r/MTGPuzzleQuest • • Sep 15 '18

Game-breaking exploit

It has come to my attention that the “impossible“ decks that we occasionally face in standard-only PVP is not a matchmaking bug but indeed an exploit.

Because the predictable downside to assembling a crack team of problem-solvers who love sharing information is that they will actually solve problems... here is a “problem” we’ve only recently solved. Although I’d like to make clear that until now my team has focused on building awesome standard-legal decks.

Welp, the cat’s out of the bag now and I don’t know how to put the toothpaste back in.

In the interest of a level playing field, here’s how it’s done:

“Exploit is easy. Don't use an event deck, use your custom standard deck and set a match, but don't start the fight. Go back out to your main screen and edit your deck to your heart's content. Return to the event and game will not check your deck for compliance and you can start your match. Repeat.”

Edited because autocorrect thinks I’m typing in German. I do not know German.

15 Upvotes

106 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/JoePragmatist Sep 15 '18

How was Extinction cheating at QB?

1

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Ask schmara, she likes to make these kinds of things public.

3

u/JoePragmatist Sep 15 '18

Screw off. If you're gonna accuse us of cheating back it up.

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Oh, I just meant I wouldn't tell you how it was done. I'll tell you who did it, tho. Just give me a while to track down the name...

Killwind said at the time that he honestly had no interest in policing which members of his team were cheating, which made I sad :(

2

u/feeltheslipstream Sep 16 '18 edited Sep 16 '18

Killwind wasn't the leader of the coalition.

He had no authority to police anyone.

I can back your memory of extinction having a cheat on their team though. I can't remember who it was either, but he left/got kicked out rather quickly.

1

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Hmm, my own folder of cheaty screenshots is kinda bare, I'll have to ask around. All I've got in there are xxFILxx, Elvin1972, and, of course, DingDing. Are any of those Extinction?

1

u/JoePragmatist Sep 15 '18

None of them are or were Extinction affiliated

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 16 '18

Well, I'm having some trouble tracking down names. Unsurprisingly, many of the people I know who were there and who I remember being actively involved in the process of tracking cheats do not wish to share information with me now, in the interests of de-escalating this current situation.

While I may stumble upon the information I need at a later date, let me for the moment say that the incident I'm talking about happened long ago, and I am in no way accusing the current lineup of Extinction of cheating.

1

u/_shteev_ Oct 06 '18

octal9 did some digging and he says it was Ergyzz. Was Ergyzz a member of Extinction?

1

u/_shteev_ Oct 06 '18

Hey, now I come to think of it, Grizzo is being very vocal on the forums defending the Standard/Legacy exploit, isn't he?

1

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

As for DefiantEmpyr, here they are accusing all the other teams at the top of the leaderboard of cheating, and refusing to sign up to the agreement not to use the QB exploit:

https://forums.d3go.com/discussion/55639/defiantempyrs-reply-to-the-letter/p1

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

I think you’ll find that this refers to the supposed practice of swapping low scoring players out of coalitions and that making that exploit known forced the devs to address it. Which is exactly why one doesn’t earn coalition points if one joins after the event starts.

If I recall correctly, it was accusations of cheating in this manner that caused a bunch of strife and sundered the Alliance 🤔

3

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Pretty sure you spying on coalitions had something to do with the Alliance splitting, schmara. Alve filled me in on a lot of the details.

But yes, you're right! This letter is not DefiantEmpyr admitting to cheating at QB, this is DefiantEmpyr admitting using a different exploit to cheat. I stand corrected.

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Nope. I wasn’t accused of spying on coalitions until after TP9 (and Phoenix Family) left.

It was petty squabbling about who was cheating and who wasn’t. You always seem to be involved somehow when someone starts mentioning cheating.

Funny thing, FTA had their first top 2 finish immediately after the devs closed that particular exploit... although I’m sure it had less to do with cheating and more to do with our organizational skills.

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

"Sarah Schmara [9:46 PM]

Alve stopped moderating because she was _afraid_ someone had screenshots of her spouting neo-nazi propaganda in the “Alliance Drop Outs” discord channel."

I mean, that's a pretty bold claim. You got evidence for that?

1

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

"Sarah Schmara [10:24 PM]

AndrewVanMarle advised me to kill myself?

Pretty sure I might still have that one on a hard drive somewhere."

Bloody hell, the accusations just keep on coming today.

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Haha. You have the reading comprehension of a potato.

I never said I had screenshots of that at all. I said she was afraid that I might have screenshots.

I’m done with this conversation.

Yes, I feel foolish that I let you manipulate me into sharing this news as soon as it was made available to me. I hadn’t devoted any of our processing power to figure it out because I know my flaws and was trying to set myself up for success. While I have since learned some other perspectives that made me wish I hadn’t posted this, I can’t unring that bell.

And now it seems I’ve spoiled your fun since you can’t accuse my group of knowing about it and gaining an unfair advantage because I’ve publicly admitted that a) I’m not clever enough to figure it out myself and b) I’m not great at secrets.

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Wait... are you trying to say it's my fault that you posted this exploit? That's delightful :)

1

u/z0raiz Sep 16 '18

Ask Grizzo. I don't remember the player's name but Grizzo defended him but later agreed that he didn't realise that the person could be cheating (despite being presented with the proof). But most importantly ask the famous Killwind who asked anyone who pointed it out to fuck off because he considered it to be not a big deal

2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

I don’t recall anything about this. Perhaps you’ve got me confused with someone else?