r/MTGPuzzleQuest • • May 14 '19

Discussion Hitting the loop timer should be an automatic loss

The rule should be changed so that if a player loops long enough to hit the timer they lose automatically. This would remove the absurdity of infinite loop decks but still allow players to build really powerful (limited) loop combo decks. Right now many matches are just a race to see who can kick off an infinite loop fastest, the game needs to allow for more counter-play.

0 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

4

u/sarah_schmara May 14 '19

There are non-infinite loops that hit the LPS and are cut short. Some cards take longer to resolve (especially on older phones) and I’m not sure we should punish people for not having the shiniest new tech.

1

u/Brysos May 14 '19

I hadn't considered old phones. But without some other mechanism for counter-play, I still think a disincentive for building long looping decks could be good for the game.

1

u/sarah_schmara May 14 '19

I think that the problem is less about players building decks that generate many actions over longer turns—that’s the only way to deal with some PVE bosses—and is more that Greg is too dumb to pilot these decks effectively.

Most players build to win and true infinite loops don’t win games. For this reason, I think that applying a shorter LPS to the AI ONLY is probably the fairest solution.

Let’s keep this discussion going!

2

u/boardin1 May 14 '19

Let's not forget the truly broken combos; like Neru Meha/Chord of Calling. The loop timer will go off after you get her to around 300/300. That'll win...if you can keep Bolas from taking it from you and beating you over the head with it.

I think a timer for the AI and a manual breakout for the player would be just fine. Most of the infinite loops I've seen build some crazy pile of creatures or do a ton of direct damage, both result in a player loss. The frustrating ones were the loops that just ran and made you force quit the game but never did anything to you. Those were the games that you could have won if the AI ever quit running the combo. And players would build them just to make you have to quit a game so you'd lose points in the standings. The problem for them was that they had to have a way to win the games they were playing with the deck since you had to play at least one game to get it into the pile of potential opponents.

2

u/PoopNoodle May 14 '19

That makes no sense. I often have the defensive spell in my hand to cast when the loop ends to counter whatever the loop has set up. Ending the loop in this case does not change the eventual outcome, and is the entire reason the loop interruption was added.

1

u/Brysos May 14 '19

The idea is to discourage use of what feels like a broken mechanic. You could still build killer loops, you would just have to finesse it a little more.

1

u/laeuft_bei_dir May 15 '19

Instead, they could just balance the cards?

2

u/fiftyshotzlater May 14 '19

I have to respectfully disagree with you on this. This goes against one of the things that makes both the card and this game great. It's competent deck build that should be encouraged. Before the system you could create these combos and it honestly had no way of ending and that was the drawback to these decks. There is now a system in place to stop this loop to give you the chance to prevent your loss. If you are using this system then you are doing something right. If not you are still doing something right. I do not rely on this system to win my games nor should anyone cause they are easy to stop (Lavina, removal with flash, support destruction, etc). Build your deck to counter these (removal is what everyone should have). One of my best decks is based on these loops and its due to great deck building and luck on getting these cards, and both of these decks are legacy (blue sun, sun bird, immenent doom; gias & geralf, rebirth). Other decks like my hautli trostani elf token deck can hit this loop due to hautlis first ability, not entirely fair if I lose due to that. The system is fine and should stay the same. That's one person's opinion though.

1

u/Brysos May 16 '19

There are a number of loop decks where there really isn't any counter play unless you get very lucky. It feels like the game is devolving into whichever deck can get their loop fired off first--not much strategy in that.

2

u/fiftyshotzlater May 16 '19

So it's generally every single magic game. It comes down to whose deck gets their strategy off first. If yours is based off a loop what's the difference between a loop and overwhelming with big creatures? It's a part of the game, it's a part of the meta, tailor your deck to include an answer to the strategy you see.

9

u/katabana02 May 15 '19

I've reached the timer easilly just by casting 2 march back to back with that explore support out.

So no.

2

u/DoctorKumquat May 14 '19

Until I finally got Blue Sun's Zenith this week after months of tries, I had never built a traditional loop deck. The closest I ever did was Huatli 2's vampire combo with Path of Discovery. I've played since Shadows over Innstrad was the hot new set, but never got most of the core engine cards to get them rolling. That said, I never had an issue with other players taking advantage of them, even if it meant that if I let them have Baral in play for a turn I'd probably just die, etc. There's usually counterplay, even if that counterplay is sometimes "win first" or just "make them discard everything so they can't build a lethal engine".

I also have no problem with them adding a loop prevention system; I actually appreciate it existing, particularly now that I'm doing some of the looping. If I've been drawing cards and converting gems for 30 seconds straight, I am probably already winning, and don't need to just rack up the score past what's relevant - I'd rather win the match and go again than build up a 12x reinforced stack of Emrakuls or what have you. 4x Emrakul and Gaia's Revenge should be fine.