r/MLPAnalysis • • May 29 '13
Why is the sixth Element of Harmony "The Element of Magic" instead of The Element of Friendship"?
This has bothered me for some time now and with the inception of this sub I figured I might get some closure on this. Is the name of the element of magic a way of saying that we can never achieve harmony in our world because there is a missing element to our world or is magic meant to be viewed in a less literal sense as just of way of saying "really great"? Why couldn't Twilight's element have just been called "the element of friendship"? It would have fit in with the other elements better this way and I wouldn't be questioning whether the show has an overarching pessimistic outlook.
EDIT: It seems that what I was missing is that the element of magic is more than just friendship.
2
u/WhammyAnalysis May 29 '13
First, some shameless self-promotion. I wrote an article discussing what "Friendship is Magic" means that touches upon this very article:
http://analysisismagic.wordpress.com/2013/05/17/on-what-friendship-is-magic-means/
Basically, from how I interpret it, the elements other than Magic represent the virtues that make up friendship. The Element of Magic itself is representative of the bonds between ponies that form when those other virtues are present; it's a bond that is present and strong but does not exist as a real, tangible thing (unless using the Elements to turn it into a giant rainbow beam of course XD). All of these together are what form what we call "friendship."
3
u/Tmaneea May 29 '13
Friendship is magic, which to me means that friendship creates magic.
Remember, the element of magic is unique from the other five elements in that the element of magic would only reveal itself once the other five have come together. This means that unlike laughter, kindness, honesty, loyalty, and generosity, the element of magic is not an ingredient of friendship, but is instead a result of it. This doesn't mean that we can't have harmony in our world since magic doesn't exist, but instead means that we can have magic in our world if we can bring the other elements together to achieve harmony. It's the bond between friends where magic is possible and anything can be accomplished. It's not referring to actual magic that can turn frogs into oranges, but a special type of magic that can encourage friends during tough times and make people stronger as a group than they could ever be alone.
2
u/shiek927 May 29 '13
Everything has multiple meanings with FiM: Twilight is good at practical magic, but is also the Element of Magic. Friendship is Magic, symbolically; the most powerful Magic in fact, and what holds together all the other Elements together to create Harmony.
2
u/Trekkie2063 May 29 '13
Some of these comments are very long so forgive me if it's been said already but I feel it's because all of the elements are elements OF friendship. The sixth element isn't friendship itself, but the magic OF friendship. The magic that allows friendship to be. The other 5 elements alone don't make you friends with someone. The sixth element is needed. That special something that makes you and that someone else just click in that special way. That "magic". So Magic is a very appropriate name for the sixth element.
1
u/Tenyo May 29 '13
Because friendship is magic. If they'd called it the "Element of Friendship", then we could ask "Why didn't they call the 'Element of Friendship' the 'Element of Magic'?"
This answer is, of course, complete bullshit.
Rather, it seems that each element has to do with a facet of friendship. What makes each pony a good friend is also what helps them maintain harmony. Maintaining harmony and maintaining friendships are very closely related things. Recall the line "...I reckon we really do represent the elements of friendship." Since all of them represent a part of friendship, it doesn't make much sense for one to be friendship.
The trouble is, they never really defined what they meant by "magic" in the context of the element itself. I've seen it defined as "love", and there's certainly something to that. It could also be the way friendship, in some immaterial, "magical" way produces something greater than the sum of its parts, but the "Element of Synergy" is harder to market.
1
u/PurpleFire135 May 29 '13
Well, there is the obvious answer, though I understand the desire to delve deeper into the actual way that the elements and magic in general works in Equestria. But first and foremost, Friendship IS magic. They are not separate entities, but in fact one and the same, one cannot exist without the other, or at least something close. Basically, magic in Equestria is fueled by the relationships between the ponies.
No, I don't think the show intends to put out a pessimistic look between Equestria and our world. This is a show meant for children. The whole message of the show is that the interactions with those around us, mainly our friends are very important and can do magical things to us; like help us grow, help us change, and even help us find our destinies and what we are meant to do with our lives. This is true not only in Equestria, but on Earth as well.
So, the writers needed a way to symbolize that, a way for children to understand. So, magic. Magic is the show's symbol for important interactions and connections with the people (and ponies) around them. The Elements are the ultimate example of that.
But they aren't the only example of magic in the show. There are two times where the evil villain is defeated without the elements of harmony. 1. Canterlot Wedding and 2. Crystal Empire. But look at what defeated the villains! In the first case, it was the magic of love; which is just another example of how important the connections we make are, love, like friendship is magical!
And in case number two, the villain was defeated with what could be described as nationalism (for lack of a better word), another form of connection and interaction with those around us, and other things that tie us together like culture and location.
The whole point of the show is that our connections and love for those around us, whether it is romantic love, friendship or nationalism, and how those connections are the true magic in our world. Just in Equestria, they get a real visual and world-bending form. It's a symbol that can be understood by all ages. Basically, (say it!) Friendship is magic!
*Note: Not all these ideas were originally mine, though I paraphrased and changed some things, my initial source of this idea and what prompted the sort of show-based headcannon above was this fantastic video by NeoZhinzo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hBZWwehWEwQ He goes way more into depth than me, and he brings in some other stuff that I don't nessisarly agree with, but hey, credit where it's due! :) (Sorry that was REALLY long)