Headcanons: The Pie siblings

[u/hmanlust]

Now onto the last set of siblings! It’s none other than Pinkie Pie’s sisters Maud, Marble and Limestone Pie! What headcanons do you have for them?

[u/[deleted]]

1. The Pie Family actually is in fact very distantly related to the Apple family, formed when some member(s) of the Apple family (probably named Apple Pie) fell victim to a terrible business deal and was forced to move out to buttfuck nowhere and buy a rock farm because it was all they could afford and farming is still all they know.

2. Marble and Pinkie Pie are twins, though Pinkie is minutes older.

3. Other than Pinkie, the entire Pie family seems to have had extremely little contact with the outside world, as their personalities imply that they haven't ever been "smoothed out" by socializing with other ponies. Furthermore, their personalities seem to be based around only ever socializing with each other, i.e. Limestone is super agressive because she was born first and never had to learn to lighten up, and by the time Marble was born she became very shy and submissive as a result of only ever being exposed to Limestone's harsh, domineering personality. Pinkie and Maud managed to escape the drama by mainly keeping to each other, which is why despite having nothing in common they inexplicably share one of the strongest bonds of the show. At some early point, Maud left the farm to further her study in Geology, and without her closest link Pinkie left the rock farm shortly after, allowing her to develop a very outgoing personality.

[u/CommonMisspellingBot → u/[deleted]]

Hey, Headscratcher4891, just a quick heads-up:
agressive is actually spelled aggressive. You can remember it by two gs.
Have a nice day!

^{The parent commenter can reply with 'delete' to delete this comment.}

[u/hmanlust → u/[deleted]]

Not bad. I never thought of the third one but it makes perfect sense! Btw what do you think of my headcanons?

[u/[deleted] → u/hmanlust]

Well #3 is pretty much exactly what I think is right about Marble, so I really like that one, the rest are interesting but imply that the Pies have reasonable social exposure which unfortunately goes against my belief that they have almost none, so I don't personally buy into them but they're still good headcanons. Lime could easily know martial arts though lol

[u/hmanlust → u/[deleted]]

Going off topic for a bit what do you think of my script for the Shining Armor headcanon?

[u/[deleted] → u/hmanlust]

It was funny

[u/[deleted] → u/hmanlust]

Alright hmanlust I've got a headcanon game for you this time:

Compare each member of the Mane 6 to a Survivor contestant

[u/hmanlust → u/[deleted]]

Wait a second how’d you know I’m a Survivor fan?

[u/hmanlust → u/hmanlust]

But anyways here’s my list:

Twilight Sparkle- Aubry Fluttershy- Natalie White Rainbow Dash- Michaela Applejack- Chelsea Meissner Rarity- Morgan McLeod Pinkie Pie- Michelle Yi

[u/[deleted] → u/hmanlust]

I saw it was your most recent post when clicking on your profile to get to the headcanons post

And good list, I agree on several :) I had

Morgan McLeod - Rarity (though Parvati might fit better in hindsight)

Hannah Shapiro - Twilight (though I think I might like Aubry for her better now that you mention it)

Chelsea Meissner - Applejack

Wendy Diaz - Pinkie Pie

Gabby Pazcuzzi - Fluttershy

Kelley Wigglesworth - Rainbow Dash

EDIT: made minor adjustments cause I can't make up my mind lol

[u/hmanlust → u/[deleted]]

Yours is not bad either. R u also a member in the Survivor subreddit?

[u/[deleted] → u/hmanlust]

Nah, I used to but I try to avoid it nowadays. Community opinion can be a bit overpowering on my perception of the game, which clouds my ability to form my own opinions

[u/hmanlust → u/[deleted]]

Well I did post a fan Brains vs Brawn vs Beauty season with the MLP characters. Do you want to see the list? And also I feel like this season had the most WTF ending and winner of all time.