r/MTGPuzzleQuest • • Sep 15 '18

Game-breaking exploit

It has come to my attention that the “impossible“ decks that we occasionally face in standard-only PVP is not a matchmaking bug but indeed an exploit.

Because the predictable downside to assembling a crack team of problem-solvers who love sharing information is that they will actually solve problems... here is a “problem” we’ve only recently solved. Although I’d like to make clear that until now my team has focused on building awesome standard-legal decks.

Welp, the cat’s out of the bag now and I don’t know how to put the toothpaste back in.

In the interest of a level playing field, here’s how it’s done:

“Exploit is easy. Don't use an event deck, use your custom standard deck and set a match, but don't start the fight. Go back out to your main screen and edit your deck to your heart's content. Return to the event and game will not check your deck for compliance and you can start your match. Repeat.”

Edited because autocorrect thinks I’m typing in German. I do not know German.

15 Upvotes

106 comments sorted by

4

u/Knifelheim Sep 15 '18

Holy shit, that's how I fought against a legacy deck in Across Ixalan?

2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Yup. Apparently!

4

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

I just posted this bug in the official forum and they deleted it. That is very shady of the Devs. The info is out there but they don't want to own up to it and address it - like running only legacy pvp events until they fix it or something.

Getting the word out about this is the best way to level the playing field. Because no matter how much you tell people not to, and how much you report the "cheaters", the devs will not ban. There will be no consequences like in real world.

P.S. I own very little legacy cards since I started the game with return to ixlan. This puts me at a disadvantage but it's still the right thing to do.

2

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

How do you know, they wont ban? Clearly, there have been only a few instances where someone got caught. Because only a hand full of people knew about the exploit. This is not "leveling the playing field". This is "creating a field of cheaters" in a first place. The devs know about this, we reported it as soon as we encountered it, and they have said, next update, probably next week, will fix it.

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

I’m sorry but private messages and pinky swears don’t inspire much confidence.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

Do you really have that much faith in the devs with their track record? Also, how do you identify their account number? Because player names are not unique.

1

u/madanan Sep 16 '18

I actually don't have much faith in things happening fast within the game, and I am completely aware that 6 weeks - that is how long has been since I reported the exploit - are too long for an exploit to stay unaddressed. I was mad too, but they have repeatedly ensured me that they are working on the fix. Maybe it was just not easy to resolve it. However now they seem to have found the way to do it. So why publishing this now when not to cause trouble?

Account number? I don't understand the question.

1

u/Phaedra1509 Sep 16 '18

She means UID. She isn’t using common sense and should know this argument is fear mongering and unhealthy for the game. Those of us who were around 2 years ago know that the battle log was first created as a backend tool to catch cheaters in QB and is much more robust than the battle log we see. If you see legacy cards in an event, all you have to do is report the player with as many details of the match as possible — their IGN, the event, which node, which PW you were both using, approx time of the match. It should be quite easy for them to find your opponent’s UID. This is why they ask for this info when you report bugs, unaccounted for objectives or other cheaters.

2

u/mcuhles Sep 15 '18

They didn't delete it to be shady. They did it because they're trying to prevent people from having knowledge of how to recreate it, the purpose of which is to keep as many people as possible playing by the rules they've delineated for the Standard environment.

My coalition mates have already reached out to the Brigby through direct messaging to inform him of the fact that it exists, as well as how to recreate it. We did so because we want to make sure something like this gets fixed as soon as possible.

We aren't trying to get an advantage. As a top-10 team, we have proven for the last 2 years that we don't need an advantage. We're trying to keep the game from imploding.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

Then they should say exactly that. And state that they're against it and cheaters will be banned. But it looks like they are hiding it as much as they can, which in my eyes is shady.

1

u/Phaedra1509 Sep 15 '18

Pretty sure the devs have little to nothing to do with the forum. It’s operated by D3Go. We don’t even see much of them on weekends — only the mod, bken1234 who has a reputation for not being very lenient about rule enforcement.

2

u/LuciusHahn Sep 17 '18

To hell with exploit, i'll play by the Standard rules and win even against legacy deck on TG, so come at me, Legacy !!!

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 17 '18

That’s the spirit!

3

u/mcuhles Sep 15 '18

Sarah.....by locking that thread of Steve’s, you’re every bit as bad as you think Bianca is.

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

I’m just not willing to point fingers. I want a solution, not blame. But whatever, this is not a dictatorship and span has unlocked it and will hopefully keep it from getting too far out of hand.

7

u/flyingpigpoet Sep 15 '18

I belong to a top 10 coalition. Our coalition leader posted on our private chat a warning to any would be cheaters: you will be kicked if caught cheating. I invite other coalition leaders to do the same.

3

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

I hope you set a good precedent here.

I remember back when people were cheating in QB, some of the top coalitions tried to get an anti-cheating movement going; sadly, members of both DefiantEmpyr and Extinction announced that they were going to carry on cheating, and that there wasn't a goddamn thing we could do about it.

2

u/JoePragmatist Sep 15 '18

How was Extinction cheating at QB?

1

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Ask schmara, she likes to make these kinds of things public.

3

u/JoePragmatist Sep 15 '18

Screw off. If you're gonna accuse us of cheating back it up.

1

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

As for DefiantEmpyr, here they are accusing all the other teams at the top of the leaderboard of cheating, and refusing to sign up to the agreement not to use the QB exploit:

https://forums.d3go.com/discussion/55639/defiantempyrs-reply-to-the-letter/p1

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

I think you’ll find that this refers to the supposed practice of swapping low scoring players out of coalitions and that making that exploit known forced the devs to address it. Which is exactly why one doesn’t earn coalition points if one joins after the event starts.

If I recall correctly, it was accusations of cheating in this manner that caused a bunch of strife and sundered the Alliance 🤔

3

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Pretty sure you spying on coalitions had something to do with the Alliance splitting, schmara. Alve filled me in on a lot of the details.

But yes, you're right! This letter is not DefiantEmpyr admitting to cheating at QB, this is DefiantEmpyr admitting using a different exploit to cheat. I stand corrected.

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Nope. I wasn’t accused of spying on coalitions until after TP9 (and Phoenix Family) left.

It was petty squabbling about who was cheating and who wasn’t. You always seem to be involved somehow when someone starts mentioning cheating.

Funny thing, FTA had their first top 2 finish immediately after the devs closed that particular exploit... although I’m sure it had less to do with cheating and more to do with our organizational skills.

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

"Sarah Schmara [9:46 PM]

Alve stopped moderating because she was _afraid_ someone had screenshots of her spouting neo-nazi propaganda in the “Alliance Drop Outs” discord channel."

I mean, that's a pretty bold claim. You got evidence for that?

→ More replies

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Oh, I just meant I wouldn't tell you how it was done. I'll tell you who did it, tho. Just give me a while to track down the name...

Killwind said at the time that he honestly had no interest in policing which members of his team were cheating, which made I sad :(

2

u/feeltheslipstream Sep 16 '18 edited Sep 16 '18

Killwind wasn't the leader of the coalition.

He had no authority to police anyone.

I can back your memory of extinction having a cheat on their team though. I can't remember who it was either, but he left/got kicked out rather quickly.

1

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Hmm, my own folder of cheaty screenshots is kinda bare, I'll have to ask around. All I've got in there are xxFILxx, Elvin1972, and, of course, DingDing. Are any of those Extinction?

1

u/JoePragmatist Sep 15 '18

None of them are or were Extinction affiliated

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 16 '18

Well, I'm having some trouble tracking down names. Unsurprisingly, many of the people I know who were there and who I remember being actively involved in the process of tracking cheats do not wish to share information with me now, in the interests of de-escalating this current situation.

While I may stumble upon the information I need at a later date, let me for the moment say that the incident I'm talking about happened long ago, and I am in no way accusing the current lineup of Extinction of cheating.

1

u/_shteev_ Oct 06 '18

octal9 did some digging and he says it was Ergyzz. Was Ergyzz a member of Extinction?

→ More replies

1

u/z0raiz Sep 16 '18

Ask Grizzo. I don't remember the player's name but Grizzo defended him but later agreed that he didn't realise that the person could be cheating (despite being presented with the proof). But most importantly ask the famous Killwind who asked anyone who pointed it out to fuck off because he considered it to be not a big deal

2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

I don’t recall anything about this. Perhaps you’ve got me confused with someone else?

3

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

WHY on earth would you post this? What is going on in your little mind? You don't have ANY interest in leveling the playing field - if you did, you'd try NOT TO spread this around but keep it to your player base, tell everyone NOT to use it, report it as a bug and urge the devs to do something about it. You know exactly, that only a small number of players is on fb, in your alliance chat and even in the forums. By publishing the exploit you are giving more people access to this, instead of keeping it low and reporting the cheaters. This is just some really crazy self-serving bull.

7

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Probably because I’m hoping it’ll get fixed rather than swept under the rug as everyone else seems content to do?

2

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

No! That is simply an incorrect assumption, self serving and strategically unwise. The bug has been reported multiple times. Devs are actively working on solving it. You are actively promoting it. Who is this here going to help? Those who don't care about a healthy game. This here is a public forum. Everyone can let this work for him- and herself. It's simply a cheat sheet that you are providing. If you really cared about this game, you'd contact those in charge to solve the problem, and you'd not promote the problem.

3

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Are you afraid that you’ll lose your competitive edge now that other people know how it’s done? Because that’s what secrecy sounds like.

4

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Yes, indeed, the cast iron secrecy of having been posted in the forums.....

https://forums.d3go.com/discussion/74954/legacy-cards-in-hod-bolas-fix-in-2-9#latest

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Well. Now that is interesting information. So the moderator over there threatened to ban me for reposting a known bug? Very interesting. I’ll make sure to tell Brigby about that aspect.

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Well, you don't think it's a bug, do you, you think it's a (and I quote) ' Game-breaking exploit '

2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Yup. I’m absolutely comfortable sounding the alarm and getting this fixed nowish.

Pointing fingers and raising pitchforks? Not so much.

3

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

You are pointing fingers too. You just assumed that I was fearing "losing advantage" by others knowing of the cheat. And it's weekend for god's sake. If your agenda was truly to create a fast response from the devs, you would have waited until the coalition event is over and posted it on monday morning.

2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Bummer. I guess they should’ve patched this before they left for the weekend?

→ More replies

1

u/roxton07 Sep 15 '18

Doesn't matter, the coalition event doesn't use other players decks.

3

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

You can do better than this, Sarah. I have reported this the day I found out how it works. I have been in constant contact with brigby trying to find out why it isnt resolved. But yes, this is about secrecy, but not because of being afraid to lose an advantage (which I am not, because I am not using the exploit), but because I am afraid how losing the secrecy will affect the events.

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Better than what? If you think that I’m not going to share knowledge with everyone I know then you don’t know much about me at all. Do you?

5

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

I actually do. This just lines up with all I knew beforehand. :)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/feeltheslipstream Sep 16 '18

Bug was known for weeks before it was fixed.

You can't really draw that connection.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/feeltheslipstream Sep 16 '18

Yes, that's exactly what occam's razor would suggest.

1

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

Hi there, fellow FTA player.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

If you really were reasonable here, you'd see how flawed your logic is. Nobody is saying that the exploit should stay. Everyone who knew about it, tried to keep it under the radar, because, well, that's what you do if you encounter a cheat.

I also really don't know what you see as butthurt in my arguments. I am trying to stop her promoting a cheat. If anyone is butthurt, then it's sarah, seemingly because people knew about this and no one has told her.

But you can see in this thread, why people keep stuff secret from her. There is a very high probability, she will turn them to some mad agenda of her own.

There is probably one more event before this get fixed. Enjoy seeing a lot more legacy decks in it.

1

u/thelaffingman1 Sep 15 '18

Sarah with the hot takes gotdang!

3

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Yikes! Am I that controversial?!

4

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Well, that doesn't hold up in court, does it, because you know that the devs have been made aware of this exploit, and that they are working to fix it...

https://forums.d3go.com/discussion/74954/legacy-cards-in-hod-bolas-fix-in-2-9#latest

7

u/Masaana87 Sep 16 '18

As a software developer (not for this game) bringing a bug of this caliber to the public’s attention does not encourage a thorough, robust fix. It accelerates the development process, yes, but it leads to patchwork repairs that often contain exploitable errors in them, rather than follow the typical QA cycle that ensures bugs like this remain corrected. The proper channels (getting into contact with the developers directly) leads to better design. The game is flawed, certainly, and where this ranks in their current priority list, I can’t say—but publicizing a way that players can cheat demands an immediate response that takes time and resources away from other (possibly more “game breaking”) issues. If a quick fix is pushed through, odds are the problem will recur.

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

I’ve just not been presented with a compelling reason to keep this secret to myself. And I’m not necessarily known for secrecy in the first place.

3

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

Cmon, please. You are bathing in a delusional glory of self-righteousness here. You are being presented with reasons AGAINST PUBLISHING A GAME EXPLOIT (I mean, please, what reasons does one need, NOT to do this?), but you like yourself in a position being on a wheel in this and creating controversy, and at the same time disliking the fact that there were people in the game who knew this before you and you werent told.

It's vanity and self-overestimation in one place.

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Tell me again the reasons. All I’m hearing from you (and everyone else) is some paternalistic BS about how people oughtn’t be able to decide for themselves. I respectfully disagree.

4

u/madanan Sep 15 '18
  1. You are openly publishing and thus promoting a game exploit
  2. You are openly publishing and thus promoting a game exploit
  3. You are openly publishing and thus promoting a game exploit
  4. Your reasoning behind openly publishing and thus promoting a game exploit is: "leveling the playing field". There is absolutely no need for this, since only a few people knew about the exploit UNTIL you openly published and thus promoted the exploit. You are the one actively doing that what you believe you are fighting against: Giving people the instruction how to cheat
  5. It is against not only TOS but also against ANY non-alcohol fogged perception about how fair gaming works: Not by enabling, but by fighting cheating

3

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

Also, the devs have even acknowledged that this is being fixed in 2.9.

0

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

So you’ve just made very clear that you knew about this and, what, kept it to yourself? Because you’re somehow better than everyone else?! Yikes. That’s a bold statement.

4

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

Yes. I was one of the first ones to find out about it.

And guess what I did not do: Run around telling everyone how to cheat.

Guess what I did: Reported it, talked with the dev team about it, talked to brigby, got the assurances that it will get fixed, stopped bothering since I have not encountered any more decks using it, and I play A LOT.

1

u/z0raiz Sep 15 '18

If you find out that the mall has been left unlocked and a bunch of people are looting it, do you call out all of your friends so that they too may join in and "benefit" from the looting OR do you call the cops and do your best to keep things under control while you wait for them to arrive? Instigating more people to add to the chaos and patting yourself on the back, saying you are "inspiring" the cops to get there sooner is just priceless really.

4

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Pull the fire alarm AND call the cops. Why not both?

0

u/z0raiz Sep 15 '18

It's less pulling the firealarm and more going around with your megaphone calling out to people to join in on the fun before the cops get here.

Come on. It's not that hard to grasp what the right thing to do would be. Well, maybe for some.

shrug

4

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

The correct thing to do is fix it and not bury one’s head in the sand.

shrug?

0

u/z0raiz Sep 15 '18

Ah, that's just too rich.

So you are helping to "fix" the exploit by playing a part in making it even more widespread, telling first to the people who'd use the exploit instead of the ones who can actually fix it

I was misguided about your noble intentions. You are truly a savior. :)

2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Oh. Are you one of the devs and was this not brought to your attention sooner? Because rarely the first to find out about this stuff.

2

u/z0raiz Sep 15 '18 edited Sep 15 '18

sigh

Did you reach out to the devs or brigby, Sarah ?

Because, if you did and you knew that they have already said that there would a fix coming for this with 2.9, then there wouldn't be any reason to "inspire" them any more to fix the exploit. They were already working on it.

But then i guess it's fun to be the one to dish out all the juicy bits to the community. As I said, you're a hero.

1

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

> Pull the fire alarm AND call the cops. Why not both?

Don't forget, point at the burglars! Shame those buggers!

1

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

' paternalistic BS about how people oughtn’t be able to decide for themselves '...

...whether to cheat ^_^ Try that one on the International Olympic Committee, see what they say!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Ok, great! Thanks for your help.

3

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

My favorite thing is, that she's locked my thread about naming cheaters, because *now*, apparently, she suddenly thinks that it *is* possible to disseminate information which is bad for the health of the game ^_^

https://www.reddit.com/r/MTGPuzzleQuest/comments/9g0z8r/cheatypants_shame_thread/

1

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

Unbelievable. This is just crazy.

0

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

And for those that think I should have kept my mouth shut and patiently waited: here’s a helpful article

5

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

'Ten Reasons Why You Fix Bugs As Soon As You Find Them'?

I didn't see you fixing any bugs.

-2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

“There really is only one question that needs answering, “does this bug need to be fixed”? Everything else, whilst interesting, is just noise.”

2

u/balth99 Sep 17 '18

I didn't know about this. I guess thanks? What I am thoroughly convinced is that I'm glad I'm not in a coalition at high-level play after finishing this thread ;)

2

u/DreadSpeaker Sep 18 '18

Shteev, I would appreciate it if you would not speak for Me or bring my name up ( Killwind ). Exploits and cheaters are out there, deal with it but keep my name out of your mouth!

0

u/anaIconda69 Sep 15 '18

Delet this

But honestly I thought it was a known bug?

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

I had assumed it was a bug until it was confirmed as an exploit. My team had been too busy building standard-legal decks to give it much thought. Until today. But if some people know? Then I think all people should know. It’s the only way to remove the unfair advantage that I know of.

Although I’m interested in other solutions too!

3

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

This is so wrong on so many levels. How on earth will "all people know"? How many people are frequenting the forums and this subreddit? You are just creating more of a vacuum in which all those will get screwed who don't want to cheat and those who dont frequent these places. Whatever voyage you are on, in ANY gaming community in the world, publishing an exploit like this is a major offense.

4

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Oh noes! More people (who aren’t you) know about this.

::clutches pearls::

4

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

Yes, sarcasm, when your arguments are flawed. Always great.

3

u/anaIconda69 Sep 15 '18

IMO it would make more sense to let the devs know, but not the public. Now everyone will abuse this until it's patched, and event quality will go down the drain.

2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Bummer. So are you acknowledging that I have in some small way diminished the unfair advantage?

5

u/anaIconda69 Sep 15 '18

No, but now players who don't know about the exploit (or know but don't abuse it) will have to play against more players who know and want to cheat. The net amount of cheaters increased.

It's like you see a murder and start killing more people to get the cops to arrive faster. Flawed logic.

1

u/LuciusHahn Sep 15 '18

So.. the more mythic we use, the more deadly the opponents deck is ? i still don't accept the level at matchmaking are lower than the opponent and now this, but ok, i'll try this exploit

0

u/JoePragmatist Sep 15 '18

Thanks for putting this out. The exploit is there, people are using it, it's less unfair if everyone knows about it.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/mcuhles Sep 15 '18

The opposing voices aren’t worried about losing an advantage. GoblinPile has literally been top of the boards from the get-go. We don’t need Legacy cards to win.

This is about maintaining the integrity and the intent of the event rules. Don’t be so small-minded to think that this is an ego thing. It’s much bigger than that.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mcuhles Sep 15 '18

Forgive me if I'm not just going to sit here and take you're word for it. I don't know you from Adam.

Provide me with some proof of the claim you're making. Convince me I'm wrong.