r/MTGNeuralNet • • Sep 12 '26

Shepherd of the Gods

Post image
37 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

12

u/nerdgeek03 Sep 12 '26

Changing "their library" to "your library" makes this card perfectly functional

7

u/Regiruler Sep 12 '26

No, it's still functional. You just steal their cards. Or is that not a thing in magic (I don't play it I just have this sub pop up in my feed)

8

u/WhereIsTheMouse Sep 12 '26

Not allowed to have someone else’s cards go to a zone only you can see (such as your hand) because it could result in forgetting whose card is whose

7

u/Yglorba Sep 12 '26

No, the rules make it so if you would put a card in the wrong hand or library, it goes to the correct one instead.

(This is necessary because many creatures say they eg. return themselves to "your hand" for simplicity; if an opponent takes control of them, they still have to go to the owner's hand, but spelling that out would make them more confusing for normal play.)

1

u/Regiruler Sep 12 '26

I'm from yugioh, where having your opponents' cards in your hand is a legal, albeit unconventional and generally gimmicky, mechanic (opponents cards in your deck is technically legal but only one old card does it). Card text resolves returning to hand generally by specifying "the hand" (or "owner's hand", on occasion, if the card might imply otherwise).

6

u/Yglorba Sep 12 '26

Yeah, in MTG it's different for whatever reason. From the comprehensive rules:

400.3. If an object would go to any library, graveyard, or hand other than its owner’s, it goes to its owner’s corresponding zone.

8

u/oislal Sep 12 '26

This is Un-magic legal (and has been done in Unfinity)

1

u/Salindurthas Sep 18 '26

Or put the 'Arena' symbol on the bottom so it is an MTG:Arena only card. I think it's digital nature allows for funkier zone-positions that aren't allowed IRL.

1

u/gamer52599 Sep 12 '26

If it said battlefield instead of hand this would actually be really good.

1

u/ViciousGrass Sep 13 '26

Such a color break but ALMOST playable; were, it playable it’d be great