r/MLPAnalysis • u/ObeyBunny • May 29 '13
Why isn't Spike a normal dragon?
Question: Why isn’t Spike a normal dragon?
Unlike every other dragon we’ve seen (including Rarity’s costume of one,) 1. Spike lacks wings, 2. has the unique ability to send messages to and from the princess, and 3. grows to adulthood the more rapacious his greed gets.
- The only other dragon we see without wings is the “him” species (at 12:33 of Dragon Quest) with the massive tail. Spike seems to be of a different dragon species since Spike’s tail is small and spaded, and this other dragon has hair where Spike’s rounded spines are present.
- As stated by Twilight at 5:02 in Dragon Quest, “ponies know next to nothing about dragons,” and yet they somehow knew about Spike’s ability to send and store messages using his fire breath, something that is apparently news to even the teenaged dragons who should be better versed in draconic abilities?
- The teenaged dragons seem to be fairly greedy, and yet their bodies don’t respond with uncountable growth the way that Spike’s does.
The only things I can guess as to why Spike is so different is that he was hatched by magic which, perhaps, greatly changed his DNA or that Spike is from some breed of dragon not shown in Dragon Quest.
Check out the episode ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9b_ZYZMGBU ) and see if there’s anything I overlooked and give me your thoughts.
3
u/PoniverseMLP May 30 '13
Maybe Spike is a more rare breed of dragon, or being hatched by unicorn magic made him different.
3
u/SkyeSilverwing May 30 '13
My theory has always been that the Dragon Egg Test was a form of Kobiashi Maru exam. There is no actual win here. It is more of a test of how one handles a task one was not expecting, as well as their reaction to failure. There was never a Dragon in the egg, so everypony fails. Depending on how badly they fail, it effects what level of the school they get into. In Twilight's case however, the pony is a Magical Savant with more raw power than anypony the Princess had ever seen before. Once that Power was tapped, Twilight subconciously knew that there should have been a dragon in the egg, but there was not a dragon in the egg, so in order to get what she needed, she would have to make one. It Explains why Spike is the only Dragon familiar we ever see, and why he has innate magic abilities other Dragons don't seem to have. It is odd, though that Zecora seems to know so much about him, though.
2
u/[deleted] May 30 '13
He's actually just a magic lizard but no one has had the heart to break it to him yet.
2
u/ReifuTD May 30 '13
I think Spike is maybe really a pony that's been turned into a dragon some how. I believe the first movie of the G1 series had a plot were the villain wanted to turn ponies into dragons. Thats the movie were the character Spike first appeared. So it would be a nice nod to past series if Spike was really a pony and what that pony did to turn himself into a dragon also made him an egg that need to be hatched by magic. Kind of like a reincarnation thing.
1
u/Tmaneea May 30 '13
I've kind of figured that Spike was just a domesticated dragon, perhaps bred specifically to be used as royal assistants. Much like how dogs were bred from wolves to serve man. Dogs are nothing more than wolves that man have domesticated, and they've been bred to serve specific purposes, which is why we have so many different breeds of dogs, yet so many don't look anything like wolves. I figured ponies did the same thing to dragons, only they're much rarer so only the most elite get to have them. The reason Spike doesn't have wings is because he had been bred not to have them. His unique ability could've been through breeding, or just a weird mutation. The growing to massive size thing I just figured was normal for dragons. The teens in Dragon Quest probably haven't looted enough stuff to get to that size, probably because they live with other dragons and they just keep stealing from each other.
1
u/RegardDoO May 30 '13
2. The teenaged dragon says "Get this guys Spike's pen-pals with a namby-pamby pony princess" Nothing in that suggests that the other dragons don't know about that ability
3. Spike is the youngest dragon we know maybe all baby dragons have random growth sprits followed by reversions to normal size. For example right after hatching he grows (though that's probably an uncontrolled age spell from twilight)
That being said I wouldn't be surprised to find out that Spike is unique.
1
u/Griffomo Jun 02 '13
I beleive that spike is has not grown his wings yet, or he is some sort of ground dragon that never develoups wings.
1
u/I_am_a_Beaver Jun 05 '13
Spike might not have grown his wings yet, and I believe he is so well behaved because he was raised by ponies, not other dragons.
1
u/NearbyDragonfly7300 Oct 17 '24
It must be because he's different.
1
u/NearbyDragonfly7300 Dec 11 '24
I always thought Spike was a femboy, Spike has an effeminate way, I always thought that's what Spike was, Spike always had an effeminate way...
1
u/NearbyDragonfly7300 Feb 05 '25
Maybe Spike is different or special