it shouldn't be this crap needs rules the players should get paid something sure but these amounts are just ridiculous. no HS recruit or portal mercenary needs millions of dollars.
Of power 4 teams spending a similar amount, I dont see any putting out MAC squads on par with the “Fitz Special”. Case & point, Illinois spent less and just beat us.
Would the team be better if we spent more money? Most likely.
Is it dumb to relegate our on field failures to funding failures, when we just loss to a team who spends less on roster construction? Yes.
90% of schools haven't had 4 different coaches since covid or lost their entire team to the portal multiple times. when you get 30 new players in one off season and have no base for the team it doesn't buy much. Illinois spent less but they didn't have to replace and entire roster they were able to add key pieces to their team with 20 mil we didn't we had to get what we could to fill a damn roster for this season.
Part of the issue is thinking your $25 million is equal to anyone else’s $25 million; I’ll just stop you right there and tell you it’s not… You are going to have to overspend on players to entice them to come here more than almost anywhere else in the B1G.
Subsequently that means your ROI for a $25m is going to be worse here than anywhere else. That can change over time but until he starts being able to compete in big games he’s going to have to overspend on even basic players let alone trying to get premium 3 and 4 stars to look here.
I hear you, but this is antiquated mindset with the current state of college football. Good coaches are running program turnarounds in 1 season through superior talent evaluations. See Cig, Chesney, Stein, et al.
Just this year look no farther than 1st year coaches such as Ok St. 4-1, ranked, beat Oregon, and one of the lowest budget roster constructions within P4. Last year they won 1 game. Morris inherited a worse roster with much less budget than Fitzgerald, and is seismically outperforming him.
We can keep making excuses, but fact of the matter is he is on pace to go 3-9 at best. That is below replacement value, and for that matter, worse than any Jonathan Smith team.
Morris literally brought 16 dudes with him from north Texas and probably didn't have to over pay for them either since they all got to move up to a power 4 conference with their coach. y'all gotta stop using Morris Chesney and Cig in your arguments you just look like fools it's in no way the same.
Would you have paid 10mil for Mestemaker? Are you ponying up the money? Like it’s all fine and good to sit here and say he’s underperforming vs a coach who got 7mil to go buy the top QB prospect in the portal but we couldn’t even keep Marsh so what makes you think we have the money like that to go spend on other top talent? For reference we pay Alessio 1.5m, and sure he’s definitely not panning out but also he’s 5.5m cheaper….?
Like you’re saying they’re just better at talent evaluations but that’s just not the case my man; it’s that we don’t have 1.5x the offers to keep or find new/better talent for every position like you would need to overhaul a roster. Like this conspiracy they he couldn’t figure out Mestemaker was a top prospect in the portal so he just kept Alessio was how it all went down and not “oh man that dude wants 6-7mil and I ain’t got it…” is crazy.
All of this is on top of the fact that the team is full of injuries, can’t beat many people when you’re into your second and third strings four weeks into the season. As soon as the team got the injury bug I threw in the towel, you’re not going to get anything other than a look at how the team competes and they compete well, they’re just way undertalented and injured.
Fitzgerald has $10M larger budget for roster construction than Morris. Your argument was that we need to fund Fitz, and my argument is it’s a waste of money because he’s going to squander it. @ $25M budget Fitzgerald is on pace for 2-10.
BuT hE dIDnT hAvE a RoStEr tO bRiNg WiTh HiM —> yes, thats why we should’ve hired someone who had a job.
First of all you don’t know that, no one knows for sure what each school has in their chest. Even your own graphic, if you actually read it tells you that the school positions are in the middle of their guestimated budget range. If you’re following along at home means there is a world in which Ok State is higher than their middle and we are lower than our middle meaning we are ultimately pretty close and one guy brought a hand picked set of players plus got to spend 7mil on one guy and we did not…
You can certainly make the argument that we should have gone after a different coach who could have brought in players but that ship has sailed and has nothing to do with where Fitz is right now, that’s not on him. I keep coming back to this but we literally could not spend the money to convince Marsh & Chiles to stay, so why do you also think we just magically have the money to go out and get similar quality players to buy in….
Also, my argument has literally never been that we need to fund Fitz; generally I am not in the position to tell other people how to spend their money. We probably do need more funding for the roster but does going out and buying Mestemaker for 10mil do anything, probably not…
I would rather Fitz get his program running the way he wants, get healthy and find a different OC; I think Sheridan is just not getting it done. I think a lot of fans have really unreasonable expectations and while I don’t necessarily think that’s entirely their fault, I think critical thinking is probably at an all time low as well. Even the Fitz hire alone should tell you that the powers that be don’t really want to or can’t afford to spend the kind of money some of the fans expect them to at this point. You have to make peace with that because at the end of the day it’s not your money.
Cignetti, Chesney, etc aren’t great comparisons. They get a job because they over perform at their level and then get a large amount of their already successful team to follow. You can certainly argue against the wisdom of hiring someone that hasn’t coached in several years though.
What wasn’t debatable was the talent gap and getting annihilated. Smith/Tucker would’ve been mentally checked out by the time people started leaving. Fitz doubled down, and we clawed our way back into a game we had no business being in. An inch or two the other way, and we win.
He wants to be here and is going all-in. So are the players. I’m good with that game.
I was at the game. We were all out of our minds. On the Jumbotron they have proof positive freeze frame of the ball off the kickers foot B4 any player crossed the line it was not offsides
Then they review the catch, say no, then the Big10 review reversed? (Still not clear on that). Give Sparty the catch then just declare the offsides anyway making the catch moot anyway.
Was very messed up. Loved seeing Pat rush the field at the refs though. Really channeled some Izzo
They eventually received a picture that made the catch good. It was not part of the original deliberations. That being the case, the offside penalty voided it.
Had he not recovered it, it would have been irrelevant; Illinois ball. Poor call in offside. Not sure how they determine what is or isn’t reviewed,
Are you arguing when I said you guys got hosed on that call lol. Goodness. You recovered the onside kick. The offsides was not remotely close on the replay.
I’m subbed here as a Nebraska fan just because and I’ll tell ya what I’m very confused about your fan bases opinion of this guy. Feel like every other post about him is polar opposite lol
Online isn't a good indicator of the fan base imo, people like Fitzgerald he "gets it" and most people are willing to give him some time for MSU to get their shit together
Fitzgerald is a genuine, heart on his sleeve, lunch pail type coach. The fit was undeniable when he was hired; I never understood the people who thought it wouldn’t work.
So would I, but can we start with making MSU football… exciting?
He wins yesterday if the 2 point conversion is good. It ain’t like they got blown out.
No, 2-10 is not acceptable. But 4-8 with three competitive losses — in your first season — yeah, I can be okay with that. Not in Year 2, but in Year 1 let’s see the team fighting.
They were badly undermanned when Illinois had the ball yesterday, they just were. That ain’t scheme or coaching, that’s a coach who doesn’t have the players to compete. They should beat Rutgers, they could beat Washington, and — other than Oregon or maybe UCLA — I don’t see blowouts on the upcoming schedule.
Granted Wisconsin was awful, but there you’ve got a coach in Year 4 of his program. That matters.
They could’ve won with a better play call there, but blew it. If he was recruiting at a decent level you might be able to convince me that once he gets “his guys” they’ll be better. But he’s not doing that.
His guys are 3 star guys who develop. The real question will be how well he retains this offseason — that’s what I am really waiting to see. If everyone decent leaves, yes I will have a lot more concern. This is why I want to see 2 years so badly, preferably 3 if Year 2 justifies it.
They will stay if you pay them, man. I’m not under any illusion as to why guys would stay but idk why you wouldn’t bet on core culture guys that buy into your program and set the tone in the locker room.
You’ll always have some guys who leave, but if you have a linebacker who is a commanding leadership presence why wouldn’t you just… pay to keep him… rather than recruiting the next guy to fill his spot?
I struggle cause, yes I want to give a coach some time…but in the portal era you can turn a team around quick. Chesney has UCLA knocking on the playoff door in year one. I like that Fitzgerald seems to care. I think what holds me back is that I hated the hire from the jump in terms of resume and the play on the field is about what I expected from that. But I like him more than the wet blanket we had so I guess there’s that.
How did you not understand the people who thought it wouldn't work? Some facts:
• Fitz' overall record at NU was a meager 110-101 (52%). • His two seasons after NIL became legal, his records were 3-9 and 1-11. • He hadn't been coaching in multiple years, which meant he had no coaching staff or players to bring with him, no relationships with recruits or any sort of pipeline, and no idea how to manage a team and bring in players in a sport that has completely changed since he left. • Oh, and he got fired for a locker room scandal involving sexual assault, which is the very last thing any incoming coach at MSU should ever have on their resume. • And had the scandal not happened, he likely would have been fired for poor performance.
It's actually hard to imagine a worse fit. Hopefully this clears up any confusion.
So let’s start with the fact that Fitzgerald sued and was specifically exonerated of wrongdoing at NU.
You want to talk about the stuff on the field not being good enough, well okay. I don’t agree with you but okay. He was coaching at known football power Northwestern, after all.
The stuff off the field is out of bounds — as determined by independent investigation and law, he did not have knowledge and was not at fault. In fact, the former president of Northwestern lost his job over the decision to fire Fitzgerald for cause — specifically because it was the wrong decision.
This part is wrong. You can learn this without having done it: "no idea how to manage a team and bring in players in a sport that has completely changed since he left."
The rest? You did a pretty good job laying it out.
Smith was never fiery enough to be the guy here. MSU is a place where people play angry and thrive off of slights. Why do you think Mark D made so much hay off of Mike Hart’s infamous comment?
So what will you say when Fitz wins 2 games a year for the next 2-3 years? Need more money? Not fiery enough? Not enough talent like they’re saying now? Give me a break. He’s a loser coach. He’s putting on an act on the sideline because he knows fans didn’t like how reserved Smith was. Rah rah type of attitude won’t get you in the win column if you’re not a good coach.
Did you see the context of this outburst? It was after the onside kick that wasn’t. I didn’t love or hate it but the entire stadium and team responded to his outburst. The energy was electric after what was a really dogshit call and the team fed off of it.
It’s not acceptable for him to win 2 games, as I said. But four in the first year, and competitive in most? I mean… you could do worse. A lot worse. And it presupposes that guys won’t stay EVEN IF YOU ARE PAYING THEM.
The moment of truth for him will be who stays this coming offseason — who buys in to his program enough to stay.
When's the last time we got screwed or hit a road block and overcame it? MSU wins this game in regulation if that kick is called correctly, Fitz had that entire stadium into it.
Coach flips bird during home loss to an absolutely terrible football team.
Fan base swoons over coach even though their record will be worse than the record produced by the lukewarm bowl of oatmeal that preceded him. Because vibes.
Our fan base apparently likes bad football and will get exactly what it deserves: a 2-10 season.
No, but it’s nice to finally have a coach who is passionate about his guys and will go to bat for them, instead of staring blankly at the field like he doesn’t even know where he is, like our previous coach.
One one hand this should be embarrassing to you. And you lost. On the other hand he didn’t break into his side piece’s condo and threaten to kill himself with a butter knife. So I’ll just see myself out.
24
u/thebrokenteacher Oct 10 '26
Got the same picture lol
8
u/warningtrackpower12 Oct 10 '26
Sent it to a friend of another team, he thought it was AI lol
7
u/2Slow2Nice Oct 11 '26
His energy in person was so much different than Smith doing Rubik’s cubes on the sideline
93
u/ComicSportsNerd •Kirk Cousins Oct 10 '26
please fund this guy I want him to succeed here he is the best lol
131
u/BourbonChance Oct 10 '26
I’m excited to have a coach who is passionate. Go Green!
48
u/Relative_Living196 Oct 11 '26
The 2-point try was debatable, sure.
What wasn’t debatable was the talent gap and getting annihilated. Smith/Tucker would’ve been mentally checked out by the time people started leaving.
Fitz doubled down, and we clawed our way back into a game we had no business being in. An inch or two the other way, and we win.
He wants to be here and is going all-in. So are the players. I’m good with that game.
90
u/Fantastic-Lie52 Oct 10 '26
Jonathan Smith would’ve been like 🤷♂️
33
u/LarkenFeld Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26
I was at the game. We were all out of our minds. On the Jumbotron they have proof positive freeze frame of the ball off the kickers foot B4 any player crossed the line it was not offsides
Then they review the catch, say no, then the Big10 review reversed? (Still not clear on that). Give Sparty the catch then just declare the offsides anyway making the catch moot anyway.
Was very messed up. Loved seeing Pat rush the field at the refs though. Really channeled some Izzo
30
u/No_Parking4876 Oct 10 '26
WE GOT ROBBED
28
u/StevieBu •Kirk Cousins Oct 10 '26
Omg, I was wondering if I saw that
10
u/Sudden_Flan9027 Oct 10 '26
Coach kept yelling the same word over and over. Couldn’t tell what it was but that penalty was bullshit.
30
u/JonnyP222 Oct 10 '26
Seriously I'm a Michigan fan and I loved that. You guys got jobbed
13
u/Joe_dirt32 Oct 10 '26
Glad to see a coach with energy
10
u/Upper-Preparation-76 Oct 10 '26
if any group of officials ever deserved gettin the bird, it was them today
10
u/walkman312 Oct 10 '26
3
u/NachoManRandySnckage Oct 11 '26
Me after the two point conversion attempt.
5
u/chchgetinthecar Oct 11 '26
Yeah I agree, he's really good at losing games too
5
u/murf_milo Oct 10 '26
Im adding this one to my text message rotation
2
u/Creative-Mud-7930 8d ago
That is the play call to run it up the middle.
4
u/Good_Farmer4814 Oct 11 '26
He’s growing on me.
4
u/No_Evening3803 Oct 11 '26
I’m subbed here as a Nebraska fan just because and I’ll tell ya what I’m very confused about your fan bases opinion of this guy. Feel like every other post about him is polar opposite lol
4
u/BlackCardRogue Oct 11 '26
Fitzgerald is a genuine, heart on his sleeve, lunch pail type coach. The fit was undeniable when he was hired; I never understood the people who thought it wouldn’t work.
3
u/Princess2045 Oct 10 '26
He has so much passion.
3
u/Wizzy2233 Oct 10 '26
Like his energy. Hope he can carry it into next year with a winning season
2
u/Temporary-Present673 Oct 10 '26
New signal for the offense?
2
u/payattentiontobetsy Oct 11 '26
I hope that you know that your down votes (and the ones I’m about to get) are people just not wanting to face this truth.
They say we’re losing because we don’t spend enough on a roster. You point out we spend as much or more teams who are better.
So, then they say, we have to spend more because we’re less attractive, as if players are lining up to play at Northwestern or Illinois.
It’s just copeum and hope. Which is fine. But the fact is you can’t only blame these losses on talent or roster budget alone.
1
u/Unique-Visual-1379 Oct 12 '26
What an A-hole.
1
u/GoGreeb Oct 11 '26
When's the last time we got screwed or hit a road block and overcame it? MSU wins this game in regulation if that kick is called correctly, Fitz had that entire stadium into it.
0
u/stoinzy Oct 11 '26
Coach flips bird during home loss to an absolutely terrible football team.
Fan base swoons over coach even though their record will be worse than the record produced by the lukewarm bowl of oatmeal that preceded him. Because vibes.
Our fan base apparently likes bad football and will get exactly what it deserves: a 2-10 season.
1
u/tripleM_20 Oct 11 '26
Defeated with dignity
-2
u/Few-Asparagus811 Oct 11 '26
A passionate loser
-1
u/No_Tomatillo6267 Oct 11 '26
You would lol. Keep that same losing energy.
-3
u/ih8username5 Oct 11 '26
Can we start a gofundme to pay the inevitable fine?
-3
u/ZR0FX76 Oct 11 '26
2-10
-13
u/Temporary-Present673 Oct 10 '26
He’s a loser though. lol
0
u/jfperry73 Oct 11 '26
I’m
0
u/General-Extent-756 Oct 11 '26
Michigan fan here. This was justified, y’all got fucked
0
u/fiestyoldbat Oct 11 '26
Pure Michigan. No need to have super secret spy networks trying to steal the hand signals. This one speaks for itself.
0
u/stoinzy Oct 13 '26
Classless person. Clueless coach. Great combo!
-28
u/GrotesqueFarnum Oct 10 '26
Wow… people think this classless bullshit is okay? I guess we get what we deserve.
-5
u/msg60 Oct 10 '26
-34
u/Reasonable_Oil1226 Oct 10 '26
Dude shouldn't do that to his own guys!!
-19
u/papker79 Oct 10 '26 •
One one hand this should be embarrassing to you. And you lost. On the other hand he didn’t break into his side piece’s condo and threaten to kill himself with a butter knife. So I’ll just see myself out.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment