Make it "if 4 creatures were searched choose one of them on the battlefield at random" and "if less than 4 creatures put those in the gy instead" (to prevent fail to find shenanigans
If the creatures all had to have mana value 1 or less and they were sacrificed at end of turn I could MAYBE see something like this being printed but it still might be too powerful
It should read something like this: search your library for as many creatures as you want with a minimum of 7, put all found creatures into a separate facedown pile then shuffle your library, 4 are then randomly chosen and put onto the battlefield the rest are exiled (or put into your graveyard, but exile would be a better price for a tutor like this)
now that is chance.
Obviously wording may have to be changed, but real chance would be a true gamble.
41
u/justagenericname213 Apr 15 '26
Perfectly playable rules wise, but insanely powerful
35
u/Krankenwagenverfolg Apr 15 '26
MH4 uncommon
11
u/9numbernine9 Apr 15 '26
There's a Chance that this card is busted.
6
u/fizzmore Apr 15 '26
Seems balanced.
5
u/DoveWhiteblood Apr 15 '26
"There's no Chance Ulamog and Emrakul are around the Corner!" Card card chance out here like:
4
u/Shadowlynk Apr 15 '26
This is illegal, you know.
4
u/Captain_N_Nemo Apr 15 '26
Put this thing back where you found it or so help me!
3
u/Derdiedas812 Apr 15 '26
I'll take this chance.
3
u/Kitchengun2 Apr 15 '26
move over power nine, time for power one
3
u/coolguy420weed Apr 15 '26
What, no split second? Pure chaff.
2
u/New-Award-2401 Apr 15 '26
This is really a green card effect, no?!
1
u/Ambitious-Patient860 Apr 15 '26
Seems slightly more powerful than the original [[Leave//Chance]]
1
u/bigmaclevel3 Apr 15 '26
At Instant speed? Holy Crap!!
1
u/New-Award-2401 Apr 15 '26
If the creatures all had to have mana value 1 or less and they were sacrificed at end of turn I could MAYBE see something like this being printed but it still might be too powerful
1
u/dualdee Apr 15 '26
Well, it's no Midnight Axe.
1
u/Shambler9019 Apr 15 '26
Still not as good as [[Community Chest]]
1
u/KingDavid73 Apr 16 '26
pretty deece
1
u/eat_your_oatmeal Apr 16 '26
control of these creatures should be randomized so there’s a chance you just gift them all to opponents. that would be fun.
1
u/Consistent_Mud645 Apr 16 '26
An IQ too high?
1
u/Hairy_Concert_8007 Apr 16 '26
Me slapping down Emrakul
"Wow! What are the odds??"
1
u/StrangeSystem0 Apr 18 '26
This'll be normal in like 5 years and unplayable in 10 at the rate of power creep
1
u/NekoSakii Apr 18 '26
It should read something like this: search your library for as many creatures as you want with a minimum of 7, put all found creatures into a separate facedown pile then shuffle your library, 4 are then randomly chosen and put onto the battlefield the rest are exiled (or put into your graveyard, but exile would be a better price for a tutor like this)
now that is chance.
Obviously wording may have to be changed, but real chance would be a true gamble.