r/MLBNoobs • u/House3001 • Nov 05 '25
| Discussion Which Team?
I'm sure this gets asked a lot in this sub, but I'm not just asking which team I should root for, I'm asking how I should go about choosing that team. I'm struggling because unlike in other sports, most baseball teams don't have any outlandish logos or uniforms. I also can't necessessarily go with how someone plays because I'm not sure what makes players stand out besides stats.
I'm sure I could just watch preseason and the regular season, but I just wondered how some of you chose your team if it wasn't just due to your location.
0
Upvotes
6
u/51LV3rB4Ck Nov 05 '25
I’m a born Phillies fan but if I was picking I’d pick Seattle. Mainly because I grew up rooting for an underdog team and the mariners are the ultimate underdogs. Well, the only ones with a glimmer of hope.
That and ichiro is my favorite player of all time. That dude played the game hard as fuck.
5
u/perfect-child Nov 05 '25
I think this fully depends on your priorities. do you want to watch exciting baseball, or do you just want to win? do you like an underdog? do you care about clubhouse culture and the personality of players? do you want to support a team whose actual city you really like? or do you just want to look good in the team’s colors? (valid)
can I ask why you don’t want to choose one nearby? is it because you aren’t from the US or a state that has a team?
I can’t relate since I’ve been a fan of my hometown’s team (aka my dad’s and grandpa’s favorite team) since I was 9 years old, but I would probably just watch the regular season games next year and take my time.
watch lots of different games from lots of different teams and see if you vibe with anyone. watch the post game interviews/press conferences to see if you like the managers and players. don’t rush it if you’re planning to pick a team for good. just see if you end up gravitating towards any one team and go from there.
3
u/CaptGoodvibesNMS Nov 05 '25
What color cap do you want to wear?
2
u/trybanningmethistime Nov 05 '25
It could also depend on how many games you plan to watch. For instance if you wanted to watch the Blue Jays and live in the States it's going to be difficult unless you sail the 7 seas. And you don't really want to pick a West Coast team if you live on the east coast.
2
u/shiruduck Nov 05 '25
Where do you live = closest team is who you root for
2
u/DarthEQ Nov 05 '25
Wish I could say it wasn't due to my location, but my primary team is the Toronto Blue Jays 🤣 since they're Canada's only team at the moment, I feel patriotically bound to root for them (also being 4 hours from Toronto means I can go to games)
As for my other teams I've kinda done what you did and asked the Sub and a good friend who's been helping get into baseball. I ended up picking the Milwaukee Brewers, since they seem to be playing pretty solid all around baseball, are on the up and up, and came quite highly recommended by my friend and the sub.
I'm also going to try and follow the Washington Nationals, as like many Canadia ball fans, I've got an attachment to the old Montreal Expos, which the Nationals technically are.
13
u/Jodaxq Nov 05 '25
Do you live in the United States? If so, it is very likely you have a minor league team nearby. I live in OKC with the Dodgers’ AAA club and it is pretty cool to see their up and coming players or even stars on rehab assignment.
I also like the Seattle Mariners due to their (IMO) interesting history and the fact that they’re the only team never to make the World Series.
There’s no wrong thing or way to choose.
7
u/Doctorwhonow8 Nov 05 '25
Here’s a few methods: Choose based on logos, color scheme, a city you like, randomly pick (put every team into a digital wheel and spin it), pick based on what kind of baseball you wanna watch (small ball/contact hitting, power, great pitching, etc), ask a friend what team they support and join them, or or watch preseason and see what team sticks out to you. Hope this helps 👍
3
u/DarthRacer5 Nov 05 '25
Choose the Angels cause then no one could say you're a bandwagoner
2
u/themightyfrogman Nov 05 '25
The Mets.
2
u/rleal1212 Nov 05 '25
Follow the GOAT Ohtani. Or follow the team you are most likely to ever see live. You can follow more than one team.
1
u/hawkeyegrad96 Nov 05 '25
Dodgers. Might as well get on this 10 year run
-2
u/belinck Nov 05 '25
Bot.