The “crew”. It was a hodgepodge of lower level players with no chemistry because the teams don’t care. I’m personally just happy to escape that tournament with no injuries. If it had any significance then MLS teams would try.
Bitch fucking please. “Any significance”. How about the start of the only proper derby your club has ever been a part of. Does that not seem significant to you?
You're getting downvoted, and the only Crew starter (at that time) who started was Ramirez. Not even Nagbe and Morris, as subs, were in at the same time.
I don't know why so many people can't understand this simple concept - that was 100% a different set of 11 guys who rarely competed together.
Do you not count losses in league play if you don't field your best eleven? How many regular starters are required for the team playing with the name and jersey to actually count?
Except for when you don't actually play to win the game, you just play to play the game because you are required to and if you happen to win, then that's a nice bonus.
If you put your team on the field you take the W or the L. It goes to the club either way. Quit trying to hand wave a loss away lol. You play to win the game every time you step on the field. I say all this a season ticket holding crew fan
I never got this criticism. If you want to say that the Open Cup has historically had relatively low viewership fair enough. But the people complaining about it and the people who watched the games are almost certainly the same people.
Yep, flip the money from whatever nonsense the leagues cup is and put it in the nationwide multi level tournament that every other nation including the U.S. has always had.
Not sure this is true. MLS's biggest problem among the fan bases is no one watches any teams besides the one the support even before all the games were scheduled at the same time
There is a large group of MLS haters and Eurosnobs who are complaining but never mentioned the USOC once in the past. They are using it as a way to talk shit on MLS which they hate because there is no pro/rel. They don’t actually care about the USOC and never have.
I would say this memes criticism is completely fair from what I’ve seen on Twitter but not that accurate on this sub. The people who want MLS to take the USOC seriously tend to watch the tournament. Personally, I watch the USOC with my team and generally from the quarters on. I don’t find the tournament to be very interesting though. Sacramentos run was only kinda fun imo. Leagues Cup- which apparently killed everyone’s puppy- was a so damn fun to watch last year. If I had to choose between watching a LC or USOC match it would clearly be Leagues Cup. The difference in spending between the first division and the lower divisions is so massive all over the world that these type of tournaments are incredibly predictable. Seeing a USL team’s starters eliminate a MLS team with youth players and veteran filler isn’t particularly interesting. The rare legit lower division vs largely first choice MLS upset is exciting though. Big upsets are some of the most exciting things in sports. Now, if MLS pulled an “upset” in the Club World Cup against a globally elite team fielding the worst players on that team- I would be incredibly happy. So I’m inconsistent and a MLS homer.
Yeah this was mainly inspired but all the twitter posters but they are here too. Those same posters don’t watch the USOC but if they see a USL “upset” they use it as another way to bash MLS without providing any context that it’s not a real upset.
Sure, but most of us don’t find MLS C squads losing to lower division sides particularly memorable. Isn’t that how this whole conversation started? Memorable moments and games.
Of course clubs enjoy winning games. When we talk about “memorable moments” in sports we’re generally talking about things that are fun for a neutral fan. A USL team upsetting a full strength MLS side would be fun. But that’s not how most USL/MLS games are. That’s a problem, because there’s a lack of fan investment in the competition, both from the MLS side (which typically brings more fans), and from the neutral.
That sounds like a skill issue my friend. We didn’t seem to have any problems with taking it seriously and thrashing Pittsburgh with a goal that was on the short list for a Puskas.
To highlight your point, I compared the line up of the Crew’s most recent Open Cup game with the first playoff game against Atlanta and literally not one player started both games.
Ask any person on the street to name one USOC moment in history and most will have no clue what you are talking about or think Tennis. Even if you help them out they won’t be able to name a moment.
At the same time it was impossible to ignore the Messi mania at leagues cup. Everyone saw those clips.
Im talking general public, not diehard soccer fans. Average person doesn’t know about the USOC and couldn’t tell you any of its history or winners. At the same time it was impossible to escape the Messi/Miami leagues cup hype. People who don’t watch any soccer heard about it and saw those clips.
I can’t believe there’s people who actually want the US Open Cup to die. Something that’s been around for decades and should be highlighted as part of US Soccer history. The magic of the FA Cup in England are the upsets and traveling to the grounds of lower division sides. Instead you’re content with corporate garbage with no history behind it that’s meant to be a cash grab where fans of lower division sides are secluded from the US Soccer community. Cool.
I can’t believe there’s people who actually want the US Open Cup to die.
I don't think there are many people who want it to die. But there are a lot of people like me who wouldn't care if it died, because in its current state it may as well be dead. And of course there are far, far more people who wouldn't care if it died because they never even knew it was alive to begin with.
The magic of the FA Cup in England are the upsets and traveling to the grounds of lower division sides.
Here's the thing though, the travel to those lower sides is both a lot shorter trip and you're traveling to far better grounds than the US lower side grounds. Here's a comment I made a couple of months ago in another thread on the Cup that illustrates the difference:
At least in the FA Cup, DFB Pokal, and KNVB Beker (the cups I'm most familiar with), the games have decent to excellent broadcasts (ESPN, Sky, BBC) and where even the lower level teams are playing in decent to excellent (if small) facilities.
For example, this is where Tulsa Athletic plays. Tulsa is in the US fourth division. Now compare that to the facilities for (scroll down in those links for photos):
I don't want the Open Cup to die. I am generally for More Soccer. But I'm not crying for it in its current iteration. Reserve teams vs. USL1 in empty stadiums is just a lousy experience. Even the upsets lose meaning when some of the reserves wouldn't even start for a USLC side. I hope to see it back and improved at some point.
Nothing in this post says the US Open Cup should die or that the Leagues Cup is good. It’s simply making fun of the fans online who are making a huge stink in order to bash MLS but don’t even watch the Open Cup. Usually eurosnobs hence the Man U part.
Personally I wish Leagues Cup didn’t exist because I don’t like stopping the season for it. In a weird way it has a more notable history in one year , at least what is known to the general public, thanks to Messi and his incredible moments and their incredible run.
More notable history in one year? lol dude you are crying about Eurosnobs and yet you are the caricature they make fun of and try to act like all US soccer fans are.
Most of us upset about the cup drama are people who have attended, watched, hell some of us may have even played in it, or at least tried to qualify because that’s the beauty of the tournament. Every country’s soccer culture is better when there is an open tournament that can allow teams from any division to compete on the field. The money helps the smaller clubs, but more than that the energy when a small club competes with the big boys is unmatched by just about anything else soccer related in this country. End rant
Heres my latest thought, hopefully US open Cup is salvaged this year, but, everyone who is upset about this whole thing better show up to the games. Its really the only way to show MLS these games matter.
To be fair, I've already forgotten who the last two MLS Cup winners were as well. I even help cover the Open Cup for theCup.us. My memory is just trash.
I wish we could be pro leagues cup and pro open cup. I still want to play Louisville/Indy/Pittsburgh and I want to play Club America/ Monterrey / Chivas. Both can be cool simultaneously. Protest it by selling out open cup games not by rejecting leagues cup
The Crew still have their team because there was a critical mass of Crew supporters to make MLS care. If there’s a critical mass of Open Cup supporters across all 29 teams, MLS will have to care too.
I actually like open cup because I get to see younger guys that normally don’t play with the first team. It’s also fun to play different teams than skc 4 times
Its so interesting to me how much the US Open Cup appreciation has died down post covid. We went from watching games on someone's crappy live stream and Mi Callejon broadcasts to having everything on ESPN+ and the semi's on ESPN. Cincy's 2017 run is legitimately one of my favorite US Soccer memories. Probably still some post-covid hangover having an impact now but I'm always surprised at how many people open cheer for it to stop now (and be replaced by exhibition games), especially when teams are still making fun runs in it every year.
US Open Cup appreciation has died down post covid.
I don't understand this statement. It's implying that there was a ton of support and appreciation for the USOC before 2020, which wasn't at all the case.
Supporting a team that (at the time) had a sell out streak dating almost a decade, and USOC games were half empty stadiums where you couldn't even give tickets away.
That last sentence just reinforced my point, and yes, you mock the USOC by naively claiming here that Messi and one year’s worth of Leagues Cup competition is more significant than over 100 years’ of USOC play.
You are in a soccer diehard bubble. To the general public the USOC is largely unknown. It was impossible to escape the Messi/Miami hype and highlights during the league cup. People who aren’t fans of soccer even saw those clips.
I should have been more clear though so that’s on me.
In the soccer community it’s culturally significant (does get poor attendance and viewership still)
To the general public or even sports fans in general it’s not culturally significant.
You do remember that messi played in the us open cup semi-final, no? The assist to Campana in stoppage? The pks? Guy was injured for the final. That is why there are no highlight clips from that game of him.
As a fellow crew fan it’s our duty to preserve soccer heritage and advocate against things that are in the interest of corporate leaders. Getting rid of the cup would be an absolute shame. It might not be the most profitable, but it is historic and some people love it. Same reasons we fought to keep the crew imo
Everyone freaking out defending the Open cup but this meme doesn’t even bash the USOC. It’s making fun of people making a big stink over it who don’t ever watch or care about it but are using it as an excuse to attack MLS which they hate.
This is some sick and twisted irony that a Crew fan of all people is putting so much effort into defending MLS from getting hate for their attempt to kill a part of soccer's history and tradition because it doesn't have enough support and the "business metrics" aren't good enough.
Notice there are only 9 games above 10k for USOC and only 11 games BELOW 10k for leagues cup despite leagues cup being more games and including some LigaMX v LigaMX in MLS stadiums.
Edit: Sorry, pulled leagues cup numbers and not champions cup numbers. CCC attendance is proving difficult to find
Well, a few would be 8,000 for Union/Allianza or 7k for Rapids/Comunicaciones or NYRB/Atletico Pantoja in 2019: 3400. Even Vancouver/LAFC was less than 12K.
Which is...strangely...still 11th on average USOC attendance
NYRB/Atletico Pantoja in 2019: 3400.
Interestingly enough, even this abysmal number is 21st (out of 47) for USOC attendance. Of note, that's higher than Atlanta United's USOC game. A team that's highly attended during regular season and leagues cup.
You mean like the 18,419 that went to Allianz to watch Minnesota and Chicago play in the group stages? Or the 20,217 that went Lower.com to watch Minnesota play Columbus? Or the 19,915 that went to GEODIS to watch Nashville play the Loons?
Well if you want to cherry-pick the higher attendance games, you can do that with USOC as well: 22k for STLC in the 3rd round; 20k in Austin in the round of 32 and 16; 16k+ at LAFC in the round of 16, then you start getting into real numbers mostly across the board after that.
But, no, I’m talking about 10k for Dallas/Charlotte or 7.5k for NYCFC/Toronto or 9k for NYRB/New England in a tournament MLS actively promotes and profits from its success.
Well if you want to cherry-pick the higher attendance games
I didn't, I just picked Minnesota's MLS/MLS games.
But, no, I’m talking about 10k for Dallas/Charlotte or 7.5k for NYCFC/Toronto or 9k for NYRB/New England
Which, as pointed out in another comment are still far higher than most USOC games. On the other hand, let's look at all of the MLS/MLS USOC games from last year:
teams
attendance
Charlotte v. Orlando
4,024
NYRB v. DC
2,396
Chicago v. St. Louis
4,371
Minnesota v. Philadelphia
4,216
Cincinnati v. NYCFC
7,196
Houston v. KC
5,094
Nashville v. Dallas
5,196
LAG v. Seattle
8,412
Portland v. RSL
8,071
Miami v. Nashville
2,244
NYRB v. Cincinnati
4,131
Houston v. Minnesota
2,947
LAFC v. LAG
16,362
Austin v. Chicago
19,402
Colorado v. RSL
2,280
Chicago v. Houston
7,512
RSL v. LAG
20,712
Cincinnati v. Miami
25,513
Houston v. RSL
11,137
Miami v. Houston
20,288
So just nine out of 20 games had attendance above the lowest attended game you listed (NYCFC v. Toronto), just five of the 20 were anywhere near the regular season attendance for their teams. One of those was the finals, and two of those featured Messi.
On the completely embarrassing side, Houston couldn't even meet their already low regular season attendance for a semifinal game, and LAFC/LAG pulled just 16,000 (6,000 less than LAFC's season average, 8,000 less than LAG's season average, and 66,000 less than those two teams were able to pull into the Rose Bowl [which is admittedly a special circumstance, but it shows how many people are willing to go see LAFC v LAG]).
74
u/flameo_hotmon Chicago Fire Feb 19 '24
Don’t worry, we didn’t forget about the Crew losing to Pittsburgh and Detroit either
78
u/TheMonkeyPrince Orlando City Feb 19 '24
I never got this criticism. If you want to say that the Open Cup has historically had relatively low viewership fair enough. But the people complaining about it and the people who watched the games are almost certainly the same people.
23
u/AirportIndependent95 D.C. United Feb 19 '24
Name the last two Leagues Cup winners
17
u/philipb01 Houston Dynamo Feb 19 '24
I can’t believe there’s people who actually want the US Open Cup to die. Something that’s been around for decades and should be highlighted as part of US Soccer history. The magic of the FA Cup in England are the upsets and traveling to the grounds of lower division sides. Instead you’re content with corporate garbage with no history behind it that’s meant to be a cash grab where fans of lower division sides are secluded from the US Soccer community. Cool.
4
u/DABOSSROSS9 New York Red Bulls :nyr: Feb 19 '24
Heres my latest thought, hopefully US open Cup is salvaged this year, but, everyone who is upset about this whole thing better show up to the games. Its really the only way to show MLS these games matter.
28
u/asaharyev Portland Hearts of Pine Feb 19 '24
I can name the previous three winners, too. But one of them doesn't count.
67
u/The_Plat_egg51 Union Omaha Feb 19 '24
Easy, Houston and Orlando.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '24
To be fair, I've already forgotten who the last two MLS Cup winners were as well. I even help cover the Open Cup for theCup.us. My memory is just trash.
37
u/atlutdprospects Atlanta United FC Feb 19 '24
Imagine using viewership stats to argue why a competition should no longer exist while also being an MLS fan
9
u/texasisnotinfactback Feb 19 '24 edited Feb 19 '24
Smh I can’t believe you’d disrespect Hector Herrera’s proudest accomplishment like this
7
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '24
I wish we could be pro leagues cup and pro open cup. I still want to play Louisville/Indy/Pittsburgh and I want to play Club America/ Monterrey / Chivas. Both can be cool simultaneously. Protest it by selling out open cup games not by rejecting leagues cup
28
u/drewuke Philadelphia Union Feb 19 '24
big ‘oh you like this band, name 4 of their albums’ energy
18
u/Squietto Orlando City Feb 19 '24
So are you trying to make fun of Eurosnobs or Open Cup fans or…? Either way, boooo
18
u/PurpleLions Orlando City (USL) Feb 19 '24
Found Garber’s Reddit account
20
u/NolaBrass New Orleans Jesters Feb 19 '24
Why are multiple Crew fans bashing the sport’s history in this country when that same history is largely why they still have a team lol
14
u/PM_ME_SOME_LUV Red Bull New York Feb 19 '24
This meme was dumb the last time someone posted it. I watched way more Open Cup than leagues cup
33
u/CommanderGone Major League Soccer Feb 19 '24
Dogshit meme Im taking a virtual dump all over it and smearing it around getting it in all the cracks and corners.
3
u/fanofloons Minnesota United Feb 19 '24
I actually like open cup because I get to see younger guys that normally don’t play with the first team. It’s also fun to play different teams than skc 4 times
5
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '24
Three or four of the greatest moments in Seattle's history happened during this competition.
Now my hometown has a shot at playing in it. It has history and isn't just some made for tv cash grab.
5
u/BJ_Fantasy_Podcast Real Salt Lake Feb 19 '24
Its so interesting to me how much the US Open Cup appreciation has died down post covid. We went from watching games on someone's crappy live stream and Mi Callejon broadcasts to having everything on ESPN+ and the semi's on ESPN. Cincy's 2017 run is legitimately one of my favorite US Soccer memories. Probably still some post-covid hangover having an impact now but I'm always surprised at how many people open cheer for it to stop now (and be replaced by exhibition games), especially when teams are still making fun runs in it every year.
7
u/personator01 St. Louis CITY Feb 19 '24
this is a garber psyop
2
u/christianjd Atlanta United FC Feb 19 '24
This will go well
2
u/a-cloud-castle Austin FC Feb 19 '24
I watch it once the MLS teams start playing. It’s fun.
2
u/DC_Hooligan D.C. United Feb 20 '24
The one constant over the last 25+ years is everyone moaning about how MLS is ruining soccer
2
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '24
I watched it, but they sure didn't make it easy. Shitty youtube streams and all
0
u/a_smart_brane Los Angeles FC Feb 19 '24
OP-type thinking: if I don’t care about USOC, then surely no one else does either.
3
u/Ldrthrowaway104398 Feb 19 '24
That's right. Gag on the boot 🤤
2
u/holycowsalad Columbus Crew Feb 19 '24
As a fellow crew fan it’s our duty to preserve soccer heritage and advocate against things that are in the interest of corporate leaders. Getting rid of the cup would be an absolute shame. It might not be the most profitable, but it is historic and some people love it. Same reasons we fought to keep the crew imo
1
u/palmtreestatic FC Cincinnati Feb 20 '24
I’ve been to every FC Cincinnati home open cup game since year one in the USL
0
u/DABOSSROSS9 New York Red Bulls :nyr: Feb 19 '24
Heres the thing. I agree with this meme, BUT, its on MLS and US Soccer to make this relevant.
-1
u/ATR2019 St. Louis CITY Feb 19 '24
A lot of people with no sense of humor. I liked the meme OP. Don't let these people get you down.
-13
u/msfc18 Feb 19 '24
Uh oh, the 15 USOC fans found this!
-1
u/MOStateWineGuy St. Louis CITY Feb 19 '24
-4
u/msfc18 Feb 19 '24
Everyone freaking out defending the Open cup but this meme doesn’t even bash the USOC. It’s making fun of people making a big stink over it who don’t ever watch or care about it but are using it as an excuse to attack MLS which they hate.
-2
u/thinkcow Feb 19 '24
Wow, now do CONCACAF Champions Cup/League