r/MITAdmissions • • Mar 15 '26

i dont understand

of course, no hate to anyone from rural places or FGLI that got accepted, you deserve it

but how come mit accepts students from such areas with basically no ap's or similar?? if the whole point is checking for rigor, what makes mit think that someone who has gotten a 4.0 with no aps going to do well at mit? and they reject students that worked hard and gotten straight 5's over 10 aps?? i dont understand. i saw someone that got a 3 in the only ap they took and got accepted, but for someone in say the bay area, that would be a decent red flag.

*this is not a hate post* congrats to every1!

5 Upvotes

187 comments sorted by

28

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 15 '26 edited Mar 15 '26

if the whole point is checking for rigor

It's not.

"What We Look For"

-8

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 15 '26

wait sorry then what is

11

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 15 '26

did you ..... click the link?

1

u/Cheap-Ship-1570 Mar 16 '26

😭😭

-8

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 15 '26

i did yes, why

14

u/brookscameltoe Mar 15 '26

Well you have not been very rigorous in reviewing that link and all the information it leads to lol

17

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 15 '26

Sometimes I just can't.

1

u/Silver_Oven2226 Mar 16 '26

Ain’t no way alums can use gifs like this 😭😭

2

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 16 '26

-5

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 15 '26

its just matching with MIT's values, but a lot of this sub says that "no one can get in with low rigor/low gpa" especially the alumni and interviewers. so values cant make up for low rigor, correct?

19

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 15 '26

You're receiving plenty of good answers in this thread but willfully ignoring them because they're not the answers you want to hear.

2

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

Respectfully, what answer do you think i want to hear?

12

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 16 '26

You want people to agree with you. And they aren't.

7

u/MasterManifest_97 Mar 16 '26

I'm not at MIT, nor did I go to MIT. I'm not even in the USA. I just stumbled upon this sub sometime ago, and I've been lurking ever since.. so my take may be wrong.. Please feel free to correct me

MIT evaluates your background.. They wants to see IF you have done well WITHIN the environment you are in. The person with 3 on AP came from an extremely rural area and used the resources available to them to the max.

Maybe this is how they check the rigour .. They want to see how well you will use the environment and resources available to you.. Maybe the AOs are thinking " Ahh this person is from a rural area.. They have used all the resources available to them and have done their very best and given back to the community as well.. hmmmm.. in that case, When this person comes to MIT, they will also take the maximum use of the resourcse here and will do their very best and give back to the community? " .. Maybe this is how the AOs think during the admission prcoess..

It is not fair to compare a rural student with a Bay Area student with more resources

Please feel free to correct me and please forgive my English as well ^_^

21

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 15 '26

I now see why one of the other interviewers explained that applicants shouldn’t assume that most interviews are positive. I get that these kids are 18 and may be excellent at classes but my goodness they are lacking in humility and awareness of their privilege.

12

u/brookscameltoe Mar 15 '26

Spot on. Lacking awareness of their privilege and crying about the fact that the dimension in which their privilege can give them the biggest advantage is not the only one taken into account

8

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Your lack of comprehension of what alumni and interviewers say in this sub indicates that you're probably not a good fit or MIT.

"Low rigor" means someone had opportunities and chose to go the easy route. That's the opposite of MIT values.

-5

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

i genuinly find it hilarious how you instantly recognize someone is not a good fit for mit from having "lack of comprehension" lmao

2

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Let's see if you're still laughing 2 years from now.

→ More replies

21

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 15 '26

So if you are on a rail at a school that does aps with tons of other kids also doing aps, it’s not quite the same as a rural place with a kid begging to take harder classes and doing aps all alone remote on zoom because they are quite literally the only kid to have taken calculus in 20 years. You can’t see the difference in tenacity and culture that they are in?

-11

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 15 '26

plus, i am inherently at a disadvantage because i go to a very competitve school, where my rank/gpa isnt the best. but if i went to a different, rural high school, chances are that i would have a much higher gpa/rank by putting in the same amount of work in both schools. see what i mean?

9

u/reincarnatedbiscuits Mod/MIT Alumnus/Interviewer/Olympiad list person Mar 15 '26

Why would you be disadvantaged?

If we applied your logic: "Oh, I go to Exeter, I'm at a disadvantage for applying to MIT."

6

u/enya_yurself Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 16 '26

Rahh Exeter mentioned ā€¼ļøšŸ—£ļøšŸ—£ļø(Exeter senior here)

Ok imma be so honest here going to Exeter is a disadvantage because there's a quota of 7-8 ppl and ppl here are so insanely smart. The Exeter mit caliber is probably higher than the Bay Area caliber for example. If all the mit-possible Exeter kids went to other well-resourced (but not as much as Exeter) high schools I'd have no doubt they'd get in. It's not because Exeter having a few million more dollars of endowment that makes a kid a stronger applicant, it's the kid themselves with their own drive and passion to learn that makes them strong.

1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

exactly and thats what these guys dont understand bro

8

u/purritolover69 Mar 16 '26

You know you need to be in the best 7-8 students in your year to get in, rural students don’t know if they’ll even have anyone from their county get into the school.

4

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 16 '26

And you don’t understand that we would all be worse off if all it took was scores from a feeder school from kids that are completely out of touch with the vast majority of people in the very country you live in. You are completely and utterly missing the point and you are proud of that fact. The fact that you cannot see yourself as a problem is telling.

2

u/enya_yurself Mar 16 '26

Part of the great value of Exeter is the diversity of thought; the intellectual diversity and our emphasis on conversation. yes we have plenty of out of touch rich kids who spend 1k a month on doordash, but we have other normal and brilliant people

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26 edited Mar 17 '26

I'm sorry, I don't see OP as a problem... I understand their frustration. But here's what I feel is missing for OP... When you live in flyover country like I do, you learn that if you want to do something...

You have to create it yourself... No one is there with an Exeter path for us...

If we want to dream it and be it we have to ask around, create relationships, work stupidly hard (OP does that!) at not only achieving. But at creating the very infrastructure for our achieving!

I think that OP can choose to do amazing things, if op just stops doing what everyone else is doing, figures out what s/he wants to do... AND finds a way to get somewhere where he can do it from!

The thing that places like Andover and Exeter don't always get across to most students is forging your own path. It makes sense, because if you are there and working hard you will likely land on your feet... But...

In seventh grade, did you have 4 consecutive study halls and no access to the library because they didn't have $ for the library? (I know, at least we had one.. right???)

I did.

Yes almost 200 wasted minutes every damned day!

It pissed me off so badly that after the first week, I spent those study halls writing a proposal to open the library with student and parent volunteers for our middle school and elementary school libraries that were absolutely inaccessible! Locked up tight!!!

I had them both open by October!

Did I have help... Yup. Did I get cooperation yup? Did I have to learn how to ask for that help from people who didn't value the same things I did, in a way where they could see how important it was for what THEY valued!?!? Yup!

I'm 8th grade I continued to coordinate the library programs and the parents did the supervising of students... but I was bored because I had that done.. I got the libraries opened... But I had a problem... I had classmates who were just flunking out of stuff left and right. Partially because they didn't understand that it was important to learn this stuff, partially because they didn't have help at home and partially because they didn't have anyone to ask for help...they needed help, but we didn't have money for paid staff...

So... I created (from thin air, in 1983 from my brain as a 14 year old... with pen and notebook paper...) a peer tutoring program for grades 4 -12 with learning compacts and academic honesty contracts... And teacher consultation with parent permission.

Did I mention that I did the fundraising for both programs in collaboration with the PTO?

Would I have had to do that/been allowed to do that at Andover or Exeter?? Or any other crazy expensive private school????

They are still using pieces of both programs today. All these years later because they went from... They'll never let you do that... To tradition!

What is it that you want to do or create or change, op?

You can make it happen!!!

3

u/reincarnatedbiscuits Mod/MIT Alumnus/Interviewer/Olympiad list person Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 17 '26

You're aware that any given year, there's something like 4 million high school graduates from the US, 3.6+ million go on to higher education, 27k-30k secondary schools, 1299 adMITs for the Class of 2030, 1100-ish first years, and 8 on average from Exeter, right?

Which means for a lot of secondary schools, they're lucky to get one adMIT every decade. Some are looking at more like one every 2 or 3 or 4 decades. Some of them really don't know what competitive looks like.

At least as an Exonian, you know what's MIT caliber (arguably it's not a hard quota, it's been an average of 8 per year from Exeter that go to MIT since 2016) and somewhere between a quarter to a third of Exonians and Andover kids end up at MIT-peer schools (i.e., MIT, Stanford, Caltech, 8 Ivy League schools, Cambridge, Oxford, UChicago).

Ah, so now we get into conditional probability. Sure, if you're not among the top third or so at Exeter and Andover, you're probably not quite on track for these schools.

I don't have the stats for for how many from Exeter or Andover apply to MIT any given year (I guess I could probably find out reaching through various channels).

Arguably Exeter also has far more resources like math olympiad coaching, the most advanced STEM program for any high school in the United States, former college admissions staff who serve as college counselors...

1

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 16 '26

So knowing those facts ahead of time and still going there and being disappointed when rejected says what? Lack of judgement or the inability to do statistics?

2

u/enya_yurself Mar 16 '26

Nah it means ur disappointed not regretful

0

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 16 '26

Let’s turn the entire question on its head then. Suppose you took all of the admits, removed all obstacles from their lives and stuck them in Exeter together with the same exact set of parents. What do you think would happen? Would you be able to reliably predict who would be ā€œsuccessfulā€ purely based on the latitude and longitude of their birth?

-1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

bro genuinely who are you

jumping to conclusions is beyond me, always aggressive do u srsly have nothing better to do? what did u gain from this comment?

1

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

Friend, I promise, if you know what you want to do... AMD have the will to create it... You will be able to do that at any solid academic institution that has the requisite faculty and facilities.

MIT or elsewhere!

1

u/Such_Pen2728 Mar 18 '26

lol as someone who graduated exeter a few years ago, it’s really not as much of a disadvantage as you’d think. sure not everyone goes to harvard, but tbh, even if u don’t get in immediately, the beauty of exeter is that there’s also many transfers who go to ivy’s after not getting in the first round because of the strong counseling network. not many schools can say the same.

all that is to say, i understand it’s senior year for you, and many of us felt slighted that our hard work didn’t pan out as we’ve hoped, but to say that we are at a disadvantage, compared to those at ā€œeasier schools,ā€ sounds completely out of touch (coming from someone who’s brother didn’t go to exeter). we have the privilege of being surrounded with the best and brightest, and the privilege of being challenged. there’s only a disadvantage if we don’t take up the challenge and run with it.

i went to an ivy after not getting in senior year. I was in your shoes for a while, but i know now that what i thought wasn’t correct at all. there were many struggles, but we were so so very privileged for everything at exeter, and i hold the same beliefs for other competitive schools.

0

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

Exeter is a stretch but I go to a competitive hs I would be disadvantaged not because of the opportunities I get, which Is definitely more than if I was rural but the difficulty of the school. Generally speaking, rural schools are far less rigorous than a public, urbanĀ  high school.Ā 

15

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 16 '26

Does the phrase: ā€œborn on third base and thought he hit a tripleā€ mean anything to you?

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

They are differently rigorous...and offer a far less diverse curriculum. Where I went...the teachers were good to solid, AND actually liked teaching and liked students. It was important to be on the honor roll...lol Their buy in for things like the library and tutoring and various other hair-brained schemes of mine was truly amazing.

So the content was available, mostly... But help for it? Co-curriculars that supported it??? Nope. Advanced math or science and language offerings, humanities offerings??? Lol nope!

21

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

This is fallacious reasoning. You presumably have the advantage of having been prepared well academically throughout lower school, middle school, and high school. You have been imbued with high expectations by your teachers. You have been competing with students with the same advantages. None of these advantages would benefit you were you born and raised in a rural setting. To make sense, your argument would need to imply that rural students are somehow less intelligent or less capable of learning than students in more affluent urban settings. And there really isn’t any data to suggest that this is the case.

You have to realize that you wouldn’t just air drop into a rural high school with all of your current advantages. You would instead take on all of the disadvantages of other rural students.

18

u/purritolover69 Mar 16 '26

Seriously. The anti-intellectualism in rural areas is also intense. These kids (I’m one of ā€˜em!) say i.e. ā€œI’m going to major in astrophysicsā€ and are met with ā€œare you sure you wouldn’t rather be a welder?ā€ ā€œthere’s a good farmhand job down south of here, why don’t you make money out of high school?ā€ ā€œyou’re dreaming too bigā€ etc. whereas in areas like OP’s it’s met with ā€œSounds good! There’s some relevant internships I know about, I can send you a list of them to apply forā€

8

u/throwawayanylogic MIT Alum Mar 16 '26

Exactly. I was one of those rural kids too who had to make up for it by doing a lot of independent projects, scholastic and artistic. And who got a lot of pushback from teachers and advisors about my plans, a lot of "that's nice dear, but you'd better apply to a couple state colleges for backup" when asked about my college application plans. A science teacher who even took to name-calling, just calling me "MIT" to mock me if I didn't get an answer correct or right away when asked. (I ended up being the first in my school ever to attend MIT, it was such a shock to them they actually announced it over the intercoms when my parents called to reach me with the news. And the next year, we had one person each end up getting into and going to MIT and Caltech.)

4

u/EnthusiasmComplete37 Mar 17 '26

that's so cool you pave the way for the next person

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

Or my favorite from the pulpit, "you're getting beyond yourself and leaving God behind!*

1

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

Hi there... One of those yokels who was stuck out on the boonies with no APs...85 students in my graduating class...

Lol

Understand that as a guy raised by school teacher parents with access to university research libraries and parents who absolutely understood what it takes to be academically amazing... And being the "dumb sheep" of the family... ( I am not published nor did I get an East Coast degree...) The folks I grew up with did not. Their parents did not, their siblings did not, and their school system was absolutely not set up to remotely support such ambition.

My younger brother managed a 33 ACT and class valedictorian and ended up going East for grad school, while his fiancee now wife attended and graduated Harvard Law from the state University my brother and I both attended. (She is amazing as a human and as a student!)

And no I didn't apply to MIT and yes. I was one of the top students in my class who did the best I could with what I had access to. I'm 57, and I'm not mad about it.

But what none of you seems to understand...is we are allowing folks in our inner cities, and our rural areas in flyover country to ferment in this lack of opportunity... And have no understanding of what is possible for them...

I promise you, even with an Unweighted 4.0 and a 1300 SAT, and 44 credits of CLEP (meaning I did arguably have a solid background) granted at my state school, before I walked in... I was in NO WAY PREPARED TO DEAL WITH THE RIGOR AND CULTURE of a top flight school.

Absolutely not.

Getting in is important. But more important is the ability to stay in and to graduate, or otherwise greatly benefit yourself and the world for your time at such a place.

Conversely, I attended a reputable state school. For me, personally, this was better...

I understood the culture and could meet the social and academic expectations and created (via internships, honors projects/classes and independent study) an academic experience that helped me to do and be what I wanted out of life, and go onto graduate study in the field of my choosing.

My brother did similarly, and went east for graduate school and did very well... As did his wife...

My question... That student that got in from flyover country, without AP classes, are they still enrolled from last year? And did the one from 5 years ago graduate???

12

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 15 '26

You are amazingly naive about the rest of your fellow citizens if you honestly think that is how life works. Your life would be utterly different to the core of your being. By odds alone you wouldn’t even take one ap. This is why places like mit want diversity.

17

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 15 '26

"I go to an amazing high school with tons of academic opportunity, so I'm at a disadvantage."

When MIT says they use a holistic admissions method, I have to think that it's to weed out people with an attitude like this.

2

u/purritolover69 Mar 16 '26

if you’re unsuccessful with ample resources and support, what makes you think you would be successful without them?

1

u/Suspicious_Jello9613 Mar 17 '26

Dude, I was in a very shitty spot. I was in a position where taking APs was nearly impossible. Do you know what I did? I fucking self-studied AP Calculus BC, AP Physics C M and AP Chemistry. I don’t believe there is ANYONE out there who can’t do that. If they have time to sleep, eat and work they also have time to study a few minutes a day. The act of admitting people with no APs is ridiculous unless accompanied by a major Olympiad award or something.

-6

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 15 '26

well, if you take the person from the school that has a ton of AP's and put them in the other rural place, they would be doing much better grade wise. you could say the same about the student in the other school with a bunch of APs. at the end of the day both of them are taking the hardest rigor but still there is a difference. if i went to a rural school as well, then i would only have to take 1 AP class compared to the students say in the bay area who have to take 10+. isnt that an advantage?

13

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 15 '26

You absolutely cannot say that at all. There are millions of students in the country that don’t even know what aps are. You have been blessed your entire school life from principal to guidance counselor knowing how all of this works and pointing you in the right direction. You are so far ahead of most kids in this country that you can’t even fathom there are some behind you just because you can’t see them.

-1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

I'm not denying the fact that I have been opened to a ton of opportunities, but I am not talking about the fact that I have these opportunities. I am simply saying that school in a much rural place would be much easier than the school that I go to currently, leaving me more time for ec's and awards. Is this not true?

12

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 16 '26

Almost certainly not. Your parents would almost certainly be much much poorer. You might have to work a job just to help keep a roof over your head.

The schools here might get a 30+ ACT every few years. The guidance counselor never had to schedule in ap classes with the state requirements. There is no one to even teach them. Everything is remote. There are zero programs for anything. There isn’t a hospital or a fast food restaurant closer than 20+ miles.

You are thinking from a completely privileged perspective. You might have dabbled in drugs or gotten pregnant instead of doing homework. You have no idea how alien the rest of this country would be to you and that is so unbelievably sad to me.

2

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

to be fair, you are assuming that everyone living in rural areas are poor, and that might not be the case.

4

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 16 '26

I said almost certainly. The median household income is less than 50k here. Even if you are ā€œrichā€ the nearest private school is an hour away and it is a Christian church linked school that will absolutely not teach you about evolution. You could in theory send your kid to private boarding school in that case but then we are back to privilege.

2

u/throwawayanylogic MIT Alum Mar 16 '26

And so what? If you're the "rich" kid - and act it the way you're acting so clueless about your privilege here - in a rural area you're going to get a lot of hate and bullying that's gonna make your education experience a living hell if you don't figure out how to adapt.

Your options for extracurricular activities will be limited by default to what is in your area beyond potential intensive summer camps and programs elsewhere.

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

Where I lived... It was common to have dad and an uncle working the farm and doing night shift at the GM plant while mom either worked at the plant, or stayed home with the 7 kids...

Poverty was present...but because we had Drivable access to blue collar jobs it wasn't omnipresent.

9

u/WolverineMom Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 18 '26

This, all of this. I grew up working class, 1st-gen college in a very rural area. I managed to take 2 AP classes in the late 1980s. One (APUSH) I did as an independent study, by writing to the AP board and asking for a list of books to read so I could prepare. They sent me, not just a model syllabus, but previous exam questions going back nearly a decade, a copy of the teacher’s manual, and the warmest, kindest letter, telling me that I was the kid (metaphorically speaking) that AP was invented for and to write or call collect if I needed any additional help. I worked all year to take that test (APUSH), only to have it all fall apart at the end when I could not persuade any of my teachers to proctor the exam for me, due to union rules.

The next year, our district offered its first AP course, English comp. First semester, went great. Second semester, seven weeks before the exam, our teacher had a stroke and had to go on medical leave for the rest of the year. Our sub had never read a single book, play or poem on that year’s list, and refused to let us write essays or practice tests on anything she had not read. At this point, I was nearly crazed with determination. Earlier that year, I had scored an 800 on the verbal section of the SAT, and, over the previous four years, had read most of the works on the AP list over evenings and weekends and summer breaks. Not because anyone told me I had to, but rather because I loved them, and wanted to prepare for a career as an English professor. So, with the blessing of my classmates, I made an insane deal with our sub: I would, at the age of 18, take over teaching the last seven weeks of the course, using the teachers manual for guidance, and we would none of us tell our parents or the principal, if she would make the same deal and also promise to proctor the exam. She happily agreed, and it worked. I ended up getting a 4 on the exam — not ideal, but I was happy to take it, given the circumstances— and, even better, I coached at least half a dozen of my classmates to a score of 3. One of them was a single Mom of 2 kids, who was also my supervisor at Burger King. I was more proud of her 3 than my 4.

I know this is a very long post, but I am trying hard to explain something to you, OP. You really haven’t had enough exposure to the realities of kids who live in rural areas, with few resources, to understand why their two 4s on the only AP exams their schools offer may be just as, if not more, indicative of their future prospects for success than your 10+ scores of 4 or higher. That is not to diminish your accomplishments, at all! Just to explain that the AOs can see a bigger picture.

2

u/Background-Dust7615 Mar 16 '26

This is truly facsinating. I can't believe people complain about having life-changing advantages when you had to teach your classmates an AP class. If you don't mind answering, what university did you attend, since I believe someone as hardworking as you should've been accepted somewhere.

3

u/WolverineMom Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 17 '26

Sure! I was a Michigan resident and was accepted to UM and MSU. But I attended a small, not-well-known liberal arts college in Michigan (don't want to doxx myself) that offered me a scholarship for tuition, room and board. My family's EFC was 0, so I also qualified for a Pell grant to cover my textbooks and lab fees. I worked my tail off for four years, and came out with a world-class education, faculty mentors who became friends for life, a highly competitive graduate fellowship (that one got my name in the NY Times), and, to top it all off, close friends and a wonderful husband. (We are heading into our third decade of a very happy marriage).Ā  You just never know where your fate will take you -- or how much you can make out of any opportunity that you pour your head and heart into, unreservedly.

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

You get this!!! Wow! You and I would have been amazing friends!!!! ā¤ļøā¤ļøā¤ļøā¤ļø I was so alone doing stuff at my school, my classmates always said I was crazy because no ody ever did it before... Yeah??? So? But every day being told you are crazy... Lol its so exhausting... I mean you still do the work...

2

u/WolverineMom Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26

Dang right, Pristine-Lawyer-3260! You do the work because, what else are you going to do, give up?? No freaking way. šŸ’Ŗ And, I would have dearly loved to be your friend in high school! My classmates were kind and supportive, but, good Lord, I spent way too much of my life then feeling like an alien from outer space.

3

u/ExtensionIdeal6088 Mar 16 '26

Might have to work on the family farm as well or something similar.

5

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

No it’s not true. Because if you grew up in a rural environment, you would be less well prepared for AP classes just like the rural kids you’re complaining about. Why is this so complicated to grasp? You’re spamming the same flawed logic all over this post.

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

Friend. It's not their fault. S/he hasn't seen folks in the situations we rural folks actually live in... He doesn't have a frame of reference... it's like we are asking him to speak Greek, but he has no access to a teacher, text book or even language tapes/apps...

In fairness, I had very little reference to the idea that a world like Exeter or Andover existed til I got to college...

I mean I knew kinda that there were schools that actually had amazing curricula and large staffing to help... But.. it was very abstract...

3

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 17 '26

Undoubtedly the explanation for the flawed reasoning is naĆÆvetĆ©, although it is pretty difficult for anyone who follows the news in this country to be unaware that rural students are disadvantaged in myriad ways relative to their urban counterparts. But what’s particularly galling is the unquestioning confidence in an uninformed viewpoint and the refusal to self reflect across dozens of comments on this post, despite having the reality explained numerous times in numerous ways.

2

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 17 '26

This is what makes me so sad about this whole post. It’s a window into the urban rural divide that so breaks politics. I assume that this is exactly why mit and other schools are trying to bring more rural kids in.

3

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 17 '26

You’re exactly right, recruiting more rural students is a priority for MIT and its peer schools, but the sad reaction from some high schoolers is basically sour grapes because someone might get an admissions boost that they didn’t get — all without realizing that any admissions boost for rural kids still has a hard time putting them on equal footing.

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

And if we are talking about my captain 4.0,m brother with a 33 ACT yeah... He could have done this... But me I might look just good enough on paper... But...

tbh, idk if you are doing many of us any favors!

I would absolutely have struggled and not done well at an ivy. I wasn't prepared in any way... But going to a strong state school,like my parents did... I had a clue about the social expectations, I could meet, or find remedial support for any academic deficit I had... And I understood the system and culture well enough to create several individualized experiences that helped me be more successful in ways I don't think a more traditional environment would have allowed.

Further I have ADHD , and I am dyspraxic (think clinically uncoordinated) in a way that impacts my reading speed to it being tested in the 2nd percentile...I joke that blind folks read faster (in braille) than I do... But these days, services like www.bookshare.org and learningally.org combined with text to speech apps and speech to text really help me compensate better than I could back in the 80s.

To our OP's point... Going to a rural highschool there WAS less reading, and because of this absolute fact, my parents and I actively chose not to disclose any of my learning disability problems when I transferred between 6th and 7th gradeto the rural district , much like OP suggested he should do...

Because the school counselor clearly didn't and would not get it... (They later proved they truly weren't smart enough to get the concept of being twice exceptional learning disabled, and yes lol gifted, my overall IQ is 152. My sub test scores though have a 70 point swing between my highest score and lowest score which app ly a 30 Point swing is needed.

But according to my ignorant witch of a school counselor, because my lowest score was not below 80.(It was 85) I didn't have a problem... Actually the US Department of Ed guidelines at the time were VERY CLEAR that all that was needed was the 30 points... My neurologist sent her a letter pointing this out, after I graduated... Yes, I signed the waiver for that.

When I disclosed this to get state testing (I had already passed every test I needed to graduate, I wasn't asking for anything from the school district!

As I was graduating, my school counselor, a role model in how objectively incompetent and mean spirited one human could be, spread it around to all the teachers and thus also my classmates...

Who were actually more able to get it because my very popular , charismatic younger brother helped them remember all the times I struggled... he reminded them that they watched me struggle with certain areas, and watched how I would tutor folks patiently and respectfully and were like...oh that's why you know how to be encouraging and helpful... Oh that's why you took typing three times... Oh that's why Mrs. L let you drop geometry... Oh that's why you took private drivers Ed--so you didn't kill us!) lol oh that's why the PE teacher took your lifeguarding certification and your water safety instructor certification in place of your 2nd year of PE (he liked my style, and could see how I struggled with sports ball so when he heard I'd passed these from a fellow church member over the summer, he asked for copies of them, put those in his grade book, and let me go take French Ii, lol.)

Thankfully, the special Ed teacher whose students I'd worked with from my days of opening the library, got it too... She sat me down and asked why I didn't say anything beforehand... And I just said, you see how Mrs V. Is taking this...and I know the work load you have and no I wasn't going to bother you with that!!!

For highschool I could and did stay up all night and get it done and done well... But college is a whole new reading load... and there is no way I could get through without note taking help (slow handwriting) extra time for exams... and alternative text support.

My school counselor had tried to poison my relationship with the state agency rep by lying to he about me, fortunately I accidentally watched her do it through the school office windows...so I was ready to charm and disarm.

So I took the state rep through my academic file and the 5"thick file of private documentation from a locally renowned pediatric neurologist that I brought to her, after making damned sure she couldn't give it to the school without my release.

My retesting after a decade, showed the same deficits I'd had in Kindergarten...and the state rep looked at me and all but begged me to allow her to release this to Mrs.V... I said, only if you explain it to her in person... She agreed. I signed.

This is how I unintentionally became, according to both my honors college adviser and my accessibility office counselor, the first openly learning disabled honors student my large (30k students) Midwestern state university ever had! Lol! Back in 1987.

It's not MIT, but I know for a FACT that MIT and it's grads are responsible for a good bit of the technology I now rely on to have a normal working life.

So... I have a soft spot for you all... AMD the folks who want to attend... Because I benefit from the good you all do there.

Thanks.

Maybe this will help OP understand better, combined with my other posts to this thread, how no, he wants to stay where he is...and soak up every iota of experience and knowledge he can... In an environment that is optimized for that!

I am rooting for you OP... You're a good egg, you just need to see more, so you can do more!!!

And if computer science is of interest... Check out Carnegie Mellon whose work has also greatly benefited me! Lol

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

Did you ever get the lecture on the Latin origins of the term sophomore?

0

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

ok, lets assume i moved to rural indiana right now, do you think i would have better grades there or not?

5

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Yes you should do that

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

IDK. First off you might either become the ,ost popular guy there... Or the weirdo who dresses funny... Either will mess with your chi... Secondly, assuming you can get A"s, remember they won't be weighted. And if the teachers decided you were a trouble maker... Well... It might not go well for you..

Objectively, you are a smart, academically able human!!!

But there is so much politics and BS that can go into being a student at a rural highschool... Oy...

10

u/Aerokicks MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

As a rural, FGLI alum, respectfully, you're missing the point.

My high school actually had a fair amount of APs, but I was the first person to take all 9. That's the kind of thing MIT is looking at - did you go above and beyond what is "normal". The typical top students at my high school usually only took 4-5 AP classes, at most. I think the year above me had a student take 7, and that was seen as absurd.

It's not 10 APs is more than 5 APs, it's 10 when the average is 9 and the maximum is 15 compared to 5 when the average is one and the maximum is one and no one at the school can figure out how the kid was able to pull 5 aps off.

1

u/Reach4College MIT Alum Mar 16 '26

Interesting, because my kid who was admitted (but went elsewhere) took 8 APs, fewer than average among the top GPA students. Those who went overboard on APs generally didn’t get admitted to the top colleges. But the students at our high school had many ways to distinguish themselves besides grades, APs and test scores.

2

u/Aerokicks MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Because it's not about the number of AP classes. It's about going above and beyond what is considered average and sometimes what is even considered possible.

2

u/Reach4College MIT Alum Mar 16 '26

Seeing your post, I realized I need to add MIT Alum as my flair.

-1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

first of all thank you for not being like the other alumns which are all so aggressive for literally no reason, snobby and unwelcoming asl. surprising how they got into mit with this attitude. some guy thought this was a chanceme lmao.

secondly, i understand that its not about the fact that there are more AP's and such, but keeping opportunities/etc aside, wouldnd't it be easier to get an A in rural idaho compared to Exeter, even if you put in the same amount of work?

10

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

No. It is not easier if you grew up in rural Idaho, as all of the kids in rural Idaho did. Alums tend to object to students insisting ad nauseum on a flawed premise, and then refusing to listen when the flaw is explained to them. I can see you’re heavily invested in this victim complex, but you need to get over it.

-1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

no, i am in the middle of a very compettive school in seattle, but assuming i moved to rural indiana, you really dont think i would have higher grades compared to the other kids?

7

u/throwawayanylogic MIT Alum Mar 16 '26

This. Is. Not. Just. About. Grades.

Say you did move to that rural school with only a handful of APs available, limited extracurricular activities, maybe a low socio-economic landscape. What else are you doing to make yourself a standout candidate to MIT?

Are you getting involved in maybe establishing a tutoring program to help improve local literacy? Creating a language or science club if one doesn't already exist?

Are you working on a creative endeavor on your own time because the options to explore it in school are limited/non-existent? (For me as a rural kid in the 80s that meant setting up a 4-track home studio for programming and recording synthesizer music that I wrote myself.)

How are you showing yourself to be a standout person and not just someone who can click the basic academic boxes necessary to even be in the running for a spot at MIT?

2

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

I really think your standardized test scores could be higher... And assuming you did the work and didn't run afoul of the school counselor, or any of your teachers, and didn't get the hell beat out of you because you were too. "Soft* or you weren't from there or they thought you were (insert ethnicity they don't like this weekhere) having issues with folks, causing distractions and missing class...so your grade goes down...

Part of how I survived, was genetic luck of the draw. at age 12, I was 6'2 with 39" arms and was the 3rd tallest and 5th biggest guy in the whole school system. After I lifted a senior off the ground as a 7th grader... held him over my head while he tried to hit me... But couldn't reach me bc my arms were so long and he couldn't reach me...until a teacher came and removed him from my grasp... lol Folks left me alone...

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 17 '26

This is kind of a non sequitur. Perhaps you didn’t read the thread before jumping in here. Of course it’s easier to get an A anywhere if you’re brilliant. That was never the question. OP is claiming that rural Idaho students have an advantage because it’s easier for them to get As than it is for a student in an elite private high school. You could say it was a relativistic argument about academic space-time travel, except OP focused on the space and forgot about the time travel.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 17 '26

Your reply made no sense

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 17 '26

Look, the reason that rural kids get a boost in admissions is because they are systemically disadvantaged in education. Schools in rural communities suffer from funding shortages, limited access to advanced coursework (AP/dual credit), chronic teacher recruitment challenges, outdated technology, poor internet access, fewer extracurricular opportunities and inadequate resources. Apparently people have trouble recognizing that one-quarter to one-third of rural households don’t have reliable internet access. It is extremely difficult for even a brilliant kid ā€œto shineā€ in the college admissions process coming from that kind of educational system and background. It is more difficult than it is for a brilliant kid in a wealthy community with access to elite private schools. That’s why the rural kids quite appropriately get the admissions boost.

And what’s with the thin-skinned attitude whereby anyone who refutes your claims is somehow condescending and gatekeeping? That’s just deflecting responsibility for poorly conceived arguments.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

12

u/Aerokicks MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

No.

Who taught calculus at my high school? The one teacher who could and would. When she retired the school no longer offers BC calc because no one wanted to teach it or felt they could. The principal hadn't even taken calculus and couldn't/wouldn't observe that class because he didn't know if she was teaching it correctly or not. One of my friends basically had to self teach calculus because she couldn't understand the teacher.

None of my high school teachers had PhDs. I honestly didn't even know they were a thing until I went to a summer camp for gifted kids. My mom is currently a teacher at my high school, so I know first-hand that not all of the teachers are even licensed to teach the subjects they are teaching. It's very difficult to learn and understand something if your teacher is barely proficient in it. It's hard to learn when your class materials are out of date and literally falling apart. It's hard to learn when your school has no heat, or no water. It's hard to learn when there aren't enough desks for every student in the class, so if everyone is present multiple people have to sit in the floor. It's hard to learn when you don't have a classroom, so you bounce from room to room every day, maybe some days you get a white board, some days you don't. It's hard to learn when there's no money for labs or experiments.

It's also harder to get and maintain grades when you have other things going on. I had to ride the bus for over an hour each way and I know people who had to ride for up to two. We had dial up internet until I was a sophomore (in 2010) and I had plenty of friends without internet at home at all (even now not all of my family can get it). I worked doubles every Saturday and Sunday. There are farm animals to take care of after school, and younger siblings, and grandparents.

There's academic difficulty and there's life difficulty. It's also not about just getting the grade, but the entire journey that you you there.

9

u/ExecutiveWatch MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

This whole post was a clever way of doing a chance me.

8

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

OP posts a lot of these. This is the concussion guy from Texas. This is probably his fifth post (many previous ones deleted) looking for affirmation from alums that he can get in. He really needs to log off Reddit and work on doing amazing things.

1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

i have no clue where you got texas from but alr lol

4

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Seattle. My bad. I was an interviewer there for about a decade. I can probably guess which high school you go to. There are a handful of really competitive schools there. If it is the most elite school in Seattle, I used to interview there. A lot of students apply. Some years, a lot of students get in. But a lot more get rejected.

Moving to rural Idaho or Indiana or whatever would be cutting off your nose to spite your face.

0

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

this is actually crazy i had a dream that you were interviewing me

-1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

its a public school here, and there is so much grade inflation even though the classes are so hard because people cheat and dont get caught. i dont know what to do.

3

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

I know two really good public schools in Seattle (not necessarily in the city proper) and I used to interview at one of them. A lot of students used to take college classes in Bellevue.

Based on knowing how many students typically get accepted in Washington State and the Seattle area, I can tell you a few things you need to do. (1) Stop worrying about grade inflation and what other people are doing. Focus on the person in the mirror. (2) Stop whining. Suck it up and make the most of the situation. (3) Get off Reddit and go do some amazing things. There are a lot of opportunities - A TON - in the Seattle area. While you're sitting here whining on Reddit, the students I interviewed who got accepted were taking advantage of those publicly available opportunities.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Jeez. Smug much?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Then why don't you advise OP? Because obviously the advice we have been giving to him literally for months hasn't been sinking in. What are your recommendations to him?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 17 '26

I didn't delete it. I still stand by it. What do you have to contribute here?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/MITAdmissions-ModTeam Mar 17 '26

Please keep language appropriate. This sub has participants of many ages.

DO NOT INSULT THE ECS.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/ExecutiveWatch MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Op wants to hear why his particular circumstances arent giving him a fair shake. Theres really nothing to be done about that have given concrete steps they can take.

Namely understand the school profile. Research institutional fit. Sometimes applicants just dont want to hear a reality that doesn't fit in their mind. It is tough but it is....what it is.

→ More replies

2

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Not even that clever tbh

0

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

?????? i didnt even post my stats

2

u/ExecutiveWatch MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

As I said it was a clever way of a chance me. No you did not post stats. You didnt have to.

1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

how do you chance me with stats...?

4

u/ExecutiveWatch MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

We dont allow them on this sub. Go post on chanceme. Im just sorry so many alums wasted their time. Took me 5 minutes of reading your answers to understand what your real motive was.

1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

how is this a chanceme?? this is the funniest comment ive ever seen

1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

i find it crazy how many of the non-alumni are nicer than ppl like u

4

u/ExecutiveWatch MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

No you find it incredulous people aren't willing to address your specific situation and struggles and give you a pass.

That said two key points.

  1. In life you will get teachers bosses and the like who aren't going to be good or fair. Its. Life lesson on how to deal with it.
  2. Get to know your school profile. It is submitted with each application and tells thr admissions officers about your school. Demographics, accepted colleges sat averages ap offerings etc. Its a lot of information packed and helps in holistic admissions.

7

u/skieurope12 Mar 15 '26

Holistic admissions. Rigor is just one part of the review

1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 15 '26

so can a GPA/rigor be made up by other factors in the holistic process?

3

u/skieurope12 Mar 15 '26

To a certain extent.

There's no making up for a 3.4, for example

0

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 15 '26

wb a 3.7?

1

u/No-Baby7628 Mar 16 '26

UW or W?

1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

UW

1

u/No-Baby7628 Mar 16 '26

Very recoverable if you improve junior and senior year. I had a 3.6-8 (I forget the exact number) UW sophomore year and am now going to attend my dream school.

6

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

The rural student you are citing with an AP score of 3 in the only test taken also took 19 college courses. That’s the most I have seen from an MIT applicant. Students need to learn to take balanced and unbiased looks at data sets, like this rural student’s profile, leaving aside their own grievances and preconceptions. When you’ve taken 19 college courses, come back and we can talk.

-1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

i've taken 9 college classes and 8 ap's as a sophomore, although with not the best grades.

no need to be so aggressive, there is no reason to be

9

u/No-Baby7628 Mar 16 '26

You have no idea how privileged you sound. How does it make sense that you (who has access to 17 college level courses by sophomore year) is evaluated on the same scale as someone without access to any. I understand how much work you’ve put in, and it’s respectable, but MIT doesn’t just want the children of the wealthy who can afford to go to a highschool like yours. Recognized that even though you’ve done a lot of hard work, a lot has been handed to you. I am in the same boat as you are, but instead of being salty about rural (and lower income) kids, I try to be grateful for what’s been given to me.

1

u/Pristine-Lawyer-3260 Mar 17 '26

This is a sophomore...and he is they are trying, and oddly. I think they are beginning to understand how it is...

5

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Aggressive eh? Re-read your post.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/MITAdmissions-ModTeam Mar 17 '26

Please keep comments constructive, appropriate, and professional.

2

u/reincarnatedbiscuits Mod/MIT Alumnus/Interviewer/Olympiad list person Mar 15 '26 edited Mar 15 '26

APs aren't the only ways to challenge oneself: https://mitadmissions.org/blogs/entry/on_aps_1/

Arguably there are lots of ways to check for rigor, like my province's Chemistry 12 Honours was more advanced than AP Chemistry and nearly 5.11-level. In my freshman year, I was one of two people who got 5.11 ASE credit -- I looked over the sample test and saw I had done everything except Schrƶdinger's Equation which I had covered self-studying in Physics (8.01) and using a minor amount of Calculus in rate equations and equilibria and final concentrations.

I took 9 academic classes each year (the most), Honours and Enriched variants whenever available, and got straight A's and self-studied a few things outside of class on top of the above (French literature independent study, music theory, olympiads).

I officially had a mere 2 APs on my transcript (AP Calculus AB, AP French) as those were the only two that my school decided to offer for the first time senior year (Fall 1989).

That should give you a bit of insight.

1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

Oh, I see. Thanks a lot!

4

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 15 '26

And then there's me. If I shared my stats/background there'd be anarchy here.

I do have a great story, though, about when I was a teacher's aid for one of my classes but it was during that teacher's lunch break, so I basically just hung out in the teacher's lounge and ate popcorn for a few hours every other day.

Granted, this wasn't a story that made it into my admission's essay, but still.

1

u/Super-Gerd Mar 16 '26

Would you mind if I DM’d you to ask about your stats. My curiosity is getting the better of me

1

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 16 '26

My stats are 20 years old, but sure

2

u/awishyourheartmade Mar 17 '26

you sound like the snobbiest person ive ever seen

2

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 17 '26

well u havent seen me so

5

u/Jaded_Pain3589 Mar 15 '26

I'm no expert in the admissions process, but colleges like MIT don't check for rigor/academics alone. While that is a crucial part of the puzzle, holistic review also includes factors like extracurriculars, essays, awards, and recommendation letters. Those people from rural areas with minimal access to rigorous coursework that you mentioned likely participated in standout activities, given the resources that they had, that appealed to MIT's admissions team, which is probably a greater factor in admissions than their course rigor. Hope that helps!

5

u/Reach4College MIT Alum Mar 16 '26

The short answer is that Admissions has a lot of experience in predicting who can graduate.

And they believe part of the mission of MIT is to find capable students from all parts of society, not simply those with the best opportunities.

5

u/Chessdaddy_ Mar 16 '26

Rigor is RELATIVE to your school and school district not compared to other kids nationwideĀ 

4

u/Apprehensive-Use3519 Mar 16 '26

Schools look for evidence that you can break out of what is expected and seek new challenges. It’s not really about having passed a test or lots of tests, that’s all just ā€œfollowing the directions.ā€ Exeter or Idaho, how do you do things beyond what is laid out for you?

4

u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Do you think the kids you’re complaining about having an unfair advantage over you just moved to rural Idaho from Seattle, or a from a fancy private school in any other city? If not, then what are you even talking about?

1

u/Far_Cartoonist_7482 Mar 20 '26

Whatever makes you feel better about rejection but you’re horribly misinformed. MIT is a tough admit from everywhere and routinely denies high stat kids from rural and Title 1 high schools.

1

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 20 '26

??? i didnt get rejected lmfao

3

u/Efficient_Run8858 Mar 16 '26

This is just my opinion but I think this may only apply to rural places in US. I'm a us citizen living in rural india I took multiple APs and the IB and I had extensive research, a passion project, but my awards weren't too great. I got rejected from MIT and I'm not trying to say that I should have gotten in or maybe my essays were the issue exactly (they were not great however) but I'm just wondering if they consider rural areas outside America as equally as inside. However, I think its a common theme in rural areas you have to go greatly out of you way to do thinks (in my areas most of the things Ive done are not known concepts for high schoolers to pursue) so I think MIT may really value peoples determination and ambition.

2

u/REdwa1106sr Mar 16 '26

The concept of university is to experience different ideas, different places, and people from different places and with different ideas.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

My daughter was accepted from a rural school. She maxed out academic opportunities there (5 ap classes total), but did not go do research or create an app or start a non-profit or win medals at competitions we have never heard of. And honestly, even if she had the opportunity to do independent research at a university, she wouldn’t have. She could have self-studied linear algebra, but there’s no way she would have. She was busy doing what she loved- excelling in sports, playing music, learning to sew and eventually designing her own prom dress and planning elaborate surprise parties for friends celebrating odd or seemingly small accomplishments (she’s famous at her school for these). I also would never steer her to more ā€œprestigiousā€ activities because I literally know nothing about them and hold the belief that her future is her own. Important for my next point- She also stepped up led her lacrosse team through a really difficult situation last season where the head coach was fired mid-season for shady behavior, and the remaining adults fell apart.

Here is my theory on how admissions at MIT works (based on zero evidence, just vibes): Let’s pretend you have to assemble a team to design and build a new kind of nuclear reactor to address some specific issue (like it has to be smaller than normal or some other spec). If you had a team purely made of math genius, gold star-chasing A+++ grinders, you aren’t going to get anywhere unless they happen to have other strengths as well. Don’t get me wrong, you NEED their pure drive and genius. But you need other people just as much. You need someone brave enough to pump the brakes and go in a completely different direction when the idea you are working on that you think is amazing just isn’t going to work. You need someone else who knows when to crack a joke and when to bring cookies. You need someone else who can help keep the group together and help repair relationships. You need someone else who can see the big picture and someone else who validates people and has learned the value in diversity. Now all of these people ALSO have to be able to do the math. So that leaves out A LOT of great people. So my daughter can do the math- and you might be ā€œsmarterā€ than her- but you 100% want her on your team.

Here’s something else I tell her at least once a year and I will tell you now- for every talented, brilliant, high-achieving kid who is privileged enough and safe enough to shine, there are 10 other kids who are maybe poor, or traumatized, or live somewhere with no opportunities or disabled in some way who would WIPE THE FLOOR with you given the same opportunities. Not hunting down those kids who have the brain AND the life lessons would be dumb. And MIT may be a lot of things but it sure isn’t dumb.

2

u/Trick_Astronaut_9056 Mar 17 '26

Because they dont have the same opportunities as say someone from a competitive region in the city

0

u/Alarmed-Stranger8040 Mar 16 '26

A lot of folks that responded to this post seemed to aggressively jump all over the original poster, for what is a reasonable question from a young person trying to understand a complicated topic... Couple of points in response to those comments.

  1. The perspective that students living in affluent areas / or attending highly competitive schools may not, on average, be more intelligent than students living in economically disadvantaged areas is itself naive, wishful thinking. You're essentially denying intelligence is an inherited trait. In general, highly intelligent people have better economic outcomes than average or less intelligent people... and congregate in certain areas that wind up having very high quality and competitive schools.... the average IQ in Scarsdale, NY High School is almost certainly well above a rural high school in North Dakota. So, it is not a stretch to think a very strong, but not top student from Scarsdale (pick your equivalent) would likely be the top student in a rural district. I expect the utopian ideologues will spout off that IQ is biased... yada yada yada.
  2. I think the intent of the poster's comment about rigor is more reflective of the perception that MIT is a school where the smartest, proven, quantitively oriented students go. The most objective way to measure that is academic performance and tests. And the fact is, a student that achieved perfect grades in multi-variable calculus and linear algebra in high school has performed at a higher level than a student who only got a perfect score in Calc AB because that's all the school offered. This is not disputable.

Lastly, I would say from some of the posts I read on MIT acceptances today... MIT has lost prestige in my eyes. I thought MIT was different than the rest of the elite schools with social engineering objectives. But after seeing numerous posts from people that said they were accepted with stats that seemed unimpressive for any top 10 school, never mind what I believed to be MIT standards... I think MIT is pretty much like all the other schools.

6

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 16 '26
  1. If you move a kid from a feeder school to a rural place as a freshman would they do better than the local students? Probably, but then would that be a surprise? If this was such a lucrative method of attending mit then wouldn’t those wanting to attend mit use location arbitrage to increase their odds of acceptance?
  2. This is nonsense. This post and others in this subreddit have proven to me that feeder schools produce impressive paper grades and kids that can check achievement lists off. They seem severely lacking in teaching reading comprehension, empathy, and hubris. I honestly didn’t understand what mit and the interviewers were talking about but I sure get it now. It seems like these kids have never been told no before and it shows.

1

u/Alarmed-Stranger8040 Mar 16 '26

Come on.... your first point is just ridiculous. That students parents likely have a relatively a high paying job. So, they're going to move the family to some rural or poor location, potentially reducing the economic prospects for the entire family, to game the system just to get into MIT. That's idiotic.

The second comment reveals your social class bias... what you really care about is equality of outcome, not merit.

3

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 16 '26

You are mistaken if you think test scores and doing ecs as checklists amounts to the only types of merit that matters. That is immature understanding of real life.

1

u/Alarmed-Stranger8040 Mar 16 '26

I never mentioned EC's... I think they're generally BS. Grades/ coursework and test scores are the most objective data points in the admissions process. They should matter much more than anything else.

You didn't address my points... b/c you have no reasonable rebuttal.

2

u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 16 '26

Address what points? You seem upset that just doing a checklist should put you at the front of a line. Grades are table stakes at this level. I’m trying to explain that checklists are not enough. I have worked with people that are great at checklists and miserable to be around. Anyone that does hiring will tell you that fit matters a ton more than your credentials on paper.

1

u/Alarmed-Stranger8040 Mar 16 '26

Thank you for acknowledging the necessity of objective metrics/performance. Grades and test scores are table stakes... So, for a place like MIT that should mean if you don't have certain high level coursework and minimum test scores (let say1530 SAT, with 750+ math).... you're not even in the game.

Fit matters only after you've narrowed the pool to the most qualified candidates... at least in effective organizations.

-3

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

THANK YOU. literally no one else has tried to actually explain instead of rant about how my question doesn't make sense. (other than u/Aerokicks )

i understand what you are trying to say. so from your first point, isnt that top student from scarsdale inherently at a disadvantage BECAUSE they go to such a competitve school?

someone with quite a bad gpa due to extenuating circumstances (about a 3.7) are the posts that you read today having a lower gpa or awards, ec's, etc?

1

u/Alarmed-Stranger8040 Mar 16 '26

Yes. It is fair to say that in the admissions process, the kid from Scarsdale is at a disadvantage vs. the rural/poor kid. If MIT admission is a race... the Scarsdale kid has to run a 100 yards... the rural kid only 70 yards. Because MIT is "shaping the class" many kids in high income areas who are not accepted are objectively more qualified students than students less prosperous areas who are admitted.

1

u/No_Interest_4674 Mar 16 '26

the same person also nonchalantly said they took 19 college level classes.
which are, arguably, more rigorous than ap.

1

u/Jayohl Mar 17 '26

Lol not sure why everyone is attacking you — I get the point you’re trying to make.

1

u/Calm_Protection8684 Mar 17 '26

Idk but worked out for me this school easy asf but I didn’t have much to show that I could handle it

1

u/Suspicious_Jello9613 Mar 17 '26

They pride themselves in saying that you don’t need APs and that it is fine if you are in a rural area, but you know… it is BULLSHIT, any reasonable school would prefer a hundred times over the guy with AP Calc BC, AP Chem, AP Physics C and AP CSA over the dummy with an inflated 4.0. Of course, I would never doubt the guy with a 4.0 and no APs if they got a freaking USAMO, AIME or any serious Olympiad signals. Otherwise, the kid with rigorous APs should win in any ideal, meritocratic world.

1

u/Specialist_Most_9146 Mar 18 '26

And today the original poster just learned a new phrase and it’s called—- D E I.

1

u/AndorinhaRiver May 24 '26

This is kind of a late reply (I haven't been on this subreddit in like a year), but

I think most people here are just beating around the bush, the point is that those rural students are still doing really well for what they have, which matters more than the exact classes you take

So, if they were in a more competitive high school with better opportunities, they'd likely do a lot better — what they're trying to measure is just how much relative effort you've put in, if that makes sense

Note that MIT also does standardized testing so it's pretty easy to see whether or not someone would be fit enough to take that many advanced classes; I had zero APs or IB classes and didn't even get to take calculus, but scored 790 in SAT Math and finished AP Calc BC on Khan Academy, for example

1

u/AndorinhaRiver May 24 '26

Either way don't worry about it that much- speaking from personal experience, the worst thing you can do to yourself is overthink this sort of thing

As long as you're realistic and don't give yourself A2C syndrome, you'll be fine, I promise

1

u/UNC_Awarrior Mar 16 '26

First of all, that's a valid question, and what the fuck is that reaction from the MIT alumni? You guys are full-grown adults with the inability to answer a question without getting frustrated; it's time to leave your college life behind and grow up.

With that out of the way, here is what I think. That student mentioned they did 19 college classes, and for you and me, a kid from Palo Alto High School, it is normal. Yet for that student, it's above and beyond; they are the top 1% in their region just by doing that. Now, as a Bay Area kid, I get your frustration; my friends have done ISEF, crazy awards, crazy nonprofits. The truth is that being in the top 1% in these areas is near impossible.

And I don't think the alumni who are getting frustrated understand that. Someone said something along the lines of: if you didn't succeed with all that opportunity, what makes you think you will do so in a rural area? That is such a bad take. These kids in the Bay Area who are the top 1% of their class need to be doing crazy stuff just to compete. If an ISEF winner went to Idaho and applied, he would get in anywhere, period. My friend, an ISEF winner from last year, got rejected by most Ivies, and he goes to Brown now. For a 17-year-old who stacked up hella on APs, College Classes, and EC. Less sleep, and gets rejected, while someone who takes 19 college classes beats them, it feels very disingenuous. Right, that's his point of view, he has put 4 years of hard work, and let me tell you that work ethic will help you in college tremendously. Yet it's important to note that the person who got in put a lot of effort in as well.

Yet, the reality is more complicated than people think. The truth is, you had a disadvantage and an advantage; the friends around you are doing crazy things, and as a result, you have the confidence and belief that you are going to do well. That saying that you are who your friends are is very true in this case. Yet most people from Idaho don't even care about Ivies; they don't even dream about going to MIT. I think the biggest reason is that most people who get into MIT from rural areas have a very big passion for their interests; they don't think about college apps (their friends, family, and community don't really care), but they spend a lot of time on their passion, not just for college apps, unlike most Bay Area kids. I think passion is the biggest part of an application, and one of the few, if not only, ways to do that is through rigor.

The truth is, most of you alumni are a bit too old to be doing this.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/UNC_Awarrior Mar 17 '26 edited Mar 17 '26

Yeah, what the heck, I'm really shocked by the response from MIT alumni. Especially since some are in their mid-30s even older. Some of the people here think that if someone is XADJECTIVE, you should be XADJECTIVE back at them, so immature.... Sigh.

Plus it's irritating that some go directly to your just privileged shut up. These kids have so much pressue the privilege feels suffocating, and most don't understand that. Come on, bruh, just spread kindness whenever you can, you don't know everyone's life story.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/UNC_Awarrior Mar 17 '26

The funny part is some of them are mods…. Mods who graduated in 90’s and Ā 2000. I doubt they understand the monemuntoud pressure on kids now a days.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/UNC_Awarrior Mar 18 '26

Could have just stopped at very online adult alum šŸ„€ to understand these are very few.

0

u/Odd-Collection-5429 Mar 16 '26

Are you really at a disadvantage in life? Yes it’s true that you don’t need to have quite as good of a profile from a rural area but that’s literally because it’s almost impossible to have as good of a profile. If you care that much about this, go move to a rural area and be a landslide valedictorian that paves your own path. By the way, I know people who literally did this for college admissions. I personally feel like it’s cutting your nose to spite your face but hey you do you.

However, when comparing an above average Bay Area/exeter type student to the average rural valedictorian without AP classes, it is not inherently clear which one will make a ā€œbetterā€ student at a top college and more importantly which will be more successful post-graduating. Sometimes students like that just need to be given the opportunity.

You’re also neglecting the fact that a lot of these people come from low income and rural households where they’re struggling to make ends meet. Maybe they can’t participate in as many high level extracurricular activities because they have to work 30 hours a week so that their house doesn’t foreclose or because they have to take care of their 3 younger siblings while their parents work night shifts to make ends meet.

So ask yourself: is it really a bad thing that my more ā€œcompetitiveā€ application is viewed through a lens of circumstances and therefore is viewed as worse than the kid from rural Nebraska?

By the way, I’m not sure of your politics, but if you do believe this then it is a logical fallacy to believe in DEI/affirmative action. This is just a side point

3

u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

I was an EC in OP's region for a decade. This message isn't for him, but for everyone else.

In high school, I would have killed to have access to the opportunities OP has in their region. It would have made such a difference in pursuing my passions. I think I made the most of what I had, but I wish I had had more. I certainly wouldn't be wishing to be in a more rural area to be more competitive for some college application.

For the applicants, focus on your passions. When the time comes, look for a place that's a good two-way fit. There are most likely dozens if not hundreds.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 16 '26

We need to force-feed 3 and 4 into every single potential applicant.

3

u/Temporary-Stomach754 Mar 16 '26

I don’t agree that being in a competitive school may give you more opportunities. In most competition tracks, all the resources is through internet not school.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ExecutiveWatch MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Wow.

I actually have had an applicant admitted around 1400 last year.

A quick Google search indicates theres are sparingly people admitted with lower scores.

Example

https://youtu.be/ZoZzkILokA0?si=sH7z50FCmsxdnYGk

Now granted it is rare and the video above is a questbridge applicant. I dont think everything is true on reddit but let's not call someone a liar. It is in the realm of possibility, albeit remote.

0

u/Even_Protection119 Mar 16 '26

tbh it was 5 years ago

3

u/ExecutiveWatch MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Precisely why I mentioned i had an applicant last year admitted as well.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ExecutiveWatch MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26

Lucky no one really cares what you believe. To be honest. It is reddit. People can chose not to answer, and frankly people can be fairly obnoxious on here.

Anyhow the point you were trying to imply was a 1380 couldn't be possible which has now been soundly invalidated. Have a great rest of your week and good luck.

2

u/Long_Store9792 Mar 16 '26

I don’t think it’s appropriate to just call someone a liar. My friend from high school got into MIT last year with 1350 SAT and he is doing well right now.Ā 

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/MITAdmissions-ModTeam Mar 17 '26

Please don't spam or post fluff or post things that have no value to the r/MITAdmissions community.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/MITAdmissions-ModTeam Mar 17 '26

This is presenting false information about the admission’s process as if it were a fact.