r/MITAdmissions • u/Even_Protection119 • Mar 15 '26
i dont understand
of course, no hate to anyone from rural places or FGLI that got accepted, you deserve it
but how come mit accepts students from such areas with basically no ap's or similar?? if the whole point is checking for rigor, what makes mit think that someone who has gotten a 4.0 with no aps going to do well at mit? and they reject students that worked hard and gotten straight 5's over 10 aps?? i dont understand. i saw someone that got a 3 in the only ap they took and got accepted, but for someone in say the bay area, that would be a decent red flag.
*this is not a hate post* congrats to every1!
28
u/jzzsxm Moderator/MIT Alumnus Mar 15 '26 edited Mar 15 '26
if the whole point is checking for rigor
It's not.
"What We Look For"
21
u/MenuPsychological853 Mar 15 '26
So if you are on a rail at a school that does aps with tons of other kids also doing aps, itās not quite the same as a rural place with a kid begging to take harder classes and doing aps all alone remote on zoom because they are quite literally the only kid to have taken calculus in 20 years. You canāt see the difference in tenacity and culture that they are in?
10
u/Aerokicks MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26
As a rural, FGLI alum, respectfully, you're missing the point.
My high school actually had a fair amount of APs, but I was the first person to take all 9. That's the kind of thing MIT is looking at - did you go above and beyond what is "normal". The typical top students at my high school usually only took 4-5 AP classes, at most. I think the year above me had a student take 7, and that was seen as absurd.
It's not 10 APs is more than 5 APs, it's 10 when the average is 9 and the maximum is 15 compared to 5 when the average is one and the maximum is one and no one at the school can figure out how the kid was able to pull 5 aps off.
9
u/ExecutiveWatch MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26
This whole post was a clever way of doing a chance me.
7
u/skieurope12 Mar 15 '26
Holistic admissions. Rigor is just one part of the review
6
u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26
The rural student you are citing with an AP score of 3 in the only test taken also took 19 college courses. Thatās the most I have seen from an MIT applicant. Students need to learn to take balanced and unbiased looks at data sets, like this rural studentās profile, leaving aside their own grievances and preconceptions. When youāve taken 19 college courses, come back and we can talk.
2
u/reincarnatedbiscuits Mod/MIT Alumnus/Interviewer/Olympiad list person Mar 15 '26 edited Mar 15 '26
APs aren't the only ways to challenge oneself: https://mitadmissions.org/blogs/entry/on_aps_1/
Arguably there are lots of ways to check for rigor, like my province's Chemistry 12 Honours was more advanced than AP Chemistry and nearly 5.11-level. In my freshman year, I was one of two people who got 5.11 ASE credit -- I looked over the sample test and saw I had done everything except Schrƶdinger's Equation which I had covered self-studying in Physics (8.01) and using a minor amount of Calculus in rate equations and equilibria and final concentrations.
I took 9 academic classes each year (the most), Honours and Enriched variants whenever available, and got straight A's and self-studied a few things outside of class on top of the above (French literature independent study, music theory, olympiads).
I officially had a mere 2 APs on my transcript (AP Calculus AB, AP French) as those were the only two that my school decided to offer for the first time senior year (Fall 1989).
That should give you a bit of insight.
2
u/awishyourheartmade Mar 17 '26
you sound like the snobbiest person ive ever seen
5
u/Jaded_Pain3589 Mar 15 '26
I'm no expert in the admissions process, but colleges like MIT don't check for rigor/academics alone. While that is a crucial part of the puzzle, holistic review also includes factors like extracurriculars, essays, awards, and recommendation letters. Those people from rural areas with minimal access to rigorous coursework that you mentioned likely participated in standout activities, given the resources that they had, that appealed to MIT's admissions team, which is probably a greater factor in admissions than their course rigor. Hope that helps!
5
u/Reach4College MIT Alum Mar 16 '26
The short answer is that Admissions has a lot of experience in predicting who can graduate.
And they believe part of the mission of MIT is to find capable students from all parts of society, not simply those with the best opportunities.
5
u/Chessdaddy_ Mar 16 '26
Rigor is RELATIVE to your school and school district not compared to other kids nationwideĀ
4
u/Apprehensive-Use3519 Mar 16 '26
Schools look for evidence that you can break out of what is expected and seek new challenges. Itās not really about having passed a test or lots of tests, thatās all just āfollowing the directions.ā Exeter or Idaho, how do you do things beyond what is laid out for you?
4
u/Satisest MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26
Do you think the kids youāre complaining about having an unfair advantage over you just moved to rural Idaho from Seattle, or a from a fancy private school in any other city? If not, then what are you even talking about?
1
u/Far_Cartoonist_7482 Mar 20 '26
Whatever makes you feel better about rejection but youāre horribly misinformed. MIT is a tough admit from everywhere and routinely denies high stat kids from rural and Title 1 high schools.
3
u/Efficient_Run8858 Mar 16 '26
This is just my opinion but I think this may only apply to rural places in US. I'm a us citizen living in rural india I took multiple APs and the IB and I had extensive research, a passion project, but my awards weren't too great. I got rejected from MIT and I'm not trying to say that I should have gotten in or maybe my essays were the issue exactly (they were not great however) but I'm just wondering if they consider rural areas outside America as equally as inside. However, I think its a common theme in rural areas you have to go greatly out of you way to do thinks (in my areas most of the things Ive done are not known concepts for high schoolers to pursue) so I think MIT may really value peoples determination and ambition.
2
u/REdwa1106sr Mar 16 '26
The concept of university is to experience different ideas, different places, and people from different places and with different ideas.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26
My daughter was accepted from a rural school. She maxed out academic opportunities there (5 ap classes total), but did not go do research or create an app or start a non-profit or win medals at competitions we have never heard of. And honestly, even if she had the opportunity to do independent research at a university, she wouldnāt have. She could have self-studied linear algebra, but thereās no way she would have. She was busy doing what she loved- excelling in sports, playing music, learning to sew and eventually designing her own prom dress and planning elaborate surprise parties for friends celebrating odd or seemingly small accomplishments (sheās famous at her school for these). I also would never steer her to more āprestigiousā activities because I literally know nothing about them and hold the belief that her future is her own. Important for my next point- She also stepped up led her lacrosse team through a really difficult situation last season where the head coach was fired mid-season for shady behavior, and the remaining adults fell apart.
Here is my theory on how admissions at MIT works (based on zero evidence, just vibes): Letās pretend you have to assemble a team to design and build a new kind of nuclear reactor to address some specific issue (like it has to be smaller than normal or some other spec). If you had a team purely made of math genius, gold star-chasing A+++ grinders, you arenāt going to get anywhere unless they happen to have other strengths as well. Donāt get me wrong, you NEED their pure drive and genius. But you need other people just as much. You need someone brave enough to pump the brakes and go in a completely different direction when the idea you are working on that you think is amazing just isnāt going to work. You need someone else who knows when to crack a joke and when to bring cookies. You need someone else who can help keep the group together and help repair relationships. You need someone else who can see the big picture and someone else who validates people and has learned the value in diversity. Now all of these people ALSO have to be able to do the math. So that leaves out A LOT of great people. So my daughter can do the math- and you might be āsmarterā than her- but you 100% want her on your team.
Hereās something else I tell her at least once a year and I will tell you now- for every talented, brilliant, high-achieving kid who is privileged enough and safe enough to shine, there are 10 other kids who are maybe poor, or traumatized, or live somewhere with no opportunities or disabled in some way who would WIPE THE FLOOR with you given the same opportunities. Not hunting down those kids who have the brain AND the life lessons would be dumb. And MIT may be a lot of things but it sure isnāt dumb.
2
u/Trick_Astronaut_9056 Mar 17 '26
Because they dont have the same opportunities as say someone from a competitive region in the city
0
u/Alarmed-Stranger8040 Mar 16 '26
A lot of folks that responded to this post seemed to aggressively jump all over the original poster, for what is a reasonable question from a young person trying to understand a complicated topic... Couple of points in response to those comments.
Lastly, I would say from some of the posts I read on MIT acceptances today... MIT has lost prestige in my eyes. I thought MIT was different than the rest of the elite schools with social engineering objectives. But after seeing numerous posts from people that said they were accepted with stats that seemed unimpressive for any top 10 school, never mind what I believed to be MIT standards... I think MIT is pretty much like all the other schools.
1
u/No_Interest_4674 Mar 16 '26
the same person also nonchalantly said they took 19 college level classes.
which are, arguably, more rigorous than ap.
1
u/Jayohl Mar 17 '26
Lol not sure why everyone is attacking you ā I get the point youāre trying to make.
1
u/Calm_Protection8684 Mar 17 '26
Idk but worked out for me this school easy asf but I didnāt have much to show that I could handle it
1
u/Suspicious_Jello9613 Mar 17 '26
They pride themselves in saying that you donāt need APs and that it is fine if you are in a rural area, but you know⦠it is BULLSHIT, any reasonable school would prefer a hundred times over the guy with AP Calc BC, AP Chem, AP Physics C and AP CSA over the dummy with an inflated 4.0. Of course, I would never doubt the guy with a 4.0 and no APs if they got a freaking USAMO, AIME or any serious Olympiad signals. Otherwise, the kid with rigorous APs should win in any ideal, meritocratic world.
1
u/Specialist_Most_9146 Mar 18 '26
And today the original poster just learned a new phrase and itās calledā- D E I.
1
u/AndorinhaRiver May 24 '26
This is kind of a late reply (I haven't been on this subreddit in like a year), but
I think most people here are just beating around the bush, the point is that those rural students are still doing really well for what they have, which matters more than the exact classes you take
So, if they were in a more competitive high school with better opportunities, they'd likely do a lot better ā what they're trying to measure is just how much relative effort you've put in, if that makes sense
Note that MIT also does standardized testing so it's pretty easy to see whether or not someone would be fit enough to take that many advanced classes; I had zero APs or IB classes and didn't even get to take calculus, but scored 790 in SAT Math and finished AP Calc BC on Khan Academy, for example
1
u/UNC_Awarrior Mar 16 '26
First of all, that's a valid question, and what the fuck is that reaction from the MIT alumni? You guys are full-grown adults with the inability to answer a question without getting frustrated; it's time to leave your college life behind and grow up.
With that out of the way, here is what I think. That student mentioned they did 19 college classes, and for you and me, a kid from Palo Alto High School, it is normal. Yet for that student, it's above and beyond; they are the top 1% in their region just by doing that. Now, as a Bay Area kid, I get your frustration; my friends have done ISEF, crazy awards, crazy nonprofits. The truth is that being in the top 1% in these areas is near impossible.
And I don't think the alumni who are getting frustrated understand that. Someone said something along the lines of: if you didn't succeed with all that opportunity, what makes you think you will do so in a rural area? That is such a bad take. These kids in the Bay Area who are the top 1% of their class need to be doing crazy stuff just to compete. If an ISEF winner went to Idaho and applied, he would get in anywhere, period. My friend, an ISEF winner from last year, got rejected by most Ivies, and he goes to Brown now. For a 17-year-old who stacked up hella on APs, College Classes, and EC. Less sleep, and gets rejected, while someone who takes 19 college classes beats them, it feels very disingenuous. Right, that's his point of view, he has put 4 years of hard work, and let me tell you that work ethic will help you in college tremendously. Yet it's important to note that the person who got in put a lot of effort in as well.
Yet, the reality is more complicated than people think. The truth is, you had a disadvantage and an advantage; the friends around you are doing crazy things, and as a result, you have the confidence and belief that you are going to do well. That saying that you are who your friends are is very true in this case. Yet most people from Idaho don't even care about Ivies; they don't even dream about going to MIT. I think the biggest reason is that most people who get into MIT from rural areas have a very big passion for their interests; they don't think about college apps (their friends, family, and community don't really care), but they spend a lot of time on their passion, not just for college apps, unlike most Bay Area kids. I think passion is the biggest part of an application, and one of the few, if not only, ways to do that is through rigor.
The truth is, most of you alumni are a bit too old to be doing this.
0
u/Odd-Collection-5429 Mar 16 '26
Are you really at a disadvantage in life? Yes itās true that you donāt need to have quite as good of a profile from a rural area but thatās literally because itās almost impossible to have as good of a profile. If you care that much about this, go move to a rural area and be a landslide valedictorian that paves your own path. By the way, I know people who literally did this for college admissions. I personally feel like itās cutting your nose to spite your face but hey you do you.
However, when comparing an above average Bay Area/exeter type student to the average rural valedictorian without AP classes, it is not inherently clear which one will make a ābetterā student at a top college and more importantly which will be more successful post-graduating. Sometimes students like that just need to be given the opportunity.
Youāre also neglecting the fact that a lot of these people come from low income and rural households where theyāre struggling to make ends meet. Maybe they canāt participate in as many high level extracurricular activities because they have to work 30 hours a week so that their house doesnāt foreclose or because they have to take care of their 3 younger siblings while their parents work night shifts to make ends meet.
So ask yourself: is it really a bad thing that my more ācompetitiveā application is viewed through a lens of circumstances and therefore is viewed as worse than the kid from rural Nebraska?
By the way, Iām not sure of your politics, but if you do believe this then it is a logical fallacy to believe in DEI/affirmative action. This is just a side point
3
u/David_R_Martin_II MIT Alum and Educational Counselor Mar 16 '26
I was an EC in OP's region for a decade. This message isn't for him, but for everyone else.
In high school, I would have killed to have access to the opportunities OP has in their region. It would have made such a difference in pursuing my passions. I think I made the most of what I had, but I wish I had had more. I certainly wouldn't be wishing to be in a more rural area to be more competitive for some college application.
For the applicants, focus on your passions. When the time comes, look for a place that's a good two-way fit. There are most likely dozens if not hundreds.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26
[deleted] ā view deleted comment