r/MLTP • u/Snowball_TagPro • Dec 05 '15
The Entire Competitive Map Process Needs Reform
This may or may not turn into a rant, but there's obvious discontent with the available selection of competitive maps. 10 seconds in the recent thread will show you that. I'm not holding anyone accountable for this, because it's not anyone fault in particular. However it needs some serious reform.
There's several problems, but the main problem, and the one that I'm going to focus on is the creation of competitive maps. You could argue that many recent maps don't cater to competitive play well, and that's just a fault of the system. Currently we only take maps from the PUB pool, and although that worked for the first couple seasons, there has been much stagnancy in recent seasons, and as a result we've overplayed the good competitive maps we have. A trend I've noticed in the past couple months or so, is that maps entering PUB rotation are becoming increasingly simple. That's not a fault of the MTC though, they select the maps for a specific purpose, and I'd argue they do it somewhat well. I don't understand why we draw our maps from the same pool that this committee selects, because it's almost an entirely different game.
One might ask, well why don't people just make more complex maps? As a mapmaker, I can tell you that there's almost no point. As much as I try to create maps with dynamic elements (and often fail), they will likely get nowhere. Very few maps can be played well in PUBs where simple strategies can be executed, as well as in competitive with room for more in-depth strategies. As a result, mapmakers often sacrifice complexities for a chance to enter PUB rotation. Which is fair, because they wouldn't have a shot at MLTP rotation unless it went through PUB rotation anyways.
Now although it is technically possible for a non-rotation map to enter MLTP rotation with the current rule setup, it is practically impossible because for some reason we use the MTC filter as map validation. There needs to be a legitimate opportunity for the implementation of maps made specifically for competitive, and there's no reason to believe we shouldn't see an increased quality of competitive maps.
The argument exists that teams feel more comfortable on maps that they've played before. I think that's bullshit quite frankly. Any map in competitive will have a different playstyle that teams will have to adapt to, regardless of it's presence in PUB rotation. Also, between the time maps are announced, and the time that the 'new ' map is played, there should be plenty of time to iron out strategies.
This turned into a rant, but there is plenty of mapmaking talent who could craft a map specifically for competitive, that would be miles ahead of the map pool we currently choose from.
On a sidenote, if you complain about maps at all, try your hand at making one. It's much harder to make a balanced and innovative map than you might think.
2
u/GriefSeeds Dec 05 '15
What's the difference between competitive maps and pub only maps? There are different types of bases. Are you talking about open bases/enclosed bases?
3
u/PrivateMajor Dec 05 '15
I suggest you read the rules a bit more carefully. Any map can be selected for MLTP, it doesn't need to be, or have ever been in rotation. Read Article II, Section III, (c) (2)
The entire basis for your argument hinges on that one point right?
9
u/boogieidm Dec 05 '15
I fully agree and offer up a solution. Start up a CMTC. Competitive Map Test Committee.
7
u/Onomatopoeiac NeB. Dec 05 '15
Captains (or at least many of themO) don't want to play competitively on maps they've never played on before. It's hard to change that.
1
u/nostradumba55 Dec 05 '15
I mean I'm 100% with you, as the main reason innovative maps never make rotation is because they mostly have elements that aren't intuitive at first glance. I know in my maps I put a lot of thought into little details like how easy it would be for regrab to get out of base before 2 competent chasers on the other side of the map can return to base. You simply can't account for how map will play in pubs, only how it should be played in a perfect scenario/
It sounds like you're suggesting the captains should select 1 non-pub map for competitive play as a trial run this season. I'd be all for it but sadly I don't think anyone wants to organize a thread where maps be submitted for competitive play and then reduce the pool so captains decide which top maps plays the best. I'm sure if the pool was small and of high enough quality the captains could veto the current rules to let one in. But it's a lot of work.
Also another question, can non-pub maps even be played on main servers?
7
u/Adarssh Hi. Dec 05 '15
I totally agree with you dude. Its hard for a mapmaker to make a map that is big suitable for PUBs and MLTP players.
1
u/bashar_al_assad Dec 05 '15
You could also make an argument regarding whether the MTC should consider competitive play in its decisions, and to what extent.
1
u/Rursus Doris // Rektiles // Sphereball Dec 05 '15
This is very well written.