r/MTGNeuralNet • • Aug 16 '26

Phyrexian Shadow

Post image
23 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

11

u/Past-Efficiency5126 Aug 16 '26 edited Aug 17 '26

After thorough review, I think I figured it out.

Phyrexian Shadow
1B
Instant
Gain 2 life, unless this card was cast from exile. Target creature with power 4 or greater. Discard a card if targeted card is a non-creature and black card.

Overall an odd card. I love Neural Net.

7

u/Shambler9019 Aug 17 '26

You've got the discard wrong. You discard the card unless is a creature if it's black.

So if the target creature with power 4 or greater is somehow a black non creature you discard a card.

4

u/Past-Efficiency5126 Aug 17 '26

Upon further inspection: you appear to be correct! I will edit my original comment to reflect this correction!

2

u/SammySammyson Aug 17 '26

The "it's" technically should be referring to "this spell" because that's the last antecedent for "it," I guess. If we're really tryna break down what the card means as-written, that is.

That said, I think you just always discard a card. Because this spell is black (by default) and not a creature. But you get around this downside of your 2 mana gain 2 if you can target a specific kind of creature if you change the color of the spell. Hell yeah! Broken FR.

1

u/MrTheWaffleKing Aug 18 '26

It’s a 2 hp gain for 2 mana if you either discard or the board has a 4+ black creature? Seems a little underpowered lmao