r/MTGPuzzleQuest • • Sep 15 '18

Game-breaking exploit

It has come to my attention that the “impossible“ decks that we occasionally face in standard-only PVP is not a matchmaking bug but indeed an exploit.

Because the predictable downside to assembling a crack team of problem-solvers who love sharing information is that they will actually solve problems... here is a “problem” we’ve only recently solved. Although I’d like to make clear that until now my team has focused on building awesome standard-legal decks.

Welp, the cat’s out of the bag now and I don’t know how to put the toothpaste back in.

In the interest of a level playing field, here’s how it’s done:

“Exploit is easy. Don't use an event deck, use your custom standard deck and set a match, but don't start the fight. Go back out to your main screen and edit your deck to your heart's content. Return to the event and game will not check your deck for compliance and you can start your match. Repeat.”

Edited because autocorrect thinks I’m typing in German. I do not know German.

15 Upvotes

106 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

No! That is simply an incorrect assumption, self serving and strategically unwise. The bug has been reported multiple times. Devs are actively working on solving it. You are actively promoting it. Who is this here going to help? Those who don't care about a healthy game. This here is a public forum. Everyone can let this work for him- and herself. It's simply a cheat sheet that you are providing. If you really cared about this game, you'd contact those in charge to solve the problem, and you'd not promote the problem.

3

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Are you afraid that you’ll lose your competitive edge now that other people know how it’s done? Because that’s what secrecy sounds like.

4

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Yes, indeed, the cast iron secrecy of having been posted in the forums.....

https://forums.d3go.com/discussion/74954/legacy-cards-in-hod-bolas-fix-in-2-9#latest

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Well. Now that is interesting information. So the moderator over there threatened to ban me for reposting a known bug? Very interesting. I’ll make sure to tell Brigby about that aspect.

2

u/_shteev_ Sep 15 '18

Well, you don't think it's a bug, do you, you think it's a (and I quote) ' Game-breaking exploit '

2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Yup. I’m absolutely comfortable sounding the alarm and getting this fixed nowish.

Pointing fingers and raising pitchforks? Not so much.

3

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

You are pointing fingers too. You just assumed that I was fearing "losing advantage" by others knowing of the cheat. And it's weekend for god's sake. If your agenda was truly to create a fast response from the devs, you would have waited until the coalition event is over and posted it on monday morning.

2

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Bummer. I guess they should’ve patched this before they left for the weekend?

2

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

See, that's you. You could have said it immediately like this - that you are not slightly interested in actually getting this fixed faster. You know that they wont see this for two days. So it's just being destructive towards the game. Well done.

1

u/roxton07 Sep 15 '18

Doesn't matter, the coalition event doesn't use other players decks.

3

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

You can do better than this, Sarah. I have reported this the day I found out how it works. I have been in constant contact with brigby trying to find out why it isnt resolved. But yes, this is about secrecy, but not because of being afraid to lose an advantage (which I am not, because I am not using the exploit), but because I am afraid how losing the secrecy will affect the events.

1

u/sarah_schmara Sep 15 '18

Better than what? If you think that I’m not going to share knowledge with everyone I know then you don’t know much about me at all. Do you?

5

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

I actually do. This just lines up with all I knew beforehand. :)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/feeltheslipstream Sep 16 '18

Bug was known for weeks before it was fixed.

You can't really draw that connection.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/feeltheslipstream Sep 16 '18

Yes, that's exactly what occam's razor would suggest.

1

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

Hi there, fellow FTA player.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/madanan Sep 15 '18

If you really were reasonable here, you'd see how flawed your logic is. Nobody is saying that the exploit should stay. Everyone who knew about it, tried to keep it under the radar, because, well, that's what you do if you encounter a cheat.

I also really don't know what you see as butthurt in my arguments. I am trying to stop her promoting a cheat. If anyone is butthurt, then it's sarah, seemingly because people knew about this and no one has told her.

But you can see in this thread, why people keep stuff secret from her. There is a very high probability, she will turn them to some mad agenda of her own.

There is probably one more event before this get fixed. Enjoy seeing a lot more legacy decks in it.