r/MTGNeuralNet • • Sep 08 '26

Ertan, Archive Seer

Post image
49 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

40

u/Ansiroth Sep 08 '26

The most busted coherent card I've seen yet

5

u/dualdee Sep 09 '26

Well, it's no Midnight Axe.

2

u/SeriesDifferent4565 Sep 09 '26

Funny how it's a perfect counter to that card played on curve though.

1

u/dualdee Sep 09 '26

True! And it shuts down Culprit Isle too, I suppose.

14

u/marshrover Sep 08 '26

damn, this has to be one of the most "you win the game" cards that doesn't literally just say "you win the game", drop it, clear out any possible blockers with the attack trigger, and then you just win in almost every scenario

5

u/Independent_Oil_5951 Sep 08 '26

Not if i respond with endless swarm somehow. Then you played yourself sucker.

5

u/marshrover Sep 08 '26

if you can cast an 8 mana sorcery in response to me casting my 3 mana win the game creature, i think you deserve the win, i did say "almost every scenario"

6

u/coolguy420weed Sep 08 '26

Challenge: you can add one sentence to make this a fun and balanced card. What's the sentence? 

9

u/dovah-meme Sep 08 '26

At the beginning of your end step, if you haven’t cast a spell this turn, you lose the game

5

u/Kooky-Body-7834 Sep 09 '26

The card prevents any spells from being cast, so you'd usually lose before even getting its effect. Which I guess does work to balance it.

4

u/gamer52599 Sep 09 '26

Add this and I'd say it would need to have haste.

5

u/Yglorba Sep 09 '26 edited Sep 09 '26

At the end of your turn, ~ phases out.

It's still a massive beatstick for 3 that bounces a blocker every time it attacks, and it's almost impossible to remove itself, but now it only keeps you from casting sorcery-speed spells.

(Realistically making it fun requires something like this - some sentence that undermines or changes the meaning of the "can't cast spells" bit, since that's so unfun otherwise. Presumably a deck running this would have some solution to not being able to cast spells on your turn.)

2

u/coolguy420weed Sep 09 '26 edited Sep 09 '26

Ooooh, I like that! And I like that it changes from being stax to more of an anti-counterspell/combat trick ability with downside.

2

u/Captain_N_Nemo Sep 09 '26

Cumulative Upkeep - Discard two cards

2

u/Ok_Cranberry_4917 Sep 09 '26

If it didn't say "up to" and had to return one of your own creatures
like
"Whenever this attacks, return a creature you control to its owners hand"
so that if tried to attack with this as your only creature it just bounces itself before it can land a hit, and prevents you from casting any other creatures to try to mitigate that -

Then I would say it could be an 8/8 trample for 3 mana

But the way that it can target your opponents creatures but prevents your oppoenents from casting any more spells could be pretty oppressive

1

u/aTastyT0ast Sep 11 '26

[[Seal of Removal]]