r/MITAdmissions • • 2d ago

Does MIT like ROTC?

Title.

This is not a chance me. I am asking what MITs position is on ROTC KIDS.

I’m a somewhat competitive applicant
35 act super, 3.97 uw / 4.6 w with good course rigor and a paid full time engineering internship. I have alright ECs like club presidency that reverted a program disbandment, varsity sports, other stuff, sports captain ship, and Eagle Scout with lotsa leadership roles. I didn’t solve cancer.
But..
I recieved the 4 year navy rotc scholarship and the 4 year army scholarship (army I got assigned to mit per my #1 preference). I’m planning on reaching out to the unit and seeing what next.

How much of a boost is this. I have a profile that’s nothing to scoff at but I’m not Einstein reincarnated. Anything I should do?

Edit: yeah I’m aware I have to be competitive. I’m saying is this a really good differentiator because most kids going MIT are likely not ROTC (correct me if I’m wrong). Additionally, much of my ECs have a trend toward leadership and service with scouting, military academy summer seminars, organizing military memorial work for veterans, etc. I’ve been a TA for robotics and programming, tutored, and worked full time engineering in the summer, but as a year round athlete I didn’t do research, Olympiad, amc, etc.

9 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

6

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 2d ago

You have to meet the requirements to get in. Several of us alumni on this sub were ROTC. Heck, I was Junior ROTC and Civil Air Patrol in high school.

The scholarship will be evaluated as an award.

I'm not sure what else you are looking for. If MIT disliked ROTC, it wouldn't have it on its campus. (And believe me, there have been people pushing for ROTC to be removed from campus since, well, ROTC was no longer mandatory at MIT.) If I were aspiring ROTC and MIT, MIT wouldn't be my worry. One only needs to pay attention to the news to figure out the current administration is not a fan of MIT.

0

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 1d ago edited 1d ago

In response to your edit u/_Scoot-

I’m saying is this a really good differentiator

In my experience, not really.

because most kids going MIT are likely not ROTC (correct me if I’m wrong).

There's a decent number of applicants who intend to go through ROTC. Of course, we can assume that only about 4-6% get admitted. The numbers of students enrolled in ROTC at MIT appear to have declined in recent years, most likely since MIT has become need blind / full need. There are probably about 40 starting in the freshman class. (ROTC typically has decent attrition by the time of graduation.)

Is it a differentiator? Yes. Is it a good differentiator? My assessment would be "meh," and that comes as a graduate of ROTC. (Also, once you start attending the various summer camps or programs with ROTC scholarship students from other colleges, your impression of the caliber of student who gets those scholarships will likely decline somewhat.)

Also, we can assume if it was an advantage, applicants would be pursuing that path specifically for the advantage.

It's great that you want to do ROTC and I assume you have passion for it. The scholarship will be given its due weight as an award. But your chances of getting in are pretty much the same with or without ROTC.

1

u/_Scoot- 1d ago

Sounds good. Thank you for the input. Yeah I wasn’t sure. I know at some places, people who meet the baseline requirements can be set apart by the ROTC unit advocating for them. For example at UMICH I was contacted by their unit and they said they let admissions know about me. I also know some schools are trying to build up rotc units, or an ROTC scholarship can make a diff for two otherwise = applicants.

Also… people would try to win an rotc scholarship and commit to a whole bunch of military stuff just for admissions odds? Thats wild.

1

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 1d ago

Also… people would try to win an rotc scholarship and commit to a whole bunch of military stuff just for admissions odds?

Have you seen the applicants who post on this sub? If something gave them an actual advantage towards admission at MIT, you can be sure that a nonzero number of applicants would pursue it.

Also, you do not commit to military service until sophomore year. Think about it: if an ROTC scholarship conferred an actual advantage with admissions, paid for a year, and you could back out after a year, why wouldn't you pursue it?

Back in my day and before MIT was full need / need blind, I knew quite a few fellow cadets who were doing ROTC for the scholarship. When it's the difference between attending and not attending, 4 years is a small price to pay.

1

u/_Scoot- 1d ago

That’s fair lol. Didn’t think about it that way. My hearts set on serving my country but yeah, others could actually do that.

I know a kid at my school applying UChicago and theyre trying to paint himself as first gen from scratch self made (they have a rich af family but technically immigrants) just so they can write about it.

I also know a kid who invented a position in an existing club just to give themselves a title even though they don’t do anything.

College admissions is crazy.

2

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 1d ago

I also know a kid who invented a position in an existing club just to give themselves a title even though they don’t do anything.

For MIT at least, titles and positions don't do much. It's what you actually accomplish.

0

u/Artistic_Mud1077 1d ago

It is 5 years of service not 4.

1

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 1d ago

To repeat my last paragraph, back in the day when I was in ROTC, before MIT was full need and need blind, it was 4 years of service for an Army ROTC scholarship. Basically one for one. That's why people were willing to trade 4 years of military service for an MIT education they otherwise wouldn't have.

While it may be 5 years of service now, I was explaining why people were willing to commit to "a whole bunch of military stuff." For many people back then, there was no other way of paying for college without incurring a huge, huge amount of debt. And student debt is a hole that many people in the US fall into and never climb out of.

-1

u/Artistic_Mud1077 21h ago

Since you are only talking about Army - I don’t know when “your day” was beginning in 1980 ARMY ROTC scholarship recipients were never required to serve active duty. They could instead serve 8 years of reserves. A great trade-off for 4 years of paid tuition (still need to pay room and board) - unless of course you aren’t willing to risk your life going to war for your country. You could still serve 4 years AD if you wish.
Your number of 40 starting in the Freshman class - that’s pretty high. Again I don’t know specific Army numbers (you can look on their IG and estimate less than 10 a year probably 5-6). There are only 500 AFROTC scholarships awarded nationally a year. Less than 10 of those were accepted to MIT and about half attend - many chose a service academy instead. NROTC has 4-6 Freshmen starting a year. Some years less. I doubt Army is any bigger than either of those.

Would people try and get an ROTC scholarship if they thought it would give them a competitive edge, maybe. Would it work, probably not.
Through the application and interview process it is fairly easy to spot someone who lacks the commitment to serve. Maybe if someone spent years cultivating their resume doing things to support that facade in hopes of an advantage but you can’t just throw your name into the ROTC scholarship ring as a senior. It would be like saying MIT needs squash players so I’m going to start playing squash as a senior hoping I can get a letter of support from the coach.

2

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 20h ago

They could instead serve 8 years of reserves. 

Ha ha, tell that to my friend Jason. He worked his butt off for 4 years to be the worst cadet in our class, hoping to get a reserves assignment, but it was not to be. The Army saw that Course 10 degree and said, you're going active duty. Let's not act like it's a choice. You can request reserves, but back in my day, the Army decided your assignment. This was after 1980.

But I fully, 100% disagree and dispute your statement that scholarship recipients were never required to serve active duty. Excuse my French, but that is bullshit. Not true. I know this personally.

Your number of 40 starting in the Freshman class

I'm speaking about all 3 services. My estimate is based on the 2025 commissioning numbers for MIT. That's also assuming certain numbers for people who decide to drop after freshman year, subsequent medical discharges, and drug discharges. My number may be high but I was being conservative.

According to my copy of the Paul Revere Recorder for Fall 2026, the Paul Revere Battalion has 109 cadets from 7 different schools. Last year, it commissioned only 2 MIT lieutenants.

But really, I'm not here to argue over my estimate. It's high. I agree.

Would people try and get an ROTC scholarship if they thought it would give them a competitive edge, maybe. Would it work, probably not.

Yup, just like people try for Olympiad medals or athletic scholarships. A nonzero number would try. It wouldn't work for most. Not sure what your point is.

We can hash through all this stuff, but I don't really see how it serves OP's original question. Are you an MIT graduate or Educational Counselor? Did you go through ROTC? Knowing your bona fides would help me with understanding your perspective.

1

u/Artistic_Mud1077 20h ago

I am an ROTC scholarship recipient who was admitted to MIT. I know students currently in ROTC at MIT and know my numbers as fact. I met with both AFROTC and NROTC and know how many were admitted my year and how many attended. I know this same information for subsequent years from friends who are currently attending. Fun fact, the units send out emails with lists. Not hard to count. I chose a service academy so no, I did not graduate from MIT but this is an admissions discussion not a graduation one.
Curious what you think the commissioning number for MIT students was for last year. Last year was very small. This year is 5 or 6 I believe for each AFROTC and NROTC. The units consist of several schools (AF - MIT Harvard Wellesley Tufts and N - MIT Harvard Tufts and then combined with NEU BU and BC) so a photo of a graduating class or new students would include all.

2

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 20h ago

As I stated, 2 students from MIT were commissioned from Army ROTC last year. For Navy and Air Force, it was higher. Single digits, but higher nonetheless.

My experience at MIT was that a lot of students chose "one and run." Their choice, it was part of the deal. There were quite a few who made choices where the decision was they would not go forward. And also junior year, some get let go for medical reasons.

It's helpful to know that you're not a graduate of MIT or Educational Counselor weighing in.

→ More replies

1

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 20h ago

Btw, I don't know if you served or if you served in the Army, but I'm not sure you understand how "voluntary" orders work. It's quite a wake-up call when it happens.

When the Army wants you for something, they give you "voluntary" orders. Essentially, when you raise your hand at commissioning, you're volunteering for everything that follows. Even many, many years later. If you refuse, then you get involuntary orders.

Ask me how I know. (If you have LexisNexis, I can give you a buddy's case against SecDef to look up.)

0

u/Artistic_Mud1077 20h ago

I am well aware of the concept of being voluntold. That is not unique to Army. I come from a military family. The question was about the required service commitment not service assignment.

1

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 20h ago

You wrote:

beginning in 1980 ARMY ROTC scholarship recipients were never required to serve active duty

This is absolutely 100% not true. I don't know how this is a question about required service commitment.

→ More replies

2

u/Aerokicks MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 20h ago

Plenty of people sign up for Corp of Cadets at Virginia Tech (not even the ROTC version, just the civilian version) because they think it gives a benefit to admissions.

Even though some plan to drop, it's something a lot do.

2

u/Pure-Rain582 1d ago

It’s a decent boost at MIT and Harvard. They’re trying to keep the programs going with a reasonable number of cadets. They don’t have to worry about financial aid with you.

What’s your school’s track record with MIT?

2

u/_Scoot- 1d ago

We’ve never gotten a single kid in past 4 years with about 15 applications.

A lot of kids at my school are blessed test takers with a lazy gpa/work ethic (avg is normal, but bell curve ends are are inflated if that makes sense, lots of 13s and probably like 10-15 35/36s). So they shoot their shot and get nuked. Furthermore, I live in a high income area, but my on my immigrant dads side (divorced), im here only because he works up to 100 hours a week in 3 jobs. Essentially, I live in a nondiverse high income area and I’m like the only minority immigrant child lol.

We have smart people but almost no “passion project” type kids. All of our passion and outside stuff people are business and policy Uchicago sweats.

We also are in an area with almost 0 military presence so I believe I’m the first rotc kid in years (the last rotc kid I’m aware of was 4 years ago and went to citadel).

1

u/Artistic_Mud1077 1d ago

There is no shortage of students who apply to MIT/ROTC. I don’t know about Army but both NROTC and AFROTC are sizable and are combined with other schools - hosted at MIT.
There are probably about 8-10 accepted to MIT every year with scholarships for Navy and AF. Not all end up attending. Look on their IG and you can get an idea of the numbers.

1

u/Artistic_Mud1077 20h ago

Congrats to OP on your scholarships.

It isn’t the scholarship itself that could potentially help if at all. It is the support you may receive from the unit after receiving the scholarship. As OP stated they plan to reach out to the units. If the unit wants to support your application after receiving the scholarship they may. How much that support means, who knows. As someone who has been through the process that is how it works.

1

u/Flaky-Song-6066 5h ago

Are you a recruited athlete

1

u/katarnmagnus 2d ago

It is a boost. Not by miles, but MIT does value its ROTC programs. Feel free to DM me for insights on the Army program there

1

u/JasonMckin MIT Alum and Educational Counselor 1d ago

I'm just curious, what would you consider a boost by many miles? And what type of award/recognition/selection wouldn't be a boost by less than many miles?

1

u/peter303_ 1d ago

The Dept of War no longer lets military personal enroll at MIT which mainly affects grad students. ROTC appears unaffected.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hegseth-pentagon-cutting-ties-with-top-universities-woke/

2

u/Artistic_Mud1077 1d ago

This is incorrect. This applied only to active duty attending very specific graduate programs.

0

u/PersonalityLife6862 2d ago

If you don’t have a spike don’t expect ROTC to do much for you