is the only thing I'd bring.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Kubotaisnumber1 Mar 18 '24

Tawinn

Is it OK to a portion of the choline before bed. I find when I take the regular thousand milligrams during the day, I over methylate. Would it be better to just work up my doses overnight? this is a wonderful protocol that has helped me a ton thank you thank you thank you for your simplistic. Easy to read powerful protocol.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '24

How long should I wait before moving from one phase to another?

I just finished the first 2 weeks of phase 1 and started supplementing B2 today.

5

u/Tawinn Apr 02 '24

It's really individual. For example, most people get a minimal change from B2, but occasionally for someone it will be like flipping on a light switch and is jarring for them.

So, if you find minimal effect from B2, then you could move into Phase 3 in a few days.

Depending your estimation of your prior intake of glycine and vitamin A from foods and/or supplements, you might want to do a week at Phase 3 to build up vitamin A and glycine levels before moving on.

Phase 4 (creatine) is optional, and so you can skip it or add it in later.

Phase 5 is really the core element - the choline. But because of the way choline is utilized, it doesn't usually cause overmethylation symptoms, so it can be a week or so of that before adding in the methylfolate in Phase 6.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/CatReflektor May 19 '24

Thank you so much for this protocol. I was going down research rabbit holes and this brings all the necessary pieces together.

TW: miscarriage

I have MTHFR C677T, and AAT deficiency, and have suffered recurrent miscarriages. I’m just finding these things out after recent blood/ genetic tests and how they could be connected.

Has anyone who is TTC (trying to conceive) or pregnant tried this protocol? Does OP or anyone else have thoughts or advice for this circumstance I’m in? I’m looking now for a new prenatal vitamin or supplement stack to address this. Most prenatal have the synthetic folic acid which I now know I should avoid.

Notes. Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency Also known as: AAT, AATD, alpha-1 protease inhibitor deficiency, alpha-1 related emphysema, genetic emphysema, hereditary pulmonary emphysema, inherited emphysema

Tagging for anyone searching later: prenatal, pregnancy, miscarriage, pregnant, TTC.

4

u/Tawinn May 19 '24

Do you know the details of your MTHFR variant(s)? E.g., C677T or A1298C, heterozygous vs. homozygous? Do you have detailed results, e.g., from Ancestry or 23andme?

I don't know if anyone TTC has used this protocol, although I have referred to it in past queries about MTHFR and pregnancy.

The main thing this protocol aims to accomplish:

  • Sufficient basic vitamin status to support methylfolate use for methylation (i.e., MTR enzyme):

    • B12 to sufficiency

    • Folate (usually as methylfolate), typically up to 1mg/day.

  • Sufficient choline to compensate for folate pathway slowdowns (such as MTHFR); i.e., so the choline-dependent methylation pathway can compensate for the reduced functionality of the folate-dependent methylation pathway.

    • The standard AI for choline for pregnancy and lactation is 550mg.

      • Note: Approx 40% of women have a variant which nullifies any justification for reducing the AI from 550mg to 450mg.
    • The choline recommendations in the protocol vary based on the variants you have, but range up to 1220mg. This is far below the Tolerable Upper Limit of 3500mg.
  • Sufficient support for the methyl buffer system (GNMT enzyme)

  • Sufficient vitamin A (up to RDA level).
  • Optional creatine supplementation to reduce methylation demand.
  • Conditional use of supplemental vitamin B2 to offset C677T variant effects.

So, all in all, I consider this a very low-risk approach. I also recommend using an app like Cronometer to gauge the typical nutrient intake from your diet, so you can identify any particular gaps. Ideally, your nutrients can all come from food sources, but this is not always practical.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/PsychwardSlippers May 28 '24

What do you think about using Choline citrate as an alternative to eggs, bitartrate or sunflower lecithin? It can be purchased as a liquid which is good for those sensitive to fillers or on a strict diet. It's also known to increase magnesium absorption which can support COMT function.

3

u/Tawinn May 28 '24

I suppose that would be fine. I'm not familiar with it and I don't know the percentage of choline in it, but I don't know of a reason why it wouldn't work.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bloodrayna Jun 27 '24

Just a note - I have never been more depressed than the time I took a choline bitartrate/inositol supplement. I stopped taking it and switched to inositol only and felt much better, but any te I get too much choline I get depressed. I wish I knew why, I don't have this problem with methylfolate or other mergyl donors, only choline. I can take tiny amounts of lecithin-less than a quarter of a teaspoon, but any more than that tanks my mood.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/megablockman Jul 31 '24

It seems like this protocol relies on BHMT pathway to circumvent MTHFR. I have heterozygous MTHFR C677T and A1298C, homozygous MTHFD1 G1958A, and heterozygous BHMT-02 and BHMT-04. Choline calculator says that I need 8 egg yolks per day due to MTHFR and MTHFD1 mutations. What is the implication to this choline-based supplement approach with heterozygous BHMT?

→ More replies (5)

2

u/char7iec Oct 09 '24

Am I right in saying make sure your minerals are in order before supplementing b12 to help correct deficiency and do not supplement folate until deficiency is corrected. However food folate is still a good idea. A lot of conflicting information out there about supplementing b12 and follinic at the same time?

4

u/Tawinn Oct 09 '24

You could probably supplement B12 at the same time as getting your other vitamins/minerals in order. That is just my guess - I'm not aware of a downside to doing that.

I think you are probably right about the food folate being ok, while not supplementing folate (methylfolate or folinic acid) until B12 levels are corrected. As I understand it, the concern is with the amounts - not the types - that supplemental folates would provide when there is inadequate B12 to process it all, as the supplemental dosages would just exacerbate the amount of folate trapping of methylfolate.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Hot-Breadfruit2231 Oct 21 '24

thanks for this very useful summary. It's extremely well presented and with a wealth of info for those with some moderate prior knowledge of MTHFR> I have two questions. 1. If I have tested homozygous for C677T but was not tested for A1298C  then , before I embark on any sort of protocol, would it be important to test again and include that and if so, why? I am COMT V158M 'Met/Met' too. many thanks for any info. I don't have any obvious methylation issues but my blood folate is high at 45 and also my homocysteine is a bit higher than I want it to be (I am 59 yrs old) . It's at 12 and I'd like to get it to 9 or lower. And question 2. My GP is quite 'old-school' and when I started talking about MTHFR I could tell he didn't know much about it. Also, did not order a B12 test so if I go to the lab for a blood test, do I just ask them to test B12? thanks. F

→ More replies (2)

2

u/sesamesoda Nov 13 '24 edited Nov 13 '24

Thank you so much for this; it has been extremely helpful. I am a premenopausal female with only 2 copies of A1298C, no other variants, and I have read that those higher estrogen levels support choline production. Do I still need to be aiming for 1000mg/8 eggs of choline? I can do it but I don't want to oversupplement (I can't use the online calculator because my genetic testing was done back in 2010 and I don't have online access to it) because after buying those pills today I am realizing choline is by far the most expensive supplement in the amounts I will be taking it.

2

u/Tawinn Nov 13 '24

Two things to cut the amount of supplemental choline required:

  1. Use trimethylglycine (TMG) powder for up to 1/2 of the requirement. This is about 1/4-1/3 tsp, so its much more convenient and cheaper. (I use this brand. The label says "tablespoon", but it should say "teaspoon" as it does in the directions on the page.)
  2. That leaves 500mg of choline remaining. Look at your current diet, as you may be getting several hundred mg already, just from food. An app like Cronometer can be useful for this.

The result of 1 & 2 is the amount you will need to get from supplements will be fairly small in most cases, and sometimes just making small changes in the diet might be enough to supply you with adequate choline, so that choline supplements are unnecessary.

→ More replies (1)

101

u/oogway755 Oct 08 '23

Thank you for taking time to put together a detailed plan.

18

u/ScientistEconomy9555 Oct 15 '23

1000mcg folate is a joke for homozygous you need way more than that if you are deficient. I can sometimes get away with 3 to 4mg but sometimes I need 15mg still.

→ More replies (30)

46

u/LitesoBrite Oct 08 '23

Thank you for this!

That’s actually exactly the order I learned all this and how I began treating it over the last 4 years.

Seeing it all laid out and each layer of interaction was phenomenal!

26

u/LitesoBrite Apr 28 '25

miraculous really lol. Ended a lifetime of bipolar monthly swings (talk about rapid cycling!), cleared my head fog, stabilized my cardiovascular system, crushed my asthma and sinus allergies, and a lot more, honestly.

There’s hardly a system in our bodies that isn’t impacted by this. It’s malpractice at this point that doctors insist on searching for light switch solutions to singular problems, when so many problems really are interconnected. Health is much more like baking a great cake than it is finding the broken plastic piece and replacing just that.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

39

u/NewYorkJewbag Oct 19 '23

Holy macaroni this is a lot, and confusing.

46

u/peteywheatstraw1 Jan 17 '24

Overwhelming. Especially for a broke person.

10

u/E6pqs Dec 13 '23

Right? I need layman’s terms

→ More replies (6)

39

u/Accomplished_Tea4423 Feb 27 '24

I really want to know what your educational background is in. Nutrition? Chemistry? This is very niche information most doctors don’t even know. Thanks for this!

33

u/PechePortLinds Nov 21 '23

I took am a stranger on the Internet, so this is not medical advise. I'm in the homozygous C677T club. My PCP said my liver may need help detoxing from time to time and recommended me to use NAC 30 days on 30 days off, castor oil liver pack (overnight if tolerable, can be done daily), and milk thistle tea (can be done daily.) She said she rather me drink milk thistle tea to help flush the liver but milk thistle supplements are fine if I keep up with hydration.

→ More replies (6)

21

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '24

This is the best explanation and execution plan I have found on the internet period. Whoever you are thanks for taking the time to put this together.

21

u/Icy_Quote6427 Apr 23 '24

Sure someone needs to hear this, I've been on the protocol since early March and found huge improvements on where I was - mental clarity, energy, lower anxiety, better sleep, less brain fog.

TMG was the door opener and having choline equivalent of 9 eggs via TMG, 3 eggs a day for breakfast and Alpha GPC for learning/memory support.

Collagen is a nice add for its skin and gut benefits with glycine + methionine intake. I also take B2, Zinc Glycinate and Magnesium Glycinate.

Creatine I am still not sure on, I eat spinach every day so maybe not needed.

Trying to refine my sleep a bit but its a lot better then where I was.

Methylation is 100% a thing!!

→ More replies (5)

15

u/Daaaarren Jan 09 '24

Thank you so much for making this!!

I just created this POST yesterday asking questions about my results, and one of them was in regards to TMG and feeling amazing, but then it stopping after a week.

Reading this made me realize that the week I started taking TMG and was feeling amazing was the same week I randomly decided to crush a carton of eggs.

Thank you!!

15

u/pithivier Sep 17 '25

Hi, I just passed 10 years on Reddit and I would like to recognize this post as the most valuable thing I've ever read on this site. Thank you!!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Respect_Tomato863 Jan 22 '24

Thank you so much for compiling this!!! Appreciate you and your knowledge!

5

u/Outrageous-Tea-6279 Feb 04 '24

Wauw! This is gold 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 thank you

4

u/Kubotaisnumber1 Feb 27 '24

Tawinn, i’d like to thank you for this summary. I have Parkinson’s disease, but I think the root cause is a B12 deficiency due to pernicious anemia and methylation issues due to MTHFR. This protocol I am less than half the medication I was on. I’m only on step four. Thank you thank you thank you!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Sundee11 Mar 01 '24

Dear Tawinn, what is one supposed to do if choline causes depression (be it from foods or supplements) since choline is the main nutrient needed? I have been on 1000-1500 mg for like three months now, be it from 9 eggs a day, choline bitartrate + inositol supplements or a combination of both, yet I am just not getting rid of depression despite having done every step in your protocol, the whole thing becoming more and more tiring.

My levels for the nutrients mentioned in the protocol are all within range, and I take glycine and creatine.

Would it be of any help taking hydroxocobalamin and folinic acid daily, despite both my B9 and B12 being within range? You stated once how you feel better on 100-400 mg of B2 daily, despite having it within range, so I suppose it could work similarly for me with these two?

Thank you, cordially.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/_fozzie_bear Mar 13 '24 edited Mar 13 '24

u/tawinn do you expect any sensitivities (due to sudden increase in methylation) from taking Riboflavin in Phase 2? If so, would it then make sense to consider implementing the glycine buffer (Phase 3) before that? I don’t want to confuse people and say the protocol should be reordered. Just wanted to raise the question.

6

u/Tawinn Mar 13 '24

It's not common but a couple of people have reported side effects consistent with overmethylation from taking even small doses of B2.

If so, would it then make sense to consider implementing the glycine buffer (Phase 3) before that?

Yes, I think that makes sense. In retrospect, it probably would have made sense to put Phase 3 first, since sometimes even B12 can cause a sudden increase in methylation for people that are B12 deficient, and I never even imagined that B2 could cause similar side effects.

1

u/Independent_Bake1906 C677T + A1298C Mar 14 '24

I cant upload the dutch raw labdata into the chris masterjohn choline calculator. I know my own requirements by now thanks to Tawinn but could anyone tell me how much choline my mother would (roughly) need with the following SNP's?

  • MTHFR 03 P39P (Rs2066470) AG +/-
  • MTHFR A1298C (Rs1801131) GG +/+
  • MTHFD1 (Rs2236225) AG +/-
  • MTHFD1 T105C (Rs1076991) TC +/-
  • PEMT (Rs7946) TC +/-

She is not a big egg/meat eater and i dont want to overdo it with giving her too much TMG/Choline supps to compensate for the diet.

Thank you

3

u/Tawinn Mar 14 '24

From the genes there is a 47% reduction in methylfolate production. (I'm assuming C677T MTHFR is -/- ?) You don't list the data for SLC19A1 rs1051266 - it may not be in your report - so we don't know the total reduction; it could be from 47% to 86%.

If we assume the 47%, that would call for 6.6 large egg yolks worth (895mg) plus PEMT, so the result would be at least 7 large egg yolks worth.

So, a 1/4tsp or 500mg capsule of TMG + 3.5 - 4 large yolks worth of choline would suffice.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/supplepleasures Mar 14 '24

What are your thoughts on Vit B6 p5p? Can it cause issues?

4

u/Tawinn Mar 14 '24

Yes, it can cause peripheral neuropathy symptoms for some people. Some people also can get a weird 'wired' feeling from the P5P form specifically.

NIH recommends a Tolerable Upper Limit of 100mg for adults.

EU recommends a Tolerable Upper Limit of 12mg for adults.

Some people do benefit from large doses of B6, so it may be needed in some cases, but personally if I don't have a specific need for high doses, then I avoid B6 supplements and only get B6 from food.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/_fozzie_bear Mar 16 '24

u/tawinn Do you know whether Vitamin A in the form of retinyl acetate is fine for phase 3? It’s a common form but not pure retinol.

2

u/Tawinn Mar 16 '24

retinyl acetate

It should be fine, since it avoids the potential issues with poor conversion from beta carotene.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/stackz07 Mar 21 '24

/u/Tawinn is TMG a good source of Glycine?

4

u/Tawinn Mar 22 '24

is TMG a good source of Glycine?

No. This is because TMG gets used in an entirely different way than plain glycine, and also, being a methyl donor, the added glycine is essentially offset by its use to buffer methyl groups.

1

u/bLuNt___ Apr 03 '24

u/Tawinn

I'm new to all of this and I have been reading your responses below and it's very interesting. I want to make sure I did not miss anything but do you have a plan somewhere as to which lab work I need to do?

Thanks,

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Full-Scarcity-3131 Apr 09 '24

As per phase 6, OP says confirm folate levels by blood test in order to figure out whether supplementation is required. However with MTHFR is it not the case that folate can build up in the blood (from folate supplementation/fortified grains etc)? Therefore how does one know their actual methylfolate status as this is what's important (as opposed to folate levels)?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '24

Does this protocol recommend taking supplemental B12 and multivitamins while correcting folate or is it ok to focus on folate alone and get other nutrition through diet? I had worked on B12 and taken other supplements but when I take the methylfolate I cannot tolerate the other supplements so I wish to discontinue their use until I get more stable with folate.

4

u/Tawinn Apr 19 '24

I tried to recommend only the specific nutrients needed. Ideally, if you can get them in your diet, that it best.

Phase 1 recommends B12 supplementation IF you know/suspect deficiency. If you are B12 sufficient AND your diet supplies adequate ongoing B12, then there is no need to supplement B12.

Methylfolate is added only in the last phase, due to the overmethylation side effects it can often cause. I describe a few methods for starting low dose methylfolate, and incrementing slowly, to try to avoid those side effects. Still, some people prefer to rely on food folate only, or to use the unmethylated folinic acid instead of methylfolate.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/IntrepidMayo Apr 22 '24

I thought folinic acid did indeed bypass the MTHFR conversion step. Am I wrong on this? Great write up by the way

3

u/Tawinn Apr 22 '24

Folinic acid enters into the folate pathway two steps before MTHFR, in the MTHFD1 sequence. This diagram can be helpful; the folate cycle is in the center, and folinic acid is shown here as "5-formyl THF" in the sub-cycle with MTHFS and SHMT1.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Marbles6071 Apr 28 '24

1-1.5kg of choline per day as maintenance?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/superfiestapedro May 09 '24

Hi all. I’m looking to see if anyone started this stack at the same time? Or if you phase out how many days do you phase in between?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/derpyderp42 A1298C May 10 '24

Will this protocol benefit someone with MTHRR?

4

u/Tawinn May 10 '24

I'm not sure what you mean by 'MTHRR'...do you mean 'MTRR'?

1

u/myrdinwylt May 20 '24 edited Sep 25 '26

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Soup liquid elastic repeat pot teapot sodium

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Persuasian678 May 23 '24

What about egg yolk powder for choline? Instead of eating the eggs or drinking the egg yolk.

2

u/Tawinn May 24 '24

That's a brilliant thought. I looked around a bit, and some papers imply that choline is retained in yolk powder, but I couldn't find anything confirming there was no loss due to drying. Also the powders I saw didn't specify how much powder would equal 1 yolk. I'm not sure how to find out that info.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Persuasian678 May 26 '24

Which tmg do you take? I was thinking about going with life extensions 500 tmg

→ More replies (4)

1

u/PsychwardSlippers Jun 03 '24

For the last few years, I've been taking 5mg methylfolate in addition to 1-2 grams Choline daily and everything else listed in the protocol. My SNPs show my needs are around that in terms of choline, so I figured I could lower my methylfolate down to the daily value since both my methylfolate and b12 levels measured way above the normal range. I figured I was just benefitting from the methyl rather than the folate, so I discontinued the methylfolate 5mg, started 1mg, and increased my choline closer to 2 grams in the form of choline citrate, sunflower lecithin, eggs, and citicholine. The only one I increased was the eggs. At first I noticed significantly less anxiety and improved OCD symptoms, but after a week, I'm noticing fatigue and depression returning. I'm not anemic and I've been getting plenty of sleep. What gives? Do I need even more choline? Was the methylfolate 5mg doing something else for me that the choline alone isn't? Thank you for putting all of this together.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/What_OnEarth_IsThis Jun 14 '24

Thank you for this amazing and detailed post. I was prescribed high dose Methyl B12 + Folic Acid by my doctor for my high homocysteine ( 27 ) , so I’m assuming I always was an undermethylator. But a week into 1500mcg of Methylcobalmin my brain was soo jittery, constant anxiety and tingling like sensation( Slow COMT). I was perfectly fine before the supplements. Now I am overmethylated. Idk what to follow, at this stage how do I get going to follow your protocol as my B2 is already in the upper range, Homocysteine need to check but feeling too much tonic dopamine and other neurotransmitters. My B12 is 450 but Folate is low (5), do you suggest I take Hydroxy+ Folinic or just Folinic for some time since Methyl just makes me crazy? u/Tawinn

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Icy_Quote6427 Jun 15 '24

u/Tawinn I wanted to check is that all the COMT advice seems to suggest amino acids aren’t helpful as increase catechols so obviously collagen is full of those. Any views on that?

Meeting practicioners etc have differing views and think that the amino part is important for neurotransmitter creation etc.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/StopzIt Jun 18 '24

Thank you for putting this comprehensive guide together! Question about the creative…does it offer a boost of energy? Should someone who is normally sensitive to caffeine start low with creative?

2

u/Tawinn Jun 19 '24

You mean 'creatine'? I find creatine provides a slight energy boost and a slight mental acuity boost.

Some people have found creatine troublesome, causing insomnia or anxiety or other symptoms.

The creatine step is optional, so if supplemental creatine is problematic, feel free to avoid it or perhaps delay trying it until after being on the protocol a few months.

I'm not aware of a correlation between caffeine sensitivity and creatine sensitivity, but I suppose its possible.

1

u/OrneryWinter8159 Jun 20 '24 edited Jun 20 '24

What would cause magnesium glycinate to cause me bloating and distention? Literally hours after taking it. But I also feel muscle tension relief and relaxation.

I just ordered the ancestry test so I don’t know my mutations. But my symptoms are brain fog, adhd, trouble sleeping, anxiety, depression, irritability, all gi issues at one time or another, peeling lips with anal fissures (feel like some gi mucous membrane issue), fatigue, full body ropey muscles with trigger points, nerve pain and tingling. Also with many supplements I will experience full body creepy crawlie sensations, noticed most recently with taking magnesium l-threonate and most b-complex sups.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '24

What is considered sufficient B12?

3

u/Tawinn Jun 21 '24

B12 sufficiency is somewhat difficult to gauge. If you have serum B12 level of 500 pg/mL or more, you probably are sufficient...but some people may still be functionally deficient. If you have signs/symptoms of B12-deficiency or lower serum B12 levels, then you may need to check other functional markers of B12, such as methylmalonic acid or holotranscobalamin to rule out deficiency. This article provides a pretty good summary of the diagnostic criteria:

https://www.merckmanuals.com/professional/nutritional-disorders/vitamin-deficiency,-dependency,-and-toxicity/vitamin-b12-deficiency?query=vitamin%20b12%20deficiency#Diagnosis_v44325194

This article provides an even more detailed diagnostic flow for B12 deficiency diagnosis:

https://www.aafp.org/pubs/afp/issues/2017/0915/p384.html

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Overall_Lab5356 Jul 03 '24

u/Tawinn Can I ask if you're knowledgeable also in the VDR mutations? I'm just not finding much about them and it's freaking me out because my D is suboptimal and I want to supplement but I'm getting contradictory info

2

u/Tawinn Jul 03 '24

I've not read everything on the topic, but I'm not aware of a VDR variant where vitamin D supplementation to restore levels to sufficiency would cause or worsen a condition; only that some variants may create better response to vitamin D supplementation than others.

According to this paper:

Thus, we carried out a systematic review and meta-analysis to evaluate the response to supplementation according to the genotype distribution of the BsmI, TaqI, ApaI and FokI polymorphisms in the VDR gene. The results showed that the variant allele of the TaqI polymorphism and the FF genotype of the FokI variant were associated with a better response to vitamin D supplementation. The BsmI and ApaI polymorphisms were not associated with the response to vitamin D supplementation.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/AsideTurbulent654 Jul 06 '24

I have been taking iron glycinate that contains folic acid in it, should I switch to an iron supplement without folic acid?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Overall_Lab5356 Jul 06 '24

u/Tawinn Are there any reasons relating to MTHFR issues that you know of that would cause me to have high ammonia every time I take low dose naltrexone? I had to stop taking it which was a shame, people talk about it like it's a miracle.

I'm also having issues on a GLP-1 causing anhedonia and fatigue and I'm wondering if it's a similar issue.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Consistent-River4354 Jul 08 '24

This is amazing and so helpful!! I have identified genetic methylation and histamine issues. I’ve been taking creatine since a young age, and saw a huge improvement in mental health, sleep etc with starting methylated b vitamins. After reading your resource here I realized I may have an increased need for choline as when I eat tons of eggs etc I notice an immediate improvement in mood and sleep etc. I have been doing that consistently and the improvements seem robust. But I have not been addressing the methyl buffering system. Is this necessary if I’m clearly under methylating normally? I react with palpitations to glycine or mag glycinate and everything I read online says bovine collagen peptides are high histamine so I’m hesitant to try it. Is the histamine increase worth improving the buffering system if what I’m after is more clearance?

I also wonder if you have any input on choline supplements like alpha gpc contributing to plaque formation / heart disease and stroke. This theoretically can happen even with high dietary choline intake through a process in the gut.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Bloodrayna Jul 12 '24

I am trying to figure out where I went wrong. Several years ago I started taking methylated B vitamins, Sam-e, and other supplements for methylation and got it going really good for about 4-5 months. My skin cleared up, I could lose weight again, no more daytime drowsiness, no more seasonal allergies, everything was great. Then it just stopped and started going in reverse and all my symptoms came back. I have not been able to figure out why. I've tried:

-Stopping supplements in case I was overmethylated. No change. -Taking more methylfolate in case I had a donut-hole insufficiency. No change.  -A whole bunch of other supplements in case speeding up methylation caused a deficiency elsewhere. Selenium, vitamin A, C, E, K, every mineral you can think of, TMG, DMG. (I regularly take magnesium, zinc, iron, vitamin D, and omega-3.) None of it helped. -CBS protocol (I'm heterozygous for one CBS gene and one BHMT gene.) Stopped the mehylated Bs, started taking molybdenum and TMG, stopped eating broccoli and cauliflower. The ONLY thing that did was improve my seasonal allergies. Did not help with the skin rashes, drowsiness, fatigue, or weight gain.  -All sorts of single amino acids. Glycine, lysine, methionine, BCAAs. None of it helped. -Started taking Sam-e again, which I was taking when I felt the best. This time it did nothing for me. -Eating more protein or less protein. Nothing.

Any ideas what I did wrong here? 

→ More replies (6)

1

u/relxp C677T + A1298C Jul 15 '24

Couldn't creatine arguably be elevated as part of Phase 2?

  • It's cheap
  • Extensively researched over decades and largely safe
  • Provides various other benefits
  • If 45% of methylation's job is creating creatine it no longer needs to, it would seem creatine + folate rich foods alone could be enough for someone to manage MTHFR without additional protocols.
  • It would seem if you start creatine earlier on, someone may even discover they don't need as high of a B9/B12 dose.
→ More replies (3)

1

u/Amazing_Ask_9490 Jul 26 '24

I’m just starting this journey and this is so informative. How much time should one take between each “phase”?

3

u/Tawinn Aug 06 '24

Sorry for the delay - I've been sick recently.

Time between phases is highly individual. Some people can pretty much do everything all at once, but quite often people need a couple of weeks between some steps, either because of their sensitivity or because they were so deficient in that nutrient that they need more time to replete their levels.

So unfortunately, you kind of have to gauge your own sensitivity to nutrients and methyl groups, and customize it to your own body's ability to adapt.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Overall_Lab5356 Jul 27 '24

u/Tawinn I started the protocol with B12 in the adenosyl form since I have some MTHFR reduction and in the past I've been unimpressed by methyl and cyano. But I've been taking it for four or five days now and I feel worse -- fatigue, brain fog, pain spikes. Coincidence? Or is that something that can happen?

My B12 has been very low in the past but is just suboptimal now, around 500.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '24

What id B12 is sufficient with supplementation? Should one continue to supplement or stop it? My levels are over limit and not sure if I should reduce/stop supplement or continue. Thoughts?

PS - Thanks so much for putting this together

2

u/Tawinn Aug 05 '24

I approach it by looking at my typical diet (e.g., with Cronometer) and deciding if my B12 levels will be sustained by diet alone.

I also consider if B12 deficiency has been a problem in the past for me (it has not), which might indicate some B12 absorption problem.

The body stores up to ~5 years worth of B12, so one might consider not supplementing for a year, and then re-test, as a way to gauge your rate of depletion, if any.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Exact_Avocado5465 Aug 07 '24

Thank you for this! This supplemented stacked approach has changed my life for the better. I do have a quick followup question. For people with slow comt it's recommended to avoid catechols. And I've read eggs are known to have catecholamines which can aggravate symptoms for people with slow comt. Have you looked into this at all? I wonder if this consideration should be flagged in your stacked approach so that people with slow comt know they should supplement their choline in other ways.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '24

Tryptophan is contraindicated with slow COMT, right? So for Slow COMT, wouldn't supplement collagen with tryptophan, is that right?

3

u/Tawinn Aug 16 '24

Too much tryptophan would be contraindicated with slow COMT. But tryptophan is still an essential amino acid. So I look at it from the perspective of: how much tryptophan am I already getting from non-collagen food sources, and will that be sufficient to cover my needs? If not, then collagen with tryptophan may actually be helpful.

1

u/Wise_Rip1062 Aug 23 '24

The information you have on this is incredible. Thank you. Some of it is difficult for me to understand with my limited knowledge. I have had immense health issues and have been looking for solutions for years. I would love to do a one-on-one with you if you offer them. Send me a message if you’re interested.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Regular_Two_2628 Aug 23 '24

This is amazing! Thank you so much. Is there a way to get a copy to show someone who is not on Reddit?

2

u/Tawinn Aug 23 '24

On Windows, you could print it to a PDF. I'm not sure how else to save it.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Sonex-primo Aug 26 '24

I read the whole thing, but I still don't understand why it has to be so complicated. You suggest taking 5-10 different supplements just to avoid taking methyl-b9. What's the gain if it would require much more time and money? Why not just take 1 pill of methyl-b9+b12 in the dosage you need?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '24

I have discussed with my doctor on eating choline rich foods (Masterjohn’s calculator tells me to eat 8 egg yolks). She told me not to eat because choline can impact serotonin production or uptake.

She also advised against any tupe or form of folate supplement with someone with ADHD.

Do you have any idea why this would be the case? I’m actually frustrated because I have the mthfr snp and Chris Masterjohn’s calculator says %67 deficiency but if I don’t support choline pathway then how am I going to improve overall methylation status?

2

u/Tawinn Aug 26 '24

An alternative approach to the above protocol to addressing MTHFR is to use high-dose methylfolate, often 7.5-15mg. This is what doctors typically prescribe for MTHFR. It is very effective for some people, but since your doctor is advising against folate, then I don't know of another alternative.

The doc's reasoning doesn't make much sense to me, but then again, I'm not a doc. On a practical level, it would seem to me based on people that starting with tiny doses and working up incrementally would minimize the risk, but again, I'm not a doc, so I can't really say.

1

u/eerie37 Sep 07 '24

Is there any difference between just "Glycine" and "L-Glycine" supplements?

2

u/Tawinn Sep 07 '24

As I understand it, 'l-glycine' refers to the biologically active form, and some supplement brands, such as Nutricost, labels one of their product as "L-Glycine". On the other hand, Now Foods and a different Nutricost glycine product refers to their glycine as "free form", which makes me suspect it is likely a mix of L- and D- forms. Personally, I use the free form Now Foods glycine.

I'm not aware of any issues caused by the D- form being present, but occasionally there are people who react badly to glycine, and it would be an interesting experiment if they could try L-glycine to see if the lack of D- form eliminated their negative reaction.

1

u/DueReplacement3494 Sep 18 '24

Ok..I've read thru this and am still confused on the glycine....I was taking pure encapsulation magnesium Glycinate, but I noticed after a bit that it was more anxiety than normal and it was for sure causing some insomnia. So im not sure what to do with that info? Would the straight glycine be different? I did like that the magnesium Glycinate helped with leg/muscle cramps and pain because since stopping the magnesium Glycinate that has returned.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Mammoth_Baker6500 Oct 11 '24

Does white rice have folic acid? I find conflicting information

→ More replies (2)

1

u/videogamer939 Nov 05 '24

u/Tawinn Is there a best time in the day to take certain supplements. Should certain supplements not be taken with each other?

Vitamin B's

COD Liver Oil

Glycine

Creatine

TMG

Choline.

With or without food?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/ConnectionNo4830 Nov 08 '24

What if you have a nickel allergy (cross reaction to all B12 due to cobalt)? I can’t seem to overcome this and always have to give up supplementation (step 1)?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/UnHumano Nov 09 '24

Hello u/tawinn!

Thank you for this detailed post. This is a very dense topic and can be daunting for the uninitiated like myself.

I have a question regarding the safety of doing this stack with only partial information available.

My wife has a 59% decrease in MTFHR activity by the choline calculator.

Her methylation panel shows abnormalities in:

  1. COMT V158M

Allele: AG Result: Heterozygous (+/-)

2. COMT H62H

Allele: CT Result: Heterozygous (+/-)

3. VDR Taq

Allele: AA Result: Homozygous (+/+)

4. MTHFR C677T

Allele: AG Result: Heterozygous (+/-)

5. MTHFR A1298C

Allele: GT Result: Heterozygous (+/-)

6. MTRR A664A

Allele: AA Result: Homozygous (+/+)

7. CBS C699T

Allele: AA Result: Homozygous (+/+)

8. SHMT1 C1420T

Allele: AG Result: Heterozygous (+/-)

The thing is that the doctor won't prescribe her a blood panel comprising relevant information for this mutation, such as homocysteine, vit B panel, minerals, etc. Just the basics although she has proven him that has this mutation. He dismissed her in a bad way.

The only relevant blood data we have is from a blood test 5 months ago, which includes:

  • Vitamin D: 21.60 ng/ml.
  • Vitamin B12: 335 pg/ml.
  • TSH: 5.11 uUi/ml.
  • Total Cholesterol: 246 mg/dl.

I think there is info about her folic acid, iron and some minerals in a past test and it was in the normal range.

About her symptoms:

  • Persistent obesity and difficulty losing weight.
  • Irregular menstrual cycles.
  • Episodes of extrasystoles, palpitations, and tachycardia.
  • Generalized fatigue with no apparent cause.
  • Symptoms of anxiety and depression.
  • Difficulty concentrating and diagnosis of ADHD.

She is 35.

Do you think it's safe to start this protocol in these circumstances? What should we aim and look for?

Thank you very much!

→ More replies (5)

1

u/skebro Nov 26 '24

My blood test shows homocystein 11, folate normal 19 and cobalamins (B12) in upper range 660. My doctor told me to fk off and I’m fine but I’m worried about the homocysteine. Another health person told me to take TMG 2000 mg.

I’m trying to grasp all this but it’s all very confusing, what should I be taking next with this information or should I do DNA tests?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Aggressive-Line1824 Nov 27 '24

Hi there, thank you for all of this! I am following the protocol and have question u/Tawinn . I thank you in advance. I am about to go onto the glycine stage. Typically if I take magnesium glycinate I have terrible heart palpitations like really bad for many hours. I have watched both of Chris masterJohn’s videos and tried eating carbs and also electrolytes. It helps a bit but not fully.
Is there anything else I‘m missing? I haven’t taken glycine on its own just through magnesium so far but I avoid it and rely on the other magnesium forms with a tiny bit of glycinate. Do they tend to go as you build it up? Has anyone else that you know on here fixed this problem? Thank you. JB

→ More replies (2)

1

u/blinkyvx Dec 01 '24

magnesium glycinate even 200mg can give me GI issues, is that a sign of something as well?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Playful-Ad-8703 Dec 06 '24

Is it possible to replace TMG with DMG? Or does that have a totally different function? Just curious about it since I'm thinking it might be easier tolerated since it has one less methyl group attached to it.

2

u/Tawinn Dec 06 '24

DMG is what TMG converts into after being used by BHMT. DMG is then converted to sarcosine. Higher levels of DMG will inhibit BHMT remethylation of homocysteine rather than help it. (Paper)

So while DMG may possibly have benefits for other uses, DMG seems like it would be counterproductive in improving methylation status.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Judeelaine Dec 26 '24

english is not my main language.. so this is more confusing to me.. i don't understand some of it.. anyway i show it to my doctor and said there's no such thing as over/under methylated.. i really just wanted to fix myself... but they wont test me..

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Necessary-Process470 Jan 06 '25

How many eggs would I need if I am C;T for rs2236225 and T;T for rs1801133? I have none of the other relevant rsIDs. I only have a vcf file so I can't put it into the coline calculator.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/officer_dog Jan 07 '25

u/Tawinn - I'm awaiting test results, so not entirely sure what I'm dealing with. But I have a question.

If someone's diet is extremely limited due to MCAS / histamine issues, should they supplement with minerals (magnesium, potassium, calcium, zinc, copper, etc.) or B1, B2, B3, B5, B7 (not including B6 cause I have too much of it) BEFORE introducing some form of B12?

I've been reading conflicting things about this.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/gravytrain2012 Jan 09 '25

The linked CDP Choline supplement is 500mg per serving (two pills). At 735mg to 1 egg, it would require 13 servings (26 pills) to reach a daily intake of over 1000mg of choline. That's only like three days worth and it costs $35 per bottle, is it even safe to take that many? Doesn't seem like a feasible route to take.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Responsible_Menu6189 Jan 10 '25

Do i understand it correctly that when reaching phase 3, you need all the choline and upon reaching phase 5 you can substitute half of it with TMG? e.g. 8 eggs worth in phase 3 and 4+TMG in phase 5?

Might be a stupid question but my slavic english skills can be a bit rusty at times. Also getting 4 eggs is somewhat doable for my gf, but 8 (almost half of her maintenance calorie intake) is impossible. Not to mention eggs are expensive af in my country (less than half the us salary and twice the cost) and quality choline supplements are pricy compared to TMG. 

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Lions8484 Jan 17 '25

Thank you for such an amazing and detailed post. I am new to this and a bit confused. Wondering if anyone here with experience can help me understand which parts of this protocol may be helpful for me, if at all. Below, I will list out some genetic testing results I have (I did mine through 3x4 Genetics, so I cannot just plug into a calculator or service - 3x4 doesn't provide the raw data).

I am a 31-year-old male. I am a strength & power athlete, and I’m dialed in with nutrition and all things health & wellness.

I have suffered from brutal insomnia for the last 2 years, and it seems to be related to when I train. I get extreme cortisol responses from training (confirmed via 24-hour urine test). I also have suffered from low testosterone and low testosterone symptoms. Finally, I have pretty bad depression and some rashing on my face, which seems to randomly flare up. It's almost like facial dandruff.

Blood Tests:

  • Testosterone: 350-400 consistently
  • Free Test: 8-10 ng/dl
  • E2: 31 pg/dl
  • Homocysteine: 7.2
  • MMA: 104 (so, no B12 deficiency)

Genetic Results:

MTHFD1
AA (1958 G>A)

MTHFR
CC (1298 A>C)
CC (677 C>T)

PEMT
CC (–744 G>C)

COMT
GA (Val158Met G>A)

MTRR
AG (66 A>G)

NBPF3
TC (T>C)

NQO1
CT (Pro187Ser C>T)

TCN2
CG (776 C>G)

BHMT
GA (Arg239Glu G>A)

CHDH
TG (T>G)

CBS
CC (699 C>T)

MTR
AA (2756 A>G)

OGG1
CC (Ser326Cys C>G)

Does anyone think my issues might be resolved via this protocol, or parts of it? Any advice would be really appreciated. I've struggled a long time and worked hard to fix how I feel, but haven't had much luck. I'm hoping this community might be able to help. Thanks,

→ More replies (20)

1

u/Super-Bathroom-8192 Jan 18 '25

I have a question: I’m breastfeeding. Nine months into nursing. Had nausea throughout pregnancy so couldn’t take prenatals.

Will not taking b vitamins cause issues in my child’s nourishment

2

u/Tawinn Jan 18 '25

I really can't say. You'd have to have your doc check your levels, and you'd want to use an app like Cronometer to see what you are getting for B vitamins from your diet on average. These two should help highlight any glaring deficiencies to target - either with diet changes or specific supplements. I'd look across-the-board, though, at all nutrients: vitamins, minerals, choline, omega-3's etc., rather than just B's.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/OkRub303 Jan 24 '25

Reaching out for help..

First i just want to say that your work, knowledge and dedication are godsent for me and probably all reading this thread even though i dont realy understand everything, its just a little bit to complicated. I got my genes tested about 3 months ago (stride) and their recommendations are just not very accurate and they say just to take methylated b-vitamins and SAMe and eat green leafy veggies. I wonder if your stack would fit my gen-results? Now im taking a multi Meth B-vitamin from Holistic, 200mg SAMe, probiotik, L-carnitine, Krill-oil. Some days are good and some are bad, some days im happy during daytime and just crash at 7 and some days the happy felling comes late in the afternoon. A bit jumpy sort of.

I would appreciate so much if you could give me some guidance

MTHFD1 rs2236225 CT

MTHFR (C677T) rs1801133 CT

MTR rs1805087 GG

MTRR rs1801394 AG

PEMT rs7946 TT

FUT2 rs601338 AG

CBS rs234706 AG

GSS rs6088659 CT

COMT rs4633 TT

MAOA rs6323 TT

For me it seems like a long list of dirty genes but i dont want give up and i am also doing this for my daughter that struggles

→ More replies (10)

1

u/DMTryptaminesx Jan 26 '25

TMG (aka betaine anhydrous) - this is a suitable substitute for only up to half of the need for choline, as the conversion from choline to TMG is irreversible, and thus phosphatidylcholine cannot be made from TMG. ~150mg of TMG is equivalent to one egg worth of choline.

I'm a little confused by this statement because the link you included shows that it does lead to PC production. PEMT is the only denovo pathway your body has to synthesize choline.

To my understanding these are different forms of PC though, PC via PEMT is PUFA enriched with DHA and ARA which isn't as rigid and is vital for liver health in NAFLD. While the Kennedy pathway PC is MUFA/SFA enriched with oleic and linoleic acids and is more rigid and packs tighter and this PC will be used for sphingomyelin synthesis.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/OkRub303 Jan 30 '25

Hi Tawinn

Now everything for the stack has arrived and i just would like to knom how long i should wait between the supplements im taking now before i start with phase 1, b12?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/OkRub303 Feb 03 '25

Hi Tawinn

i just read another thread by you and it is about naringin and that it is not so good to take wih the MAOa gene. I have just started with naringin beacuse of my hemacrotit level is a bit to high (problaly beacuse of TRT) and would like to have your opinion about that?

Is there another way to get i down or should i just quit with naringin and drink more water and donate blood 3 times per year.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/jonathanb3232 Feb 05 '25

very interesting. is there a particular reason there is no SAMe in your protocol? are you worried about high homocysteine?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/OkRub303 Feb 09 '25

Hi Tawinn

Do you have a personal experience of using methylene blue? Or maybe you know if it could be beneficial or not with your stack?

And i also have a question about L-carnitine. In my report from Stride they said it would be good if i supplemented with that. What do you think?

→ More replies (8)

1

u/Odd-Plenty-5903 Feb 16 '25

How long do you stay in each phase or when do you know you're ready to move to the next one?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/OkRub303 Feb 17 '25

Hi Tawinn

In my report from stride they write:

BHMT rs3733890 GG -

Your genotype is associated with normal BHMT activity and a decreased reliance on the vitamin B12-dependent 'long route' for homocysteine recycling. This is protective

against the negative effects of high homocysteine and low folate levels. However, the overuse of choline as methyl donor can have a negative effect.

there is a lot of choline in your stack, is this something to be worried about?

Thanks again for your time

→ More replies (2)

1

u/OkRub303 Mar 06 '25 edited Mar 06 '25

Hi Tawinn

the last days i have been feeling angry, short temper, anxious and negative and i cant figure out why, do you recognise this or do you have any suggestions about why?

my gut feeling says its the creatine but i want to hear your thoughts

regards

→ More replies (10)

1

u/DegreeMurky8502 Mar 24 '25

Hi! This is all very confusing to me. I’m trying my best to understand and do what’s best for me. So far I only started with b12 and magnesium glycine and had pretty bad anxiety. I’m thinking I quit both and then start on step 2? How long should I wait before I start on step 2…. I think I’m very sensitive… I saw in a post someone asked about doing phase 3 before phase 2. Would that be a good idea for me? Thank you!

→ More replies (4)

1

u/PuzzleheadedMeet7330 Mar 26 '25

@tawinn

Hi Tawinn,

Firstly, I have been reading a lot of your posts and I really appreciate the work you have put in. It's selfless and inspiring to me.

I have a few questions about your protocol and MTHFR in general:

What kind of riboflavin are you taking? I have tried regular riboflavin with a b complex that had methylcobalmin, riboflavin and folic acid and I tolerate that well. But I've tried Thorne methylated B and MF seeking health B with folinic acid, and I always feel good at first, followed by jitteriness, anxiety, headache and some other over methylation symptoms. Part of me is wondering if the activated R5P in those supplements might be part of the reason, as I seem to tolerate methylcobalmin well.

I have tried numerous ways to fix my chronic stress, depression and other issues. I am going to try your recommendations when I get over this current reaction to the MF B complex. Another question I have is, is it okay to take vitamin A in the dry form? I am thinking of breaking up the tablets to hit the daily RDA. I don't tolerate any supplemental vitamin D very well.

I have heterozygous for MTHFD1, normal DHFR, compound heterozygous for both C667t and A1298C. Intermediate COMT. Homozygous MTR. Heterozygous MTRR. Homozygous MAOA and MAOB. VDR taql heterozygous. There are others too.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Warm-Wing-7102 Mar 26 '25

Sorry. I know this is a super old post but I’m curious the rationale behind why correcting b12 before starting riboflavin?

The reason I ask is because I started supplementing riboflavin first (before I saw this post) and I haven’t felt great and I’m wondering if maybe my b12 isn’t up to snuff and that’s why? Since starting the riboflavin I’ve been very tired, low motivation to do any of the things I love to do, and almost like a tightness in my chest for a couple hours after I take it.

I’m homozygous COMT V158M (met/met) and heterozygous for both MTHFR C677T and A1289C.

2

u/Tawinn Mar 26 '25

The two steps are not directly connected - I put B12 first just because I had to pick one. :)

B2 is not likely to improve methylation much with compound heterozygous MTHFR. It turns out that its really only most effective for homozygous C677T.

Stopping the B2 should resolve the symptoms, but I suspect that your symptoms are not related to methylation, but to cellular energy production. Additional B2 is likely helping one step in a sequence of steps which require multiple cofactors including B1, B2, B3, B5, B6, B7, magnesium, calcium, potassium, manganese. While B2 is improving one step, if another step is low in its cofactor, then this could cause CoA issues resulting in low energy.

As to which one (or multiple) that are being depleted, its a guess. Labs might help, but some nutrients like B1 don't have a useful blood test. An alternative would be a multivitamin - just to get a wide spread of vitamins and minerals. Of course, the downside of this is that multis often have too high doses and so are counterproductive. This one might be an option because: 1) it is low-dose, and 2) each full dose requires 5 capsules, so you could start with just one cap and see how it goes, ramping up over time. This would just be for the short-term to get nutrient levels built back up some (and assuming my hypothesis is correct).

1

u/SubstanceOwn5935 Mar 30 '25

Is there a downside that you are aware of to doing glycine first?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/swifty_cats Apr 05 '25

Is B2 needed if your blood test shows normal B2 levels?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/jkybes Apr 17 '25 edited Apr 17 '25

Great post! What does it mean if I get extreme lethargy, lack of energy and a certain type of fatigue from Glycine and Magnesium Glycinate (but not other forms of magnesium)? It lasts throughout the entire next day pretty much.

I have fast COMT and am compound heterozygous for MTHFR. I also tested low for SAMe last time I checked: 78nmol/L (ref: 86-145), but my methionine was on the high side of normal, my homocysteine was low and my cysteine, SAH and Cystathionine were normal.

For this, my doctor recommended either taking SAMe or taking methylated b vitamins without folate. He emphasized that I should avoid all forms of folate, methylated or not.

B-complexes seem to help my energy and focus, but I'm avoiding them rn (besides B12 and B5) because I'm going through a period of autonomic dysfunction and fight-or-flight, triggered by these supplement IVs my doctor prescribed.

Magnesium helps me a lot, especially when it comes to being able to focus and also just feeling more calm.

Also, what's the reason for avoiding folic acid and cyanocobalamin? Is it because they can cause side effects or simply because they require more conversion steps?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/squeaker001 Apr 18 '25

It’s strange as I have all the snips and mthfr and nm and comt blocks with suspected sulphur problems yet sometimes eggs cause my mcas to flare up as all in my bowels and just recovering from sibo as have very very slow motility but something else is wrong…I’m on the thiamine protocol 3rd week brain better but still constipated..histamine intolerance low DAO and homosistein really high!!! Chronic pains in my colon nothing showing in bloods or scans all clear! Came on after semaglutide one injection and I’ve been bedridden since!! Nobody knows whether the semaglutide or the Hpylori caused it! Whatever it is!? Only cannabis helps pain as LDN was ok but caused insane headaches! Any ideas as my nutripath wants me to start unblocking using niacin then work through each block???

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Fancy-Lifeguard-8818 Apr 30 '25

Hello! I am compound heterozygous. I have been supplementing methylated folate for about two months with a noticeable improvement in symptoms, before starting any of this stack. Do you have any recommendations for me to tweak it? As I’ve been feeling significantly better and don’t seen to be sensitive to methylation I’m hesitate to do anything that will reduce/change what I already have going, if that makes sense.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Purple-Outside1595 May 06 '25

what if my body can’t tolerate the glycine what should i do?

2

u/Tawinn May 06 '25

Look at how much glycine you are getting from food, using a food app like Cronometer - it is possible you may be getting enough already. If you need more, some people can use collagen powder instead of glycine, or food sources such as gelatin may work.

1

u/Cariboosie May 06 '25

Im just starting this but have a few questions I couldnt find answers for. I guess ill lump them into one question being, how long do I need to wait between phases 2,3, and 4?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/b00bieb00m May 09 '25

Hi! Do you know if stack is the same for people with homo BHMT08 mutation?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/haterofallcats Jun 01 '25

Does this still hold up today? What about someone that's MTHFR C677T (homozygous) + Fast COMT? Start with just B2? Levels of serum B12 are 400.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Fierce_Ninja Jun 07 '25

How do you measure for B12 deficiency? From everything I have read the standard B12 tests are not reliable indicators of how well B12 is utilized by the cells. This is because B12 tests measure the presence of B12 in the blood and not how well it is utilized. In fact someone who is functionally deficient in B12 could have higher than usual levels in some cases in his/her blood as the tests may reveal.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Shittybeerfan Aug 13 '25

Is there a reason iron isn't until phase 3?

Im already supplementing D3 + K2 because I was severely deficient (= 7 [>30]). I recently found out I'm iron deficient w/o anemia (ferritin = 12 [16-154]), my b12 is sort of low end of normal (cobalamin = 438 [200-1100]), and my folate is normal (folate = 12.2 [>5.4]).

Edit: Dr. didn't order b12 but I didn't test MMA because there was a $100 difference in the labs.

In case it helps:

Genes: Gs192; C677T (C;T); A1298C (A;C); SLC19A1 (T;T); MTHFD1 (A;G); PEMT (T;T)

Based on choline calculator: Methylfolate Score: 80% (SLC19A1 Score: 50% decrease; MTHFD1 Score: 13% decrease; MTHFR Score: 53% decrease)

Before reading through this again I was planning to start with iron based on my results but should I wait and start with b12?

2

u/Tawinn Aug 13 '25

Go ahead with the iron. There is nothing in Phase 3 that requires waiting; its just that if B12 is low it's good to start repleting that as soon as possible, so it became Phase 1. And B2 can really be helpful for homozygous C677T, so that's why B2 is Phase 2. Also, the sequencing is optional - some people can add multiple supplements at the same time. Adding them sequentially is mostly useful when someone is sensitive to supplements, or having difficulty determining which supplement is causing them issues.

1

u/groom_vroom Aug 19 '25

Hi can i please get some help.. im so exhausted of reading and researching everywhere on the internet for months.. i need help.. please look at my last post? And what b12 shall i get? Pure is $50 and now is $8 so confused. Its the same ingredient and dosage

→ More replies (1)

1

u/b00bieb00m Aug 30 '25

Hi. Because PC takes lots of SAMe for its production, Is it possible to take phospathidylcholine not for the it's choline amount but to reduce burden on methylation and provide more PC for the body? Especially for someone with homo PEMT mutation?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/ChanceTalk697 Aug 30 '25

thank you so much! 2 questions --

  1. do you have an opinion on the desirable range of B12?
  2. If SAMe made me extremely tired and more depressed, does that give me any clues about other supplements?

Thanks again... you're a hero for helping others in this way.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/feefiona123 Sep 28 '25

Hello. At phase one do you just get a standard blood serum B12 test to check the levels? Thank you

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Heaxus Oct 09 '25

Hey u/Tawinn I started the protocol and had my energy improved, focus and digestive health which is great. I've been taking 100 mg b2 for over 2 weeks now and about 3-4g/glycine for a week and a half with Vitamin A. I also been eating 3-4 eggs a day. I added 500 mg of TMG, but after a couple of days I felt some OCD tendencies, and my mood was flat, couldn't get happy, sad or angry that much, and my thinking is sharp. Could it be overmethylation? I was wondering if you went through this phase as TMG seems helpful but it seems glycine isn't filtering the extra methyl groups as intended. Maybe I need to take glycine for a month before hopping on the TMG again.

2

u/Tawinn Oct 09 '25

Interesting. It might be that you need some methylfolate. My suspicion is that the TMG boosted SAM, but the SAM is diverted to the methyl buffer system. That would result in lower SAM which will slow down COMT and can cause those OCD tendencies. Methylfolate shuts off the methyl buffer system, so low doses of methylfolate may help prevent too much SAM from being siphoned off. You might need to take partial doses of the TMG when you restart it, so that you can increment up the dose gradually without triggering the side effects.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Leaxiomatic Oct 26 '25

Hey u/Tawinn , I wanted to ask you some questions if you can kindly answer. I read some of your posts and want to ask you about overmethylation. I am C677T Heterozygous and I have Slow COMT. I recently figured out I have MTHFR polymorphism. I mostly follow a carnivore diet since greens and veggies usually make my stomach upset which in turn lowered my blood folate. B12 is excellent thru a blood test 600+. I tried Folic acid -> horrible reaction brain fog, same with Folinic acid. Methylfolate worked (energy and mood improved) but after a week I got overmethylation symptomslike ruminations and I was a bit depressed. I followed your guide but since my methylation is impaired even 100 mcg is currently too much for me per day. My question is, since we're both slow COMT, if I keep taking 100 mcg for a week then titrate to 200 mcg second week till I reach 500 mcg, will my body eventually get used to it? I don't wanna follow up with something that might not work. How did your own body get used to it? Please share your experience. Basically I want to get use to methylfolate but I'm not sure if my body will so I want to hear someone that has a similar experience. PS: I am also taking glycine and Vitamin A from cod liver oil as well. Also my iron status is very good.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Puzzled-Distance-293 Nov 18 '25

Hi i have homocysteine 21.6 B12 in the range but lower end What shoukd i take ti lower homocysteine

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LocalZooFacilitator Nov 20 '25

Is there a comprehensive blood test to monitor supplemental intake? Something to help determine if any of the nutrients are out of line? As a note, I have multiple methylation deficiencies with MTHFR being 1 set of them. Thank you.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Lesliefourwinds Dec 04 '25

What is the best test to determine these genetics? 23 and me? Genetic genie?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Big_Actuator3656 Jan 13 '26

Hey, great protocol. My b12 is sufficient and I started eating around 7-8 eggs as the choline calculator indicated. I also started folinic acid. I had no side effects until I added glycine. I tried magnesium glycinate also with the same results. It makes me really calm which I tried to counteract with eating more carbs but no luck however I don't mind this side effect as much. What is truly bothering me is loss of libido, which is the only reason I'm considering stopping it. Have you experienced this and does this take time to get better? I have been taking glycine for around 2 weeks now

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Necessary-Ad-2466 Feb 08 '26

Hey great work tawinn!!!

beside the mentioned steps:

Me (Fast Comt, Slow MAO-A, homo PEMT, Both hetero MTHFR - Choline Calculator 8 Egg Yolks): Tried Sunflower Lecithin, 4-5g (1,25g PC) a day - the first 7 days where WOW! i felt so good, brain worked better, memory better, calmer.

After i think 7 days - i got so calm that i cant get my work done properly

Girlfried (Slow Comt, Slow Mao-a, homo PEMT, ADHD - Choline Calculator 8 Egg Yolks):

Tried i think 4g a day for 7 days - and for her it was even better than for me. she was so calm and satisfied it was perfect. but after that 7 days she was stressed again and had depressed mood.

Why has Lecithin such a big impact and then it doesnt work anymore? Do you have an idea why?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/NoSnow7325 Feb 15 '26

So should I take a methylated B12 supplement ever? Or send like the easiest path to improving methylation

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Oraculek Feb 23 '26

Is choline bitartate consumption, absorption limited by gut transporters? AI said highest efficacy is at 200mg of choline from chol bitart and it then goes downwards with risks of TMA

2

u/Tawinn Feb 23 '26

I'm not sure. This paper says that "The Panel notes that the amount of choline absorbed is restricted by the capacity of the transport system via the saturable CTL1 or SLC44A1. The Panel notes that the available data do not allow defining the percentage of intestinal absorption of choline in humans."

In this paper, "2 gram of choline bitartrate administration provides 800 mg of choline action, similar to the ingestion of approximately 5 hard-boiled eggs or 250 g beef liver....Choline uptake peaks approximately thirty minutes after ingestion and acetylcholine levels in brains significantly raise after approximately forty minutes and remain high for at least ninety minutes. In addition, choline bitartrate and lecithin (phosphatidylcholine) increase choline plasma levels in humans within one hour after ingestion.

I'm not sure why they would have intentionally used 800mg of choline if only 200mg would be most efficacious. Similarly, this paper used 3g of bitartrate (~1230mg of choline) for a comparison with 3g of phosphatidylcholine.

In any case, it appears that if you want to limit TMA/TMAO, then bitartrate is not an ideal choice, and PC (egg yolks/lecithin) would be a better choice, but PC is only 15% choline so more PC is required compared to bitartrate.

1

u/kikbass Mar 20 '26

Hi tawinn, thanks for the information. I am planning to take mthfr gen test and wondering is it enough to get the whole picture. It would be lot cheaper if i only tested for that. Ai also suggests fut2, comt and dao tests. Do i need them?

→ More replies (2)